r/RealPhilosophy • • Aug 26 '26

The more I study and think about the meaning of life and philosophy.. The more I think that a god exists.

27 Upvotes

We can make up just about any scientific theories about how the universe was made, what the purpose of the universe truly is for, when the universe was made… But it hasn’t helped us answer the question: What created that? What created the big bang? How did humans think of the concept of time? Can our concept of time relate to the universe? What is time? If the big bang created the universe, but for what? to see universes reborn and get different evolutinal differences? I don’t believe in a god in a sense of explaining scientific phenomenas, mostly through moral reasoning. But to explain how things are made? Whats matter? Can platos allegory cave explain everything?


r/RealPhilosophy • • May 10 '26

Faith is truer than emperical fact

0 Upvotes

I know nothing outside my subjective reality.

All I know is my perception.

Life gives force to my perception.

All I deam True is through my subjective perception.

What is most True is the basis of my perception, because it is from that which everything is derived.

I would not die for emeprical fact.

Therefore, emperical fact is not the basis of my reality.

I would die for Faith and the people I love.

Therefore, my Faith and love for them is absolutely True.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 25d ago

The Universe is Infinite

1 Upvotes

First philosophy writing (I don't know what else to really call it) and I hope y'all think it's interesting 👀

. . .

You will never fully comprehend the complexities of our Universe, no matter how long or hard you work. There are so many layers to every quark, atom, and electron that it is not possible to see every single detail about anything.
My years of thought on this subject has brought me to a difficult realization: everything is too complex. Our creator, our creations, our possessions–they are nothing we could ever understand. The layers run deep–deeper than any human will ever be able to comprehend. Every rock, human, and blade of grass is made up of something similar to that of a small string–one smaller than the eye can see–that tangles with itself infinitely. These complexities living among one another create more strings, tangling with the next object in a largely different way. The sets of string intertwine, adding more infinites to the already infinite number of layers. 
Humanity is stuck in something I like to call “Humanity’s Box.” This is where all of humanity is held. We can look all we want; We can analyze, study, and invent, but we will never be able to see outside of our Box. Humanity will never see what holds this Box and see the infinite Universe outside of it. Some may say, “We have advanced so much, reaching so far away from our planet, so how come we cannot break out of this Box?” To answer that question, I respond with the idea of Humanity’s Box not being us trapped inside or outside the Universe–it is the idea that we will never be able to fully grasp everything. We can expand the box, look deeper and deeper into the complexities of something, but we can never fully leave that box.
A billion years from now–if humans had some way to live until then–people will be able to understand numerous other layers that make up every physicality. However, no one will ever be able to reach infinity and break free from Humanity’s Box. What others render a concept, I consider a reality. The Universe is infinite; that is a fact. And, if our Universe is something without end, who is to say the makeup of it cannot have the same level of complexity? I also do not speak of this complexity with zero backing behind it.
If you look at another person, you’ll see someone who has changed drastically. Their eyes may have changed color, their interests may have changed, the way they talk may have changed. This is the proof of our Universe’s infinite complexity. This is proof the Universe cannot even understand itself due to its own complexity, similar to how no human can understand themself. It tries to figure out and remember every small detail, but it misses small ones. So it makes everything that makes everything branch out into different paths that were never there before. Then, it begins to fill the small gaps between the branches, creating different ideas you may have never even thought of before–sometimes with things you don’t even think of now.
You see, you were born without a full consciousness at your birth, but due to the Universe’s slight change in details, you have grown into someone with an infinite amount of branches. You like this action; you dislike this feeling; you love this person. You are made up of different complex branches with ever so slight changes that begin to shape you into a new being. This new being is who you are now. You are proof of infinity.
Some may disagree with my views, but that cannot be seen as a sign of stupidity. That disagreement is another proof you have made–the proof of the infinitely tied strings not being one and the same. You show the Universe that you are not one of God’s, Allah's, or some other omnipotent being’s creations–you are one of the infinite creations of the Universe. And, due to your creation coming from an infinite, you, yourself, are infinite as well. 
However, infinite does not mean invincible. You may die, you may feel pain, you may feel emotions, but you are still infinite. When this Universe eventually begins to collapse, it will revert to its original form, breaking everything inside it into nothingness. It does not stay this way forever, though. It will repeat itself. It will break from its dense form of nothing, and it will expand, reforming our concept of time and eventually creating the place we call Earth. There, your great grandparents will someday be created again, leading to your grandparents, then parents, then, eventually, you. It will keep happening over and over… for an infinite amount of time. You will follow the edge of the lemniscate until the end of this current time, but you will never find an end.
Now to wrap things up, I would like to mention one last thing: I am no god. I am no Universe. I am no Higher Being. I am you. And you are me. Because, in the grand scheme of things, every string ends up coming around; it intertwines with every other string–every rock, every human, and every blade of grass–you intertwine with yourself, the ones you love, and the ones you hate. We are not alone; we are one. We are not different; we are the same. We are not finite; we are infinite.


