r/Python • u/alexflint • Mar 28 '17
Kite, the copilot for programmers, available today for Python
https://kite.com/#11
u/TheTechAccount Mar 28 '17
The privacy page now gives a 404:
4
u/cyanydeez Mar 30 '17
I like how it redirects to "security".
Like, secure in the knowledge that your privacy will only be invaded by the proper third parties systems.
-4
28
u/shaggorama Mar 28 '17
It's a cool idea, but I fundamentally disagree with how they keep using the phrase "context switch" in the video demo. If I'm googling around for a solution to a coding problem, I'm still deeply engaged in that problem. Just because I've pivoted from my text editor to my browser doesn't mean I've "switched contexts." A context switch would be if, while I'm googling around for python syntax, a coworker comes in and asked me to help them construct a regular expression on an unrelated problem.
3
Mar 28 '17
And I happen to have multiple monitors...
1
u/cyanydeez Mar 30 '17
yeah, I get context switched when I'm working on my UI in javascript, and suddenly realize that the problem is on my backend in python.
I mean, I understand walking out of a door can make you forget things, but are there really programmers who lose track when they leave their IDE to go look at code bits?
1
40
71
u/nio101 Mar 28 '17 edited Mar 28 '17
I installed it on my win10/sublime text 3 computer, tried it, didn't like and then uninstalled it. Uninstalling it immediately made me lose my ethernet adapter, showing only a "limited connection" warning icon. Tried to understand what what going on, removing/reinstalling the ethernet adapter hardware... no luck. I Had to do a windows restore to get it back. There's something seriously wrong with your product... :(
45
u/auxiliary-character Mar 28 '17
In addition, there's something seriously wrong with your operating system.
0
2
u/WellAdjustedOutlaw Mar 29 '17
Uninstalling the "agent" on MacOS (which Atom helpfully installed on its own a while ago), was also a real pain.
9
Mar 30 '17
Absolutely! I played with it for a few minutes, but then found that the application never really "quit". It left these child processes: kite-engine and kite-helper that refused to die, even with killall commands. They just ran in the background continuously. Totally unacceptable. Apparently I needed to kill the kit-engine, move the kite.app to trash, and then kill the kite-helper. Seems a little too malware-ish for my liking.
14
9
u/not_perfect_yet Mar 28 '17
Honestly, I couldn't think of a usecase for this, even if it supported my os or my editor...
Good luck, it's just not for me I think.
8
u/joesacher Mar 28 '17 edited Mar 28 '17
If you have 2016.3 and 2017.1 PyCharm Installed, it seems to only install to 2016.3 on Windows.
Popup is all over the place. Can't mouse over to it without holding Ctrl to keep it from closing. Seems to have the info that PyCharm is popping up for me already, for the most part.
2
u/joesacher Mar 28 '17
Uninstall of Kite also doesn't remove plugins. Which makes PyCharm perform terrible until you figure this out.
3
u/mad-friend Mar 28 '17
Why OS X >= 10.10 only?
6
u/alexflint Mar 28 '17
This is because we rely on the version of WebKit that ships with your OS to render the sidebar, and we judged it too painful to support versions of macOS < 10.10. Sorry...
7
u/ticketywho Mar 29 '17
So...$20 a month for alt-tab. Cool.
Also, not available for Linux yet? Come on - it's a dev tool. That's just crappy roadmapping.
5
Mar 28 '17
I'd like something like this for C/C++. Python is fairly well documented. Looks neat but I'm concerned about some redditors saying it spies on you. What's up with that?
1
u/cyanydeez Mar 30 '17
Well, it's goal is to analyze your code...and provide you with code...do you think the code is provides is...from...PEOPLE?
1
30
u/Bonejob Mar 28 '17
Why are you wasting my time, no Linux support. Then you want a monthly subscription at $18.90 per month for pro. Go jump in a lake. And take your "Social Media" sales crap with you.
0
Mar 28 '17
[deleted]
9
u/troyunrau ... Mar 28 '17
If
0
Mar 28 '17
[deleted]
3
u/ticketywho Mar 29 '17
You're a danger to yourself and your employer if that is how you vet development tools.
6
u/Mioced Mar 28 '17
It's 2017 and people still believing & buying this crap. Amazing.
All you need is a simple text editor, terminal and a brain, That's it.
4
u/cyanydeez Mar 30 '17
That's not really true, don't go so far left that you forget whose shoulders you stand on.
4
3
u/phira Mar 29 '17
There are some legitimate complaints on this page, but I feel like it is overly focused on the negative. Kite certainly has flaws, but there are many good things to come from their approach.
For a start, this is a tool clearly aimed at those of us who believe in trading computing resources for faster, more accurate coding. As a professional developer I will happily accept any assistance I can get in writing my code. I've been a long-time user of Intellij tools, Dash etc for this reason.
