In Re:Zero, Roswaal is responsible for several undeniable atrocities, from possessing his own descendants to prolong his life to orchestrating events throughout Arcs 1 and 4. However, I believe some accusations against him go too far, particularly those involving grooming.
Let me make one thing clear: Roswaal is a horrible person, but that doesn't mean every accusation against him is justified.
To begin with, grooming generally refers to manipulating a child into developing trust or emotional dependence in order to facilitate sexual exploitation. However, this is not what we see in Ram's relationship with Roswaal.
From their very first meeting, Ram was aware that Roswaal was trying to manipulate her. She knew he was a bad person, understood that he intended to use her, and never believed his intentions were benevolent.
After the events of the side story The Oni Sisters of the Hidden Village, where Roswaal saved them and helped Ram and Rem take revenge on the Witch Cult, Ram willingly swore loyalty to him. She did so despite knowing his true intentions and understanding that he might use or even sacrifice her one day.
Of course, this doesn't mean their relationship was free of manipulation. Roswaal undoubtedly manipulated Ram emotionally. However, emotional manipulation and grooming are not interchangeable, and the story provides no evidence that he intended to groom her for sexual exploitation.
Another accusation concerns the destruction of the Oni clan. Roswaal's decision to let the massacre happen was certainly morally reprehensible, but that doesn't make him responsible for carrying it out.
He neither organized nor participated in the massacre. He simply chose not to intervene. Furthermore, he had no particular obligation towards the Oni clan, yet he still chose to save Ram and Rem and help them get revenge.
If people still want to hold him morally responsible for failing to save the Oni, then they should apply the same standards to Priscilla's, Anastasia's, and Crusch's camps. During Arc 3, they knew the Witch Cult posed a threat to Emilia's camp and the village of Arlam, yet they did nothing to protect them. Despite this, they rarely receive the same criticism for their inaction.
As for Roswaal's actions in the main story, his involvement varies considerably between arcs. He directly orchestrated the events of Arcs 1 and 4, whereas Arcs 2 and 3 are different matters. In the latter, he knowingly chose not to intervene despite having the means to help. Nevertheless, there is an important distinction between allowing something to happen and being responsible for causing it.
Finally, discussions about Roswaal often seem to overlook his positive actions. In the same side story mentioned earlier, he helped Ram and Rem eliminate more than fifty Witch Cultists. He also killed Hector, saved numerous people during the Demi-Human War, as depicted in Wilhelm's EX trilogy, and gave many demi-humans access to education and a chance at a better life.
None of this excuses his crimes or makes him a good person. However, if we're going to discuss Roswaal's character and judge his actions, we should acknowledge the entirety of what he has done rather than selectively focusing on his worst deeds.