r/RedDwarf • • Dec 30 '25

So what is it? Change in views on religion?

12 Upvotes

Not trying to start a debate on religion here. Just curious about whether the writers have had some change of heart along the way.

Am rewatching earlier seasons. Lister is a pantheist. Intolerable Rimmer is atheist. Kryten believes in Silicon Heaven. Cat has Cloister. The show treats faith with respect even while having a fair poke here and there. It includes smart philosophy. I love the ending of 'Justice' where Lister understands why life requires suffering and Cat even follows with a 'Thank God for that'.

But the more recent series have a lot more "hur hur religion is dumb" moments and also has that episode where Kryten gives the universe an existential crisis which he solves with some of the poorest bottom of the barrel philosophy going. Rimmer also seems to be a believer in the Church of Judas, no longer a lapsed Seventh Day Hoppist. And they blame Christianity for loads of wars, which is factually incorrect. It's like it can't be the same smart people behind it. Did something happen?


r/RedDwarf • • May 18 '24

Takin' the Smeg I’m sorry… what the hell am I even watching?

0 Upvotes

I have heard that Series VIII was bad but this is just dumb, it’s just been sex joke after sex joke for the past 5 episodes, now I’m on episode 6 and I have just watched a 5 minute boner joke. No wonder I didn’t get to these episodes the first time round. Anyways, I heard good things about Series X and on, also the new TV movie coming in 2025 is something to look forward to but my God is this one of the worst cases of seasonal rot I have ever seen.


r/RedDwarf • • Aug 14 '25

GELFs *are* aliens (functionally)

0 Upvotes

Right so basically what it says. Cards on the table I firmly believe there is life on other planets out there in the universe, the odds of our planet being the only one is astronomically low and it would be deeply depressing if it was.

But regardless I accept that in the fiction of Red Dwarf Earth is the only planet with life forms. However clearly the writers got around that by creating GELFs and other creatures that are descended from Earth but have spread across the universe over the last three million years.

And I’m here to say that makes them technically aliens. Their distant origin might be on Earth but they’ve had three million years to evolve and develop new cultures and societies on other planets. Things like the Kinitowawi are fully formed warrior cultures that evolved without any human influence at all. It’s likely a lot of them forgot there ever was an Earth.

Humans have only existed on Earth for 300,000 years and human civilization is only about 6,000 years old. So for many Gelf and droid and other civilisations that means they’ve had way way longer to change and evolve. There might be whole planets, warring cultures and other things like that. A thriving universe full of a variety of species and creatures.

There’s a common trope in sci fi precursors ancient aliens that started everything and maybe even seeded life. Intentionally or not that’s what Red Dwarf did with humanity.

The universe was dead and empty until humans came and seeded all life in the universe. Now there’s a densely populated universe full of races of creatures, reptile, mammal, fish, bug, squid and weird ones like the Polymorph. And when the human race went extinct they became a myth and all these new civilisations took over.

Which kind of makes Lister God in the sense that he’s the last human, the last of the Precursors.

So yeah it’s not technically accurate to call them aliens but by this point they’ve been colonising and living on non Earth planets longer than humanity has even existed. I’d say that counts.

Also Quagaars.


r/RedDwarf • • Oct 16 '24

Takin' the Smeg Never meet your heros... On weed 😂

Post image
2 Upvotes

Last night there was a new show on the Beeb with Lenny James and it reminded me of a classic RD smeg up!!

Back in my uni days, I had a classic celebrity encounter at the Notting Hill Carnival that deserves a sitcom episode. So, there I was, blissfully baked, when a friend spotted a bald guy with a gotte and glasses munching on jerk chicken. He screams, “Oh my god, it’s him!” Naturally, we sprint over like we're training for the Olympics.

I had been watching "Buried" and, in my herb-induced haze, was convinced it was Lenny James (The Walking Dead) I couldn’t resist: I hugged him like we were long-lost pals, raving about how I watched his show and how brilliant he was. I even offered him a ready made spliff, thinking I was the coolest person alive.

When we’re leaving, a confused friend asks “who was that?” I say with pride, “Lenny James!” My other mates facepalm. “No, you idiot, that was Danny John Jules!”

