r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Oct 14 '26

Spoilers All The fool being toxic Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I’m currently reading the tawny man trilogy. When fitz tells the fool he isn’t attracted to him in a way that he wants to bed him, the fool should’ve just taken the L. That happens to all of us. Unrequited love is harsh, but we must understand and move on. It was kind of disappointing to me that it’s still lingering almost through the second book. No one wants rumors themselves flying around. There is nothing wrong with only being attracted to a certain type of people. I will see how this all turns out……


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Jun 18 '26

Assassins fate, servants. Spoiler

Post image
1 Upvotes

Alaria and Vindeliar to Bee after they pass through the first skill pillar.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Feb 04 '26

Farseer Trilogy - Verity is dumb?

0 Upvotes

I'm sorry for being blunt here - but coming into this trilogy, I expected Fitz to be making horrible decisions all the time based on so many reviews. After reading it, I can't help but notice that he was just going along with what was thrown his way - usually by Verity. Fitz made some dumb decisions/mistakes (like not realizing Molly was pregnant), but Verity is on another level.

This dude is so clueless about everything going on around him, even though Fitz and others notice and tell him. Few examples below:

  1. He has no idea how his wife feels, and ignores her all the time. He is then surprised when he finds out she is depressed, even though Fitz specifically told him that she needed him around more. Wtf?

  2. At the end of the first book, he acts like he can control Regal (even though he tried to kill Verity). It was clear to basically anyone that Regal would not stop. The guy then decides to embark on quest and leave the kingdom to his evil brother who already tried to kill him for the throne.

  3. This quest is something he said "he had to go do alone" and that only he could do it. Turns out, he wasn't even needed and someone with Wit/Skill like Fitz could have finished the thing a long time ago, and Verity could still be alive.

  4. He knows the public doesn't like him very much, but refuses to do anything to fix it. He doesn't even try. He just sulks and says he wishes Chivalry was still around.

Anyways, Verity just came off as a nice guy, but completely oblivious and stupid. He really would have been an awful king (though not nearly as bad as Regal).

Also - I just finished the trilogy. This last book was rough. Just constantly setting up camp and drinking tea. Completely different than the first two books, which I loved. I hope the rest of the series is more like the first two.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Jun 21 '26

Opinion on age gap in Tawny Man and Liveship Traders trilogy

1 Upvotes

Hello!

I discovered Robin Hobb’s Realm of the Elderlings earlier this year and have already read the Farseer Trilogy, the Liveship Traders, and the Tawny Man trilogy. So far, I’ve really enjoyed all of these books. However, there’s one thing I don’t understand: the age gaps in some of the romantic relationships. I’m specifically talking about these couples:
- Malta (13) and Reyn (20)
- Elliania (12 at the start, then 13) and Prince Dutiful (16, I think)
- Even Molly and Burrich, though that’s a bit different (less disturbing I would say)

My issue is that I don’t understand why the author chose to pair such young girls with much older boys—men, really. Personally, I find it unsettling. I also don’t buy the explanation that “you could tell she was already a woman in her mind,” which is used for Malta and Elliania. The books describe these girls as growing up faster and maturing quickly to face the challenges in their lives.

But at the same time, the prince and Reyn are sometimes described as immature, and by the end of the books, it’s mentioned that they’ve matured or that the prince is developing his royal aura, or something like that. My point is, both the girls and the boys are still growing and maturing through their experiences. So why didn’t Robin Hobb just use older girls to match the age of the men? Either way, they’d still have to grow up and mature.

This is especially confusing when sexual desire is involved. I mean, both girls were only 12 or 13. I’m not denying what they might feel, but I don’t think it’s okay to pair them with 16- to 20-year-old men.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Aug 10 '26

Real quick pass at a live cast for the Farseer Trilogy

Post image
0 Upvotes

Obviously missing some very notable characters, but this is what I've got so far. Open to suggestions, but I will not be accepting anything other than Brad Dourif as Chade. Also, the trilogy takes place over a long time, so just assume any actors chosen can be made to look age appropriate for their role and/or that a suitable child actor would be found for the younger versions.

