r/QuakeLive • • Feb 20 '15

Quake Live's developers

Do they even give a shit about what their players want? It seems like they don't. The lack of modding support, requiring players to pay money just to be able to vote on the next map, removing all gibs and blood textures, screwing up the weapon balancing, getting rid of the classic announcer voice, dropping support for Linux (even though Quake 3 is an open source game), the whole doing away with the unique hellish-themed level design in favor of boring, futuristic sports arena levels, etc. I will say it's much smoother and less laggy than Quake 3 and there's lots of other improvements, but it seems like for every improvement they added in Quake Live, they did something dumb that made it shittier. And going back to the original Quake 3 isn't even an option because all of the players left and went to Quake Live when it started, and now that community is dwindling off as well. Do the developers even interact with their players at all? It seems like they are completely out of touch with the Quake community and everything Quake is supposed to be.

0 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

40

u/SyncError Feb 20 '15

I'd say that we care way more than anyone will ever realize or give us credit for. We know there has been a lot of disdain from the more hardcore crowd in the community, but we're doing a lot of good things behind the scene and we hope that everyone will have some faith and look forward to the future.

4

u/TuringsTesticles Feb 20 '15

Sincerely asking here: what does your vision for the future of QL look like?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

A 404 page.

4

u/theStingraY Feb 20 '15

Get real, it'd forward to bethsoft.com

7

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

As a fellow software developer, you have my sympathies in having to deal with so many cranky adolescents. I greatly appreciate your efforts and understand how difficult it is to do what you do. While there's always room for criticisms, you guys seem to be moving the game in a good direction.

the whole doing away with the unique hellish-themed level design in favor of boring, futuristic sports arena levels

I, for one, appreciate a simpler more "sporty" aesthetic and hope that goes even further. If Quake is the quintessential FPS arena game, I like the idea of a purified no bullshit art direction. Would love to see the classic maps re-skinned with that in mind.

9

u/SyncError Feb 20 '15

I don't think anything is wrong with a sporty minimal them, but it is tough to do it here and there, but not throughout. In the end I'm a sucker for the Quake 1 Lovecraftian environments more than anything else. They have a great appeal (and not just one that stems from nostalgia).

3

u/onastyinc Feb 20 '15

We need GL Quake Live!

3

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

omfg that would be amazing. Quake 1 with real actual netcode? I'd shit my fucking pants to play some Netquake CTF

3

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

Quake 1 has netcode - it's called Quakeworld.

1

u/bobwinters Feb 22 '15

I think he means better netcode with hitscan, but I see your point.

2

u/theStingraY Feb 20 '15

That would be so wonderful. I wish more versions of multiplayer quake were under the Quakelive service.

1

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

The creepy demon-alien bio-robot-hybrid stuff has a special place in my heart too; especially being young and getting spooked out in single player. I just tend to turn the video settings way down so things look homogenized anyway. Would be cool if there was an Emil Ruder theme/mode that kinda ran with that tendency. Totally agree that consistency is paramount though. Thanks for chiming in!

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

What was your favorite Quake 1 level? Was it the brown castle, the other brown castle, or the puke-green castle?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 20 '15

I'm a software developer too, and I'm 25 years old. I'm not a cranky adolescent, I'm just a longtime Quake fan offering some constructive criticism. But instead of behaving in a professional manner and actually listening to customer feedback, it seems like the QL devs (if this person even is a real dev) prefer to get into childish internet flame wars with their rapidly dwindling playerbase and monetize the shit out of the game just to keep their profits in the black. Go ahead and downvote all of these people's criticisms into obscurity if it makes you feel better to bury your head in the sand, but it won't change the undeniable fact that your game is in its death throes and your business is failing.

3

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

What flamewars are you referring to?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

The one we are in right now.

1

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't you create the topic? SyncError's replies are measured and a lot more civil than they probably should be. If anyone has been childish in this whole thread it's certainly not the QL devs. It's possible that SyncError posted a snarky comment and deleted it, but, I don't see anything that I'd flag as a "flame" -- that's why I asked.

