Well, the problem with a double pendulum is that only the inner mass stays on a circular path (in 2D, or a bowl in 3D). The outer mass will move pretty randomly throughout the volume of the bowl, so you might not be able to put anything into it.
This can be somewhat solved by making the inner pendulum longer than the outer one, but it's still gonna be a hard print because 3d printers cannot print random loops in the air, every layer has to be supported by the one below it.
Still, it's a cool idea and I might try to do it later this summer :)
Ok, hear me out: what if you modeled this two pendulum system, but had pendulum 2 tethered to a frictionless sphere/ellipsoid? So in 2D it would look exactly like OP’s gif, but in 3D it would create a useable bowl? You would just calculate the 3D coordinates of pendulum 2 using the geometric constraints. Maybe that would force the length of the line between P1 and P2 to be variable.
Edit: in my idea, pendulum 1 (P1) keeps its 2D constraints, and pendulum 2(P2) can move freely in 3D, but angle P1-P2 must be between 90° and 270°. So theoretically P2 would move along a tire-shaped hollow toroid. In reality it would create a real cool, wild looking bowl. I think.
Edit 2: the shape would only be a weird toroid if you kept the length of P2 constant. If it was variable, you could have it travel within a sphere, always tangent to the inner surface of the sphere.
Yes, that's a nice way to get a working model. I'm not sure if the resulting movement would be 'cool', though.
Like in the 2D case, if you constrained the outer mass to stay on a circular path, then it would just move back and forth like a regular pendulum.
The 3D case has more degrees of freedom, but the behaviour might be similar.
edit: I missed your edit while writing out my replay. I really like the idea to constrain the angle of P2!
A constant length makes for a way easier simulation, but the second option with variable length could basically be solved with a projection from P2 to the sphere afterwards. Really cool!
9
u/ThortheAssGuardian Jul 26 '19
Very cool. Makes me wonder if you could model such a pendulum in 3D and use the line tracing as a model for a crazy looking 3D printed fruit bowl.