r/Python • • Jan 22 '12

Python packaging cat jumps out of bag

http://mail.python.org/pipermail/catalog-sig/2012-January/004152.html
3 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

15

u/lense Jan 22 '12

Why not tell us about your exciting new benefits now instead of later?

-11

u/aclark Jan 22 '12

In time. You can infer them though, if you look close enough. If you are interested, I'd suggest you 1.) sign up for the beta (please, we need people to help test, and only beta signups get first access). and 2.) Login to the site with your github account and start featuring packages. This will become more important later ;-) Anyone can do this now.

7

u/erez27 import inspect Jan 22 '12

I enjoy trying new and interesting ideas, but if I'm going to use up a portion of my precious "work time" I need to have a better reason than an anonymous wink.

-3

u/aclark Jan 22 '12

The "secret" feature is to be delivered by the end of Q1 2012, probably sooner. Beta members go first. I don't mean to be secretive, but that is where we are at. So the best I can currently offer is those two things: beta sign up and logging in to feature packages.

10

u/Mob_Of_One Jan 22 '12

You don't get to waste our time arbitrarily for your attention-whoring.

Give us a value proposition or fuck off.

4

u/erez27 import inspect Jan 22 '12

You're right, but it doesn't justify living up to your username.

3

u/Mob_Of_One Jan 22 '12

I didna pick the name for nuttin.

-3

u/aclark Jan 22 '12

Actually Mob_Of_One is incorrect: I posted a milestone about a project I care about. It's my right to do that, and it's Mob_Of_One's right to tell me to fuck off, or click -1 (but not to demand a "value proposition" or to stop "attention-whoring" because both are subjective interpretations of my behavior. And you sure as shit don't need my posts to waste time on reddit ;-).)

3

u/grayvedigga Jan 23 '12

Surely a value proposition would encourage people to take your effort more seriously. The cool response you have on the mailing list is to be expected: you're introducing complexity and another surface of failure points to a system people are currently reliant on, without any indication that you are taking the responsibility and potential issues seriously, nor any explication of the benefits. For all I know, your project could disappear or go commercial before its killer feature is unveiled, or simply be rejected by the community for any number of reasons. You don't seem to have a history in the community which would give people confidence that you understand what you're stepping into or have compatible goals.

Do you really think this is a good way to promote a project in the open source world?

-4

u/aclark Jan 23 '12

Surely a value proposition would encourage people to take your effort more seriously.

The beta is scheduled for launch by the end of Q1 2012, but probably will launch much sooner. ~80 people already take it serious enough to sign up for the beta. I'm simply noting another milestone in the project, nothing more to see here…

The cool response you have on the mailing list is to be expected: you're introducing complexity and another surface of failure points to a system people are currently reliant on, without any indication that you are taking the responsibility and potential issues seriously, nor any explication of the benefits.

Are we reading the same thread? Looks like I'm taking it very serious to me.

For all I know, your project could disappear or go commercial before its killer feature is unveiled, or simply be rejected by the community for any number of reasons.

Then don't sign up for the beta.

You don't seem to have a history in the community which would give people confidence that you understand what you're stepping into or have compatible goals.

http://aclark.net/team#aclark

Do you really think this is a good way to promote a project in the open source world?

I think it's a good way to promote a commercial project that markets itself to Python developers, yes.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '12

I don't see the point. Is uploading your package to PyPI really that hard?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '12

Doesn't matter if this makes it significantly easier or more convenient.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '12

That's my point. Does it make it significantly easier? My guess is it does not because the current process is fairly easy...

1

u/aclark Jan 23 '12

The point is not so much to make it significantly easier (though it will) but rather the amount of features you can build on top of a service that automates the package release process, e.g. https://twitter.com/#!/aclark4life/status/161270097422458881/photo/1

6

u/LoveGentleman Jan 23 '12

I dont like your secrecy and artificial mystery-creation thus I wont like pythonpackages.com

1

u/LoveGentleman Jan 23 '12

What are you hiding in that bag aclark?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '12

[deleted]

1

u/takluyver IPython, Py3, etc Jan 23 '12

I'll give this a chance. As an analogy, preparing a patch and emailing it to the maintainer is easy, but Github's edit-online-and-submit-a-pull-request-instantly model makes trivial changes ridiculously easy.

If we want to grow the programming community, I think we also need to stop assuming that everybody has a terminal open all the time and wants to remember a list of commands.

That said, aclark, I think this sort of thing would make more sense as part of PyPI, than as a separate site. The management interface there could easily have links to the project's version control repo, and a way to pick a tag and release it. Or even to set up automatic releases triggered by certain tags.

-3

u/aclark Jan 23 '12

Right, no one is disputing this is trivial for you :-) See above. I'm more interested in the automation than the "typing it is saving me". With this service it will soon be possible to do a release to PyPI entirely TTW (i.e. via github merges and then pushing the release button. Look, ma! No terminal! There, I said it :-p. Now go sign up for the beta already ;-))

0

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '12

[deleted]

-3

u/aclark Jan 23 '12

Like I said, I'm not disputing the workflow is trivial for you. What I am saying is that I've configured a new PyPI user to upload packages sans credentials via pypissh, and that I'm using that approach successfully in my web application. If PyPI gets OAuth support, this will all be moot (which could happen in March, if you read the catalog-sig thread).

0

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '12

[deleted]

-2

u/aclark Jan 23 '12

By paragraph: 1. pythonpackages.com does not host any packages. 2. Yes, much harder than it should be. 3 and 4. That's a different issue, but yeah the goal is to raise, not lower standards. 5. That's a different issue, too :-) 6. Thanks!

4

u/LoveGentleman Jan 23 '12

Why dont you solve the problem for pypi rather than make your own?