r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jul 10 '14

Reddit PSA: In order to get more people to upvote threads instead of just brushing past it, we've now added something to the upvote button. Give it a try and make a habit of upvoting GOOD posts!

1.2k Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jan 30 '20

Art [Art] Out of boredom, I have created a new design for the Friend List

Post image
868 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Nov 14 '16

Noob question here (dont upvote)

804 Upvotes

If i have 3 tengus and 1 red odin, can i skill transfer my red odin skill to all three of my tengus?

Thanks.

Edit: GG guys, 24 hours later and my noob question is top three for this sub.


r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Aug 13 '15

Misc. [Misc][Image] Enemy's point of view

Thumbnail
imgur.com
797 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Sep 07 '20

Shitpost Simpler times

Post image
755 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Mar 05 '21

Shitpost [Shitpost] I'm from 2023. You may not like it but this is what peak PAD performance looks like. Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk

Post image
745 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Aug 10 '19

Brag We met through PAD back in 2016. On Thursday, we got married. We're still playing!

Post image
674 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Nov 01 '17

Shitpost [Shitpost] PAD showerthought: If we got a water Athena she would be called bath

650 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Mar 05 '17

Misc. [Misc] chicken

Post image
638 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Apr 14 '23

Guide Teambuilding guide for Wolf Daytona + Royal Nautilus

Post image
619 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Aug 12 '20

Misc. DadGuide and Miru Bot end of life announcement

579 Upvotes

Overview

I've received a request from GH's lawyers (via Apple) to take down DadGuide. If you're interested in the details, you can read them here: https://pastebin.com/9U56CyzS

I'll be releasing a new version of the app on the Play Store shortly which will contain details about the shutdown; unfortunately my release certificate for the AppStore ran out a week ago and I'm not motivated enough to fix that and do a release for iOS.

Timeline

The app will be removed from the AppStore on Friday. It will be removed from the Play Store a week after I receive their complaint there.

The data endpoints will continue running for 30 days, after which I will disable it and existing DadGuide installations will stop updating.

Some time after that I will take down the machine hosting Miru Bot, and delete the various resources (images, voices, animations, raw data, etc) that I'm serving from the CDN.

Replacements

If anyone is interested in running the data/image pipelines, all my code is open source, mostly scripted, but will still take quite a bit of effort to get things running. You should have experience with MySql, Python, Bash, and general sysadmin type work.

If you're interested in hosting a replacement for Miru Bot (assuming someone handles the backend data that Miru relies on) all those plugins are open source as well.

Feel free to speak up on Discord if you're interested.

Thanks to everyone who used and supported DadGuide and Miru Bot over the years! It's been fun.

Edit:

This is a pretty disappointing outcome to me, and I've mostly been staying away from discussion on the topic to avoid unnecessary stress. In the interest of centralizing answers to some common questions, here you go:

Q: They can't do this, or you have the legal right, blah blah.

A: Pretty sure they can, pretty sure I don't, even if they did, lets be realistic about who Apple/Google will side with.

Q: You didn't have permission to do this anyway.

A: I had asked a GH employee a few years ago and they said GH didn't care about third party info sites and that the stuff I was doing would be OK, although they couldn't officially condone it. Obviously they can change their mind about this at any point and I have no recourse.

Q: Why did this happen?

A: Speculation is that GungHo is cracking down on data mining, particularly because they're annoyed about some Persona/Sins data leaking ahead of time. It's hard to know, because they refuse to say what I can do to keep the app up. Their complaint is so general it could even cover stuff like explicitly listing the shield percentage in place of their garbage 'prevents some damage' text. In the past, GungHo NA had asked me to not publish some stuff, and I had complied. GungHo JP has never asked though.

Q: Will this happen to other sites?

A: Unclear. The majority of resources use ads to support themselves. My guess would be that NA-only sites (Ilmina, PDX) will not be affected, and JP sites probably have some kind of relationship with GungHo JP to resolve issues proactively.

Q: Is anything else affected by this specifically? Why is Miru affected? Why is the backend being taken down if the app was targeted?

A: pad.protic uses some of the data, some posting may be limited in content, slower, or skipped if it gets too annoying. Ilmina is not affected. Valeria is only affected for dungeon data. Miru is affected because it uses literally the same backend. The backend is coming down because it's the boring stuff I had to keep working to support the fun stuff, and I'm not interested in doing it without the fun stuff to keep me going.

Q: What did this cost? How much did you make? How many people used it?

A: Costs were $50-$70 per month depending on usage (unsurprisingly this correlated with big content releases). If you just wanted to host a Miru clone you can probably get away with $8/month on some cheap VPS, a lot of that cost was for a beefier server and bandwidth. Ad revenue bounced between $70 and $110 per month, IAP was about $15 per month. I had about 2,500 DAU and 10,000 MAU for DadGuide, probably a 3:1 ratio of Android to iOS.

Q: I'm interested in hosting a clone of the bot, or doing the backend. How do I get started?

