r/RealTimeStrategy • u/ByzDragon • 2h ago
Discussion I play RTS for the wrong reasons
Most play to beat the other guy. I just want to build a pretty base, while kicking ass. Two mutually exclusive goals, apparently. Age of Empires/Mythology, BFME2, CNC, 0AD - doesn't matter. It all comes down to base building for aesthetic appeal and realism. I should be optimizing building placement for booming and security, but everytime, I end up focusing on just realistic city-building, with conquest a secondary concern. I keep bumping into these two bottlenecks: farms and base defenses.
BASE DEFENSES
I especially loath the physical seperation between wall and towers in RTS design, when they should be integrated.
I would fix it by making outposts cheap, weak, somewhat defensible on borders, outskirts and resource nodes, and placeable anywhere on a map. The strong towers should be placeable only along a bastion wall - like a gate upgrade in many titles. Maybe the tower is a distinct building, but can only be placed on an existing wall foundation, the way trade posts (AOE3) and Town Center (AOM) Is limited to specific sites already placed on a map.
The Stronghold franchise does this best IMO. BFME2 feels like it got the wall system almost right. Segments can be upgraded to more than just gates. It still continued the trend of separating towers from walls, though.
Just imagine a lone tower out in the middle of nowhere. Real soldier could just rush it, break down the door, and kill the dozen men defending it. Lone towers aren't protected in the same way wall turrets are. It's access point is always vulnerable. Constantinople fell fast because a gate was left unlocked. This should be taken into consideration when designing base defenses.
The scenario fort in AOE3 looks like an actual fort, with tower integrated into the very walls. Too bad you don't get cannons on the walls. Just the ridiculous looking Fortified Outpost, the successor of the AOE2 Bombard Tower. Stronghold did it right. Real fortified towers should be part of an actual fortification - a city wall, castle or fort. Not standing out in the open, like it's compensating for something.
Placing initial walls to be large enough to hold all the civic buildings, but small enough to prevent city creep takes a lot of practice. Frequently, I have to demolish my initial wall segments and make new placements.
Should an outpost even look like a lone tower? If an outpost is a frontier fortification meant to defend a strategic point like a resource node, border, or pass, then it should look more like a Blockhouse (AOE3). Castles and Forts could serve this function, but I think they shoild be split into cheap expendable version, and a premium strongpoint meant to control a zone outside the main base.
FARMS
I find the AOE2 town center surrounded by farms meta ugly as hell. It makes no historical and economic sense. Rather than placing houses and farms quickly close to the command center, I place them deliberately to form blocks, destricts, and outskirts.
I believe that the biggest problem with farming in competitive RTS like AOE2 is that there is nothing preventing players from building plots in the middle of a city. Stronghold Crusader had the best solution by turning arable land into a strategic resource. If players are forced to place farms in specific areas to gain access to this resource, maybe a minimum radius away form the first town center, it will add strategic depth.
Turtling might work later in the game with high stockpiles in the granary, but keeping early military production up requires venturing outside the safe zone. Counter rushing would be encouraged, since both sides would be equally vulnerable. This is another reason I like CNC Tiberium series so much. The primary resource is scattered throughout no-man's-land, presenting both opponents with the same strategic opportunities and constraints.
Either way, farms do not belong inside an urban center IMO.
