r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 18 '15

J-Mod reply in comments This game has potential to be fun, but I can't get past the PvP flaws introduced by EoC.

407 Upvotes

Abilities are not the main reason people disliked EoC, and Legacy only served to remove abilities. The flaws introduced by EoC still plague darkscape. Since DS is PvP-focused, we have to address these issues if we want this game to be exciting.

Issue #1: THE TIER SYSTEM MUST BE ABOLISHED AT THE EARLIEST POSSIBLE DATE. BRING BACK DIVERSITY!

As it stands now, your damage output and accuracy is strictly dependent on your weapon's required level. Are you using a level 50 weapon? Congratulations, your DPS and accuracy is the exact same as any other level 50 weapon in existence. As a result, there is absolutely no reason to use any weapon which is significantly more difficult to obtain, and players will opt for the easiest level X weapon, and every other weapon of that type is obsolete.

We need weapon diversity. We need unique accuracy values, unique DPS tied to weapons, and a reason to use different types of weapons at the same tier other than special attacks. Without this, players will continue to opt for the easiest weapon route, and do as much damage as if they had gone for something more difficult to obtain.

Best example - Adamant 2h Sword. It's cheap, easy to obtain, and a level 40 weapon. As a result, no other level 40 melee weapon is in any way relevant. There is no reason to go out and obtain adamant scimitars/longswords/claws/maces/warhammers/daggers/swords/spears/halberds because the adamant 2h already does exactly what those weapons do. This applies to any tier, whatever the easiest to obtain weapon of level X is, all others are obsolete save for a few with special attacks.

This gets worse as you increase tiers.

Issue #2: Damage is vastly dependent on your weapon level (This issue is tied with Issue #1)

Your damage output is far too strictly tied to your weapon of choice. A player with 99 strength using a granite maul hits for almost the exact same as a player with 50 strength using a granite maul. As a result, the optimal PvP build revolves around players picking the highest tier they can access and not levelling your skills past that tier, as your damage doesn't increase significantly enough to justify the combat level increase. This is less relevant in zones without level boundaries, but it's still an issue.

I shouldn't be hitting similar to someone with 50 strength if I have 99 strength using the same weapon. Remember when dragon scimitars fought whips, whips fought rapiers, rapiers fought saradomin swords, saradomin swords fought dragon claws, claws fought MSB, MSB fought Rune crossbow, rune crossbow fought rune knives, rune knives fought dark bows, dark bows fought ancient staff, ancient staff fought master wand, master wand fought polypore staff, polypore staff fought staff of light. There was insane diversity Pre-EoC, because players weren't limited by the level requirement on their weapon!

PLEASE BRING BACK WEAPON DIVERSITY!

Issue #3: Rock-Paper-Scissors combat

Pre-EoC, the combat triangle was a guideline, but each combat style served a purpose.

-Melee had high burst damage/tankiness, but had to fight up close.

-Range was filled with high dps low accuracy weapons (MSB, Knives), and high accuracy slow weapons with decent damage (Crossbow), but had meh defences and underwhelming special attacks.

-Magic didn't have kill potential, and had low defences, but offered insane utility and the ability to kite your opponent forever. Deadly in deep wilderness.

EoC created one combat style, and skinned it three times. They at least tried to diversify it slightly by giving each combat style different abilities (take a look at them, they're like 90% the same though), but Legacy completely removes the one tiny attempt to make combat classes different.

As it stands now, in DS, literally the ONLY difference between the three combat styles is their position in the rock-paper-scissors fight. If you start fighting someone at the better end of the triangle, you just lose. If you hybrid someone, you no longer switch classes depending on what you need (high burst? utility? ranged DPS?), you switch because if you don't, you lose.

End result? Bridding is kind of pointless, and fights will settle at both players using the same combat style.

Each combat style needs its identity back (this ties in with weapon diversity). Until then, people will choose the most convenient style (handcannons anyone?) with the easiest to obtain highest tier weapon, and that'll be the only viable option.

If Jagex addresses these issues, it'll be a start. I'm curious to see how others feel about this before I bother listing off other issues I have with the game.

Let's build this game's PvP up to what Legacy/EoC COULD have been.