r/RealPhilosophy • • Jul 24 '26

Infinite Soldiers Paradox (Made by Myself)

Post image
8 Upvotes

There is a war happening between kingdom A and Kingdom B. Both Kingdoms are equal in every way. Both nations are large and have Infinite people. So they each have infinitely large armies.

If either of them fight their soldiers are 100% equal and any battle between an equal number of soldiers will lead to everyone's death.

One battle they both send out 1 row of soldiers, infinitely long. They both have the same amount of soldiers (Infinity).

Then kingdom A sends out a second row of soldiers behind the first one, they still (technically) have the same number of soldiers, but Red has 2x more and wins the battle.

Why does red win when Infinity is the same as Infinity?

Edit: Red wins is not the end all solution its just what I think will happen is red has 2 lines of soldiers


r/RealPhilosophy • • 12d ago

CMV: I do not believe in right or wrong

0 Upvotes

Hello, I was scrolling through this subreddit and reading some cmv entries and I feel that this is a different topic than what usually seems discussed here. What I mean by not believing in right or wrong is I believe everyone is allowed to have an opinion and I do not feel as I am the one to dictate whether one’s opinion is wrong or right because in their eyes they may be right or maybe they feel wrong, but this is a small example of what I’m trying to get across, my father is who talked to me about this topic and went over it in much deeper detail but I wanted to raise the question in hopes of a conversation about it as well, as I do truly agree with my father but I am curious on what others opinion on this may be. Of course I would like for scenarios to be included in this topic as well because I do feel like this is a good philosophical topic.


r/RealPhilosophy • • 28d ago

Math and The Divine

0 Upvotes

Consider mathematics. It is numbers and structure, and it was invented by a man, then expanded from that origin. Theorems, formulae, and algorithms have since been built upon it, with infinitely more possibilities yet to be explored. Yet mathematics had a beginning. It started with us.

Sex, by contrast, is something closer to a root of existence. Biology ensures attraction between opposite genders, and pleasure is derived in order to reproduce. This is an innate form of human biology existing independent of us. It never began or ended. It is root in its form.

The same cannot be said about mathematics. What if the first people who invented it had done so differently, or had not done so at all, and it had never been discovered? What would follow? All of the abstraction that now occupies so much concern would simply not exist, because it is entirely man-made.

Or is some form of mathematics truly rooted in nature, since it did advance the understanding of the world? Even so, had it been invented or discovered differently, understanding might differ, and so might the inventions built on it. Or the same inventions might be built upon a new version of mathematics, or perhaps something else altogether.

So if mathematics, that which is considered divine and absolute, is itself an abstraction, then everything else must be questioned: morals, philosophy, science, language, and the rest. All of these are forms of abstraction. Frameworks of the absolute have somehow been developed around them. Definitive codes of morality have been written in holy books; science that revealed the laws of the universe has ironically been built upon this same mathematics; languages that we have created are now the foundation of governance and law bearing real consequence. Yet, within the framework of the accepted abstract, a reality was constructed that enabled the understanding of the universe and the pursuit of innovation that made real impact.

All of this man-made abstraction can serve as a framework for producing real change.

Perhaps the same is true of the mind. A belief, which is abstract, can be posed as absolute, or close to it, and used as a framework to build through the corners of the mind. Had intelligence never been measured, would a person still consider themselves inferior to another? Had time never been divided into milestones, would one feel behind in life? The differences would remain, as would the passing of years. Yet something of their meaning might disappear. 

As a student of mathematics and computing, and a lover of philosophy, this raises an important question: how much of what is called reality is reality itself, and how much is the interface through which human minds make reality intelligible?

This may be the real question.

A man once described how he could never imagine his partner being with someone else, despite having no intention of marrying her. Suppose the biological drive towards sexual exclusivity did not exist, and society had never equated love with possession or fidelity. Would he still feel betrayed at the thought of her being with another person? How much of the hurt remains if neither his biology nor the world around him had taught him to expect her exclusivity? Perhaps the attachment itself would survive, but the betrayal would not. Or perhaps even the attachment is inseparable from the framework through which he has learned to love. This only asks the question in miniature: how much of what is felt is the thing itself, and how much is the interface we are indoctrinated into?