FitzChivalry - Eman Esfandi
Burrich - Josh Brolin
Chade - Brad Dourif
Kettricken - Anya Taylor-Joy
Molly - Odessa A'zion
Regal - Austin Butler
Patience - Anne Hathaway

Shrewd - ?
Verity - ?
Lacey - ?

Let me know what you think and who you'd hypothetically cast differently!


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Oct 20 '26

Spoilers Fitz and Fool Really loved the books, but that ending…

8 Upvotes

Really did not enjoy that ending, mostly because I don’t like the Fool’s character.

I don’t get how what he and Fitz have is not considered an abusive relationship. All the Fool does is use and manipulate Fitz, causing him great amounts of physical and mental pain, then he abandons him - knowing this will cause him even more pain - because he “has to”, only to return again when it’s convenient for him/he needs something from Fitz.

How is he the person that Fitz abandons his freaking daughter to a bunch of people who he at least knows are wildly incompetent for? How is he the person that Fitz “loves the most”? More than Kettricken, more than his own daughter?


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Sep 29 '26

Liveship Traders, does it get better?

2 Upvotes

I started Liveship Traders about a week ago and I’m 200 pages in. I feel like it’s almost like a car wreck, where you can’t look away. Does the story pick up or will I ever like any of the characters? I really want to like it but everything is pure misery and no brakes.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Aug 26 '26

Convince me to pick up Ship of Magic

0 Upvotes

HELP!! Ok, so I read and devoured the Farseer trilogy about a year ago. I took a little break and am wanting to dive back into this world, but I may be in a reading slump. I think that starting a book that doesn’t involve Fitz is a roadblock for me. Without spoiling, convince me to pick up this book!! I’m itching to pick up a series.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Oct 08 '25

Do I DNF Ship of Magic?

1 Upvotes

Loved the first farseer trilogy and trying to do the series in order but I’m 20 chapters into Ship of Magic and I am not interested in the slightest, does it get better or have I got to a point where if I don’t like it now I won’t at all?


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Aug 25 '26

If I’m not liking it now, will I?

0 Upvotes

I’m reading this series for the first time and I’m about 70% of the way through Royal Assassin. It’s not really that I don’t like the story. It’s entertaining enough for me to get through almost 2 books. It just hasn’t gripped me yet. I’m reading it to check the book off my list more so than because I am excited to know what happens next.

One of my problems is that I am finding that I dislike Fitz more and more as I go on. As someone else here said “get it together Fitz!” Really sums up my feelings towards him.

My other problem is that I feel like nothing is happening. It feels like a really long slice of life type of book, which is not really what I want in a fantasy series.

Does Fitz ever get more likeable? Do things get more exciting/puzzle pieces start to come together soon? I don’t want spoilers, just want to know if I’m not really into the story yet do you think I should put it down?


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Nov 05 '25

Finished Chapter 17 of Assassin's Apprentice. This is how Robin Hobb writes Fitz (Assassin's Apprentice Spoilers) Spoiler

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • May 02 '26

Struggling to get through The golden Fool. Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I really want to just rant about all my difficulties with this book and really the tawny man trilogy as a whole. (Also I want to preface this by saying I am only on page 115 of the golden fool). When I finished Farseer, I was so distraught and wanted to get through Liveship Traders as fast as possible to get back to Fitz and continue the story. But to my disappointment, it is not really a continuation of Farseer. I loved Fitz in the first trilogy because of his connection / relationships to all the other characters and literally NONE of them are in the series so far. Like its so devoid of any depth or feeling to me, because it is legit JUST FITZ. At least in Fool’s Errand there was Nighteyes, but now Nighteyes is dead. AND I feel like Fitz does not even care he is dead. I do not feel any emotion or grief from him at all. He is just going about his day to day life. I felt more emotion from Kettricken when, she pulls Fitz into her room and apologises for Nighteyes dying and then cries. Fitz is just so sterile to me. His misfortunes in Farseer, made me feel so deeply for him because we were watching him grow up, but its been 15 years and he has made no growth at all. I also feel no connection at all between the Fool and Fitz because they spend all their time as their aliases. Like I feel like I have to read between the lines and conjure up feelings on their behalf just to feel some type of connection. I also do not understand why he has chosen such a depressing life when he can just go back to his family and friends. Why does he not go to Patience, or Molly or Burrich. Why could he not give less of a fuck about his daughter??? I do not understand him at all. Also I think im struggling adjusting to the first person POV after Liveships. Being in a depressed lonely middle aged mans mind is not that fun. Liveships is literally my favourite trilogy of all time, I LOVED it so much and I am going to be chasing the high of reading Ship of Destiny for the rest of my life.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Aug 26 '26

