r/RIE • • Jan 17 '21

RIE is also about respect

28 Upvotes

I’m seeing a common theme amongst the philosophy followers and my own practice, and that is how sometimes we try to follow it to the letter. So, I wanted to remind us all that respect for our infants and toddlers and children is also a strong part of the philosophy and sometimes that might mean we do something different, like feed to sleep or sit up in a laid back position when they have sore tummy’s etc. Love and respect and communication... doing our best most the time- It’s what we do most that counts. 🥰


r/RIE • • Dec 12 '20

Who else is applying Ellyn Satter method at meals?

19 Upvotes

Hi folks

On a recent post here I was recommended to check Ellyn Satter method to apply at meal times. I'm really interested in it, but have been struggling to find online communities to share some thoughts with other parents.

Is anyone else here applying it that can recommend me some forums/groups online for more discussions? I've read a lot in the official website but I miss the ability to chat with others about it.

thanks in advance


r/RIE • • Mar 23 '21

How do you get grandparents on board?

18 Upvotes

So many things about how our parents raised us goes against RIE. If your parent is stuck in their old ways and wants to take care of your baby (their grandkid), how do you approach it?

I’ve tried gently explaining what we do and the why. I’m just not getting through and it’s gotten to the point I don’t like how grandparent treats my baby.

Edit to add: I browsed Janet Lansbury’s site and chose this article for family to read. They said it helped them understand. Hope it helps you too.

https://www.janetlansbury.com/2010/04/baby-interrupted-7-ways-to-build-your-childs-focus-and-attention-span/


r/RIE • • Nov 15 '23

Help me become a less reactive parent please!

17 Upvotes

I have not been myself ever since we moved out of state 2 years ago away from family. I also became pregnant with my third shortly after we moved.

I used to be so patient and respectful. I loved spending time with my kids and delighted in their silliness. Now I find myself getting frustrated and annoyed so often. I’m short with my kids, so impatient, and usually want to be left alone.

I’m sure morning sickness, loneliness, sleep deprivation and stress over time are to blame.

However, we are now in a better living situation with baby sleeping better, but it’s like my body/mind are so used to being this way, I don’t even know how to be the mom I was before. I don’t know how to break free of this constant stressed, irritable, and tired state I am in.

Please help me with any advice!

(Cross posted)


r/RIE • • May 29 '20

My child’s pain hurts me

16 Upvotes

I’ve been listening to Janet Lansbury’s podcast, and I just got to the episode titled “Our Biggest Challenge as Parents”. It really clarified for me the struggle that I’ve been having about my child’s emotions.

How does one empathize with pain, without wanting to stop the pain?

I can grasp it intellectually. You can see the pain, speak the pain, without taking it over as your own. But guys, seeing my child in pain hurts. I don’t know that I can stop it hurting me.

Which leads me to my own pain tolerance. One of the goals of the RIE method (at least as Janet represents it) is to build resilience by allowing children to experience and move through emotional pain in their own process. This is not a skill that was instilled in me. I don’t have a process for accepting pain and letting it flow through me. This is a skill that I will need to develop in myself, on the fly, if I am to be able to help my child develop it.

Learning this parenting method is more like going through intensive therapy than learning a technique. Sheesh.


r/RIE • • Apr 26 '22

My 4-year-old slapped me in response to a boundary I set

15 Upvotes

This morning my 4-year-old wanted ice cream after breakfast and I calmly told her no. Then she yelled “No! Give me ice cream!” and then slapped me in the face. I calmly told her that hitting and using her hands is not going to get her what she wants. I really hope this doesn’t continue to be a pattern. I imagine she did this because she felt powerless. Any advice on parenting situations like this?


r/RIE • • Apr 27 '21

RIE and constant hitting

15 Upvotes

My 4.5 year old son is constantly hitting me, his dad, or his 2 year old sister. I'm no stranger to this parenting method. I have read all of Janet Lansburys books. I follow several conscious parenting influencers on instagram and have done lots of research. However, it seems to escape me in the moment and I get upset and raise my voice. My son likes to run, play, and in general is pretty rough. So, when he gets upset he'll constantly hit whomever is upsetting him. I'm not going to waste my time and say how smart he is because I know emotional maturity is different. Him being only 4.5 I'd like any tips or advice or even just stories you may have. This has been happening since he was about 1.

