r/Python • • Aug 17 '24

Showcase Standalone GUI app that executes python scripts: Run py scripts without any installations*

Announcing an app (portable executable) I build which is a solution for running Python scripts without any prerequisites or external system dependencies, eliminating the need for Python installation on the systems. Catch is that the packages which script uses should be bundled during app build process, so a new app should be build respectively. there is a plan to provide option to include local package path if exists on system.

What My Project Does

  • Runs python script out-of-the-box provided the packages that are used by script are add during build pipeline.

  • isolated from system. meaning doesn't affect any changes in system or python, don't need to fiddle with paths and packages

  • Output of script are displayed on terminal like console

Target Audience

  • This was build to help run scripts consistently across systems with any breakage from python or packages.

  • imo this can also help make non-technical people's life easy.

Comparison 

  • This works like python interpreter without the hassle of setup and management

Limitations

  • Script execution fails if the required package is not already bundled in the app.

  • Python and Packages are immutable, they cannot be modified including versions.

  • App size and initial load time increases as more number of packages are added.

  • Pyinstaller is pain to work with (imo), and any windows os change might break the app.

https://github.com/Nannigalaxy/PyScript-Engine

executable: https://github.com/Nannigalaxy/PyScript-Engine/releases/download/v1.0.0/pyscript-engine_v1.0.0_py3.10_x86_win64.exe

let me know if you have any thoughts on this.

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/denehoffman Aug 17 '24

What’s the difference between this and running python myscript.py in a command line? You still need to install dependencies, and if running a python script in the manner I just described is too technical for people, then this will probably be as well. Also, you made it windows-only and I honestly can’t see a reason why, other than using windows path objects?

-4

u/nannigalaxy Aug 17 '24

no, this app does require anything to install on the system. no python or package, this'll already be bundled in the app. you just share this app to user, they open and execute the script. hope this clears the usecase

6

u/w8eight Aug 17 '24

What if the user has some dependencies in the script, that aren't installed?

0

u/billsil Aug 18 '24

Drop the files from the package into the python path. I've hacked new packages into Abaqus CAE and Paraview. It's just a matter of finding compatible versions of packages based on the version of python and other dependencies they're running. Generally you can just look at when packages were released (by checking PyPi) and trying versions from around then. Bisect from there to try and find the newest possible version.

0

u/w8eight Aug 18 '24

But this solution doesn't require python installed (I assume it's in the executable)

And manipulating packages manually kinda defeats the purpose of this program, don't you agree?

0

u/billsil Aug 18 '24

I don’t understand your use case, so defeating the purpose of your project is not my aim, but people have been trying to use python without installing python for all 18 years I’ve been using python for various reasons. People find workarounds.

You’re on windows. Why not use the Microsoft Store? It’s really hard to mess that one up.

PyInstaller sometimes works and regularly breaks when new versions of Windows comes out. Installing python is the best solution.

1

u/w8eight Aug 18 '24

Dude, I'm not the owner of this project, I just mentioned the caveats of it to the op (besides the obvious ones that come with usage of pyinstaller)?

I personally would never use stuff like this project, just wanted to point out the shortcomings to the op. Either learn to read the comments you respond to, or simply don't respond.

0

u/billsil Aug 18 '24

Sure seemed like you were based on your questions to me.  Why did you assume my questions were to you and not OP? You did the same thing.

It seems like we both don’t understand the use case.

-1

u/w8eight Aug 18 '24

Well usually when you respond to someone's comment, you want to interact with that person, I don't know why I should explain that to you...

If you want to point things out to the OP, maybe respond to the post next time.

0

u/billsil Aug 18 '24

You asked a straightforward question that I responded to. You responded with questions and then I thought you were OP. You did the exact same thing as me.

→ More replies (0)

-7

u/nannigalaxy Aug 17 '24

yes this is the caveat. need to build a new app and ship it

4

u/Specialist-Arachnid6 Ignoring PEP 8 Aug 17 '24

uhmm so basically pyinstaller exe with more steps or is my dumbass missing something here?

0

u/nannigalaxy Aug 17 '24

let me give you more context why i built this. in my workplace people run python scripts manually for some tasks. they are not programmer. very agile code expect for package and versions, they remain more or less the same. so had to install and manage on many systems. sometimes something changes in path and it breaks. also people had hard time navigating to script to run via terminal, not much standard was set.

6

u/denehoffman Aug 17 '24

Why not just put python scripts in users’ $PATH, chmod +x them, and add a shebang at the top with a venv or the system Python with the packages installed? Then they don’t have to search for scripts at all and they also don’t have to open a GUI to run a Python script

3

u/Specialist-Arachnid6 Ignoring PEP 8 Aug 18 '24

this's much more effecient tbh