Why Division 3 is Just the Worst
If you’re looking to make the playoffs, you can’t do worse than being drawn into division 3. To explain why, let’s take a look at the ticket distribution first:
Division 1 - 1st goes to original playoff, with a bye week, 2nd, 3rd and 4th go to the original playoff too, 5th goes to the new playoff with a bye
Division 2 - 1st, 2nd and 3rd go to the original playoffs, 4th goes to the new playoffs
Division 3 - 1st goes to the original playoffs, 2nd and 3rd go to the new playoffs
Division 4 - 1st goes to the original playoffs, 2nd and 8 best 3rd placers goes to the new playoffs
Division 5 - 1st goes to the original playoffs, 2nd go to the new playoffs.
Additionally the REL RAMPUP, GMan RAMPUP, Stunty Cup winner and the Minors champ will get tickets to the new playoffs.
I’ll be focusing first on the main playoff first, since it is by definition, more important. First thing to notice is the ticket drop from div 1 to div 2; a drop of 1 ticket. The ticket allocation from div 2 to div 3 drops from three tickets to one. One ticket per division remains steady across divisions three, four AND five. Fresh teams have the exact same chance to make the main playoffs that teams in division 3 do. The problem with this is that the level of competition in division three is ostensibly higher than that found in division five, and even division four. And for their troubles, coaches in division three are rewarded with the exact same number of playoff tickets!
So we are left with a system that basically rewards divisions one and two, and lumps everyone else as roughly the same. There should be some reward for playing in division three over division five. I think a much fairer system would be one that change ticket allocation in one of two ways, or perhaps a combination of both:
a) Decrease the difference in ticket allocation between divisions two and three. For example:
Division 2 - 1st, 2nd and top 3rd go to the original playoffs
Division 3 - 1st and top 2 second place finishers go to the original playoffs
b) Increase the difference in playoff ticket allocation between divisions 3, 4 and 5. For example:
Division 3 - 1st and second place finishers go to the original playoffs
Division 4 - 1st goes to the original playoffs
Division 5 – Top X first place finishers go to the original playoffs
This way there is at least some differentiation between divisions 3-5 to reward players for beginning to climb the ladder.
I’ll save you from an extended discussion of the new playoff ticket distribution, as it is by definition, less important. Suffice it to say that the ONLY difference in ticket allocation between divisions 3 and 5, is one extra guaranteed ticket to the new playoffs for division three.
Put another way, you can be the 234th most competitive coach in REL (ie. The least competitive) and have the exact same numerical odds of making the big dance as the 43rd most competitive (most competitive of 3A). However, 43 will be facing, on average, stiffer competition. This doesn’t seem right to me.
I’ll pause here to say this, because it’s important. This is intended as constructive criticism, and as a way I think ReBBL would be made better. I am not taking shots at the admin team, nor am I encouraging others to do so. I’ve been a part of many different gaming leagues, and I’ve found the team here at ReBBL to be better than one could reasonably expect. I daresay the best group I’ve come across. This, however, does not make all decisions infallible or without room for improvement. It is in this spirit I make these comments.
I hope this post generates some public conversation and I think that is always to the good, as long as it stays constructive and on topic.
And now to address some preliminary feedback I’ve received:
-“There are 600 people in the league, not everyone can make the playoffs”
Of course not. But there should be incremental rewards for incremental moves up the ladder. Sorry an extra ticket to the consolation bowl doesn’t do it for me.
-Hey zug, just get good and win your division. Problem solved
“Get Good” is an awful solution to any systemic problem. Sure the divisional winners are happy, but that doesn’t solve the problem for the rest of the coaches in division three, who are getting the shaft.
-there are 600 people in this league and some of them (zug) sure seem entitled to a playoff ticket
I want to make the main playoffs as much as anyone, and I think being in a higher division should earn a higher chance of doing so, which at the current juncture, is the opposite of what happens. Being generous it can be described as equal, until division 2 of course. But if you haven’t figured by now, I find myself in division three, and there’s no way I write this article if I had made division 2. In that regard I am acting in self-interest. However, people rarely work to fix the disadvantages that others are experiencing; it’s up to the affected to do something about it. So here I am. I wouldn’t expect a division 2, or 5 coach to speak up about the problems of division 3. Why would they? Outside of the hassle factor, it would be actively working against their own best interests. Ultimately, any change this might affect likely won’t happen until next season anyhow, and who knows where I’ll be by then. I just think it’s good for ReBBL.
-but zug, you’re assuming that the level of competition is better in division 3 than it is in division 5. Good coaches reroll all the time!
Championship caliber coaches are sprinkled throughout the league, in every division. Teams are certainly more developed in division 3 as compared to five, and therefore on average better equipped for the playoffs. While fresh divisions may have a former champion reroll into them, they may also have newish coaches, experiencing top flight competition for the first time. The latter is not a coach that will be in division three. Besides, isn’t the idea behind promotion to promote good teams? They’ve had at least some success, compared to a fresh team, which may be great but is unproven.
-zug, you’re understating the importance of the consolation playoff. It’s awesome!
Maybe it will be, and if I get a ticket to it, I’ll play my hardest and I’m sure it will be fun. But the main playoff is ultimately what matters to me and why I play in the league. The consolation playoff is just that, a consolation. For US college basketball fans, you’ll remember who wins the NCAA tournament. No one really cares who wins the NIT.
Anyhow, there’s 1,200 words on the subject. I’m happy to discuss it with whoever. I’m around.
mighty zug