Consider integral calculus. Draw a curve on a sheet of paper and imagine finding the area beneath it. Integration truly gives us a way to determine that area, even when the curve bends in ways that make direct measurement impossible. The framework can tell us precisely what must be measured, even when we cannot find a neat expression for the result. Some integrals resist every method we have devised further suggesting there is a rooted truth underneath. Is this merely a system we invented, or one we are gradually uncovering? The notation is ours, but the result does not appear to depend on what we call it. Perhaps the mathematical framework describes the structure of reality in a way that is absolute, and only the manner of describing it is ours.

And then the scale. It must have started with two rocks and three rocks, and objectively those are five rocks. From there we have discovered geometry, calculus, quantum physics, computers, artificial intelligence, and more. Somehow this ever-growing framework called mathematics keeps capturing reality without deviating from it, conforming back to its own roots, or so it seems. 

Is mathematics divine, or god itself? 

Calculus was invented only a couple hundred years ago. How did Newton even discover it? Newton and Leibniz arrived at it about ten years apart, both already indoctrinated in all the mathematics that came before them. A shared inheritance would explain the convergence, and so would a world that pushes back, and from inside the overlap the two cannot be told apart. Now widen the gap. If someone had reached a similar version hundreds or thousands of years earlier, working from a different toolkit, the coincidence would be much harder to blame on an interface, and the question might finally be answerable.

Mathematics is not a root of existence, yet it is not mere decoration. It is a constrained invention: a human interface that the world presses back against. That pressure separates mathematics from a story. A belief can be made absolute by decree. A theorem cannot be made false by one.

The test then travels. For all other abstractions, the frameworks of the mind, the useful question is not whether it was invented. It is what, if anything, pushes back.

One must aspire to see reality without its abstractions. The mind has been indoctrinated over time into forming an interface, and the task is to see through it. From childhood, we inherit distinctions we rarely seek to question: that truth is preferable to illusion, that certainty is preferable to doubt, that consistency is preferable to contradiction. We come to believe that to name something is to know it, that to explain something is to understand it, and that to distinguish is to discover a distinction that already exists in reality. These ideas gradually become so embedded that we cease to recognise them as ideas at all. The mind has been shaped by the very interface it must now attempt to see through. In fact the very belief that there exists a reality beneath our abstractions is itself an abstraction, another framework through which the mind attempts to make sense. 

Yet one can get closer and closer to the ultimate possibility: a free mind, of clear vision, able to see reality for itself. Through awareness of social norms, of abstractions, and of the root beneath, one can learn to see reality. At the same time the interface cannot be rejected, for without it, even the simplest interactions with the tangible world become difficult to navigate. One must learn to interact without mistaking an interface for reality. Perhaps this is what a full and true life holds.


r/RealPhilosophy • • Sep 26 '25

12 rules for a life that no longer exists

0 Upvotes

Let's start with a thought I’ve wrestled with for a long time: "Hey, isn't Jordan b Peterson kinda right?"

I see his appeal. I see the power in his message. He is wrestling with the most important questions of our time. But I’m not coming at this from an anti-capitalist position. I actually think capitalism, at its best, works better than most alternatives leftists propose. It is a beautifully low-maintenance system that runs on the elegant engine of self-interest.

And Peterson, at his best, seems to understand this. When he talks about God being the base of a person's value hierarchy, it's kinda insightful. He’s taking the old Cartesian circle, the philosopher's leap of faith, and making it psychologically useful. He’s showing that for a person to function, they must act as if a God, a highest value, exists. It's a brilliant reframing of a logical bug into a feature of the human psyche.

My appreciation for him is genuine. I followed him for a while, and with all honesty, I did sense some kind of hope coming back to me after listening to him talk about slaying the dragon and the heroic journey. Because I know, and all of us know it, we are struggling. Intensely. We are lost, and he was a voice like some tough father to lost men.

And then I got to his solution: tidy your bed. Huh? Seriously? In this economy?

This is where the paradox begins. Because the entire framework he is selling is a defense of a capitalism that is already dead.

Peterson is telling people to play by the rules of a merit-based, individual-responsibility capitalism that has already been devoured by platform monopolies, regulatory capture, and rent extraction. He's telling young men to be honorable players in a game where the most successful winners have already abandoned the rules entirely. He is defending a ghost.

