r/Qtum • • Oct 20 '17

How QTUM Foundation lost my 48,000 tokens. And didn’t care.

87 Upvotes

It all started just over a month ago when I was caught up in the Chinese exchanges’ closure with my tokens in ICO365.

I had followed QTUM with interest for a while and I was very excited about the project, so much that when the ICO came I decided to invest a good amount on it, buying 48,224 tokens from ICO365, equal to almost 0.1% of the total ICO offering. The main reason I invested so much in it was the quality of the team behind the project: a quality team for a quality project, I thought. Well, I would eventually change my mind about that.

Around the beginning of September I tried to withdraw my tokens to get ready for the long awaited swap with the launch of Ignition, but when I contacted ICO365 about that I was given the first bad news: no withdraw was allowed until the Chinese situation with the exchanges was clear. Of course I was a bit nervous but trusted that it was only going to be a temporary itch, something that would be sorted very soon. Unfortunately if only got worse.

After a few days of me chasing them, ICO365 communicated me that the tokens ad been returned to the QTUM Foundation and in order to receive them I had to deal directly with them. After an initial panic and some online research I found this:

https://medium.com/@Qtum/qtum-community-development-updates-september-18-31970934b7d3

the famous development update where they were clarifying the timing of the swap

"The Qtum team currently holds all of the main network tokens until the swap happens on October 4th, 2017 (6pm PST)”

  • and the part I was more interested about -

"A quick reminder to withdraw your Qtum ERC20 tokens from Yunbi.com, and if you have tokens that were not retrieved from ICO365, please e-mail [email protected] >and we will get back to you within 1–2 weeks. "- .

I sent my first email to [email protected] on the 19th september, asking for clarification. I didn’t expect them to respond straight away, as they made clear that it would take time, but when 10 days past without any news I started getting worried again.

I sent them another email on the 29th asking for any more news and what details they needed from me. I got no answer.

On the 2nd of October I sent them a new email, with my ICO365 details, email, username balance and my Bittrex erc20 address, so that they could send them straight there it would be swapped straight away. For the third time no answer. We were getting closer and closer to the swap date, and no one was paying any attention to any of my emails. Of course at QTUM they were very busy with the launch of Ignition, still it had been over 2 weeks and we were not talking peanuts really. We were talking about 48224 tokens, now worth more that an average property, but still no answer.

I decided to let the swap period pass so they could sort their things out, but more and more worried by their complete silence.

On the 9th of October, when the swap was supposed to had been completed for 5 days, I sent another email with the details from the previous one, specifying that the erc20 address was before the swap, and adding the new QTUM address from Bittrex. At this point I was emailing not only [email protected], but also [email protected], hoping for anyone to answer, or at least to acknowledge that someone was looking into it.

Finally, on the 10th of October I received an answer from [email protected].

It simply read:

tokens are sent https://etherscan.io/tx/0x011c6d4be72386a5b0082e606172e780fe4d6f93336c8bae9d448a0d9779a1cb

Nothing more, not a note, nothing about our previous emails. Not even a greeting, nothing. But even worse, it was an ERC20 transaction. On the 10th of October. After the swap.

I panicked straight away, they had sent the tokens to the Bittrex ERC20 address I gave them from the old email, despite the deadline of the swap having being a week before. Why would they do that? First thing I did was to check my Bittrex account, but there was no trace of them there. I contacted Bittrex support straight away, which, contrary to QTUM, responded promptly, unfortunately with bad news:

Hi They sent it to the wrong address. We won't recover it since it was sent on the 4th after our wallets turned off. You contact them about this problem.
https://support.bittrex.com/hc/en-us/articles/115001606011-Support-for-the-Qtum-QTUM-blockchain-upgrade

Now I was gobsmacked and, even worse, seriously worries! It had already been surreal to receive a 2 line answer from QTUM after all the emails I sent them, how was I going to sort this out?

In the meantime I received an email from [email protected] which just said:

sorry, we cannot send anything to you because we didn't receive any of your information from ICO365 office. please check with ICO365 first.

I didn’t know if I was supposed to laugh or cry. Who was I dealing with? Two email answering my request with opposite responses, both of which didn’t make any sense. More and more worried.

I contacted them again forwarding the Bittrex email asking why they had sent the tokens to an ERC20 address after the deadline that THEY had set up and communicated in their blog, and how we could solve this situation. This time the answer was prompt, but their style was the one I was getting used to:

we just checked again, we sent the tokens to the ERC20 address 0xfd56adb0d3db185afc59c75138b45bde292e8a28 you gave us. and here is the record. you can >check again

I emailed them again and again, pointing out that I cave them the QTUM address, and the ERC20 was before the swap, but there was only silence from their side after that. That was it.

Now, the current value of the tokens easily surpasses half million dollars, currently reaching almost 600k, and I want to make clear that I’m not millionaire and for me it’s a life-changing situation. But believe it or not what makes me almost as mad as the money loss is QTUM Foundation behaviour.

I believe in them, in their project and in their team and I invested in them a fair amount before the ICO craze that hit the blockchain, how could this happen?

