r/Rammstein • • 3d ago

Attempting to decrease the shakiness

Trying to see if I can reduce the shaking effect a little bit before my BluRay gets here. Took the Sonne music video as a test and did some editing in DaVinci Resolve. Been staring at the edit for so long, I can't tell if it made a difference. Original video on the left, my edit on the right. Do people notice a difference, or is this a fool's errand?

186 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

77

u/Embarrassed-Turn1277 3d ago

I would say it did make a difference. I kinda like the little shake that your edit could not remove, that actually feels like just sheer vibrations coming off the stage, very powerful.  While the shaking felt way too artificial to me. 

20

u/ltjojo 3d ago

Yeah I wasn't trying to COMPLETELY eliminate it, because it is a cool effect, but it felt overused when I saw it in the theater. Plus, being a first crack to see if this would even work, I didn't want to overdo it

5

u/FlonkyBoi 2d ago

100% it is exactly how it should have been in the first place. Love it <3

28

u/ninjagaidenpatru 2d ago

I'm glad I'm not the only one who finds these official edits weird and a bit annoying. What are they thinking when making these? If I watch a concert film I want to see it kind of like if I was there. The lights and pyrotechnics are already there to enhance the show.

I think your edit is better, but I still find it weird. I don't think you can undo it easily.

6

u/ltjojo 2d ago

Yeah, it probably can't be COMPLETELY undone, but if I can dampen it a bit and have it not happen AS much, then I think that'd be a win. Better than trying to undo Jonas' CGI bullshit from Paris at least haha

4

u/ninjagaidenpatru 2d ago

Oh man, that one was even worse. I get that they try to make it special, but their show and music are already special. The video edits just make it hard to watch.

I am curious what your end result will be, probably a lot better.

1

u/jh5992 2d ago

Where was this one?

13

u/XeNoGeaR52 2d ago

Live at Paris was jumping from a camera to another every second. Whoever is editing these videos should calm down a bit and learn meditation lol

4

u/southass 2d ago

I thought this trend had died, I really dislike those shaking cameras and fast changing angles, let me watch the fucking show without feeling I'm having a stroke!

28

u/ProjektBlackout 3d ago

I seriously disliked the exaggerated fake shaky-cam in this otherwise brilliant DVD.

19

u/randompersonx 2d ago

I agree. Honestly I don’t understand why Rammstein … famous for amazing music videos, who puts on such an amazing live show… insists on having such terrible editing on their live releases.

At least the editing isn’t as annoying as Paris.

2

u/ltjojo 2d ago

That's this film's saving grace. I'm still not a fan of TQP being after the credits, for example, BUT at least there isn't a needless 60 second black screen with no sound before the song. It just dove right into it as the last of the credits left the screen. And thank god there no useless CGI effects

7

u/realMates1 3d ago

I don’t know about other people or you OP, but I really like the shaking in certain most heavy spots like Puppe for example. When I first saw the shaking (I guess right away in AdT, or whatever song used it first) I was amazed, but the repetition and overusing killed it after. How do you feel about it OP? Will you remove it entirely, or keep it in the “heavy” parts?

5

u/ltjojo 3d ago edited 2d ago

For certain heavy parts, absolutely! It's a great effect when used sparingly. Like in Sonne, I probably could have left the first shaking effect after Schneider started the song and the guitars kicked in, then tampered down some of the other needless shaking. I get the effect is to portray the raw power of the show, but....if the camera is shaking for the duration of the entire concert, kinda defeats the purpose of the effect

Edit: damn fat fingers - fixing typo

4

u/realMates1 2d ago

100% agree

2

u/RandalZM 2d ago

I hated the added shakiness. How did you remove it?

3

u/ltjojo 2d ago

Manual editing in DaVinci Resolve. Basically, played the clip, cut it into smaller chunks where I saw shakiness start and stop, and apply a Stabilization filter to the individual segments. Seems like it basically finds a stable point in the clip and tries to keep that centered as best it can. After that, I had to apply a crop to make it look more "professional" i.e. not seeing the original clip bounce around trying to remain centered.

3

u/pferden 3d ago

Why not play the videos in sync?

3

u/ltjojo 3d ago

I tried to - I had two instances of VLC open and trying to get them to start at the same time AND record the screen was tricky.

4

u/pferden 2d ago

I appreciate the effort

0

u/Rasputin1493 r/Rammstein staff 2d ago

ikr. the irony of not using a video editing program for this

1

u/ltjojo 2d ago

Yeah in hindsight, I should have just had the original and my edit side-by-side instead of my ghetto way I went with 🤦‍♂️

39

u/ndjs22 3d ago

Your edit is vastly superior to the original, imho

6

u/CaffeinatedPenguin0 2d ago

YES GOOD JOB OP! Director should be ashamed of that choice. He knew he had to deliver massively after the dumpster fire that was Paris and he did this shaking.....hmm!!!