TL;DR - ABILITIES ARE NOT THE SOURCE OF EOC'S PROBLEMS; TIER SYSTEM & LACK OF COMBAT STYLE IDENTITY & MINIMAL STAT CONTRIBUTION TO DAMAGE ARE THE REASONS PVP SUCKS

EDIT: It seems that the general consensus of the subreddit users is that Pre-EoC had diversity issues as well/wasn't a perfect system, but legacy/EoC's attempt still failed to address them.

If the devs are willing to work with us and address these issues (and others mentioned in the comments), we could have an amazing PvP experience in the next few months. I'm hoping for acknowledgement from /u/JagexPi more than anything!


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 29 '15

Give us feedback: Potential big changes to DarkScape combat.

363 Upvotes

Hey all,

Following a large amount of feedback on legacy combat and a few hot topics we’ve seen mentioned (such as https://www.reddit.com/r/RSDarkscape/comments/3lfqr0/this_game_has_potential_to_be_fun_but_i_cant_get/) the DarkScape team and other combat guru’s at Jagex decided to all jump in to a room and not come out until we had a decent proposal for you. Below you will find the results of our initial talks and a set of rather interesting updates focused around solving the problems raised. Have a read and give us your ideas and opinions on what we have so far.

These are only our initial thoughts and suggestions, the ideas are very much high level concepts and would need more in depth design work. Everything noted here is subject to change before we start moving further. We plan to work with you from this early stage and all proposals will be tweaked based on your feedback and suggestions before we flash out the designs further.

Problem: Weapons are not diverse enough and same tier weapons having the same DPS and accuracy is boring.

Proposed solution:

We will redefine what each weapon in each tier is supposed to be good at and weapons in the same tier do not have to have the same DPS or accuracy, they can be min/maxed based on the weapons chosen niche.

Ideas so far are akin to the following:

  • 2h swords – Focus on burst damage, lower DPS than average but higher max hit. Standard accuracy.

  • Scimitars – Balanced, current tier.

  • Daggers – Lower DPS, Lower damage, higher accuracy

  • Long Swords – Higher DPS, Lower max hit, normal accuracy

For magic the basic spells would follow this and base their niche via the spell element. Ancients will be for utility.

For Range: New craftable arrows and bolts that min/max these values. Adds diversity to range and an extension to the fletching skill. “Sharp arrows/fire arrows/ice arrows/blunt arrows”.

Problem: Strength is useless as a skill

Proposed solution:

Make strength a global skill for all 3 combat styles and rename it power. All three styles would take power in to account for your combat level.

Rather than a weapon having a flat damage, instead it will have a base damage and a scalar for each weapon which will scale as you level your power (strength) up. Higher level weapons would have better base damage and scaled damage but you can take your level 50 weapon and apply your 99 strength to it to boost its damage. (i.e. a dragon dagger would have 30 damage + 0.46 damage per level)

Problem: The combat triangles rock/paper/scissors system is enforced too much and boring

Proposed solution:

Totally remove the combat triangle from the accuracy calculation to remove the rock paper scissors combat.

Combat styles will be more about what type of game play that style offers. Initial thoughts are:

  • Melee – High defence, burst damage

  • Range – High DPS, low defence i.e. glass cannon.

  • Mage – Control and utility.

Problem: Armour is useless and 1-itemers have it far too easy.

Proposed Solution:

Every armour set in the game will get set effects (2pc/4pc/5pc). Some of these may be global to all styles (i.e. for 2 pc melee, you get a strength boost). Some will be specific to that tier(i.e. wear full mystic and your binds will bind for 1 more second). Every set effect will enhance the style of play for the combat style using it.

Damage reduction on armour will be bolstered so that armour doesn’t have to rely on accuracy to sell it. This should ensure that armour is always worth wearing. This would be direct damage mitigation rather than the previously implemented damage soaking and the current percentage based system.

Prayers will be locked behind wearing armour. In order to get your melee boosts you’ll need to equip a few pieces of melee armour. To get higher boosts you’ll need more pieces of armour of that style. Protect item will be locked behind at least 3 pieces of armour.

That’s all for now, let us know your thoughts on the proposed solutions and any changes you think would be beneficial. Any other ideas to combat the problems raised above are very welcome. I look forward to working with you guys on the issues and making some awesome changes to the system.

The DarkScape Team


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 17 '15

Why darkscape is better than runescape...