So, are you OK man? Seriously, I am having a hard time understanding where your outlook and attitude are coming from. I'm starting to wonder if you need some fresh air, a walk around the block, and maybe a hug. Pet some dogs. Have a pint.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '15

Have a pint.

I think you've had one too many.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

I don't understand what you are complaining about. It's because of people like you that Quake has a toxic community. My only concern is that: toxic / immature community. Hell, someone told me he was going to "cut my throat" because we lost a 2v2 Thunderstruck game, what the f*** ? I am in no way a noob, and some of you might have played with or against me in CA.

For the Linux part: I don't know at what level you are playing but I can tell you this: I have tried linux and it just didn't compare to windows in terms of performances, ie: mouse drivers suck in Linux. These are little things that makes you loose the edge. I don't mind rebooting to windows to play Quake.

Also, you are young for a quake player. The only game that has my interest is Quake Live, and it's saying a lot because I don't play videogames anymore, they just don't interest me.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 20 '15

Toxic community? What are you talking about? I've been playing Quake for like 15 years and the people seem pretty much the same to me as they've always been. If anything, they are more civil than ever; in the early days, shit talking was much more rampant.

1

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

http://www.reddit.com/r/QuakeLive/comments/2wf1yk/your_community_is_really_bad_sorry/

It's a common observation. QL is not a welcoming group. That more than any of your criticisms is responsible for its lack of growth.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

Eh, I don't agree with that sort of thinking. Blaming the online community is like getting mad at the weather. Whenever you connect to a public server for any online game, it is inevitable that you will run into a lot of annoying idiots. People on the internet are going to be assholes and there's nothing that can be done about it, it's just something we all have to deal with.

4

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

We can't really change the weather. But we can influence the community and try to nurture a more inclusive culture. Throwing your hands up and saying "eh, it's the internet. that's just how it is" is a complete cop out. No one is saying you need to pussy-foot around every critical issue, but not being an asshole about it would be a good thing to keep in mind.

You say you're a software developer? There are number of articles and essays that expound on the power of culture surrounding languages, projects and technical ecosystems. For instance, I'm not a "Rails guy", but I recognize that a significant amount of its cachet comes from the strength and helpfulness of it's community. In contrast, Linus Torvalds has alienated a lot of people over the years while developing an arguably less durable cult of personality around himself. This kind of stuff is important whether you think it's uncontrollable or not.

You came on this sub and, with little tact or diplomacy, spat unhelpful criticisms and invectives. I don't know how much of this was because of your own personality or because you think this is an appropriate tone for this community. Either way, I've voiced my opinions in hope of nudging the QL ethos in the opposite direction so it becomes something we "have to deal with" less and less.

4

u/reallyserious Feb 20 '15

Please provide source for your claim of flame wars from the QL developers.

4

u/Blood154 Feb 20 '15

The problem is your Support. They really don't give a shit about players. The net forums are full of threads about false bans. If you want respect, get rid of the parasites at your support. I speak about the one using Sasparillo nick. I'm sure you could find plenty of cases about false positives he ignored.

The thing is your anticheat is broken, but you don't get the information about it, because fucking support don't give a shit.

4

u/-Venser- Feb 20 '15

You should do a reddit AMA ;)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Jun 26 '16

[DELETED]

2

u/volchonokilli Feb 20 '15

... What about Ukraine servers :/

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Jun 26 '16

[DELETED]

0

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

Can't imagine why doing business in Ukraine would be difficult right now. /s

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

I doubt it has anything to do with the current political climate of Ukraine; it's more likely that they don't have anyone in their staff who can communicate in Russian or Ukrainian.

0

u/volchonokilli Feb 21 '15

... If that was the case, why not trying to communicate with English? -_- Really, that your reply doesn't make any sense

1

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '15

English isn't a commonly spoken language in the Eastern Bloc. Russian is.

0

u/volchonokilli Feb 21 '15

And? That doesn't mean that support of the company don't know English... Or someone else.