By focusing so intensely on individual responsibility, his philosophy becomes a powerful form of personal anesthetic. It helps you endure the hardships of the current system, but it never asks you to question why the game is rigged.

And make no mistake, his method is as old as civilization itself. The trick of using grand, beautiful, and "eternal" myths about cosmic order to justify the brutal, temporary, and deeply unfair realities of the current social order is not new. It's the oldest trick in the book. He's literally using the same methods that were used by slave owners, but with a new academic paint job.

The slave owner did not say, "Obey me because I am more powerful and I will hurt you." He said, "Obey me because this is the natural, God-given order of the universe. Your suffering is a noble and necessary part of a grand, cosmic plan."

Peterson does the same. He takes the very real and personal suffering of young men, and instead of directing their anger at the rigged, unjust, and often absurd economic system that is actually causing their pain, he tells them that their suffering is a timeless, archetypal, and noble battle against "Chaos." He is not giving them a tool to break their chains; he is giving them a beautiful and compelling story about why their chains are, in fact, a sacred burden.

I want to be clear: his analysis that society is emergent from individual psyches is not dumb. His proposed solution is. It is a solution designed for an era that is gone forever. It is a set of rules for a world that no longer exists.

He's simultaneously propping his audience up for being smarter and more realistic, while treating them as idiots who won't notice that his cure is a medicine for a disease we are no longer suffering from. The old capitalism is over. We are now faced with a stark choice between two new, evolutionary paths: a descent into a new form of techno-feudalism, or the creation of a new system of universal ownership.

The real challenge is to find a new system that requires even less maintenance than the old capitalism did.

And this is where Peterson’s project fails completely. He is not a guide to this new, terrifying future. He is a nostalgist, trying to resurrect a corpse. He has given us a masterful diagnosis of the modern illness of meaninglessness, but his cure is a perfect, 12-step guide to a life that is no longer available.

Have the solutions of Jordan Peterson ever had an appeal to you ? Do you think he's got some merit ?


r/RealPhilosophy • • Aug 14 '26

Why existential nihilism often stems from a forgotten truth: We are animals

1 Upvotes

Many discussions surrounding meaninglessness and existential dread seem to share a

Fundamental flaw: they evaluate human existence through an anthropocentric lens, secretly expecting humans to be "above" nature, and then mourn when no grand cosmic purpose is found.
When people conclude that "life has no higher meaning," they are usually comparing human existence to a fictional ideal, a universe designed specifically for us. But from a grounded, biological perspective, this disappointment makes no sense.
Here is why this perspective is flawed:

The Biological Baseline: We are, first and foremost, biological organisms. Our fundamental baseline, our "objective" foundation, is rooted in biology: survival, homeostasis, adaptation, and continuation. Expecting a cosmic mandate beyond this is biologically illiterate.

The Subjective Value Fallacy: The absence of a cosmic, objective purpose does not imply a total lack of meaning. It simply shifts meaning from objective or given to subjective or constructed. The fact that our values, desires, and emotional drives are tied to our evolved neurobiology does not make them any less real or valid to us.

Constructing Meaning: Once we accept that we are animals with a complex conscious experience, the lack of an inherent objective purpose ceases to be a tragedy. It becomes a clean slate. Pain feels bad, joy feels good, curiosity drives us, and connection fulfills us. These subjective experiences are real because we experience them.

Dismissing life as pointless simply because there is no grand divine blueprint ignores what we actually are. We don't need the universe to give us a reason to exist; as living organismsi with subjective experiences, we hold the authority and the responsibility to define what matters to us.


r/RealPhilosophy • • Oct 03 '25

Capitalism is Leaking value, and It’s a Good Thing

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
3 Upvotes

Hello philosophers, I've written a piece on the efficiency of capitalism as a value extraction paradigm, I'd love to hear your thoughts on my idea, thanks !


r/RealPhilosophy • • Jul 07 '26

Is The end of the human Philosophy?