2

u/MetalExile 3d ago

Your version is definitely better. I was hoping someone would try this. I supported the official release and I can’t wait for it to get here, but I secretly hope someone makes a version I can get hold of that does this with the whole movie. That awful artificial shake is a blight on an otherwise brilliant concert film. Fortunately, unlike the madcap editing of Paris, maybe this can be fixed.

1

u/ltjojo 3d ago

Agreed - having it shake a few times is fine, but to have it shake so much was annoying. Once my disc is here, it's getting ripped to my media server anyway. Perfect excuse to keep working on the other tracks and dial in the video settings 😉. Not gonna lie, I HATE how Te Quiero Puta is after the credits like Paris did it...that's gonna get changed too

2

u/MetalExile 3d ago

I didn’t mind TCP so much. Felt like an encore in movie form. I get where you’re coming from though.

The shaking was so overdone. Even if it hadn’t looked like a cheap, distracting hack job effect, it was overused. I’m genuinely surprised that effect made the final version because it looked so amateurish. Everything else about the film I thought was great (slight overuse of black and white aside), but that artificial shake was just awful. Not ruinous fortunately, at least to me, but hugely distracting.

2

u/ltjojo 2d ago

I will give LiM's encore song treatment credit that, even though it happens after the credits, at least there isn't 60 seconds of black with no sound before playing like in Paris before Frühling played. That was a shit decision on top of the mountain of other shit editing decisions for that DVD

5

u/TokyoDave43 2d ago

I see some improvement. Good job. When I saw it in the theater, it was definitely annoying and I don’t understand why they did it at all…

1

u/grabarz941 17h ago

The reduced albeit not eliminated camera shake looks great. I think that what I feel when seeing your edit is what was the intention of the original, but someone decided to overdo it and now instead of seeing it as vibrations from the sheer power of sound, it made it look artificial. I'd buy you a beer if I could download your edit of the full show.,

1

u/ltjojo 15h ago

Exactly - the editor applied the effect and then just dialed it up to 11. There are parts where, to me at least, it makes no sense having it...like at the end of Zick Zack when the song didn't use that effect at all, and the ending of the song isn't even super heavy.

What I realized after watching the BluRay last night also is that it would have been better if they matched the effect to follow the drums and/or guitar beats/strums when they go into a heavy bit. Instead, it seems like once a "heavy" part was decided on, it just is applied for X duration. It could have been done a lot better

1

u/grabarz941 15h ago

Yepp, the way they implemented it makes it feel cheap, cheesy. If you have a workflow figured out and if you are able to reduce the shake in the entire live I think it will improve the watching experience greatly. Honestly speaking, the camera shake brings otherwise 10/10 concert to a 7/10 at best (for me). It's very annoying.

2

u/ltjojo 14h ago

I'm gonna give it a shot - made notes last night where I saw spots I wanna fix. I have a rough workflow, hopefully it'll improve as I go.

3

u/sjolmers 3d ago

I 0refer your edit over the original. It is more pleasing for my brain somehow

1

u/Accurate_Vehicle9459 2d ago

Anyone have a link to the volkerball live show?

1

u/skontem 2d ago

why though. shakiness gave me goosebumps

1

u/No_Collar2291 2d ago

Yes, the change is noticeable, and it will be even more so if you apply it to everything on DVD and leave it in key moments like in "Puppe" (already mentioned). I like it.

Personally, I wanted an animated wallpaper, but I don't know if it's just me or if the DVD has grain (I don't like the grain), so I cut the fragment of the burning scene, about 1-2 seconds, reduced the grain, increased the contrast and color, increased to 120 fps to put it in slow motion and for Wallpaper Engine, I added some fireworks, all very amateurish but I liked the result.

So it's not a waste of time if the editing is for something you want and enjoy.

0

u/scoza05 2d ago

I personally like the shaking effect. I'm not having much luck finding the place to order the blu ray.

1

u/ltjojo 2d ago

There's Amazon, the official site, and Universal Music Store. I'm sure there's other places based on regions and such too

0

u/Ironheart_1 2d ago

Come on man, there's nothing wrong with it. That shakiness only adds to the experience!

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted]

3

u/ltjojo 3d ago

Meh, I was bored and thought I could make it work 🤣

3

u/N999neRoses 2d ago

You absolutely did. Thank you for showing us what it could have been. Haters gonna hate…