Does anyone else not want this? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Does anyone else NOT want a trilogy about Bee to come out? I feel like the story of these characters has been told and I don’t really need to see Bee go through more unnecessary suffering (we all know that’s how it would go with Hobb’s writing). I feel like she has beat up this cast of characters enough. I’d be more interested in a story about characters we haven’t met before in a different part of the world.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • May 10 '26

Just got spoiled about fitz Spoiler

0 Upvotes

ya idk but I was looking at the wiki and saw it by mistake how big of a spoiler is it i know nothing else outside of this I have finished the farseer GOT SPOILED ABOUT FITZ BECOMING A DRAGIN


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Dec 19 '25

Can I skip the Rain wild chronicles?

1 Upvotes

Ok. I love the Fitz books. Royal assassin and Fool’s fate are my top two favorite books of all time.

That being said, I did NOT like liveship traders. I went through it because people said it was important even though it felt like a chore to me. I was going to do the same thing with Rain wild chronicles but I can just not get into this set of books. I have absolutely no desire to.

Is it a huge deal if I go into Fitz and the fool without having read the rain wild chronicles?


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Jun 06 '26

Can I just read a synopsis of the Rainwild Chronicles?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been obsessed with the series up until now. I loved the Farseer Trilogy, enjoyed but wasn’t too fussed about the Liveship Traders, and completely adored the Tawny Man trilogy, and tore everything so far in about a month and a half.

I really want to complete this series, so I started the Rainwild Chronicles, and I’m about 15% through the first book. It’s put me in such a reading slump for over a month, not that I don’t like it so far, it just hasn’t gripped me. After reading six books worth of Fitz and the whole cast, trying to get into new characters when I know there’s more Fitz to come is difficult (he’s quickly become one of my favourite characters ever).

Should I continue pushing on, does it kick off soon? I’ve been looking through some posts here and I gather that some of the stuff in the Rainwild Chronicles is important in fully understanding the plot in the next trilogy. Would a synopsis be enough to understand it, or is reading it necessary to get the full background?


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Nov 03 '25

Assassin's fate Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I'm super struggling to finish this. So much introspective flagellation! Is it worth it?

Spoiler removed. I'm 12 hrs deep in the 39 hr audiobook


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Aug 14 '25

Is this how yall see it? Because I disagree (or am I just dumb) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This was a post made on tumblr-

*sits up in bed*

Chade wasn't sure what to do with Lant because he wasn't turning out to be a good assassin, so he sent the kid into Bee's nursery so that Fitz would kill him and solve the problem.

Chade was getting old and forgetful, but he knew full well that 1. Lant was not very sneaky, 2. Fitz is an extremely paranoid and more than slightly deranged person who IS very sneaky, and 3. Chade had ALREADY SEEN what lengths Fitz would go to and how many people he'd kill to protect his daughter.

Chade Fallstar Farseer was there for all of Tawny Man, and he sent Baby Lant to wander between Bee and her daddy who kills people.

Chade wanted Lant out of the picture and he tried to make Fitz do it to keep his own hands clean.

Again.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • May 30 '26

Characters of liveship traders

0 Upvotes

So i have read 2 to 3 chapters in ship of magic and almost all the characters are unlikeable. Like athlea feels like a entitled person and kennit feels narcissistic and selfish af also wintrow feels like he thinks everyone else is below him


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Mar 27 '26

Can I go from Farseer trilogy to Dragon Keeper?

0 Upvotes

I know the order and I've seen the way it truly lays out but I finished the Farseer trilogy and my wife got me dragon keeper. I'm packing for a vacation and I really want to read it. Will it mess things up much? Sorry if this is posted somewhere but I didn't see a clear cut answer.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Oct 15 '26

Spoilers Farseer Trilogy Should I expect noticeable character-growth? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I recently returned to the series (having read the first trilogy about a year ago). Currently reading the Mad Ship but I have a few questions problems with it).