0

u/volchonokilli Feb 21 '15

Well, UA servers disappeared like already one year ago... Back then I really can't see why doing business in Ukraine would be difficult. And there were always people on Ukraine servers.

1

u/veringer Feb 21 '15

Political instability and an active conflict with a nuclear power?

0

u/volchonokilli Feb 21 '15

I've typed - "back then", around one year ago, before Crimea's annexation...

1

u/veringer Feb 21 '15

The Euromaidan unrest was happening well before the Crimean annexation.

0

u/volchonokilli Feb 21 '15

That was after. And was doing business hard even when we had unrest?.. I was actually stunned how life was ordinary during it aside battles is the center... And thugs freely wandering in groups on streets until organized groups of self-defense was repelling them...

→ More replies (0)

2

u/volchonokilli Feb 20 '15

sweet 3 ms ping... I really miss it

2

u/NewW0rld Feb 21 '15

The bad aspect of your job is that no matter what change you make there will always be some players who shit on it and on you. I want to say that--despite me not liking some of the major changes that have been made recently--I respect your work, your dedication and resoluteness. It's a tough job to make improvements when the playerbase is spread so thin, and a particularly unpopular update could kill the game; that's a heavy weight to carry on your shoulders.

1

u/NewW0rld Feb 20 '15

The bad aspect of your job is that no matter what change you make there will always be some players who will shit on it and on you, but I want to say that--although I didn't like some of the changes you've made throughout the years--I respect your work, your dedication and your resoluteness. It's a tough job to improve the game when the playerbase is spread so thin that an espeecially bad change can kill the game; that's a heavy weight to carry.

1

u/gowhatyourself Feb 22 '15

It's not that people don't want to give you credit, it's that changes keep being implemented for things it seems very few people are asking for. Nobody really knows what the future of the game looks like because you guys never articulate it. If you can't do that then I wouldn't expect anyone to understand what it might be. I'm only saying this from a business perspective. The subscribers, both potential and current, really do not know what you plan on doing. That should change if you want people to keep the faith.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

I'd also like to point out that you, the person whose job it is to listen to feedback from the community, have not addressed any of the points I made in my post.

-24

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

Well maybe you should spend more time working on the game and less time shitposting on Reddit and getting into petty arguments with your own fucking fanbase.

19

u/SyncError Feb 20 '15

I have both my coding environment and my level editor open atm working at midnight. There is no room to put me down for also taking the time when I'm at home to read community postings. Isn't that the entire point of the post? That you questioned whether we were even in touch with what people are feeling and saying?

8

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

I appreciate yall's work and it's awesome to hear there are eyes on the future of the game. Quakelive has undergone a lot of changes over the last couple years (for the better!) and has more activity than ever. Thanks a lot, I'm a long time fan. I'll be going to my 12th quakecon this summer <3

-19

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

Are you really a QL developer? If so, that explains a lot.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

[deleted]

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 20 '15

I know who SyncError is - he's the PR lackey Id hired to do damage control every time they make a poor business decision that alienates their entire community. But I didn't know he actually worked on any of the games.

10

u/veringer Feb 20 '15

Wow man. You are a piece of shit.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

These problems aren't programming issues; because of John Carmack, Quake already has an extremely solid codebase, as evidenced by the sheer number of highly successful games based on its source code. And Quake Live did a great job of improving the code - the game is a lot smoother than Quake 3 was and lag is a lot less of a problem than it used to be. The problem is the design choices and business decisions that seem to have been made out of desperation rather than rational thought. The game is losing popularity and the developers don't know what to do about it, so they're trying to appeal to a wider audience and all it's doing is alienating the diehard Quake fans, while the mainstream crowd still has zero interest in playing a 15 year old game.

4

u/exocortex Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 22 '15

First oft all you are not criticising constructively nor politely. So if you want to have people listen to you be nice. A lot has changed in quake live. A lot I also don't like that much. But I can say that in a respectful way. Try that and people will start to listen to you.

