r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/Delicious_Maize9656 • May 05 '24
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Jul 25 '22
what is phi^3?
So, I was watching a lecture on QFT, and Dr. Susskind (casually) mentioned: let's say you have a quantum field of phi3. That means you will have cross terms, such as xy2. This corresponds, for example, to a particle x "coming in," and decaying into two particles "y" leaving.
My question is twofold. (1) this seems to imply that Phi is (x +y), because that's how you get FOIL cross terms like x2y, or xy2. Why would Phi be simply (x+y)?
Secondly, what is phi? Is he saying that Phi is a particle, so phi3 is merely 3 particles? And again, if so, what is phi if it is x+y? A particle in a state of superposition?
Thanks in advance.
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Sep 15 '18
Electron in QFT
One physicist say: QFT is not suitable for describing the electron movements as well as any other time-dependent process. This is because the traditional QFT does not have a well-defined Hamiltonian (=time translation generator). Does this mean that according to the quantum field theory, electrons can not move and go from one atom to another?
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Jul 13 '18
In the quantum field theory, electrons exist only when we observe them?
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/OkConnection9727 • Mar 10 '25
Simple question
In qft and in qcd how many dimensions are there.
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/AdditionalEbb6036 • Nov 05 '25
The D1 Cosmological Model: Single Scalar Field Unifies Baryogenesis & Cosmic Acceleration, Statistically Excludes ΛCDM at 10σ
Hello r/QuantumFieldTheory,
I’ve recently completed and submitted the full derivation and observational testing of the D1 Cosmological Model. This framework posits that the dynamics of a single, ultra-light scalar field (Φ_D1**) is responsible for both the matter-antimatter asymmetry (Baryogenesis) and the late-time cosmic acceleration (Dark Energy).**
I’m posting here to invite scrutiny and discussion on the core mechanisms and testable predictions. The full paper link is at the bottom, but here is a summary of the key findings:
Key Findings & Discussion Points
Statistical Exclusion of ΛCDM: Testing the model against global cosmological observations (SNIa, CMB, BAO), the constrained evolution of the Dark Energy equation of state, w(z), robustly indicates a dynamical component. The D1 model statistically excludes the non-evolving ΛCDM benchmark (w=-1) at the 10σ level. This is the strongest constraint from our analysis.
Explicit Mass Prediction: The model's weak-field evolution permits a direct, non-adjustable calculation of the D1 particle's mass, linking its microscopic properties to macroscopic expansion: m_D1 1.3 x 10^-33 eV/c^2
Falsifiability via Modified Gravity: The D1 framework is highly falsifiable. Its non-minimal coupling to matter and gravity predicts unique deviations from General Relativity in the strong field regime, specifically in the form of Scalar Hair around compact objects. This signature is potentially testable by next-generation gravitational wave detectors like LISA and high-precision observations from the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT).
I am particularly interested in feedback concerning the consistency of the Φ_D1 potential required to smoothly transition from the early universe (Wave-Trough Collapse/CMB initial conditions) through Baryogenesis and into the late-time acceleration regime.
Read the full paper/thread here: https://github.com/Andyc316/D1-Theory
Looking forward to a productive technical discussion. Thank you.
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Nov 01 '18
Electron wave packet
Electron is wave packet in field.Can the electron wave packet expand in the atom or does the nuclear charge prevent the electron from expanding?
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Sep 14 '19
A new design could help you make the this page better.
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/GeneYoungDho • Sep 27 '24
Curtis Callan deserve to receive nobel prize, what is your opinion?
After a few days, annual announcement of nobel laureates is just return. Clarivate expects Quantum Informatics is the most-likelyhood field, which receive nobel physics prize this year.
I knew 2022 Nobel Laureates of Physics are in Quantum Informatics such that I'm not sure nobel commitee's choice picks Quantum Informatics again.
Instead, I think that Curtis Callan deserve to receive nobel prize for "Development of Scaling Methodology into Asymptotic Physical Investigation". Callan's Method (CS Equation) uses various part of QFT due to the Asymptotic Scaling of Renormalised Solution. Most of all, Frank Wilczek and David Gross, 2004 Nobel Laureates of Physics applied Callan's Method into Strong Interactions in their Main achievement for Nobel Prize. What is your opinion?
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Dec 29 '24
How much time should you dedicate to maths to be successful in physics?
Hi guys!
I ll try to keep it short!
We see many sad meltdown stories of smart people failing to understand QFT or GR at the graduate level because of their level in mathematics being too weak.
And sometimes they sadly realize afterwards only that their low level in mathematics was the real obstacle.
My question:
In the ideal case, starting from a regular undergraduate level , if you could assign your time exactly as you want, how much of your time would you allocate to study mathematics and how to study physics when your goal is to master QFT and GR?
Please avoid the "it depends" thing...I just need a rough percentage...60% physics/40% maths etc
If you can't avoid the "it depends" thing then please only address your personal case: how much time did YOU spend doing pure maths in proportion to physics during your studies?
Currently I am sticking to 33% maths/66% physics and I kind of feel I should increase the time allocated to maths...