I can’t think of any decent company that was dismissing their misplacing of over 120 BTC worth of tokens in a single line. I can’t thing of any decent company that would ignore one of their investor’s requests of clarification over a half million dollar transaction which disappeared. Nor I can’t think of any decent company with such a combination of arrogance and incompetence blended in a mix of disregard for their investors.

Is this what the crypto idea of business is? Are these the companies we think will create the future? Incompetent, arrogant, complacent and, almost more scarily, dishonest?

What I almost hope is that all this business was dealt by an intern who didn’t have a clue of what he/she was doing nor any english, it’s the only explanation I can think of for the rude responses and the daft actions. My hope would be for someone from QTUM to come forward and offered to take some interest on what has happened, showing some sort of professionalism that would be expected from a billion dollar company. Half a million of which they seem to have taken from me for good.

----- UPDATE -----

Final welcome update. All tokens were sent to me yesterday (I could check only now) as I was promised by Patrick. As you can guess it's a HUGE burden off my stomach, and I would like to thank both the community for their support and the team for a prompt help. At the end I think it was just some admin cockup (even though a costly one) and once the team was (eventually) aware of it, they jumped in straight away and solved it. I'd like to thank Patrick Dai for the personal interest he took and, for more than obvious reason, I hope this project can keep going the pace it is. I'm a happy man. Thank all of you again!


r/Qtum • • Sep 13 '17

Official Qtum AMA Thread. Starts at 10pm Beijing Time (10am New York, 3pm London), September 13th

69 Upvotes

The format is simple, the most upvoted questions will get answered first. We will be live from Shanghai between 10pm-midnight, we will upload pictures along the way.

We may not get to every question, and we may not answer ones that are downvoted by the community, but that doesn't mean you can't ask whatever you want.

You do not have to wait until 10pm to ask a question, you can ask now and start voting so the action starts right away. Please remember that it can take up to 10 minutes for a response to questions that require long responses.

Things to remember:

Do not ask about anything illegal Do not ask about price predictions Do not ask questions that have been answered many times Do not ask us what we think about other projects

Here is the link to the Main Network 1.0.1 release: https://github.com/qtumproject/qtum/releases/tag/mainnet-ignition-v1.0.1

Qtum Explainer Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_YT6Xvbbe3Y


r/Qtum • • Sep 08 '17

Main Network Complete!

Thumbnail
twitter.com
66 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Sep 13 '17

Main info from AMA - looking good

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Feb 17 '18

Spacechain (QTUM Project) Bringing the Blockchain to Space (Video Interview)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
60 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Mar 19 '21

⚠️ Mandatory Update 💥Qtum Core Mainnet Fast Lane v0.20.2 Hard Fork - Update Before April 30

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Jan 24 '18

Satellite is Ready Making Qtum the First Blockchain Network with a Fill Node in Space on February 2, 2018!

58 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Dec 31 '17

Nasdaq : Forget Bitcoin and Ethereum: Say Hello to Qtum

Thumbnail
m.nasdaq.com
58 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Dec 19 '17

Please do not "bash" other projects

57 Upvotes

We dislike censorship, and have been very lenient about the posts in this subreddit. We ask that people do not bash other projects. If we see this kind of activity we may delete the posts. We do not want to create an aura of Qtum-maximalism, or cult-like behavior. This post is directed almost exclusively at people who are lashing at out Neo/ANS, please stop this.


r/Qtum • • Oct 16 '17

What Is QTUM? (Without the Bullshit)

Thumbnail
storeofvalue.github.io
55 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Feb 05 '18

Patrick Dai CNBC interview "Regulators need to see the 'big picture' of blockchain"

Thumbnail
cnbc.com
54 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Jan 16 '18

HUGE: Qtum Partners With Starbucks

Thumbnail
luvcrypto.com
53 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Dec 19 '17

Good exposure in Forbes! Alright QTUM

53 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Jan 06 '18

QTUM'S B.I.G ANNOUNCEMENT IS FINALLY READY!!!

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Jan 18 '18

Motley Fool: Step Aside, Ripple and Stellar: Qtum Just Landed 2 Big Partners in 2 Days

51 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Sep 01 '17

NEO vs QTUM: An Objective Comparison

Thumbnail
storeofvalue.github.io
50 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Nov 30 '23

Qtum Core v24.1 Hardfork Mandatory Update

Post image
48 Upvotes

Qtum has a scheduled mandatory update estimated on November 27, 2023, 00:24 UTC for the Qtum mainnet. Please update your Qtum build to v24.1 by the main network before block height 3385122 (3298892 testnet).

This upgrade aims to enhance the platform’s performance and security, further solidifying Qtum’s position in the cryptocurrency market.

As the hype around the potential approval of a spot Bitcoin ETF by the US SEC grows, Qtum’s proximity to Bitcoin is pushing its price higher. QTUM token price has surged by 23% over the past 24 hours and 38.68% in the last seven days.

Do people have any plans with QTUM in the future? Sell ​​or buy more? QTUM and RBIF are the two projects that I invest the most at this time. These will be two projects that I will never sell for any reason. I will continue to buy and hold waiting for the upcoming uptrend

https://github.com/qtumproject/qtum/releases/tag/v24.1


r/Qtum • • Jan 25 '18

Robinhood is adding crypto investment options for users. QTUM made the list of the 16 coins.