I feel like I've tried many things. We sing songs, dances, music, draw, read books. I've created a calm down corner and I try to help him use it, but he doesn't seem to want to. Everytime he says he doesn't need to calm down then I ask if we should draw a picture. So, I ask you, how can I be more patient in those times?


r/RIE • • Jul 04 '22

Toy recommendations from “baby knows best” (RIE book)

14 Upvotes

I copied these out for me to reference and thought others may also find it useful. Feel free to add your own suggestions

Pre-crawling:

  • metal frozen juice and canning rings

  • Plastic hair curlers

  • Links, rings, keys

  • Silicone muffin cups

  • Plain cotton napkins tented

Crawling add:

  • balls of various textures and material

  • Water or laundry detergent bottles without caps and throughly washed

  • Child sized bowling pins (lying down)

  • Metal and plastic bowls and colanders

  • Napkin holders

  • Plastic or wooden cups

  • Dolls with clothes that snap or zip to take on and off

  • Nesting cups or boxes

  • Stuffed animals

Toddlers

  • things to roll

  • Cars

  • Trucks

  • Containers to collect things in. (Baskets or bowls or purses)

  • Containers with lids that lift off or unscrew

  • Puzzles

  • Hats

  • Purses


r/RIE • • Apr 29 '23

Potty training

13 Upvotes

I am confused about the RIE approach when it comes to potty training. I read the Janet Lansbury article on this and it basically said don't potty train and wait for your kid to initiate it.

My girl is 27 months old. I read another book on potty training that states the best window to train is between 20 and 30 months because after that they become defiant and will resist potty training efforts.

She currently knows how to use the potty and will do it when prompted after brushing teeth in the morning and before bed. And she's enthusiastic about wearing underwear. But she's not getting the hang of it or cooperating when we suggest she uses the potty during the day.

I'm not sure whether to try harder at this or wait for her to initiate it.

Any advice or sharing of experiences would be helpful. Thank you!


r/RIE • • Jul 31 '22

at a loss about coparenting

13 Upvotes

I feel at a loss right now. My partner and I have very different parenting styles, and I work very hard to navigate that in a way that respects his relationship with our son and allows him to do what he feels is best. However, he just told me he feels I sometimes micromanage his parenting. I thought I was just sharing my point of view and stating any serious concerns I had. He says he feels like I don't trust his judgement... well, sometimes I don't, if I'm being completely honest, and I told him as much. I explained that he just doesn't seem to be mindful of some things that I think are important; he seems to think a lot of things don't make a difference. An example would be assuming since our 2 year old doesn't APPEAR to understand his words, he doesn't have to filter himself. He also said things before like "I'm much bigger and stronger than you so I can make you do this even if you don't want to" re: diaper changes (said in a calm voice, but I don't like the sentiment) . I don't know what to do. Maybe I am just supposed to keep my mouth shut and do my own thing? But I can't even do that because when he makes a decision while we're both present he expects me to follow his lead. I'm just at a loss. He and I have similare values but they just don't seem to be translating to parenting all the time. Any advice on how to communicate and come to a compromise with someone who doesn't particularly value respectful parenting approaches?


r/RIE • • Aug 19 '21

So much anxiety around doing things “right”

13 Upvotes

I feel like I am so uptight and hard on myself while trying to parent. I’m wondering if anyone else feels this way/has tips on how to move more authentically through my day? And how to stop being so harsh on myself


r/RIE • • Jul 18 '21

My Wife and I are not on the same page with some RIE related things. Any similar situations or advice?

13 Upvotes

Our daughter is not super motivated to follow directions. An example is a dance class we signed her up for. She wouldn’t follow directions and just wanted to play. She’s 3 1/2. All I care about is that she’s having fun. My wife is quite upset that children younger than her stay still and follow the directions. She’s kind of starting to blame me.

Frankly, I think our whole society puts WAY too much pressure on kids to conform, and I really don’t care at all if she does or does not follow directions in a dance class. I will ask her to try to not interrupt the other kids, and I will repeat and repeat that, but I am not about to bring aggression into it to scare her into following these weird rules.

Anyway, a sincere question with a bit of my own rant in there. Am I letting my kid be “bad?”


r/RIE • • Mar 06 '21

Is physical restraint for necessary tasks ever okay?

13 Upvotes

One of the most valuable things I’ve learned when it comes to toddlers is to give choices. For example, instead of saying to my 27mo old, “Can you put your shoes on?” we’ll say, “Which do you want to wear, your blue shoes or your red ones?” It works like a charm almost all the time. But there are times when her answer is just a flat-out NO.

