r/PurePhysics • • Nov 10 '16

A New Thought about Gravity

0 Upvotes

A speculation on the true origin of gravity

Daniel L. Wu, Ph.D. Columbia, Maryland, USA

November 9, 2016

Abstract

Albert Einstein’s general relativity (gr) is the current mainstream theory of gravity wherein gravity is explained by the warping of space-time and a gravitational force does not exist. We however believe there is a gravitational force, an inertial force or pseudo force caused by the accelerated expansion of our universe which was discovered in 1998. This is a generalization of Einstein’s equivalence principle. The elevator acceleration is replaced by the universe acceleration. If our speculation turns out to be correct, modern cosmology has to be rewritten and the artifacts of gr need to be removed.

The new equivalence principle

Isaac Newton’s discovery of universal gravity is one of the greatest achievements in mankind scientific development. But Newton could not explain the origin of gravity in his lifetime. In 1915 Einstein came to the rescue by presenting his beautiful theory of general relativity (gr) in which there is no gravitational force. According to this theory the presence of energy, momentum and mass would distort the 4-dimentional space-time and curve the path of a particle, resulting in gravity. We feel that Einstein went too far and did not explain the reality. We think nature ought to be simple. In his famous physics textbook [1], Richard Feynman says “The possibility exists, therefore, that gravity itself is a pseudo force.” without naming a cause. The great discovery of the accelerated expansion of universe in 1998 [2-3] gives us a clue – the attractive gravitational force may just be the inward inertial force or pseudo force caused by the outward acceleration of space (not space-time) in the universe. Newtonian physics clearly indicates that any acceleration must instantaneously produce a counter inertial force in the opposite direction. In Einstein’s equivalence principle, an accelerated elevator is equivalent to gravity. We simple replace the elevator with the whole universe! We thus boldly claim to have found the true origin of gravity!

Variable gravity

How strong was the gravity in our universe 5 billion years ago? We don’t think anybody presently can answer a question like this. We now know that the accelerated expansion of universe only started about 5 billion years ago and the universe was thought to be slowly decelerating since the initial inflationary epoch right after the big bang. This implies that

1

in terms of our proposal gravity has been a variable! Gravity has become significant only in the past 5 billion years. Before that gravity might have been slightly repulsive or non-significant except for the initial inflationary epoch.

Primordial black holes, dark matter and structure formation

According to modern cosmology, after the big bang a small space containing extremely dense energy experienced an exponentially accelerated expansion within a split second – the inflationary epoch. We speculate that the extremely powerful counter inertial force in the inward direction could condense energy into very dense primordial black holes and possibly dark matter – a mystery solved! Also, the large scale structure formation of our universe might only be significant in the last 5 billion years instead of an even progress.

Time

Time in gr is an ambiguous quantity because it does not appear in Einstein’s field equation. In his theory time is supposed to be a stretchable dimension along with the other three space dimensions. The flow of time depends on the configuration of energy, momentum and matter. We believe that time dilation in a gravitational field is not due to the distortion of time dimension as described in gr, rather, it is a consequence of special relativity (sr) in accelerated frames of reference.

Prediction of the existence of a black hole

Many gr textbooks give the impression that the existence of a black hole is predicted by gr. But elementary classical physics also predicts the existence of a black hole: Escape velocity = √(2GM/R) By putting in c, the speed of light, as the escape velocity, one obtains R = 2GM/C2 , the event horizon of a black hole as defined in the famous Schwarzschild solution of gr. In other words, inside a sphere of radius R and mass M, even light cannot escape - the basic concept of a black hole.

Gravitational waves

In gr the change of gravity as a result of re-configuration of energy, momentum and mass triggers gravitational waves which travel at the speed of light. Despite the recent claims of successfully detecting gravitational waves by the LIGO team, a recent investigative report by Bibhas De [4] gave little credibility to their results. There are additional potential problems here. First, the universe is expanding and accelerating, therefore the gravitational waves constantly experience distortion and dispersion. Second, the

2 gravitational waves carry a gravitational field in which time is dilated. Many gr textbooks describe gravitational waves in terms of the classical wave equation. We think this is inadequate. If gravitational waves do exist, the classical wave equation must be modified to reflect the two factors discussed above. It is a challenge to write such a wave equation. If our generalized equivalence principle turns out to be true, gravitational waves probably do not exist and the LIGO team’s detections may be just background noises.

Re-interpretation of gr effects

After seeing our Newtonian approach of gravity as an inertial force, all gr followers would undoubtedly cite many gr effects with experimental proofs to dismiss our argument. But our position is that many of these gr effects can be explained by Newtonian mechanics. For instance, gravitational lensing due to curving of a light beam around a heavy mass could be probably explained by light scattering and refraction. New efforts are needed to re-interpret gr effects in terms of Newtonian mechanics.