315 Upvotes

I CAN FINALLY (edit: AT LEAST TRY TO) KILL THESE ASSHOLES WHO THINK IT'S OKAY TO JUST START MINING MY ROCKS AND I'LL HOP LIKE IT'S ALL GOOD.

that is all...


r/RSDarkscape • • Oct 06 '15

TFW smuggling

Thumbnail
youtu.be
290 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 20 '15

J-Mod reply in comments Please enable weapon sheathing > When sheathed, players are right-click to attack

262 Upvotes

As title says, please allow us to sheathe our weapons. (I know this isn't available in Legacy mode normally, but the mechanic already exists, so just implement it)

When your weapons are sheathed, make all players right-click-attack only. Solve the mis-click problem permanently without making it any less convenient to PK. I think this would be a brilliant solution that is acceptable to everyone? Sound off if you agree/disagree.

It would be even better if you disabled auto-retaliate automatically when weapons are sheathed. Then if someone has their weapons sheathed and goes AFK while skilling they are a target for PKers. Bonus points if the sheathing mechanic only works while a player has a weapon equipped and can't be used when they're unarmed.

Chop chop, Mod Pi.


r/RSDarkscape • • Feb 29 '16

The JAGEX approved guide of creating a new game.

260 Upvotes
  1. Make promises of an awesome game.

  2. Release a broken mess.

  3. Somehow convince players to have faith in the development cycle, promise significant improvements to fool them into investing time and effort.

  4. Never actually fix the broken things, instead release shitty miniscule updates to keep the players moderately happy for the time being.

  5. Fully ignore the entire community for weeks on end because taking five minutes out of your day to write something is too much to ask.

  6. Say, ah fuck it we'll shut er' down. Not enough players._

  7. Close the game and think that you did the best you could, while really you did a lazy shit job and the only reason your game died was because of your incompetence.

There you have it, now you too can create a legendary shitgame that ranks among the likes of transformers universe, the various funorb games and cardscape. (yes it will obviously die since why the FUCK would you play cardscape (chronicle) when theres hearthstone with a competent developer behind it?


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 30 '15

Make Firemaking Light up the Wildy Minimap

257 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXD0ykS2xt4

Since the dead trees in the wild aren't able to be chopped down, let players choose to bring a couple logs with them to strategically set up bonfires that will light up a small area of the minimap for all players while the bonfire lasts.

Just adding a PVP feature to the lamest skill in RS.


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 26 '15

How I imagine them...

Post image
249 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 17 '15

They should change "Preparing Your Greatest Adventure" to "Preparing Your Worst Nightmare"

237 Upvotes

Would make much more sense to me. PVP is scary stuff. It would also match their dark and bloody aesthetic they are going for with the menus too.


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 20 '15

[Suggestion] 1000 Total level should give you 50 more bank space in every area, 1500, 2000, and max. 300 bank space total :)

226 Upvotes

Edit: (my bad english sorry) Think about it. U cant pk with a 2 hander forever. What about all pots for pk? food? gear for all sets? All loot u get from PVP? and much more... Thats only for PVP. Think about everything else, slayer loot? yea u can add so much to the bank that u NEED. We got a toolbelt atleast for now ;)

This idea will not ruin the idea of going from bank to bank and g.e to g.e. Cuz there is still the threat areas u need to look for. Bank space is only a positive thing. And the idea of getting higher total to get more bank space, just a cool idea to feel much more rewarded, u need to go out from the guards and get some lvls, and that way ppl can pk you. This is fun for all of us! :)

Edit2: I see that many agree with this. I mean. If ppl only gonna pvp, also with 100 bank space... then we can only pvp with addy 2 hander... forever, fun? I dont think so... Need more space to the PvE style. Cuz without PvE no PvP... Who is gonna get all your food, pots, godwars itemes, barrows...? whips? U can think about all the other things..;) Its much that needs a bank. Its good for the economy too. Theres still Threat Area that make u move with stuff, dont worry. You can PvP them too when they change banks and G.E. Everything cant go to a low bank. Just becuz the Threat Areas. It still MUST BE MOVED somehow. Think about it... ^


r/RSDarkscape • • Oct 19 '15

PKd for 11.5m at GE in Lumbridge w206 (Missed Connection)

199 Upvotes

I was wearing nothing, and was about to buy some dragon bones for prayer

You were wearing a magic shortbow and 4-6 rune arrows

Fuck you, you fucking piece of shit, I hope you die in a fire, in real life


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 21 '15

[Suggestion] Add this to help keep track of items kept on death, especially in combat

Post image
198 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 23 '15

Make it so your killer's name appears in chat

184 Upvotes

Right now, if you kill somebody, it says something like "You have killed playername," but if you die to someone, it only says "Oh dear, you are dead!"

