r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Apr 07 '23

Music is subjective and we love different albums for different reasons, they’re all winners!

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Feb 09 '23

Unpopular opinion. Josh’s work on his albums is better than John’s comeback. I fully regret never seeing them live with Josh.

0 Upvotes

The new songs did NOT hit live in Melbourne. I heard people literally saying new track time to hit the bar. People were not interested.

Josh actually has a mega hit to his name and they refuse to play any of his work. In a recent interview with Josh he mentioned John was upset at the fact the band would go on without him.

I love John, I love his contribution to the chili peppers but I think his ego gets in the way. Their latest two releases really missed and I often think about the 3rd Josh album.


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Dec 03 '24

You’re all wrong besides me, I’m right, I’m a little pea

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Apr 10 '23

I’m sorry, but The Strokes sucked as an opener

49 Upvotes

The Minneapolis show…. I found them very sloppy, unprofessional and down right boring. We all had to sit through a very awkward birthday bit for a guitar player. Also a mini thing about Prince, that was barely coherent. Dude seemed like he was pissed he had to be there. I’m sorry, you’re opening for the RHCP… respect that!

Edit: my main point being they showed very little respect for the situation, imo.. that’s cool if dude wants to play the “bored rockstar” cliché.. then rock on man. But you are opening up for true legends. Fuck you for making me pay to see you “bored” when countless people and bands would trade places in a heart beat.It should be an honor to share a stage with Chilis... treat it as such.


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Aug 17 '22

Hot take- Stadium Arcadiam is a great album.

17 Upvotes

Edit: Yes I know Arcadium.


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Jun 20 '22

[DISCUSSION] I will take The Getaway over Unlimited Love even if only slightly.

25 Upvotes

Both great late era albums but The Getaway has a vibe that UL doesn’t. There is a feeling of just getting started and knocking the rust off on UL- despite how great it is- which makes me think what may follow could be a top album of their career.

Two and a half months since release, how do you view The Getaway and Unlimited Love?


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Aug 09 '22

[DISCUSSION] Anyone have a more sour taste of Flea since UL was released?

38 Upvotes

From the details of the way he treated Josh on his firing, to his podcast with Rick on his relationship with Chad, to him now saying he won't take pictures of fans and not actually answering why not, and then not addressing the hypocrisy when someone showed him and KAJ's picture, I can't help but feel he's not as good of a guy that I thought he was.


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Nov 10 '23

[SPECULATION] John can end all the current wars going on rn but only if he played songs written wth Josh Klinghoffer and Navarro for 1 special concert. do you think he'll set his ego aside this time and bring Peace and Love upon this earth or he'd rather see it burn and let all the innocent kids and women suffer?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Jun 18 '25

Nine years of The Getaway, the best album ever.

8 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Aug 10 '24

[DISCUSSION] Why cant we discuss how Anthony Kiedis was a pedophile?

0 Upvotes

If we cant discuss it and still enjoy in spite of what he has done doesnt that just stowly kill the following?


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Jan 31 '22

[DISCUSSION] I dislike Snow and here is why.

0 Upvotes

Don’t kill me. I just feel like Snow missed the mark. I get the cool Hendrix kinda riff. I get that it was a huge SA single. But man, I just can’t do it.

It feels inauthentic to me. Not necessarily uninspired but just- I can’t even fully say. It just does not do it for me. Never has. And RCHP is a top ten band of mine.

Don’t kill me! Help me to see what I’m missing if I am wrong. Thanks gang!


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Apr 17 '26

Do you still love him despite Anthony's controversies?

0 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Sep 09 '21

New song in 12 days?

1 Upvotes

I have heard the rumor that a new song will be released on September 22nd and possibly days later the album, what do you think?


