r/Reds • • Aug 29 '26

RBI matter. Period

Thumbnail x.com
3 Upvotes

WAR is just a stat for nerds to try and decide who's better without having to watch any games. It's a lazy cop-out for writers to act all high and mighty by trying to downgrade what Sal is doing. Old school numbers, like RBI, matter.


r/Reds • • Aug 06 '25

:reds1: Commentary Perhaps an unpopular opinion: Thom Brennamen has had some epic calls of historic Reds moments and they were pretty good.

2 Upvotes

Ramon Hernandez game winning HR on opening day.

Clinchmas.

Scooter Gennet 4HR game

DID HE? DID HE? HE DID! HE DID! REDS WIN!REDS WIN! REDS !WIN!

Homer Bailey's 2 no hitters.

Aquino's magical 10 game stretch.

Didn't enjoy him as a regular play by play announcer. Definitely don't support the comments he made that got him deservedly fired.

Randomly ended up hearing some of these calls recently, have to say I got goosebumps a couple of times the man was talented.

Glad we have Sadak now, he's better and I wouldn't trade him for anyone.


r/Reds • • May 20 '24

Elly?

1 Upvotes

I keed 😎


r/Reds • • Sep 02 '23

From everyone at r/Brewers, thank you! FTC!

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Reds • • Dec 21 '23

Have they convinced you they want to win a World Series yet?

2 Upvotes

I haven’t seen anything this offseason that sends a message to the fans that they are actively trying to win a title. Have they improved? I think to some degree. A couple decent arms but nothing that says they’re all in. Isn’t that the point? If they are just trying to make a playoff run or being content with just having a winning record, then what’s the point? I know it’s not over yet, but just as sure as I’m posting this, I can almost guarantee they will declare that the pieces they needed weren’t available. They don’t ever seem to be available. There are some very nice arms left still. I will give krall the benefit and trust that he’s trying to be smart with our trade bait, but right now they have s a lot of question marks and that isn’t what you want when making a run. You want the players and fans to feel confident that they are the team to beat. I believe we’re at like 98 days. Tick tock uncle Bob!


r/Reds • • Dec 13 '20

misleading title Trevor Bauer Top 5. (Reds not included...)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/Reds • • Jul 30 '25

:reds1: Commentary Apparently the Castellini’s Won’t Spend Another Dime. Embarrassing

Thumbnail x.com
0 Upvotes

If this is the case then we are fucked. No other way to say it. I already thought that Bob and company were asshats but if we are this poor then just phone it in. I’m not normally a doomer whatsoever but seriously I could write a novel about how bad this is.


r/Reds • • Nov 12 '23

:reds1: Analysis For everyone holding out hope of the Reds trying to add free agents

Thumbnail
facebook.com
0 Upvotes

Reds beat writers already throwing a wet blanket on that. Does not make me feel better about the reds getting better.


r/Reds • • Jun 19 '25

Some Reds "fans" on Reddit ...

0 Upvotes

... spend a lot of time and space hating on this team. Apparently they live in an endless slough of despair. The throughline: "No good will ever come of anything anybody does." Just trolling? Or a cry for help?


r/Reds • • Oct 25 '23

Castellanos question?

8 Upvotes

As a Reds sub do we only get to bring him up when he makes our "favorite team" look bad or can we discuss when he's 0 for his last 23 AB's in the NLCS with 11 K's to end the Phillies season?


r/Reds • • May 14 '25

Unpopular Opinion

86 Upvotes

14 was a liar and a criminal. He made Cincinnati look like an ass denying he did anything wrong and then decides to write a book and confess…. and Cincinnatians are okay with that? Bullshit.


r/Reds • • May 13 '24

I still can't believe Mike Ford is on this team.

6 Upvotes

That tells me they aren't serious about winning.


r/Reds • • Jan 07 '26

We're so back

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Reds • • Jun 20 '22

Remember The Enemy!

2 Upvotes

16,702. That is our average attendance this year. That is far too high. Do not give Bob a single penny. Drive him and his son out of Cincinnati and back to his fruit warehouse is Kentucky where he belongs.