Assuming you're of a similar mindset, Kite brings a number of new concepts to the table that have been unavailable until now. While Intellij and other IDEs are improving their ability to understand the codebase you're working on and provide useful insights as a result (autocomplete, type checking, refactors etc), it's almost unheard of to provide insight into one codebase based on a different one you've already built. Kite not only does this, but it also provides insight into your current codebase based on aggregate codebases from all over the internet.
Assuming you like code assist, it's difficult to argue that this isn't an improvement. We routinely follow similar patterns over and over when building software components, and Kite takes advantage of this to give you hints on what you might want to do, based on what you and others have done before. At the moment this comes in the form of the sidebar information about common usages and in prioritising autocomplete suggestions based on popularity (I admit this was one of the stand-out features that got me interested in Kite), but we're really only looking at the very start of the opportunities the approach brings.
These hints and instant solutions absolutely have the potential to increase productivity. Increased productivity is cash in hand for me and many others. The individual subscription is US$7.90/mn, it's not a killer if coding is your bread and butter.
Kite has downsides. The use of the cloud service to perform local code analysis naturally arouses some suspicion, however Kite quite legitimately point out that services like github are routinely used by many, many developers, myself included. They have some trust to build, but access to the source is not part of the problem.
In the early beta there was an issue in that you were unable to prevent passwords and cryptographic keys from being uploaded as well, unlike github where you could use gitignore to keep those local. This is an issue Kite has solved in this release, with .kiteignore acting in exactly the same way. You can also configure Kite to only index in certain directories in the tool itself.
Finally, this is their initial release. There are bugs and there are bits they're clearly still working on. Some of these bugs are causing problems for me at the moment, but I've reported them and I'm confident they'll be solved in short order.
Kite is a great - even logical - step forward in code assistance. Whether Kite itself or some similar approach will inevitably make its way into the mainstream within the next couple of years.
2
u/rothnic Mar 29 '17
I think the negative comments are a bit over the top. I think it is an interesting service and tried it out. I think it was a little difficult to get things working, but was able to do so when it was still in the beta.
Overall, I found that the example use cases it provides are very helpful and as someone that ends up with way too many tabs open it helps avoid that.
However, I do think the yearly/monthly charge is going to be a bit much for a lot of people. I think you should consider the fall off of subscriptions as your price goes higher. You might have priced it so high that you would receive a disproportionately lower amount of subscriptions than if it was priced half of what it is for an individual. As an individual, $39 for a year is a lot easier to swallow than $79. Especially as an additional service to IDE costs people are going to pay.
1
u/h4ck3rm1k3 Mar 28 '17
Nice idea....
3
u/h4ck3rm1k3 Mar 28 '17
It would be nice to have an autocomplete for the floss code I have on my machine.
1
-2
u/alexflint Mar 28 '17 edited Mar 28 '17
Alex from Kite here. When we launched Kite here on reddit almost a year ago we were blown away by the enthusiasm for our smart copilot vision. Over 65,000 of you signed up for Kite in the first 72 hours, and over the past year we've been working with many of you to deliver that vision. We're excited to be opening up Kite for everyone to download today.
Here's what we've been working on:
Deep editor integrations to make Kite better for smaller screens and more integrated into the coding workflow. You no longer have to dedicate a sidebar of your screen to Kite; instead, recommendations from Kite replace your editor’s autocompletions and hover results.
Fine-grained privacy controls modeled after the .gitignore file format means that you can selectively and precisely decide which files and folders Kite indexes.
Next generation type inference engine that uses both static analysis and statistical inference over Github. Kite beats PyCharm and Jedi by 32% on a typical Django project, offering more completions when you need them.
Ranked completions which put the most relevant completions at the top of the autocomplete box using techniques traditionally used in web search.
Kite for Windows (And Linux in testing!)
Check it out at https://kite.com/
7
u/encc Mar 28 '17
Hey Alex, on your security page you have a link pointing to https://kite.com/smart which shows a 404 page.
5
u/kirbyfan64sos IndentationError Mar 28 '17 edited Mar 28 '17
Hey, I think your "Choose language" dropdown is a bit broken on Chrome for Linux: https://postimg.org/image/ggoerv56r/
Also, you should put a link to your GitHub page: https://github.com/kiteco
5
u/Rosco_the_Dude Mar 28 '17
Lol I distinctly remember most of the comments were much like the ones in this thread. Inattention to privacy, and the kicker: lack of a real use case that justifies the ridiculous price.
3
5
u/StandardUser_ Mar 28 '17
Any chance you will add support for WingIDE? Currently it is not even in the "let me know" list :(
3
u/lookatmetype Mar 29 '17
Why is this being downvoted? Why are people being such dicks about this software? If you don't like it, point out the flaws. This is terrible behavior for this community.
1
1
u/tialpoy Mar 28 '17
I using PyCharm on a 4K screen. After clicking "more" on a piece of code, the text in the tooltip is so small you'd need a microscope to read it. Is the microscope part of the Pro version?
2
0
0
46
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '17 edited Mar 28 '17
What about all the concerns with keys/etc. private data stored in the cloud?
EDIT:
Agh! It costs $18/mo!? This costs more than the IDE it's assisting!? A bit much, imo.