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Oct 06 '23

[DISCUSSION] RHCP Album Tier List

Post image
4 Upvotes

Hey y'all back again, I've been listening to a lot of RHCP stuff that I never gave a chance before. so I thought it would be appropriate for a updated tier list. Here you go :)


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Mar 11 '26

psst...the josh albums are better than the recent john albums

96 Upvotes

I don't know if it's josh's new influence on those, or the guys getting back together and falling into familiar grooves but like - Monarchy of Roses, Ethiopia, Brendan's Death Song - these are fucking amaaaaazing songs and John had nothing to do with them.

I'm a lifelong John stan but I've just got to say, I don't think he brought that much when he came back. It's very middle of the road.


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Jul 20 '22

[DISCUSSION] Just listened to I’m With You from start to finish. From Stadium Arcadium, an album full of atmosphere, huge sounding songs, full of guitar solos and passion to this uninspired, boring, poorly written record with the exception of maybe 2 or 3 songs. Whats every1s thoughts? Is it purely down to Josh?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Aug 12 '21

[SHIT POST] IM DELETING YOU, ANTHONY KIEDIS!😭👋

0 Upvotes

IM DELETING YOU, ANTHONYKIEDIS!😭👋 ██]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]] 10% complete..... ████]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]] 35% complete.... ███████]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]] 60% complete.... ███████████] 99% complete..... 🚫ERROR!🚫 💯Anthony Kiedis 💯 is irreplaceable 💖I could never delete you Anthony!💖 Send this to ten other 👪RHCP Fans👪 who give you 💦The Gloaming💦 Or never get called ☁️squishy☁️ again❌❌😬😬❌❌ If you get 0 Back: Kick out like Josh 🚫🚫👿 3 back: you're squishy☁️💦 5 back: you're Anthony's girlfriend😽👼💦 10+ back: Anthony😛😛💕💕💦👅👅


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Jan 22 '23

AK really thinks he’s doing something with this at every live show..

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Oct 05 '24

They wrote the new KSI song

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Jan 25 '24

...seriously

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Aug 19 '22

[DISCUSSION] Tippy My Tongue is better than any song on UL.

115 Upvotes

True or false?


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Aug 01 '25

Name a better album. I’ll wait.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Oct 02 '22

[DISCUSSION] Does anyone else think the song The Getaway is one of the boys best ever?

1 Upvotes

Honestly feel like it is criminally undervalued. Should’ve been a single. If any song from the Josh albums I want to see them play now, it’d be this.


r/RedHotChiliPeppers • • Dec 27 '25

[DISCUSSION] I’m Beside You >>>>>> the last two albums

27 Upvotes

I listened to I’m Beside You for the first time in ages today and it suddenly struck me really hard just how much BETTER that collection of B-sides is as an album than the last two albums with John, especially the load of tripe that was Unlimited Love.

Seriously, in every possible way I’m Beside You is superior.

Better songwriting

Better arrangement

Better song structures

Better melodies

Better lyrics

Better vocal production (good takes, less reliance on autotune/more transparent autotune)

Better overall production

Better recording

Better mixing

Better guitar playing

It’s kinda crazy how much higher the quality of the songs they made with Josh at the time were than what they’ve come out with recently.

There are a handful of decent songs on UL and ROTDC is a big improvement on that but really overall neither of those albums come close to IBY. Especially when it comes to Anthony’s lyrics and vocals which are absolutely dreadful on the last two albums.

IBY has SOOO much vibe - the absolutely euphoric rolling repetition of In Love Dying, the industrial rock meets gorgeous melody of Victorian Machinery, the angular funk of This Is The Kitt… seriously, every single song is interesting, catchy, well written, well performed, beautifully mixed - even the little subtle production nuances across the album like the glitchy percussion in In Love Dying - everything is just so much better.

I really loved the direction they were going with Josh and I’m sorry to say that having John back has made them take a big step back in creativity. John had his time, made some incredible albums and then moved on. They should’ve kept Josh, he was keeping them fresh and interesting.

Oh well, rant over. Curious to hear others’ thoughts on this.