1 Upvotes

r/RealPhilosophy • • Apr 26 '24

New theory

1 Upvotes

So i discovered something mildly interesting which involves human fighting instinct. I found out that human is affected by the so called "Yammagon". So "Yammagon" actually shows how people should act. it was discovered in 1456 by the greek philosopher Sokratis Papasthopoulous. He proved that the epilespy systems in Saturn actually triggered our human brain that dictates fighting. He decided to call it yammagon which indicates that there are 5 in our universe. If we look deeply in the Yammagon cells, we see that yammagon is actually older than the human race, which could mean it affected dinosaurs. This also means that dinosaurs were aggresive because of Yammagons. But when dinosaurs went extinct and humans start to take over, Yammagons thought that we were the new "dinosaurs" and they spread their energy to us. Although this was not as effective to us humans as it was to dinosaurs, the energy still came inside us which means that we can be little aggresive. I also found that it effects people differently. For instance, this is why Hitler was so aggresive because his body consumed lot of energy that was provided to him by the Yammagons.

Thanks for listening folks, ill catch you later when i have done more research

Mr. Fartsmella


r/RealPhilosophy • • 12d ago

Humans Were Created to Discover Reason, Not Simply to Use It.

0 Upvotes

People think they are using their intelligence. But think about it: if human beings were not created with reason, how can they use something they do not possess?

The Creator was Just. He did not place reason inside humans or animals. Instead, He placed it within every reality He created.

My definition of reason:

Reason is the correct relationship toward reality.

Human beings were created with seven elements that enable them to search for and discover that correct relationship. Through these seven elements, we discover reason.

Who can tell me what these seven elements are that help us discover reason?


r/RealPhilosophy • • Apr 24 '26

Have the political left wing and right wing essentially become different cultures?

14 Upvotes

r/RealPhilosophy • • Nov 08 '24

philosopher tier list

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RealPhilosophy • • Sep 29 '25

How conflation, power, and platforms normalize atrocity in Gaza

1 Upvotes

From Sacred Exceptionalism to Shielded Impunity

How conflation, power, and platforms normalize atrocity in Gaza

Thesis (one sentence)

A cluster of mechanisms—scriptural exceptionalism → semantic conflation → ethnonational law → allied impunity → media indexing → platform throttling → open dehumanization → material erasure—has produced, and then normalized, what the UN Commission of Inquiry now calls genocide in Gaza, while critics are chilled by policies that equate anti-Zionism with antisemitism. ohchr.org+1

Premises and scope (audit)

  • We analyze systems of power, not “Jewishness” as essence. The empirical referent is state policy and institutional behavior.

  • The legal baseline: ICJ provisional measures (Jan 26 and May 24, 2024) and the UN COI’s September 2025 genocide finding; these create a duty to prevent for states and firms. icj-cij.org+2icj-cij.org+2

Mechanism 1 — Sacralized exceptionalism (the script)

All three Abrahamic canons tell their own community it is specially chosen—fertile soil for in-group moral licensing when fused with state power.

  • Hebrew Bible: “chosen… out of all peoples” (Deut 7:6; Amos 3:2). biblegateway.com+1

  • New Testament: “a chosen people… a holy nation” (1 Pet 2:9). biblegateway.com

  • Qur’an: Israel “favored above the worlds” (2:47); Muslims “best community” (3:110). Quran.com+1 Claim: Texts aren’t destiny; they are scripts—activated by institutions.

Mechanism 2 — Strategic conflation (the shield)

“Jew” deliberately slides across ethnicity / religion / nationality. Critique of state ideology (Zionism) is framed as bigotry (antisemitism), enabling impunity. Policy uptake of the IHRA definition has been used to police speech in universities; UK ministers even tied adoption to funding. Analyses document chilling effects. theguardian.com+4theguardian.com+4universitiesuk.ac.uk+4

Mechanism 3 — Ethnonational law (the structure)

Israel’s Basic Law: Nation-State (2018) codifies that “the right to national self-determination… is unique to the Jewish people.” That legal architecture formalizes hierarchy at the constitutional level. adalah.org+1

Mechanism 4 — Allied impunity (the backstop)

  • The United States has vetoed repeated UNSC ceasefire texts (six by Sept 18 2025), insulating Israel from enforcement. Reuters+1

  • Germany elevates Israel’s security to Staatsräson (raison d’état)—explicitly in Merkel’s Knesset address (2008) and reiterated by Scholz (2023). This narrows the policy space for accountability. m.knesset.gov.il+1

Mechanism 5 — Media indexing and propaganda filters (the narrative)

Mainstream coverage indexes permissible critique to elite debate; where allied elites are aligned, dissent is marginalized (Bennett’s indexing model). Paired with structural filters (ownership, ads, sourcing, flak, ideology) from Herman & Chomsky, this predicts systematic understatement of state crimes by allies. Stanford University+2oxfordre.com+2

