r/Python • • Jan 05 '18

Really??

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

317 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/anvils-reloaded Jan 05 '18

Every time I've asked about how to pre-allocate some space in a dictionary where I know the exact keys I want to have, I've always gotten the answer of "don't worry about it" or "stop trying to prematurely optimize your code". In any other programming language, this would just be a part of the process of writing the code. I really do want to learn Python better (I've done some work on Python projects without really knowing what I'm doing, just winging it), but it's not something that I can just stop caring about.

3

u/Smallpaul Jan 05 '18

If you want to preallocate with known keys then a dictionary is probably not the right data structure. You could use a class with _ _ slots _ _ or a struct.

But usually the people telling you not to prematurely optimize are right. You didn’t really explain why you feel this is bad advice.

1

u/anvils-reloaded Jan 05 '18

If I know what the keys are, I don't really want to load them one at a time, right? This is for situations where I have a specific sized table that I want to use for counting. (I was originally going to use a list but decided that they're not really designed for lookup like dictionaries are). I don't consider it premature optimization because I'm not really optimizing anything, just applying what I know about the problem.

2

u/Smallpaul Jan 06 '18

... just applying what I know about the problem.

But to what advantage? How would your way result in easier to read or more maintainable code?

Could you show what you want to do in Pseudocode or Java so I know what you're trying?