Nobody will listen to you're words when your telling people that they are stupid and everything they do is wrong.

edit: spelling

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

First of all, I didn't call anyone stupid. Second of all, this is the internet. If you're too thin-skinned to handle any kind of criticism, then go somewhere else.

3

u/reallyserious Feb 20 '15

If you want to see development, vote with your wallet. If more people paid for QL then they would never have dropped linux and mac support. The reason there is so little development is that there isn't a strong financial incentive to support a community that doesn't pay.

I'm often alone with pro status when I play.

1

u/theStingraY Feb 20 '15

I tried to buy pro status during the holiday sale. I never heard back from the QL support when I ran into issues buying a year sub.

1

u/HeilHilter They've Ruined QUAKE!! Feb 20 '15

I did vote with my wallet, I was a pro subscriber until they started fucking with the core gameplay mechanics such as gather weapons and items. They added loadouts and a new gun which made the machine gun never be used. I exclusively played FFA, it was great fun. But now it's just cluster fuck of rocket spam. Just spared? Already got rockets to spam, get killed again, instantly rewarded with more rockets to spam. Now imagine that shit on a full server. It's constant uncontrolled chaos.

1

u/reallyserious Feb 20 '15

I, too, am disappointed with the loadouts. On the other hand it has made me try out the other game modes more and some of them are really fun.

-7

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 20 '15

You're saying that the reason there is little development is people aren't giving the QL developers enough money; that's ludicrous. The way business works is, you make a good product and then the money comes after. It doesn't work the other way around. It's if you build it, they will come. Not if they come, you will build it.

Also, dropping Linux and Mac support due to financial reasons doesn't make any sense. Linux and Mac support equals more players equals more profits. And Quake 3 was already a fully cross-platform compatible game until they got done with it.

2

u/reallyserious Feb 20 '15

It's if you build it, they will come. Not if they come, you will build it.

Sorry, no. There's no guarantee that if they build it (whatever it refers to here) they would get more sales. Given the small revenues ql generates there isn't a big budget to take money from to build things either.

Also, dropping Linux and Mac support due to financial reasons doesn't make any sense. Linux and Mac support equals more players equals more profits.

Linux + Mac users were 6% when QL was still a browser plugin. I vaguely remember reading that the amount of paying customers running linux were also lower than on the other platforms. Maintaining several platforms costs money in suport and maintenance. Given how low the revenues were for those platforms compared to what they would cost to maintain and provide support for it's an easy decision to ditch them.

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 20 '15

It doesn't cost anything and it doesn't require any extra maintenance. Modern Q3 sourceports already support Windows, Mac, and Linux players playing on the same server without any modification needed. There isn't a different source for each platform - it's all the same code. Quake 3 is an open source game and modern Q3 clients use OpenGL and are entirely cross-platform compatible. Unless they switched to using Visual Studio and Direct3D for developing QL, there's simply no excuse for the game not being cross-platform. The entire reason QL is failing is because they took an open-source game, broke it, and tried to monetize it, without adding anything that gives players an incentive to pay.

2

u/reallyserious Feb 20 '15

Every platform they support needs to be tested on those platforms for every release. That costs money.

When there is someone having problem with the linux or max version they need to be able to answer that. That costs money.

If the money it costs is larger than what those platforms generate it's a losing proposition to maintain them.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 20 '15

With modern, open source ports of Q3, there doesn't need to be a "Linux version" or a "Mac version." It's all the same code. As long as they use GCC to compile it, OpenGL to render the graphics, and avoid bad programming practices like using platform-dependent system calls and deviating from ISO standards, the code is guaranteed to compile on every platform that supports GCC, which is pretty much every platform.

One of the reasons John Carmack became disillusioned with QL and Id Software in general is he is a strong proponent of doing things the modern, open source way as well as things like modding and community involvement, and they prefer doing things the outmoded, proprietary way like not allowing mods or player-run servers and using Microsoft's Visual C++ compiler and Direct3D instead of GCC and OpenGL. It would be both cheaper and easier to do things the John Carmack way - it doesn't require purchasing licenses for proprietary software and OpenGL is much easier to use and understand than Direct3D is.

