Frustrated home buyer/seller. Spent all of 2026 contemplating a move (sell first, buy second), and it seems like all my options suck, and the market just keeps getting worse.
Current:
2023 SFH, 3 BR, 2 BA, 3-car garage, one-level, 1485 square feet
Bought in 2024 for $409K at 5.375%, current balance $315K
Comps selling for $415-485K in my neighborhood over the past year. I would list around $435K.
$2385/month PITI (Will increase in spring; still unsure how much)
$323/month HOA (Just increased 49%!!! No amenities other than a stupid gazebo!)
Pros: Quiet neighborhood, walking distance to school, nice light
Cons: Small second bathroom, far from retail, 30-minute commute; taxes, HOA, and insurance all rising faster than my salary (even with two promotions since moving here)
Resale:
2003 Townhome, 3BR, 1.5BA, 2-car garage, 1500 square feet
$265K at whatever ridiculous rate
$280/month HOA
Pros: End unit (but back-to-back), private-ish, close to retail, good assigned school, most affordable option
Cons: All original mechanicals, not much natural light, next to busy road (but buffered from trees), longer commute
New construction option:
Townhome, 3BR + loft, 2.5BA, 2-car garage, 1600 square feet
$320K at 5.99%
$306/month HOA
Pros: Same neighborhood as current home, kids stay in same school, walking distance to school, decent natural light
Cons: Near freight train line, interior unit
SFH, no HOA:
Not an option for me. All the SFH under $350K in my area are 50s/60s era fixer-uppers with huge yards that I don't have the money or time to maintain.
Rent:
Rent averages $2,500-$2,700 for a 3BR townhome.
Finances:
Take-home from FT job is $5,300/month (after $500/month goes to retirement). Expenses are $3500/month (not including mortgage and HOA). I have an 18-month emergency fund. No debt other than my current home. The extra PT jobs have been keeping me afloat financially, but I worry about counting on them since they're variable income.
Higher-paying FT jobs require more on-site time (I currently telework), and the 30-minute commute feels like a barrier with kids' transportation and school schedule. To get closer to work would mean an even older, more expensive resale (80s-era townhome, $292K, $380/month HOA).
Are any of these options viable/sustainable? I hate how much strife housing is causing me.
ETA: Recalculated my take-home pay. I can maths.