Mechanism 6 — Platform throttling (the amplifier reversed)

Documented, systemic suppression of Palestine-related speech on Meta platforms (HRW), controversial crisis “safety” measures, and Oversight Board rulings show uneven enforcement—limiting the visibility of harm and solidarity. The Oversight Board+3hrw.org+3hrw.org+3

Mechanism 7 — Dehumanization & explicit intent (the permission)

Genocide is about intent. Senior Israeli officials’ public statements—e.g., Defense Minister Yoav Gallant calling Gazans “human animals” while ordering a “complete siege” (“no electricity, no food, no fuel”)—are classic incitement markers; HRW and UN experts have flagged starvation as a weapon. timesofisrael.com+2congress.gov+2

Mechanism 8 — Material erasure (the outcome)

Independent soldier testimonies (Breaking the Silence) and international reporting document the deliberate creation of a deep “kill/ buffer zone” inside Gaza—leveling homes, farms, and industry—consistent with group destruction and territorial reengineering. Breaking the Silence+1


r/RealPhilosophy • • 4d ago

Kids owe their parents nothing. Parents owe the kid everything.

31 Upvotes

Person A lives in Mumbai. Person B lives in Hyderabad. B has never met A and doesn’t even know A exists. A does a task, call it X. Then A calls B and says: “I did task X, so now you’re obligated to do task Y.”

That makes zero sense. B never asked A to do X, never agreed to anything, and has no obligation to A.

Now suppose it’s the very nature of task X that once it’s done, task Y must be done by B. It’s still unfair. The nature of X doesn’t change who chose to do it. A chose X, so the consequences of X are A’s, no matter what X naturally leads to. B had no say in any of it.

Now replace A with the parent and B with the kid. The parent did the task (creating a life), and the outcome was a new person. Parents did the work, the outcome was a new life, and they can’t expect that new life to do anything. The kid owes nothing, and I mean not a single task. Everyone is a distinct individual, and two individuals can owe each other things, but nothing here makes the kid owe the parent.

What the parent imposes on the kid

Nothing about this was the kid’s choice. The imposition isn’t only the big things like going to school or marrying someone. Even if those bring happiness, or sadness, they are still imposed on the kid, because the kid never chose to exist in a world where those things happen.

It goes all the way down:

  • Existence itself. The kid’s life was imposed on them, and so was being a life form at all.

  • Breathing. The brainstem, mainly the medulla oblongata, generates the rhythm of breathing automatically. The kid never decided to breathe.

  • The heartbeat. The heart has its own built-in pacemaker cells that make it beat, and the medulla speeds it up or slows it down. The kid never decided that either.

  • Moving the body. Moving arms, even moving the pupils: the brain and nervous system run machinery the kid never asked for and cannot opt out of.

  • Everything that comes with it. Every need, risk, and limit exists because the parent acted and the kid never agreed.

And it doesn’t matter who the parent is. Even if a person with 10 trillion dollars has a kid, the kid’s life is still imposed by the parents. Wealth can change what the kid’s life contains, but it can’t remove the imposition.

The parent didn’t just do a task. The parent imposed a whole existence on someone who couldn’t say no. That is why the burden is on the parent and not on the kid.

The first burden: justification, before any oweness

Before the parents owe the kid anything, something comes earlier in time. Right after the parents have sex in order to have a baby, the burden of justification falls on them. Not after the kid is born, and not when the kid grows up and asks. Right at the act.

You may ask: justification to whom? The kid doesn’t even exist yet.

But justification doesn’t need a person to hear it. Justification is not an excuse, and it isn’t about protecting yourself from anyone. It is the natural reasoning behind an act. Every act should have a justification, because a justification is just the reason you did it. So the act of having a kid puts a burden of justification on the parent, and it comes way before in time than any oweness. First the parent justifies the act. Only then does the question of what they owe begin.

My principles

  1. The burden is on the parent. Duties come from your own acts. The parent did the act, so the duty is theirs, and the kid has none.

  2. Oweness doesn’t decay with time. The degree of owing is the same now as a month later. A 99-year-old father who created a son still owes him.

  3. No limits on the duty. If parents can’t fulfil it, the answer isn’t “the duty shrinks,” it’s “don’t have the kid.” If a task is extremely difficult or impossible and you still owe it because you did act X, then simply don’t do X.

  4. Acting is signing an unread contract. A should only act if he knows the consequences of the act. If he acts anyway, he has already accepted every possible permutation of it, read or not. He signed anyway.