We deserve someone who is capable of running a sports franchise. It’s not the losing driving me to make this post. It’s the lack of vision. Every time Minor takes the mound remember his salary is equal to Miley who we cut to save money. The kind of sense does that make?

We are a rudderless ship in an ice field that has already struck a few bergs. Bob needs to go down with this ship. At least if we sink the Reds and make it an embarrassment to be seen at the stadium, we might get a new captain with a better ship.

Fuck Bob and Phil. Sell the team!


r/Reds • • Aug 26 '23

Playoffs? Nah, let's pitch Brett Kennedy for 4 innings instead.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Reds • • Apr 09 '15

I Fucking Hate People Enjoying Themselves

13 Upvotes

Seriously. If you're going to spend money and go see my favorite baseball team, can you at least try to have less fun? I'm the idealized fan and I know exactly how people should behave in the presence of my favorite club, and let me tell you, some of these people get it flat out wrong. Personal enjoyment ought to be banned so that perfect fans like myself can not pay for tickets and enjoy the game from the comfort of my own home without it being ruined by other people enjoying themselves.

In other words, shut the fuck up about the wooing. People are having fun, they're going to the games, they're having a good time. You sound like the kind of people who watch friends play "Rock Band" while lecturing that they're not really musicians. Just let people have fun, god forbid someone enjoy themselves at a baseball game.


r/Reds • • Sep 15 '23

The Reds in The Playoffs

1 Upvotes

Hey Guys! Brewers fan/writer here, just wanted to first off say I'm really rooting for you guys to get hot and into the playoffs, with the asshat owners and exciting rookies, I think this team as it was pre trade deadline deserved the shot. I am wondering though, sitting one game out at the moment, how much consternation is going on about the lack of TD upgrades? Canha and Santana have been big for the crew, really solidifying the offense, and I can't help but wonder if the Reds had added some veteran experience in the rotation, or even outfield help.

So is there a lot of ill will directed towards the lack of moves looking back on it?

Hoping you guys get into the playoffs, as a fanbase you guys definitely deserve something to get behind in October, and as we all know, once you're in, you can win


r/Reds • • Mar 22 '24

:reds1: Commentary The Marge Schott Curse

2 Upvotes

I just looked at the active roster. Marge would've sent 19 players to the barbershop before opening day.

Can you imagine how mad she is up there about India? Long hair, check. Facial hair, check. Living with his fiancee, check.

Is reversing this curse the golden ticket to a dream season?

We just need India to elope in Vegas on the way back to Cincy and for the entire team to show up clean-shaven with military cuts by March 28. If a single player arrives with an earring, the 2024 season will be cancelled.

Men, you've got six days to fix this. Don't let us down.

/s (in case that wasn't clear)


r/Reds • • May 05 '24

:reds1: Analysis The front office does not have the best interests of the fans or players at heart.

19 Upvotes

Which is fundamentally a failure at every level. We wasted Joey Votto, we still haven’t won a playoff series in the 2000s. Why?

We, as fans, care about winning, so of course we are tempted to interpret every choice as though it’ll be helpful for the team on the field. But that is not even close to their top priority. They have PR people and Nick Kirby to spin everything as ‘this is actually good for the Reds’.

But they do not care about the Reds. This is an investment for them. The standings are background noise, playoffs are just more billable hours for workers. They do not live in our world, they occupy a plane much more sinister.

In sports, you generally try to capitalize on momentum. The 2023 Reds had momentum. They exceeded our wildest expectations after a 100 loss season and were in first place in late July, perhaps the hottest team in the majors. And we all know what happened after that.

You can’t tell me we were so worried about prospects that we had to do that. (We just let Mike Ford leave for nothing! Where is this immense gold mine of rookies now? Why was maybe winning later more important than a meaningful, tangible chance at winning now? I don’t understand how you can watch the games and pull that ‘optimism’ facade off. (My favorite TV show is on for 3 hours a day all summer and I don't get emotionally invested in the episodes or outcomes or characters or plots at all, I'm waiting for it to be good 3 seasons from now. Maybe 5.)) Not making a move there to bolster the confidence of the rookies, the team, the fans was an absolute disgrace. I don’t care what the market for pitching was — it is a disgrace to say to a team that had worked so much magic up to that point: “Well, let’s wait til next year and see.”

