r/QuantumComputing • • Dec 04 '19

TIL that one interpretation of quantum computing is that we are borrowing compute power from parallel universes.

2 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

7

u/dbulger Dec 04 '19

Can you elaborate or provide a link?

3

u/EngSciGuy Dec 04 '19

Try David Deutsch's book "Fabric of Reality". He kind of goes down that rabbit hole, and also uses it to explain how time travel could work. Interesting thought experiments.

7

u/dbulger Dec 04 '19

I guess my main worry here is that this bare statement, with no further detail, will suggest to some readers that we're in a kind of computational arms race with our own parallel selves. Almost surely that's not what was really meant.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '19

I would read this short story.

1

u/dbulger Dec 04 '19

Haha yeah actually that could be good. But also, you might like The Last Legends of Earth, by A A Attanasio; it's not quite the same idea, but close.

2

u/EngSciGuy Dec 04 '19

I don't follow. Have you read the book? That isn't really how it is explained.

4

u/dbulger Dec 04 '19

I've read some material from Deutsch before, but not that book, nor any other version of this claim other than the one in the OP's subject heading.

If you mean "that isn't really how it is explained" in the book, that's kind of my point. Summarising whatever Deutsch was actually saying into this one sentence, which doesn't clearly describe the idea and is easy to misunderstand, seems counter to the subreddit's goals, and probably counter to OP's intention.

That's why I asked for a source (and I was hoping for an online one); it wasn't meant as an attack, I was just trying to draw out the OP about this potentially interesting topic.

Anyhow, since you've read it, are you up to explaining the idea?

6

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '19

I think the strongest evidence against this is that if this were the case, that would mean parallel universes would also be borrowing compute power from us, and I'm pretty sure we'd notice if our quantum computers started running on their own. And you can't claim that parallel universes would only ever run their computation at the same time as us, because there's always going to be a universe where Craig got up slightly earlier in the morning and got to the quantum computer first.

3

u/rrtucci Dec 04 '19 edited Dec 04 '19

Making fun of Neven's religion, eh? Now you'll never get a job at Google. You'll have to work for Microsoft instead. You're screwed

Harmut Neven believes that his double exponential Neven's Law is confirmation of parallel universes. See this video from 16:30 onwards https://youtu.be/l3ufl6YomTQ

1

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '19

Did classical computers not grow double exponentially for a while, since we were adding bits and storage and processor speed and improving everything about them all at once? (That sounds kinda hand-wavy as I ask it, but a few years isn't enough time to know if this trend will continue).

These are all pretty weak criticisms coming from some random guy in the internet, though. I dislike Many Worlds, but some really smart people seem to like it, so maybe I'm the asshole?

1

u/rrtucci Dec 04 '19 edited Dec 04 '19

I like the Many Worlds Interpretation so much that I was moved to make a movie about it. This is in honor of David Deutsch, Max Tegmark and Sean Carroll

https://youtu.be/7IYP3TwwsDE

3

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19

It's a valid point, but I think strong evidence against this is also that you must expend work to get useful information, or you are violating the laws of thermodynamics. To leverage imaginary parallel worlds of compute is to receive the beneficial information from the compute without expending the energy to do the compute. Effectively, it is the old zero point energy system again, but using parallel worlds as the source of the energy.