r/Python • • Aug 05 '19

Python's response to MATLAB

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/I_Feel_It_Too Aug 06 '19

Oh for Christ's sake. Here's math.js, copied and pasted from docs:

// create an array and a matrix
const array = [[2, 0], [-1, 3]]               // Array
const matrix = math.matrix([[7, 1], [-2, 3]]) // Matrix

// perform a calculation on an array and matrix
math.square(array)                            // Array,  [[4, 0], [1, 9]]
math.square(matrix)                           // Matrix, [[49, 1], [4, 9]]

// perform calculations with mixed array and matrix input
math.add(array, matrix)                       // Matrix, [[9, 1], [-3, 6]]
math.multiply(array, matrix)                  // Matrix, [[14, 2], [-13, 8]]

It's even easier with C++:

#include <iostream>
#include <Eigen/Dense>
// Create a 2x2 matrix called a.
Matrix2d a;
a << 1, 2,
     3, 4;
// Create a 2x2 matrix called b using an alternative but just as easy syntax.
MatrixXd b(2,2);
b << 2, 3,
     1, 4;
//Their sum
a + b;
//Their difference.
a - b;
// Increment a by amount b.
a += b;

// Make some 3d vectors.
Vector3d v(1,2,3);
Vector3d w(1,0,0);
// Mother fucking scalar product.
w - 2*v;
// Vector product. BAM!
w*v;

It's almost like you've never even fucking seen vectorized calculations done in C++.

And I'm not even sure if you are using that word right. MathWorks sure as hell doesn't. You see, in the world of numerical computing, vectorization means using processor instructions (sometimes called SIMD instructions) that are designed to work on multiple data elements at the same time, whereas in the land of Matlab it means not using a for loop. Which, to be fair, is good advice in most languages, but especially in Matlab where interpreted code is apparently transcribed by a hamster before execution on an abacus.

The Eigen C++ code above automatically uses SIMD instructions. In fact, it automatically uses the most powerful SIMD instructions on the many different hardware platforms it supports.

Meanwhile, Matlab... might use SIMD instructions maybe? depending on the computation you're doing. And despite being a CAS specifically focused on linear algebra, Matlab only gained this ability in, like, 2011. I kid you not. And it only got it then because it adopted MKL. Which means, for those keeping track at home, that only those operations for which Matlab uses MKL (plus FFT, apparently) use SIMD. How... cutting edge.

1

u/mexiKobe Aug 06 '19 edited Aug 06 '19

You said MATLAB was an ugly language for matrix calculations and then responded with some extremely basic operations in C++ using an external library. I don’t know what point that’s supposed to be proving. No one in research uses C++ as an alternative for MATLAB for a ton of reasons, one being that you have to compile it. This should be obvious to you.

I mean you claimed MATLAB was worse at managing memory than C++ which is nonsensical. C++ is slowly dying specifically because it doesn’t manage memory

and yes ‘vectorized’ in MATLAB means using vector operations instead of for loops so it is optimized better. If you really need to use SIMD you can always write a MEX function

1

u/Feminintendo Aug 06 '19

You give C++ and Javascript as examples of languages in which "vectorized" arithmetic is ugly, and when someone literally "gets back to you" with explicit examples in both languages showing how trivial it is to do those computations, you can't fathom what the point is? Here, let me quote you to make it easier to see what the point of those examples is:

"I mean saying it is uglier than C++ is kind of silly. Try doing simple vectorized calculations from MATLAB but in C++ and get back to me on that. And JavaScript? Come on man lol."

You see, the point is that, despite your claim to the contrary, doing "simple vectorized calculations" in C++ and JavaScript is trivially easy, extremely readable, and at least in the case of C++, much more performant, not to mention free. To spell it out for you, the point is, you have obviously never tried to do "vectorized" computations in anything other than Matlab. Which gives weight to the argument that the only reason you think Matlab is any good at the things you think it's good at because you are ignorant of the alternatives. I don't know whether or not that's true. Maybe you aren't. But damn, those examples really make a strong case.

No one in research uses C++ as an alternative for MATLAB for a ton of reasons, one being that you have to compile it. This should be obvious to you.

Obviously many scientists don't use C++ for their research. My reading of the anti-Matlab crowd is, that's exactly the whole complaint, that is, that scientists make really bad decisions about which software to use. In my experience, scientists are the worst at using the wrong tool for the job, which the widespread use of Matlab testifies to. They just use whatever their advisor tells them to use, because they don't know any better. So you end up with this mish-mash spaghetti code in Matlab that took some poor graduate student 9 months to code when they could have learned how to do it in Python from scratch in a week with a simple "import sklearn" or whatever. Hey, I don't know you, so I don't know if that's you or not, but I mean, your comments aren't painting a picture of a scientist whose very well-informed with respect to the available software tools in the numerical computing space. (Scientists don't use C++ because it has to be compiled?! Really?!)

Of course, tons of scientists do use C++ and Python for their research. Maybe in your field the only thing people use is Matlab, and so "if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail." But if you branch out a bit, you'll find a ton of statisticians, data scientists, and ecologists using R, HPC people using C++, mathematicians using Python, Pari, and Mathematica, physicists using a lot of C/C++ and Mathematica, etc. From my point of view, scientists in other fields have the same problem of not using the right tool for the job. For example, I think R is the Matlab of ecology. Nothing against R, but it has its strengths and weaknesses, and it just shouldn't be used for everything under the sun. Sure, do your data analysis and plotting in R.

1

u/mexiKobe Aug 06 '19 edited Aug 06 '19

They didn’t show any examples of simple vectorized equations that you can do in MATLAB. They loaded an external library and showed that you can multiply matrices together which is not what I was talking about.

Arguing that C++ or JavaScript are just as good as MATLAB for this stuff is just wrong. There is no debate here.

To spell it out for you, the point is, you have obviously never tried to do “vectorized” computations in anything other than Matlab.

You don’t know what you’re talking about. In fact it actually appears you haven’t used MATLAB very much. Are you aware of how many built-in functions MATLAB has? Especially with the toolboxes. And they’re all optimized already.

There are many reason to not use MATLAB, but the claim that it is an ugly language for linear algebra etc.. is plainly wrong and using C++ as the paragon is hilarious

edit: As an example, let's try and create a diagonal matrix with the values being the square roots of 1 2 3 and print it out

In C++ with eigen:

#include <iostream>
#include "Eigen/Dense"
int main()
{
    Eigen::Matrix< double, 3, 1> v ;
    v << 1, 2, 3;
    Eigen::Matrix< double, 3, 3> m = v.array().sqrt().matrix().asDiagonal());

    std::cout << m << "\n";

    return 0;
}

The equivalent in MATLAB:

m = sqrt(Diag([1 2 3]))

You should probably not comment on things you don't know anything about.