Totally get why they say you should never meet your heros 😂


r/RedDwarf • • Mar 30 '24

Only Joking Lister wants fish

1 Upvotes

r/RedDwarf • • Feb 04 '25

Takin' the Smeg Why is The Inquisitior an episode with the most inconsistencies and illogical scenes?

2 Upvotes

Edit: I'm putting edit here in case some people find this too long as some comments suggest. Thanks to all that actually engaged in the discussion and added couple of things. That's what I hoped for. I know it's "just a TV show" but I like to analyse, discuss etc. The rest of you.. I don't know.

I've made a list of Why is The Inquisitior an episode with the most "why didn't they just do this?" Here goes:

The Inquisitior visits Thomas Allman and basically wakes him up to tell him he's been deemed unworthy of existence and therefore he'll be erased. Thomas clearly confused asks Is it you mother? The Inquisitior proceeds with erasing him and Thomas is asking Why me? Reply is All will be judged. Expect you Thomas you lazy dick. You had no trial I just decided to erase you.

Why did the Inquisitior bother with taking control over Starbug to judge the boys on Red Dwarf? Can't he judge them where they are right now?

We all covered that Kryten and Rimmer shouldn't be judged at all because Kryten is a robot and Rimmer died which literally makes it pointless to erase his existence. Cat technically shouldn't be judged either because he's not human. Is Inquisitior visiting really every soul capable of thinking and giving the world such pleasure for having a great ass?

They are judged by themselves. True the Inquisitior says it's metaphysical but still unless you have serious suicidal thoughts or existential crisis your survival instinct would prevail.

Is it fair to judge someone's existence when they're in their mid twenties? Or did The Inquisitior's clock actually showed Lister as 3,000,025 years old?

The Inquisitior surgically removed Lister and Kryten from time but he already created new Lister and Kryten before getting rid of Old Listy and Kryters? At the begging he completely removed Thomas Allman before creating new one.

Those who were judged and passed had their memory erased? Rimmsy and Cat don't remember any inquisition.

Also new Lister looks and behaves exactly like old Lister so can we expect new Lister would soon be visited by the Inquisitior to be removed and so on?

When the Inquisitior looses his hand+gauntlet his hand "grows" back but not with the gauntlet on. How did he get a second gauntlet? Also if he somehow got another why did he bother chasing the crew if he can clearly posses Lister from far away.

And finally. When they temporarily freeze the Inquisitior why couldn't they just erase him and undo everything? Is he the only one who can erase people including himself? And when they take his second gauntlet why can't he get himself a third one?

Just so you know guys this is purely anecdotal. I love Red Dwarf and all the episodes. I just thought this would be fun to read for some as it is for me! Come on give me five! Or fifteen?


r/RedDwarf • • Mar 14 '25

Series 1-2 summed up in one image

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/RedDwarf • • Oct 18 '25

Someone wrote “Smegma” on the school wall seen in the opening school scene. This movie just keeps on giving!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RedDwarf • • Jan 25 '25

Ok how do we feel about this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

This Elon thing is in the media everyday. Then I remember this scene in Red Dwarf

Do you think it should be removed?


r/RedDwarf • • Jul 06 '25

Series 8 is a real gem isn’t it ?

20 Upvotes

I gave up on Red Dwarf after Series 5 or 6 when it was getting repetitive in its ideas. Randomly watching Series 8 now and it’s brilliant. Fresh ideas and plots and some perfect comedic timing. Lister / Rimmer banter is great and the other characters are very funny too.


r/RedDwarf • • Aug 09 '24

Takin' the Smeg What’s every example of someone ripping off red dwarf you can think of?

0 Upvotes

I’ve recently got britbox and giving the series a rewatch, and my god, I’m starting to think this is the most ripped of show in history.

Family Guy did a backwards episode.

Futurama had a body swap episode that started with someone wanting to get in shape.

Futurama had an episode with time jumps extremely similar to the episode with time echos.

I know a lot of episodes can vaguely point to earlier pieces of fiction, but some are pretty damning if you ask me.

What are some stories on RD that are similar to later works?


r/RedDwarf • • Aug 11 '22

unpopular opinion: Backwards isn't very good. Entire episode based around one "gag". doesn't make sense, and isn't funny. except Rimmer's Father Christmas bit.