A: The bot is just a V3 Red Bot with some plugins from here. You are and always have been free to stand up your own copy. There are some instructions on the repo, send me a PR if you find anything missing or want to improve the docs. The bot won't live past 30 days though, unless someone starts doing the back end. The repo for the backend is here, it's a lot of stuff to set up, but if you can at least independently get your own image generation and database updating working, and commit to publishing the exported database, I'm happy to work with you on completing the setup.


r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Feb 20 '19

Misc. [Fan Art?] I tried my best to recreate Cammy's art. How'd I do?

Post image
577 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jun 05 '22

IRL PAD Puzzle finally almost complete!

553 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jan 02 '24

Misc. [Misc] Ilmina is now offline. Thank you everyone

544 Upvotes

A lot of you have found out by now, Ilmina has been taken offline. I wanted to get this out sooner but I really wasn't feeling up to it and needed some time to digest, opting for the short post onsite as the start. I do have some stuff I'd like to say though, while it's still fresh in my head.

Unless you're active in the community server, you probably don't know much about the behind the scenes of the site. It started with 2 people and eventually remained as just me, in terms of updates. I wanted a skill search tool that I could read, and thought it'd also help the community. It was a rough journey, and I had a lot of fun and also a lot of rage. I know that towards the (now) end, it wasn't the most up to date. It fell behind on some skill types and I'm sorry I never got around to fixing them. I couldn't find a sensible way to make them work with search. Things got really complicated to sort nicely.

Some people have thought that I've been burning out and there's some truth in that, but I wanted to keep going and at the very least I wanted it to end by my own choice. I'm sorry to start your new year like this, but it's very unlikely this can continue. I won't go into the details, but yes Ilmina was taken down for DMCA reasons. I don't like stringing people along, I won't dangle hope to make things worse, but I really cannot think of a way to keep Ilmina going in any way that will make it the slightest bit convenient for anybody. Nobody's going to use something they have to screw around with on multiple ends and maintain, and never be able to use it mobily. As it stands, this is almost definitely where it ends.

I also have a lot of people to thank. Or at least, that I'd like to thank. Doing this truly alone wouldn't have been possible, and there's very talented people out there doing amazing things and we'd help each other wherever we could. Updates would have been way further back without them. They're really good friends and I want so so much to give them recognition and show off their accomplishments. But I really don't think I can do that without putting their work at risk and possibly shutting down more things. It feels really bad. I know they know who they are, and I want them to know I appreciate everything they've done for the community and for myself.

I'd like to thank the community and the people using the site too. I wouldn't have done any of this if I didn't like the community and thought they'd like Ilmina. I didn't even initially know how receptive people would be to it. It was so messy. But in its early days, so many people expressed their thanks and were so encouraging, it was so motivating to fix it up. Really, you all contributed more than you may think.

Lastly, and I don't think I want to say too much about it, but about the feelings of the EN tooling scene. I know a lot of you have sour thoughts about what's been happening steadily recently. I wish I could reassure people on that end but I might just make it worse. You'd all be very surprised if you knew just how much overlap there was between many of the EN resources you knew that are now also offline. In terms of the popular, large projects that have existed, there was an alarmingly small amount of people involved. I really don't want to think about what would happen if even a couple of them had to leave. I hope you can all find a way to keep enjoying things, in some way, in some form, in some definition of enjoy.

Thank you again everyone, for everything, for the past few years. I really hope Ilmina was helpful during its stay.


r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Dec 07 '16

Misc. [Misc] Tamadra one-shot Kali

Thumbnail
gfycat.com
539 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jan 25 '21

Mantastic

530 Upvotes

Just wanted to do a little post showing my appreciation for this guy and his work.

When i first started PAD i had zero idea what i was doing (some things do not change) and i stumbled across his videos by accident when looking for help on YT for some random dungeon.

I was drawn in by his knowledge and positivity he seems to radiate on each vid, and his summaries of events on his website are eagerly awaitied by many of us i'm sure.

I know he is having some health problems and if he ever reads this i hope he feels better soon, and i guess thats my little thank you done!


r/PuzzleAndDragons • • May 09 '21

Shitpost Nice

Post image
522 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jan 08 '20

Misc. Wishing Mantastic a healthy recovery

511 Upvotes

As part of the same community I wanted to wish Mantastic a healthy recovery from his back issues. We hope to see you back soon and look forward to your thoughts and insight in the future.


r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Nov 30 '19

WHERE ARE THE MAGIC STONES

Post image
511 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Dec 10 '18

Misc. Goodbye

Post image
510 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jan 09 '19

Misc. [Misc] My suggestion for a small UI improvement. I hate when I can't tell at a glance how much damage I'm doing.

Post image
505 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Feb 21 '20

Misc. Shinnosuke Hino 8th Anniversary illustration

Post image
502 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jun 06 '26

Best Of Chip, Iroh, & Mantastic Meet IRL

Post image
491 Upvotes

I have known Chip IRL for ~10 years and we regularily get together but this was the first time Iroh visited Canada so we all met up for games and fun!

Happy Puzzling!


r/PuzzleAndDragons • • Jun 05 '19

Shitpost jUsT oNe MoRe

Post image
471 Upvotes

r/PuzzleAndDragons • • May 04 '21

📰News Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in

Post image
462 Upvotes