  5. Kids should help parents, but that isn’t owing. We should help our parents in every possible way, out of love, but nothing is owed.

The conclusion: the kid owes nothing, the parents owe everything, and parents who can’t deliver shouldn’t have had the kid.

Attack it.


r/RealPhilosophy • • Sep 08 '26

I watched a man let his dog out for thirty seconds

3 Upvotes

I was sitting on the street, looking at life passing by when I hear the door of a house slowly creaking open. I see a guy slowly walk out the door, I follow the top of his head. He pauses, and then I hear a dog, it’s nails hit the hardwood floor as he springs up to go outside. The owner opens the gate and lets his dog out on the tiny grass pad in front of the house. The dog walks around, chooses a spot, then pees. The dog walks back to the owner, and they go back inside. I thought to myself; what a terrible life to be living as a dog. And then I realized that the question we ask ourselves to base the quality of an animals life is. How much does the owner take the dog out? Lives a life only inside: bad owner. But why should we treat ourselves any different? Yes animals have their own houses where they can lay and sleep. But none of them has built a nest so comfortable, so attractive and so entertaining, that they wouldn’t want to leave.

Why not you, the consiousness, treat your human body like a dog? It needs to be well fed, follows a diet and is only allowed the ocassional treat, have good bowel movement because your dogs poo tells you a lot about whats going on inside, outside time (every dog is different, some dogs like to socialize and run around at dogs park, some dogs might want to walk around alone, and some will walk around in a basket), and speak to him nicely.


r/RealPhilosophy • • Jul 05 '25

Deep Thinking Debate Take Part ⬇️⬇️⬇️

0 Upvotes

According to you all how was the first thought of knowledge created?

Was it it existential or gained via experience.

If so why


r/RealPhilosophy • • Nov 24 '25

Am I not allowed to follow core virtues I believe in without religion?

0 Upvotes

I have been looking into the biblical prophecy a bit and it seems like the solution they want is for more people to follow the prophecy and that the religious people will win in the end. My question is really only the title. I'm not religious but I don't really have an impact on the prophecy. I just wanna follow my core virtues then die.


r/RealPhilosophy • • May 09 '25

As ancient Greeks investigated the human body, they ran into problems about what blood was and where it came from. Intellectuals, like Plato and Aristotle, developed sophisticated answers to these questions about blood, and more.

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/RealPhilosophy • • Jul 17 '25

The adventures of Professor Playdoh (A Satire on Plato, Philosophy, and idea overload) NSFW

Post image
0 Upvotes

The r/Philosophy reddit is filled with a bunch of intellectual jerkoffs that give into the thing I hated most about my philosophy degree: the elitism. Philosophy should be common spread and I feel its these barriers that make people give up. I can't put the link and the photo in the same post, but I'll be linking the work I referenced in the comments. I really do stand by what I said above, and I thought it might be enough to get them to let it through, but I was wrong. They want to stay in the internet bubble they've created.


r/RealPhilosophy • • Oct 06 '23

A coffee analogy

0 Upvotes

The "coffee question" is a seemingly simple and mundane concept, but it can serve as a profound metaphor for the human experience and our pursuit of meaning in life.

At its surface, the coffee question represents a moment of decision-making, where one must choose between two options: whether to add sugar to their coffee or not. This decision, though trivial in isolation, reveals a deeper truth about the human condition: our constant search for balance and satisfaction.

In the absence of sugar, the coffee represents the bitter and unadorned aspects of existence. It symbolizes life's inherent challenges, hardships, and moments of discomfort. Yet, it is through these experiences that we grow, evolve, and develop resilience. Just as the bitterness of coffee can awaken our senses, life's difficulties can sharpen our awareness and lead us to profound insights.

On the other hand, adding sugar to the coffee represents our desire for sweetness and comfort. It embodies our pursuit of pleasure, happiness, and the avoidance of suffering. This inclination towards sweetness is a fundamental aspect of human nature, as we seek meaning and fulfillment in our lives.

The coffee question mirrors the eternal struggle between embracing life's bitter truths and indulging in its sweet pleasures. Philosophically, it raises questions about the nature of happiness, the pursuit of pleasure versus the acceptance of suffering, and the delicate balance between these opposing forces.

Some may argue that a life without sweetness, like an unsweetened coffee, lacks vitality and joy. Others may contend that excessive indulgence in sweetness, akin to adding copious amounts of sugar to coffee, can lead to shallowness and a fleeting sense of contentment.