0 Upvotes

Edit: Actually that was Listers line.


r/RedDwarf • • Jul 28 '25

Watched Series 1-8 and ranked them in my personal preference

1 Upvotes

Series in order of preference 2 1 3 4 5,6 8 7 What’s your order ?


r/RedDwarf • • Dec 15 '24

Meme What is this?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/RedDwarf • • Feb 04 '17

Is it Just me, or did Series 11 suck?

0 Upvotes

Seriously, was it just me or did everyone else hate series 11. It's just wasn't funny. Instead of Red Dwarfs character based, at time situational, humor it was blah blah blah technobabble, blah blah blah make fun of Rimmer. Let me know what you guys think.


r/RedDwarf • • Feb 09 '25

Takin' the Smeg Crappy episode, but what a guy

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RedDwarf • • Mar 16 '24

Unpopular RD opinions

0 Upvotes

Here's some of mine:

*Doug Naylor >>> Rob Grant. I don't resent Rob for leaving, but ousting Doug years later and writing a script that makes all post-VI Dwarf not canon? Wtf. That's a Rimmer level of petty.

*Backwards is one of the worst episodes. It just feels like they're playing in the editing room. Even on a conceptual level, it's boring. Stuff goes backwards. So what? How is that funny?

*Timewave was ahead of its, well, time.

*I don't mind Gunmen of the Apocalypse, but I don't really get the love for it either. It's a western pastiche. Mid tier Dwarf.

*VII-IX were hit and miss, but I remember them way more than III-VI. I like that Doug tried to experiment with the format.

*The Cat didn't become likable until the Dave era. And he was intolerable during I-II when half of his dialogue was just random singing. They should've told Danny to take it down a notch or twenty.

*Whiny VII Kryten is easily Llewelyn at his funniest.

*I much prefer being on Red Dwarf to being on Starbug. The episodes set on Starbug almost always tend to be some wacky sci-fi concept instead of character comedy.

*I've never liked the casting of Mac MacDonald as Hollister. He just looks bored in every episode and doesn't add much.

What's your unpopular opinions?


r/RedDwarf • • Feb 01 '24

Thought my fellow Dwarfers would appreciate this

4 Upvotes

Youtuber and author The Critical Drinker aka Will Jordan mentioned Red Dwarf as an example of multiverses done right in his video on multiverses. It's so nice to see Red Dwarf acknowledged for its fantastic writing.

https://youtu.be/7wbze2o3WuY?si=420LESA05qaOCYhE&t=625


r/RedDwarf • • Jan 17 '25

Meme This going to sound very strange but the only reason I found this subreddit or the theme song for this show i never watched is because of this lolcow channel.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Idk what to say but yeah the song is great.


r/RedDwarf • • May 02 '25

Discussion S7 - I just can’t

26 Upvotes

I gave up on RD completely at some point during Series 7. For me it just fell apart. The writing was awful and the storylines were lame. Pretty sad about it as it had been such a great show in my formative years. I just had another go and gave up after Episode 2. I couldn’t bear it. It’s just not enjoyable.

Did it ever get better? Is there another series I can jump to when it got its spark back? Or shall I just go back to enjoying Series 1-6 again and pretend that’s all they made?


r/RedDwarf • • Feb 20 '25

Discussion Major nitpick/pet peeve

0 Upvotes

I hate the way Red Dwarf's interior looks like in series 3-5.

In the first two series and in the Dave era, the ship is so well defined, it's lit normally and it looks functional.

Series 3-5 Dwarf looks like a vague mesh of Alien/2001: A Space Odyssey. The bunkroom and the science room are lit in sickly yellow, and the rest of the ship has one light bulb per corridor. It's simultaneously an eyesore and too ambitious. The characters don't fit in it at all.

EDIT: Back to Earth is probably the worst design, though.


r/RedDwarf • • Mar 07 '25

How come no one's adapted the Hobbit with Norman Lovett?

1 Upvotes

He's already a Hobbit.

(Danny can be Gandalf)


r/RedDwarf • • Sep 22 '25

So what is it? Changing of Holly between seasons

8 Upvotes

Was there ever any clear explanation for this or are we sticking this in the each season is set in its own unique universe type of thing which I've just basically always done.


r/RedDwarf • • Dec 28 '24

What's going on with Barrie's chin here?

Post image
17 Upvotes