Today she wanted to jump on the trampoline. It’s cold out, she needed socks. I asked if she wanted to put them on or have me do it and she told me she didn’t want socks. She got agitated. I was saying, “I understand you don’t want to wear them. The problem is, it’s cold and your feet will get cold.” She was adamant about not wearing them. (In hindsight this is the point where I should have said okay, I’ll let natural consequences sort this one out and when she realizes her feet are cold, maybe she’ll want the socks.) I wasn’t really thinking it through, and I decided to put them on no matter what. So I was holding her feet while she was kicking and trying to get away. It escalated more than I should have allowed it to, and it turned into a full-blown meltdown.

If you really need to do something and they really refuse to cooperate, is it ever okay to go against their protesting and force them to do it (within reason, obviously)?

The funny thing is, she ended up taking the socks off as soon as she got on the trampoline. 🤦🏻‍♀️ Lesson learned. But say we absolutely needed to get somewhere and she refuses to put them on...you’d have to use some force, right?


r/RIE • • Sep 09 '21

At what age does a tantrum turn into abuse?

12 Upvotes

This is a throwaway account - I know we are supposed to let kids scream, swear, block them when they hit, but just let them get a tantrum out and express it fully, but at what age is this no longer ok? Asking for two reasons - first of all, I have a 7-year-old, and he just loses it on a daily basis, screaming, biting, hitting, kicking, swearing, etc. I have been asking my husband for years to get on board with me to let me have his tantrums and hold boundaries. The problem is that my husband, who is almost 50 does the same thing - he screams horrible things at me, swears, punches holes in walls, breaks things in the house, etc, when he is angry. Now when I tell him to stop and the kids start freaking out because they are scared of him, he turns it around on me and asks me "what happened to your advice to allow all expressions of emotion?? I should be allowed to get it out. Let me get it out", then he yells some more, breaks more stuff, etc. He had a very traumatic childhood. He is in therapy. It has helped a little, but he still does this maybe once a week or so.

So my question is two fold - 1. Is this ok for him to do? Should he be allowed to get it out? Where is the boundary? Is it different for him vs the kids because he's an adult? Eg - we should let our 7-yo scream if he is angry. But when my husband does this, it really scares the kids. Should there be a different standard for this? Husband says no, should be the same standard. He is not hitting, and we tell the kids we don't hit. He says as long as he doesn't hit, he should be ok to do it.

My husband's temper is probably due to his past abuse so I have no idea on when the line should be drawn for my 7 yo. If there is a different boundary for my husband for screaming, is there an age in which we need to draw this same boundary for our son? Like let's say he is 8, 10, 15, or whatever and he is still screaming, kicking, hitting, does it become not ok to just hold him off or block him and tell him "I understand you are angry but we don't hit"? At some point does it no longer become ok for him to even try to hit?

Thanks so much in advance for any responses.

  • One more thing to add - because of my husband's issues, I have to admit that it is making it very hard for me to allow my son to express his emotions. I try my very best, but I have to admit that deep down, I'm very afraid that my son is going to do this into adulthood, and someday what if he has a family and tries to hit them like he does to us? I'm afraid that if I let him do this and don't make a big deal, he won't know it's wrong like his dad? Any advice on this? Do most people outgrow this at some point?


r/RIE • • Jan 22 '21

Tummy time for babies?

12 Upvotes

Hi! I’m a nanny and have been a huge proponent of RIE for a couple years, but I’ve only worked with toddlers in that time.

I just had a curiosity about the logistics of not doing tummy time for babies. I’m not completely sold that putting babies in positions they can’t get into themselves is always bad. Babies freaking love bouncing around in their bouncers and stuff, even when they can’t stand, and love sitting up in laps so they can see what’s going on around them. I can get behind why you should let them figure some things out on their own from a physical strength standpoint. I wouldn’t feel comfortable propping a baby up with a seat when they’re not ready. but I don’t necessarily feel that they’re getting negative messaging in every instance, like if you let them hop around and laugh in a bouncer.