Thumbnail
cnbc.com
48 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Jan 04 '18

Qtum Partners With Baofeng To Become Bigger Than Bitcoin And Ethereum

Thumbnail
chipin.com
48 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Oct 24 '17

Qtum Confirmed QTUM MOBILE WALLET - DOWNLOAD NOW

Thumbnail
play.google.com
47 Upvotes

r/Qtum • • Oct 21 '17

Qtum Official The Qtum Foundation is not "dumping coins", nor are we "cashing out"

47 Upvotes

Unsure how this rumor/FUD got started, but the Qtum Foundation is not "dumping coins". We have never sold a single coin from the foundation account. We use Qtum directly for funding some things, like hackathon prizes, helping projects get off the ground, etc. But we use the Bitcoin raised in the crowdsale from March to fund all operations of Qtum and pay for salaries etc.


r/Qtum • • Oct 08 '17

Upcoming exciting news about Qtum blockchain.

46 Upvotes

So last night Patrick Dai, the founder of Qtum, had a long and productive discussion with the community on Telegram and provided some exciting information regarding Qtum and its bright future.

Here are some snippets:

• Top 5 exchange will list Qtum next week https://i.imgur.com/88FAwd5.jpg

• Working towards establishing a Qtum Enterprise Alliance (QEA) https://i.imgur.com/ogrOwEu.jpg

• Ledger support by mid October, Trezor possible as well https://i.imgur.com/iLhkmI3.jpg

• Mobile wallet releasing very soon https://i.imgur.com/KWFlH47.jpg

• Technical info regarding PoS, and its rewards https://i.imgur.com/n6VoGwi.jpg

• Network staking from above will be a reality https://i.imgur.com/xpznd5J.jpg

• Regarding Coinone's token swap delay https://i.imgur.com/2H9y9F7.jpg

• Lightning network in development, coming soon https://i.imgur.com/cjDGL3a.jpg

• Japanese and Indian exchange(s) will list Qtum https://i.imgur.com/xnxDbUR.jpg

• Working on some collaborations with the Chinese government https://i.imgur.com/XS0ASFR.jpg

Also, an updated roadmap is coming out this month as well.


r/Qtum • • Nov 30 '17

Qtum added to the ledger!

45 Upvotes

Qtum has just been added to the ledger I think twitter post


r/Qtum • • Oct 23 '17

Qtum Official Qtum's PoS vs CASPER (and the nothing-at-stake problem)

45 Upvotes

Someone asked about this in Slack, and I know I've been asked a few other times about it. So, I'll make an actual post for everyone's benefit.

Qtum's PoS implementation and CASPER serve the same basic purpose and have the same overall goals, but their implementation and design is completely different. First, about CASPER:

  • CASPER uses smart contracts in order to track the stakes and funds created.

  • CASPER requires a minimum amount of coins to participate in staking

  • CASPER requires making a "deposit" and locking your coins for a set amount of time in order to participate in staking (I believe this is something like 30 days)

  • CASPER provides a partial solution to the nothing-at-stake problem by punishing stakers who misbehave (ie, they lose their deposit)

  • CASPER's full nothing-at-stake solution is both the punishment feature, and users choosing off-chain centralized servers to determine which blockchain is legitimate in the case of multiple.

And now, compared to Qtum:

  • Qtum uses basic Bitcoin Script opcodes and transactions to track stakes and funds created - We believe this is better just because it has been tested for far longer. It is slightly less flexible, but ultimately encourages decentralization and stability.

  • Qtum does not require a minimum amount of coins to participate in staking. 1 coin can help secure the network the same way 1 million coins can, though 1 million coins will of course find more blocks, etc

  • Qtum does not require locking your coins. It only requires that the coins mature for about 20 hours before they can be used for staking. Afterwards, the coins can be sent very quickly in case of network issues, private key compromise, etc. (though immediately after your coins have staked, you must wait 20 hours before they can be spent)

  • Qtum plans to provide a different solution to the nothing-at-stake problem and will never punish stakers that misbehave other than kicking them off the network. We believe no software can be made perfect, and so the risk of a bug causing the staker to misbehave and lose millions of dollars is unacceptable to us

  • Qtum's nothing-at-stake solution will be implemented in 2018 and will be an optional consensus feature (ie, no fork etc required). Basically, we will put some data on the Bitcoin blockchain that can be later verified through SPV. This makes it so that it is impossible for an attacker to lie about when a particular block was created, which is the biggest vector used to construct a nothing-at-stake attack setup.

Beyond that, we are confident that the nothing at stake problem is pretty overblown, at least with the way our consensus system works. It's incredibly expensive to construct the setup for the attack, and when it is all setup, the only nodes you can really convince to follow it are ones synchronizing to the network the first time... and it's incredibly easy to detect by checking any centralized off-chain resource such as block explorers. It is also very easy for us to add checkpoints etc to the code at a more frequent pace and do faster releases in order to ensure that nothing-at-stake chains never have any significant amount of power.