r/Python • • Aug 05 '19

Python's response to MATLAB

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

54

u/mexiKobe Aug 05 '19 edited Aug 05 '19

The language is ugly

Not at all for numerical calculations / matrix math etc. It’s very good for that, better than Python with numpy. Look at these comparisons https://docs.scipy.org/doc/numpy-1.15.0/user/numpy-for-matlab-users.html

I mean saying it is uglier than C++ is kind of silly. Try doing simple vectorized calculations from MATLAB but in C++ and get back to me on that. And JavaScript? Come on man lol.

But yeah the problem is when engineers and scientists only use it and try to write applications with it. I’ve seen some FUCKED UP code written in MATLAB being used at huge research hospitals and in national security, and “subversioned” with duplicates on Dropbox. It’s actually extremely common, which should be shocking

4

u/log_2 Aug 06 '19

But yeah the problem is when engineers and scientists only use it and try to write applications with it.

That's because there's no good way to write such applications in Python. The deployment of Python GUI programs for deployment to desktops is a complete nightmare. PyInstaller, p2exe, pyfreeze have all attempted it but they either don't work with everything or needs massive amount of trial-and-error configuration which can completely break as soon as some extra (or newer version) package is required.

All Matlab has to do to keep a hold of it's share is improve the GUI, make it faster and nicer looking (like proper layout), and Python will be left in the dust by people currently looking to switch to it from Matlab.

1

u/Feminintendo Aug 06 '19

But yeah the problem is when engineers and scientists only use it and try to write applications with it.

That's because there's no good way to write such applications in Python.

Surely you're not serious.

Python will be left in the dust by people currently looking to switch to it from Matlab.

I have never heard of anyone who has switched to Matlab because they wanted to. The only people I know who are proficient in other languages but who use Matlab do so because of a project lead who doesn't understand the sunken cost fallacy or because there is literally no other tool that does some very specific obscure thing that Matlab does. It is painfully obvious you are not among that group.

1

u/billsil Aug 07 '19

People switch to Matlab from Python because they're forced to use certain libraries (e.g., signal processing, Simulink, machine learning). My company doesn't like using it, but when it's better, fine...

1

u/Feminintendo Aug 07 '19

Yes, that makes sense. But it's a deal with the devil: you get to use that one obscure library that can do what nothing else can, but you have to use a heinous programming language and pay a lot of money.