Which is fundamentally a failure at every level. We wasted Joey Votto, we still haven’t won a playoff series in the 2000s. Why?
We, as fans, care about winning, so of course we are tempted to interpret every choice as though it’ll be helpful for the team on the field. But that is not even close to their top priority. They have PR people and Nick Kirby to spin everything as ‘this is actually good for the Reds’.
But they do not care about the Reds. This is an investment for them. The standings are background noise, playoffs are just more billable hours for workers. They do not live in our world, they occupy a plane much more sinister.
In sports, you generally try to capitalize on momentum. The 2023 Reds had momentum. They exceeded our wildest expectations after a 100 loss season and were in first place in late July, perhaps the hottest team in the majors. And we all know what happened after that.
You can’t tell me we were so worried about prospects that we had to do that. (We just let Mike Ford leave for nothing! Where is this immense gold mine of rookies now? Why was maybe winning later more important than a meaningful, tangible chance at winning now? I don’t understand how you can watch the games and pull that ‘optimism’ facade off. (My favorite TV show is on for 3 hours a day all summer and I don't get emotionally invested in the episodes or outcomes or characters or plots at all, I'm waiting for it to be good 3 seasons from now. Maybe 5.)) Not making a move there to bolster the confidence of the rookies, the team, the fans was an absolute disgrace. I don’t care what the market for pitching was — it is a disgrace to say to a team that had worked so much magic up to that point: “Well, let’s wait til next year and see.”
That group of guys was in first place in July despite Luke Weaver starting 15 games. Despite the absolute state of the bullpen. Despite $10M in free revenue from disgracing the jerseys with Kroger ads. (Where did that go? Candelario??)
The only clear-eyed conclusion you can come to after witnessing this, year after year, ‘wait til next year’, is that they don’t care about baseball the way that we do. A middling .500 team with cheap rookies is better than a ring for them. You can string the fans along, build this narrative of hope and fight and the Rally Reds, get the attendance numbers, watch them fall short, and go back to looking at your revenue spreadsheets (or golfing or a fifth of whiskey or whatever).
Sell the team. Or at least set up a gofundme.