I understand the reasoning behind no tummy time because I’m sure it feels extremely oppressive and scary for baby to be stuck in that position but my question is — if you can’t lay a baby on their tummy or sit them up, and you don’t want to hold them all day long, doesn’t that just leave laying on their back? And if they’re doing that all day they’re going to get an extremely flat head. I’m sorry, this is probably a very silly question but I’ve always wondered what y’all do with your babies all day, haha!


r/RIE • • Mar 17 '22

Crying when saying bye

11 Upvotes

How do you explain to family that, although a toddler may cry when saying bye, this is better than the family member “disappearing”?


r/RIE • • Mar 10 '21

Best strategies for a toddler that won’t let her parents talk?

11 Upvotes

My 28 month old is very attached to me (mom). For a while now, she has had a zero tolerance policy for me and my husband having conversations that don’t involve her. She will be off on her own, not paying attention to us, and literally the second she hears me talking to him, she runs up to us and starts making noise to end the conversation, grabbing at me, asking to nurse, etc.

I have tried acknowledging in the moment by calmly saying, “I hear you. I’ll be with you in a moment” and going back to talking to him. It doesn’t do anything.

I’ve tried completely ignoring her, which just makes her angry and louder, then I have to talk super loud over her so my husband can hear, and it’s just a mess.

I try so hard to not react angrily/strongly to it because I know that will reinforce the behavior but I am so fed up with it. I feel like I’m not allowed to speak to my own husband.

I’m at my wits end.


r/RIE • • Oct 30 '20

How to frame RIE when family seems to discount it

11 Upvotes

First time mom here. Many has struggled with health issues so my mom quit her job to help us with our 14mo daughter. I'm super grateful for her help. Very different generation, she's used to rewards, praises, tricks, guilt when trying to get my daughter to do something. It's hard to watch my mom treating my daughter like a training dog. I've done my best to share with her my respectful parenting approach (shared books, websites, podcasts, heartfelt conversations). She just doesn't seem to get it and it's really hard for all parties involved. I really want to make this work, any ideas on how to reframe the situation? Has anyone cracked a similar situation? I really would benefit from insight or resources. Thanks so much!!!


r/RIE • • Jun 01 '22

How do you deal with people excessively baby-talking to LO and praising for no reason?

10 Upvotes

(Apologies for the awkward phrasing)

I feel like it’s mainly the older generations doing this. It feels like how these/some people talk to their pets? Phrases like ‘you’re such a good boy’ and ‘who’s the best boy’ repeated over and over (like 10 times in a row that it nearly sounds like they’re training a dog) to/at LO when they’re not or haven’t been doing anything that. It’s almost grating to hear when it’s just repeated at your non-verbal LO and you know this is how they speak to their pets


r/RIE • • Oct 14 '21

Grandparents/ family members who fake cry

10 Upvotes

Hello! My partner and I follow RIE/Pikler and recently started taking a class to go over more principles in depth. I’ve got an engagement with my partner’s family next week and I’m not sure how to handle a few things. They are big on using guilt to get someone to do things for example one time my daughter didn’t want to give her granny a cuddle after a visit and my MIL started to fake cry to get her to, I was there and stepped in immediately saying you don’t have to give her a cuddle(not even sure if this is a good response) They also are constantly asking my daughter to perform for them, example where are your eyes? Where are your ears? What comes after one? Can you say (fill in blank) Even though I’ve said several times we ask before we touch her they still continue to just reach out and stroke her hair or try to tickle her feet. There is a history of mental illness in the older generation of family and can honestly be described as adult children who suffer from complex trauma, they take offence to anything that goes against what they believe to be “right” especially if they are tired, hungry etc I’m looking for guidance on what I can say or how I can step in to set boundaries so my daughter isn’t being emotionally manipulated or being forced to do things for others?

Side note; I’m not as worried about the relationship with his family as I am the effect it can have on my daughter.

Edit; forgot to put my daughter will be 2 in Dec


r/RIE • • Sep 08 '21

How do you navigate differing parenting beliefs between you and the people who raised you?

10 Upvotes

My parents and I have a pretty good relationship, and they spend a good deal of time with my son. He is seven months old just for reference.

My husband and I have been trying to parent gently and to model for our baby that it’s OK for him to have true and authentic reactions and that all feelings are valid. My mom and dad are of a different generation, so we frequently run up against conflicting ideas about parenting. And if I say something about it or do things differently, my parents tend to take it as a personal affront and a criticism of their parenting style and my entire childhood. For example, my baby fell and bumped his head, and while my initial reaction was wanting to say, “You’re OK , it’s OK,” I took a moment—really a split second—and picked up my baby and said, “You fell and bonked your head” and let him cry for a moment while holding him and rubbing his head. My mom got upset that I wasn’t telling him that it’s OK but I mentioned that if he cries he’s telling me that he’s not OK so I want to hold space for that. That totally set her off.