BUT REALLY TO BE FRANK I FEEL THE MOST LOGICAL WAY IS TO STUDY ALL THE MATHEMATICS NEEDED AND ONLY THEN START TO STUDY PHYSICS!!! I FIND IT COMPLETELY STUPID TO INTRODUCE UNKNOWN MATHS TO PHYSICS STUDENTS AND LET THEM DEAL WITH IT!!! WHY WOULD YOU WRITE TRIPLE INTEGRALS IN YOUR PHYSICS COURSE WHEN YOUR STUDENTS HAVE NEVER SEEN THIS IN A MATH COURSE BEFORE??? SERIOUSLY WHY???? THE ONLY REASON I SEE IS TO ALLOW STUDENTS WHO CAME FROM A FAMILIAL ACADEMIC BACKGROUND TO HAVE AN EDGE ON OTHERS BECAUSE THEIR PARENTS WOULD HAVE MADE THEM AWARE OF THIS MADNESS!!
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/Qwery2496 • Mar 18 '25
Ask me any question, and I will answer it with quantum theory
This
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/GeneYoungDho • Jul 31 '24
How do you think QFT Cellular Automata can be the solution of Quantum Gravity?
After I read “G. ‘t Hooft, Nucl. Phys. B 386 (1992), 495”, I think The σ Spin Matrix in Cell (2.1) with automaton’s procedure for Jordan-Wigner Transform & Fourier Transform may consider a solution of QG.
‘t Hooft said this is not easy for adjusting QFT Cellular automata with non-convergent issue in large-distance domain & Low-energy. What if we use Local weyl transform in σ’s Fourier transform?
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/Ethrena • Jul 15 '24
Is it good to start with "FIELDS"
Hi, as in the title I want to study QFT but I am not sure if should begin with the "FIELDS" by Warren Siegel it has 1k pages after all. I know there exists an introductory textbook e.g. Ashok Das or Peskin but I want to know more alternatives. I am familiar with introductory field theory and know a bit about group theory tho.
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/suburban-operator • Sep 27 '24
Mind blowing experience: it felt like the Quantum Field uploaded a pamphlet into my brain-can anyone help me understand?
Hey everyone, I recently had an incredibly strange and profound experience that left me feeling both amazed and confused. It was like a pamphlet of information was downloaded directly into my brain—only I can't fully grasp it. The 'data' I received seemed to explain complex things in the simplest terms possible, like how time works and the nature of the smallest objects that exist.
I know this sounds wild, but I'm posting here because this group focuses on the quantum field theory, which is the closest thing I can think of that relates to this experience. Has anyone here ever had anything similar happen, or can someone help me make sense of what might be going on? I'm looking for scientific, philosophical, or experiential insights—anything that might help me understand this better.
Thanks in advance for your thoughts!
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/WatsonRotWeiss • Sep 10 '24
Help (Pleassse) at Obvious Lorentz Invariance
Tl;dr: I need some advice on how to spot "obviously" Lorentz invariant terms.
So, i was repeating the chapter to Quantization of the Electromagnetic Field in the book "Relativistic Quantum Mechanics and Field Theory" by Franz Gross. Where he introduces the relativistic Lagrangian in terms of the Field Strength Tensor. Shortly after, he continues by saying that this is obviously Lorentz invariant. But after 2 hours thinking about it, I still don't get why it is invariant...
This is not the first time, that I'm struggling to identify these "obviously" Lorentz invariant terms. I think I'm missing out on something here. So maybe some of you might have a tip for me on how you all can spot these Lorentz Invariances sooo easily.
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/timedonor • Feb 12 '17
The mystery of the fine structure constant has been solved
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/3f43aa0d • Jul 12 '17
Path Integral Project — Quantum Field Theory under Path Integral Formalism
path-integral-project.readthedocs.ior/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Dec 09 '24
A good book on classical fields?
I need recommendations on good books for studying classical fields
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/Formal-Tourist-9046 • Dec 06 '24
Looking for People to Learn QFT with me
Hey everyone,
So my school does not offer any quantum field theory, so I decided to use the materials for MIT courseware to learn on my own. I tend to struggle in some chapters and was hoping to possibly collaborate or have someone to regularly reach out to, if possible, with questions regarding the subject.
Thank you in advance!
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/Boleslavski • Dec 07 '24
Creation Operators Question
Let's say I have a position operator ψ(x)† acting on the vacuum state |0⟩ and I want to create a two particle fermion system. Is it simply...?
ψ(y)† ψ(x)† |0⟩ = ∫dp/(2π)^3*dq/(2π)^3*(f(p)g(q)-f(q)g(p))*(e^i(p_μ x^μ))(e^i(q_ν y^ν))a(q)†a(p)†|0⟩
Where I am using the p_μ four vector shorthand to save space writing the energy component times time minus the dot product of p and x.
If I wanted to produce a gaussian distribution in momentum space what would the normalized relativistic gaussian look like? It's quite easy to find the non-relativistic gaussian solution to the schrodinger equation, but I'm having trouble finding sources that describe what a relativistic gaussian in momentum space would look like.
r/QuantumFieldTheory • u/[deleted] • Oct 19 '20
Newbie
I have a QFT module and I've never done special relativity etc before. Are there some good lectures I could watch?