That group of guys was in first place in July despite Luke Weaver starting 15 games. Despite the absolute state of the bullpen. Despite $10M in free revenue from disgracing the jerseys with Kroger ads. (Where did that go? Candelario??)

The only clear-eyed conclusion you can come to after witnessing this, year after year, ‘wait til next year’, is that they don’t care about baseball the way that we do. A middling .500 team with cheap rookies is better than a ring for them. You can string the fans along, build this narrative of hope and fight and the Rally Reds, get the attendance numbers, watch them fall short, and go back to looking at your revenue spreadsheets (or golfing or a fifth of whiskey or whatever).

Sell the team. Or at least set up a gofundme.


r/Reds • • May 10 '24

Coach

2 Upvotes

Anyone else tired of the lineup lottery every night? I know the 1-6 hitters on most teams and they don't change. When the opposing team throws a lefty, Bell tries to put 9 right handed bats in there. Doesn't matter if they belong on the MLB roster or not. Can our lefties not hit a lefty? I don't understand. I understand it for pinch hitting situations but how can anyone get comfortable in a lineup when you are constantly being shuffled? These guys don't even know if they are playing when they show up to the park. Look at any other good team. There 1-6 does not change daily.


r/Reds • • Jun 28 '23

My proposal for the Cincinnati Reds to trade for Shohei Ohtani

0 Upvotes

TLDR: The Reds have had a very magical past 2 months and should look to make themselves a legitimate threat. The Angels have had disappointing success with only Trout and Ohtani as their sure-fire superstars and should look to get deeper and remain competitive for the long-term (without breaking the bank).

Ok, I'm going to caveat this post with a bunch of things:

  1. Not a baseball expert, casual (lifelong) fan of the Reds and would love for them to take advantage of their momentum this year to turn themselves into something meaningful.

  2. I did my best to layout why I think this could work but I understand the chances of something like this are like 0.0001%.

  3. The Angels are completely in contention and likely would never even consider trading Ohtani anyway

  4. I have 0% faith that the Red's owner would ever want to pay Ohtani what he's going to be looking for.

My proposal:

Reds receive:

  • (SP/DH/OF) Shohei Ohtani [and sign him to a long-term extension]

Angels receive:

  • (OF) T.J. Friedl

  • (3B/INF) Cam Collier

  • (RHP) Chase Petty

  • (Probably at least one other player - say someone like Rece Hinds or something)

Background: The Reds are pretty insane right now, they have a bunch of young guys leading the charge and have more hype than any other time I can think of in my life, not to mention that they still have a ton of potential high-end talent in the minors and not enough positions to go around on the MLB team. They also desperately need rotation help to even have a shot at the post-season. The Angels are really competitive right now but floundered in recent years with Trout and Ohtani only being able to carry them so far into the playoffs and Ohtani is looking to get paid. My proposal would be for these teams to work out a trade that could benefit both sides.

Assumptions:

  • The Angels would even entertain these talks.

  • The Reds would figure out a way to lock up Ohtani long-term.

  • The Angels are looking for long-term prospects as well as guys to help them stay competitive this year.

  • I used https://www.baseballtradevalues.com/trade-simulator/ to try and mock up some fair trades

  • The Angels and Reds completed the Raisel Iglesias trade back in 2020 so my hope would be that the front office of each team know each other pretty well and are interested in dealing.


r/Reds • • Aug 29 '22

:reds1: Commentary Let’s be thankful the Reds traded for all those shortstop prospects

0 Upvotes

Because Jose Barrero is hitting .167 since coming up. Great defensively,and before you all get mad and say give him time, this man has had time. He will be a good bench piece.


r/Reds • • Jul 21 '24

Doomer = A Realist

0 Upvotes

It’s time to stop calling people doomers. We are being realist. We have decades of proof. Prove me wrong.


r/Reds • • Nov 30 '23

Do you think the Reds should make a trade for Juan Soto?

0 Upvotes

Title. Soto would rake in GABP.