Instead, make it so that if someone kills you, it will say something like "playername killed you!"

By changing this, it makes it a lot easier to track down your killer and seek vengeance for his crimes.


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 16 '15

By far, the best feature of darkscape

Post image
183 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 16 '15

J-Mod reply in comments Thank you for not polling this like how OSRS would. I like surprises

183 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 25 '15

When you're smuggling 500 lobbies from high to safe and a guy with a Ancient Staff walks by

179 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 23 '15

J-Mod reply in comments Hey Jagex can we get some Darkscape Moderators please?

Post image
172 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 18 '15

Loot from 2 hours of killing skillers

Post image
168 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Oct 02 '15

PSA: Summoning familiars ruin pking

166 Upvotes

As many times as this has saved my ass, it shouldn't happen in a game like this. If I have a terrorbird (or any attacking familiar out) and someone hits me, my familiar will hit them... And then they can't attack me anymore because they're already under attack.


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 16 '15

Make the Lodestone Network map show what threat levels each area has

Post image
166 Upvotes

r/RSDarkscape • • Oct 27 '15

Jagex can we have a vote to keep all microtransactions out of darkscape? I would rather pay double for darkscape membership than have some kid who asked his mom for $20 have a superior advantage to players who are very true to a game. This is why I left Runescape after 10 years of playing.

161 Upvotes

Please Jagex. I want to play a game, and I understand you need to make money and we're willing to pay to keep the game alive. Keeping this game a true competitive game is what has reignited the fire in me for this game, and when I read you are are thinking about introducing bonds I died a little inside.

I spent 73 days of my life on RS only for all the gold I had collected to be worth around $50. That hurt more than you know.

Edit: thank you everyone for your support I'm so glad most people feel the same as I do!

Jagex I hope you see how much attention this has gathered and how strongly we feel about it. This truly makes or breaks the game for a lot of us.

81% 86%! of darkscaping redditors have agreed so far, and I think we make a great representative population.

Thank you for all that you do for us Jagex and I hope we can keep this game with a more than satisfied userbase and lots of money in your pockets!


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 29 '15

J-Mod reply in comments Player named bones!

160 Upvotes

I think it would be a cool idea for when players die, instead of dropping normal bones, they would drop bones labled with their names so "OtherRobots Bones".

They would function exactly like normal bones but it would be cool for bragging rights and would make a whole new area of hiring players to attack others and would provide proof that they actually went through with the deed.


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 16 '15

J-Mod reply in comments What are some things you should immediately do ASAP on Darkscape?

154 Upvotes

I'll add things to the list if you comment anything below.

Global:

  • Waterfall quest. Att/Str stats instantly go to 30+.

  • Suicide to quickly unlock lodestones. Gameplay settings > Death respawn settings. There is now a pillory timer for getting killed by a guard. +30 seconds wait time for every time you are killed by a guard.

  • This video has been recommended.

  • Lodestones. Unlock them if you're nearby.

  • Leathercrafting can may be decent beginning cash. (Sell to a general store)

  • Logs into arrow shafts is also good beginning cash. (Sell to a general store)

  • Do God statues for Construction & prayer/slayer xp.

  • Don't bother trying sinkholes. Dg xp lamps will not award dg xp.

Lumbridge:

  • The circus D&D can be used for quick magic, ranged and agility xp.

  • The Nexus is just south-west of the Lumbridge castle. Free prayer xp.

Taverly:

  • Get a wicked hood.

  • Talk to Major Mary Rancour for 5 potion sets, a dwarven army axe and a steel full helm.

  • Mess Sergeant Ramsey sells 500 pots of flour for 14gp each and 10 chocolate bars for 20 each. Could be useful for cake or chocolate cake.

  • Head Farmer Jones will buy anything that a general store would. Loot from 1 cow is around 19 coins. Kill 2 cows to be able to afford a rake, seed dibber, and a bucket of compost. Claim the 3 free potato seeds and plant them in the patch right next to him.

Varrock:


r/RSDarkscape • • Sep 17 '15

mfw when I play Darkscape

Post image
150 Upvotes