r/Python • • 10d ago

Discussion PYTHON πŸ†š ALL ...

"If you want to learn programming, don’t start with Python; you should start with another language."

This advice seems ridiculous to me, even though I hear it everywhere. Can someone explain this advice to me... and are they right?

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/DreamingElectrons 10d ago

There is this persistent misconception, that you need to start learning with basic underlying data structures and memory management to truly get programming, this is mainly prevalent in academia, where people traditionally start with C and the keyword here is "traditionally" because that's all that is, a tradition. There is no benefit in starting with low level stuff it just makes things look harder than they really are and result in people feeling accomplished in having understood something like a pointer which isn't a hard concept at all once you are used to thinking like a programmer.

Start with something high level and then work yourself down as far as you need. Learning C at some point is beneficial because it makes a lot of weird quirks of python and other high level languages suddenly click into place, but without they simply are gotchas that you stumbled over once and then just have to remember about. It's also turtles all the way down, once you ended up at C. there still is assembly below that, and then you are just entering a field of electronics below that and can see physics lingering in the depths below...

TLDR: The advice to start with something other than python is just people parroting stuff they read online without ever having understood the argument that someone tried to make when saying that.

3

u/kcunning 10d ago

I can confirm the academia bit. My youngest (freshman in college) had to struggle their way through a CS class that did zero programming and focused on reading 'pseudocode' that was less clear than if it were just written in Python. They left the class thinking that maybe CS just wasn't for them, which broke my heart a little, because I know it is absolutely something they not only could do, but likely will have to do for their chosen career path.

1

u/swift-autoformatter 10d ago

I don’t know, but isn’t it too late to first meet programming at that age if someone picks up this profession? I mean that the hundreds of successful sw engineers I met during my 25+ years career, all of them were pretty into this stuff earlier in their life (me included).

5

u/kcunning 10d ago

Being "into something" is a completely different mindset than learning something because it's important for your career path / required for your degree / just something you have to know in order to be an adult in modern society.

When you're really into something, the details are going to fascinate you enough to keep you going. There's a good chance that you're already inclined to be good at retaining those details, either due to being primed by life experience or some other natural talent. That doesn't mean it's the best way to learn for everyone. It just means that you're winning at a race because your racecar has been specifically tuned for this particular track.

For those that aren't, scaffolding has long been known to be the best way to introduce learners to a concept. Introduce them to the part of the craft or field that they can grasp, then encourage them to stretch slightly out of their comfort zone, while someone more experienced helps them.

Also, and I say this as someone who also has over two decades in the field... nerds lie. It's a form of posturing to say how long you've been into computers and how many hair dryers you disassembled before the age of six. Some are probably telling the truth, but I promise you, many are stretching it, if not not outright lying because nerds are also extremely judgmental.

4

u/Emergency-Mission705 6d ago

Thank you so much for sharing this! I'm also a CS freshman with no prior coding experience, and I really relate to your youngest.πŸ₯² What advice did you give your youngest when they were struggling? I'd really appreciate your wisdom!

3

u/kcunning 6d ago

I told them that not every teacher is good, and not every required curriculum is going to work for everyone. We sat down, looked over test questions, and I showed them how I found answers when things were breaking for me. To be honest, watching me go "what the f--" a few times made them feel a lot better.

I also explained that their class didn't really mimic the way the real world worked.