1

u/reallyserious Feb 20 '15 edited Feb 20 '15

With modern, open source ports of Q3, there doesn't need to be a "Linux version" or a "Mac version." It's all the same code. As long as they use GCC to compile it, OpenGL to render the graphics, and avoid bad programming practices like using platform-dependent system calls and deviating from ISO standards, the code is guaranteed to compile on every platform that supports GCC, which is pretty much every platform.

I'm sorry but it's clear that you don't understand what it takes to do professional development for paying customers. Selling a product and providing support for it is different from running an open source project as a hobby.

One of the reasons John Carmack became disillusioned with QL and Id Software in general is he is a strong proponent of doing things the modern, open source way as well as things like modding and community involvement, and they prefer doing things the outmoded, proprietary way like not allowing mods or player-run servers and using Microsoft's Visual C++ compiler and Direct3D instead of GCC and OpenGL. It would be both cheaper and easier to do things the John Carmack way - it doesn't require purchasing licenses for proprietary software and OpenGL is much easier to use and understand than Direct3D is.

Please provide a source for your claims on Carmack's reasoning. It sounds like you use Carmack's name to project your own ideas.

It's funny though, I remember an interview with Carmack a long time ago where he said he preferred developing on windows since the tools were better than what was available on linux.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

This whole clusterfuck of a discussion reminds me of those restaurant reality shows. The restaurant owners are panicking and don't know how to stop their business from failing, Gordon Ramsey comes in and tells them what they are doing wrong, then they get all butthurt and call him an asshole for criticizing them.

1

u/lol_like_for_realz Feb 25 '15

Looks like the same complaints since I started playing shortly after QL's release.

1

u/erkmemiwiwiwiwiwiw Feb 25 '15

Quakelive is fine where it is.

Developers? With perhaps 50-60 paying customers world-wide, I don't think they're in a position to 'develop' much. It's a tiny, tiny scene.

The only things I'd like to see: updated player models, and custom game modes. Getting people to play your game is not a matter of: graphics, skins, weapons, but GAME MODES.

I'd like a game mode that resembles CS's gun game, for instance. Or how about a version of Freezetag where you do more damage when more of your teammates are dead... that's be awesome.

-11

u/HeilHilter They've Ruined QUAKE!! Feb 20 '15

I'd say a definite nope. This is a sad excuse of a game. People who are just getting into quake will think this was the glorious quake 3 of our times, when in reality it's call of Duty with reskined maps. I think the worst offenses were the loadouts and voice announcer. Once in a great while a kind soul will host a classic FFA server with no loadouts. And it is so fun! The game is more complex and has different phases of battle (hiding and gather supplies, then battle and control item spawn points, die, rinse and repeat). Now it's just a cluster fuck of rocket spam.

1

u/hommesuperbe Feb 20 '15

Not seen one server i played on with load-outs.

2

u/ziel Feb 20 '15

Still don't get at all why they even put it in. Haven't played quake in a while but ive never read one positive thing about loadouts. Were they really hoping having this messed up system would attract some cod players? It only seems to have made all people who already liked quake lose faith.

1

u/seviliyorsun Feb 20 '15

I like the loadouts. It's fucking ffa not duel. Just spawn me with the guns I want so I can get straight to clicking on people.

-8

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

Yeah QL is like a diet version of Quake 3 Arena, it's basically the same game but with all the fun filtered out. It's kind of like when Jack N the Box takes all their leftovers, throws them in a tiny box, and sells it to you under a stupid rebranding like "Munchie Meal" or "Late Night Foodie Call" bullshit when they're really just trying to sell stale shit that expired hours ago (or in this case, decades).

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '15

Forgot to add, after Carmack left, the untrained interns had to copy and paste code from unlagged, cpma, and defrag and put a QL logo on top of it. The sheeple still buy PRO.

2

u/hommesuperbe Feb 20 '15

John carmack didnt have anything to do with the port of quake3.