The conversation, although I’m not sure it was a conversation so much as a lecture to begin with, devolved to her asking if they did a horrible job as parents and never validated my feelings. Spoiler alert: it doesn’t feel like they really did validate my feelings much.

I think it’s true that my parents did the best that they could at the time with the tools that they had, but I do think that there’s a better way, which I’m trying to do for my son. I don’t want to give him the message that he can’t be sad or angry or have any negative human reaction or emotion and that only happiness is allowed. How does that inspire joy and comfort in a child?

So my question is, how do you navigate or bridge differing parenting beliefs with the people who raised you? I don’t know that I’ll be able to change my parents’ minds, but I would like them to respect the choices my husband and I are making in parenting our child.

Thanks for any input you have to share!


r/RIE • • Mar 29 '21

Is it ever okay to let a toddler cry it out?

10 Upvotes

I know CIO is a super contentious topic and I’ll just start by saying I’m not an advocate of using that as a sleep training method. However, 99% of the time I’ve seen it discussed, it’s regarding newborns and infants, not older kids...so I’m wondering about this one.

My 28mo old has been fighting sleep lately, naps and bedtime. We have a consistent routine for both and we try to prepare her in advance instead of springing it on her suddenly. We read books, nurse, then leave her in her room and she’s free to look at books, play, whatever, until she falls asleep. That has been working well until now. She lays on the floor at the door and screams and cries as soon as we leave. Sometimes she falls asleep there on the floor. Sometimes she gets into bed after a while. Sometimes we give in and just let her skip her nap.

I know she’s tired - she will have all the signs of being 100% ready for sleep...until we leave the room. We can’t keep playing into it and going in to soothe her, but leaving her there crying on the floor doesn’t feel like a respectful approach at all.


r/RIE • • Mar 10 '21

Finding fellow RIE parents

10 Upvotes

First time mama of a nine month old. Anyone know of any online RIE parenting groups? Or interested in starting one?!


r/RIE • • Mar 06 '21

Is "Mama gets grumpy" a valid natural consequence?

10 Upvotes

Some of my 2-year-old's behaviors irritate me but have no actual "natural consequences" for him. Dump a box of legos on the floor? Oh look, there are legos on the floor. Dig dirt out of a plant pot? Oh, look! Dirt!

I have the impression that according to the "natural consequences" school of thought, I'm supposed to make up artificial natural consequences: no more toys out until you pick up the legos, no more fun until you sweep up the dirt. Whereas in reality I eventually clean it up myself because I've caused myself enough injuries slipping on toys and I mind a dirty floor even when no one else does, and my other kid doesn't deserve to suffer from a bored toddler.

Is there anything terribly wrong with the natural consequence of a mama who is grumpy for a few minutes?


r/RIE • • Feb 18 '21

Help navigating push back when under time constraints!

10 Upvotes

I wish I had found this page earlier! I could use some suggestions! I am an avid RIE parent, as much as I can be at least! I have two toddlers. 4.5 and almost 3yo. I try to keep my cool as much as I can, but I’m human, and I am working on childhood traumas. I am having a hard time with RIE in time-constrained moments.

For example; getting ready for Pre-k or Dr. appointments etc. My kids just really go at their own pace and fight everything!! My 4.5yo is in a SPED Pre-K as she is really high intensity and has transition and frustration issues. RIE has been a god-send for her and us! Here are things that I try to do. I give options, I show examples, I explain what is going to happen and what we need to do, I’ve started waking them up earlier in order to give us more time. I just can’t seem to win and we are about late for everything. They fight me in it all, eating, getting dressed, doing their hair, putting on socks (this is the biggest battle(sensitivity issues with 4.5yo)) and coats and shoes. I feel like I need to repeat myself 30 times before I need to become bad mom. I obviously do not want to be bad mom but understanding mom, but by the end I am succumbing to bribes, threats and raising my voice. I want to turn This around so badly, but I can’t let go when it comes to being on time for certain things. I am much more willing to allow them the time when it isn’t necessary but man I feel like I’ve put myself into a lose-lose situation right now. I would love any tips on getting us back on track!