My main gripe with the books so far is that whilst I have no problem reading character focused books even if they experience many hardships I kind of want the characters to grow/deal with their problems. I had high hopes with specific characters in the first Liveship traders book at the beginning but that kind of stopped being the case. Also especially in regards to Fitz I would like for him to start learning a bit more because even though I understand his troublesome starting point, it kind of becomes unbelievable or at least disappointing not seeing him figure things out at least a bit.

As my time for reading is limited and the series is quite long I would really like if someone could tell me if it gets better (especially in regards to Fitz but also the "spin-offs"). And yes I googled this question before posting but there were quite a few conflicting answers. Also this is in no way meant to attack the books, I know tastes differ.

Anyways, thanks for reading and have an amazing day!


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Oct 02 '26

Does liveship traders get any less depressing???

2 Upvotes

Im on chapter 29 of liveship traders and my gosh this is depressing..... i cant think of a single good thing thats happened the entire book as of now. I love the story and am reading it after the first trilogy but someone please tell me there is some light at the end of this depression tunnel. I cant take 2 more books like this.


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Jul 27 '25

Having a hard time with Ship of Magic

2 Upvotes

I'm sorry, I'm having such a hard time with this book. I really enjoyed the Farseer books, but I'm 30% into ship of magic and it reads like a bad soap opera. Is there a payoff or is it just more of the woe is me attitude and pirates not doing pirate things? HELP!


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Aug 25 '26

Spoilers. Liveship traders. Should I tell her!? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

The title said it all. Should I tell my wife that Amber is the Fool

She just went through the assassin apprentice saga. And she continues with the lifeship traders. At this moment she's at the point where Amber carves Fitz features in Paragon. She did not make the link.

Should I help her make the link? Tell her that Amber is the Fool? Or should I wait until she gets into the Townsman saga?


r/RealmOfTheElderlings • • Sep 30 '26

Just started Fool's Assassin - a bit of a vent Spoiler

2 Upvotes

The ending to Fool's Fate devastated me. "I am content", what the hell was that? But I felt much relief in learning that Fitz had been traipsing through the last 15 years forged, and now that he's not, maybe there is some happiness and dare I say better decision making in store for him.

I made in through the Rain Wilds Chronicles and was excited to join Fitz & crew again when I began Fool's Assassin. But so far, all I'm doing is raging at what a terrible husband he's been to Molly.

Starting off strong with the winterfest party, he's gotten so distracted with going ons that he misses the first dance with her. We get a brief glimpse of happiness/excitement from Fitz as he tries to track down the party crashers, while ignoring his wife who just fainted.

Soon after that, we're in a market which Fitz says is meant to be a way to spend time with Molly, yet he says so from the tavern where he's drinking alone while she shops for medicines. A flirty girl asks if Molly is his wife or grandmother. This detail would upset me less if this weren't a first person recollection - why immortalize that small barb in ink, Fitz??

Then when Molly falls pregnant and Fitz's first reaction is to believe she's senile. Perhaps it's easier for me to feel upset about this as a reader who gets to know the conclusion of the pregnancy in 30 minutes, rather than a man who's 53 year old postmenopausal wife claims shes been pregnant for 2 years. But there was a quote from Molly that has stuck with me, when she learns he also doubts her - "I need you to be on my side, Fitz. Even if you think I'm crazy, I need you to pretend you believe me."

Nevermind all the times in talking about Molly that his sentiment is, again, "I am content with her" or "She is enough for me". I'm reminded of a music review where the critic hears a track and says "That was fine", then laughs and follows up with "I guess thats kind of an insult. If you sleep with somebody and they say 'that was fine', then its time to go jump off of a tall building". Fitz is very "this is fine" about Molly overall.

I suspect that's my issue. Fitz is loyal to a fault in a lot of areas of his life, but it feels a disservice to the woman he supposedly loves for him to stay loyal for loyalty's sake.

Thanks for reading my vent. I just wish I could reach into the page and shake him like a snow globe. ​