In essence, the coffee question serves as a microcosm of the human condition, where we navigate the constant tension between embracing the harsh realities of existence and seeking the fleeting moments of pleasure and comfort. It reminds us that life's richness lies not in the absence of bitterness or the excess of sweetness but in finding the delicate equilibrium between the two.

Ultimately, the coffee question invites us to reflect on our choices, our desires, and our understanding of what it means to lead a meaningful and balanced life. It challenges us to savor the bitterness of existence, for it is in that bitterness that we find the depth and richness of our human experience, just as a well-brewed coffee reveals its true flavor when savored without excessive sweetness.


r/RealPhilosophy • • May 10 '17

Relationship Philosophy question

0 Upvotes

My girlfriend and I were talking about our relationship and about thoughts we were having. Or worldviews differ and so do our reasons for these thoughts. Where they come from, what do they mean?

Our question, and I say our question because she is asking this too ,and she knows I'm posting this, is: what does it mean that she has thoughts, and so do I, that she cannot shake such as that she wants to have children with me. Is it destiny, fate, God, evolutionary instinct to find the best mate to perpetuate the species in the best possible way or what? Why are we having this discussion?  Why do I agree?  Is this a side affect of true love? A logical conclusion of true love?  Or is there something else? I have never had these thoughts before. Never considered having children, starting a family or being able to even be with someone for the rest of my life. But yet these are our discussions. Can anyone relate? What is happening between us?


r/RealPhilosophy • • Sep 29 '26

What comes after reaching complete self control, and a previous habit of mine 🚗💨

0 Upvotes

(Journal Entry)

Swimming

Now I know that I can have everything I want. So it’s not about that anymore. Dreaming and planning doesn’t excite me like it used to, when I was searching for the how, when deep down I knew the person I was couldn’t do it. 
There’s nothing stopping me now.
Desire isn’t what excites me. It doesn’t excite me because I’ve fulfilled it. Everything I want I already have, it’s only a matter of time. There’s no question, no logical reason for anything to be internally out of my control. I guess what I pursue as a person is solving questions. It’s a relentless obsession. I’ve never been able to sit with myself if there was even an ounce of confusion. It created an inability to feel peace, to feel accomplishment. It felt wrong, and detrimental. Like a virus almost. And my brain, like an immune system, needed to put all it’s energy into attacking it before it fucked me up. 
I get to the absolute bottom. I dig up all the dirt, excavate every treasure, and lay it out in front of me, so that I can see it all for exactly what it is.
And now, the next questions unfold. And they have nothing to do with what, but with when.
And I can’t put those questions into words yet, but I'll tell you what I can. I’ll tell you that I think about destiny a lot. 
If it’s real. If it’s determined. What is truly in our control. If the will of our tiny human minds and hearts can really leave a footprint on something so vast and self regulated like the perfectly balanced universe. My hands have finally found the wheel and I've always known how to drive. Now I want to know how fast I can go. Or more so, how quickly I can get to the destination. What it takes to beat the eta.
What is the magnitude of what I can do now and how will that compound as I gain. How full will the bucket become when I squeeze each and every opportunity dry. How far can I push the bounds of destiny until the universe intervenes. That’s what fires me up.
My engine ignites and the location is set. I follow the map and hold the time on it as a suggestion not a definition, and so is the speed limit. Pure curiosity, pure thrill bringing my foot down harder on the pedal. The streets have rules but only a physical barrier can stop this object in motion. Their architecture and the other cars are exclusive to my concentration. I maneuver erratically, tires skid, forceful breaking and acceleration. On the freeway the other cars are slow, I’m not. I find the openings, hit the gaps. I don’t look at the back of the car in front of me and I'm moving too fast to need the rearview mirror. I look ahead, I look at it all, there’s no option to slow down and at this speed I can’t stop. People ask me if I'm afraid I'll crash. To me it’s not a possibility, I'm blind to it. I can’t see collision, I see where I fit, and where I'll keep fitting, connecting like a maze to the empty spaces ahead. They teach you it’s a must to drive defensively, but that’s under the impression that the other cars are unpredictable. I disagree, I know exactly how a driver will act, based on their car and how they’re driving. How clean it is, how dirty. What the cars are doing around it. It’s not asphalt, and painted lines, and vehicles getting to where they want to go. It’s the funnest game in history. The rules? Don’t get caught. I guess that’s the universe pulling me over to stop and think. But what do I know? Most people consider me a dumb driver.