Quantum gravity

It is fashionable to try to quantize gravity and incorporate gravity into the standard model in which the other three forces are mediated with virtual bosons. But our explanation of gravity is based on an inertial force. Virtual bosons (gravitons?) are not needed. Also, an inertial force cannot be constrained and therefore not subject to a quantization attempt.

Conclusions

We have presented a simple and bold explanation of the true origin of gravity. This is merely a starting point of a conceptual re-thinking about gravity. Further discussions and new experiments are needed to support our approach. Do we really need gr? Do gravitational waves really exist? Do we really need relativistic cosmology? The Friedmann equation, the heart of modern cosmology, can be easily derived without gr. Many gr effects in our view are superfluous.

References

[1] Feynman, R., The Feynman Lectures on Physics (Addison-Wesley, 1963).

[2] Riess, A.G. et al. High-z Supernova Search Team (1998). Observational evidence from supernovae for an accelerating universe and a cosmological constant, Astron. J.,116, 1009.

3

[3] Perlmutter, S. et al. Supernova Cosmology Project (1999). Measurements of omega and lambda from 42 high redshift supernovae, Astrophys. J.,517, 565.

[4] De, B., Unchallenged Privilege, the Billion-Dollar Trilateral Gravitational-Wave Discovery Scam (Books by Bibhas De, 2016).

4


r/PurePhysics • • May 10 '19

Have you ever heard about Door To Hell? It has been burning for almost 50 years...

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Aug 15 '14

Does anyone know the name of or anything about this 3x3 matrix? (x-post r/puremathematics)

1 Upvotes

I came across it while looking into currency pairs. The price of currency i in units of currency j is p_ij. Well here it is

http://i.imgur.com/SVdaghU.jpg

I may not have listed all its properties. You may assume, I guess, WOLOG that currency 1 is the "best" followed by currency 2 and 3 so perhaps also (but I suppose not always)

0 <= p_13 <= p_12 <= 1

I think when p_12 = p_13 special things happen, but I'm not sure. Anyone got anything?


r/PurePhysics • • Jun 11 '23

Faster than light communication using entanglement

1 Upvotes

Requirements for FTL using entanglement:

  1. Only entangled particles are used for communication. Because other forms of communication are not faster than light.

  2. Entangled particles created with not random value for a property used for communication. Needed for a receiver to detect sender's influence on entangled particle.

  3. Receiver is able to detect the sender's influence on entangled particles.

Experiment setup that meets all those requirements.

  • Source of entangled particles produces entangled photons that are always polarized vertically. For example using SPDC of type 0 or type 1. Entangled photon are separated and one is send to a sender the other to a receiver.

  • Sender uses a polarizer set to one of two angles to influence entangled photons. Detector after the polarizer may be used for monitoring.

  • Receiver uses a polarizer at fixed angle before a detector to detect the sender influence. Because entangled photons are produced randomly. Receiver will use intensity of light at the detector. For that to work, source of entangled photons with stable enough intensity is needed.

The last thing is that sender should be "closer" to the source than the receiver. To make sure that the sender's polarizer affects entangled particle before it reaches receiver's polarizer. It also means that for sending information back the second source in a different place will be needed.

I wonder what do you think about this?

More details in Faster than light communication document.


r/PurePhysics • • Sep 05 '13

A PHY101 "parallel axis" problem might be able to explain hydrogen fine structure. Pedagogical exploration.

5 Upvotes

I quite like this problem. I think I will use it to teach in the future, so I want to share some of my explorations. Perhaps they are not valid - I don't know.

I'll start with the easiest to swallow, and get progressively crazier.


The Parallel Axis Theorem

Physics students tend to use the "parallel axis theorem" here. Years ago I probably would have done the same.

In hindsight, I see this quite differently. Each orbital penny is made, by friction, to rotate once about its principal axis with each revolution about the inner penny. The parallel axis theorem is a realization of this phenomenon, in fact.

This is really classical spin orbit coupling, mediated by the force of friction. When the friction meets a critical condition, the outer pennies exhibit angular momentum S due to principal axis rotation for each orbit. Call S spin. S is given by

(1) S = 1/2 m r2 ω

The total angular momentum of the system is the sum of the orbital parts and the spin parts

(2) J = L + S

We can relate this to a very simple, naive calculation of the total moment of inertia. To find the total moment I, pretend the outer pennies are point particles at position x, having moments given by

(3) I_point = m x•x

and correct the expression adding the individual moments of the pennies about their principal axes

(4) I_total = 6 I_point + 6 I_disk

Multiplying (4) through by ω will result in correct expression for this system of the form (2).


The magnitude of the induced spin is a property of the penny, and depends on nothing else. It is...intrinsic spin.

Here is a subtle point worth mentioning, that makes this remind of quantum spin orbit coupling.

The spin S resulting from orbital coupling is a property of the penny only. You might say it is "inherent", "innate" or even "intrinsic." For, the induced spin S does not depend on the qualities of the surface providing the friction constraint...any surface that passes e.g. is sticky enough to provide the critical value of friction will provide exactly the critical value, which is set by the penny's properties, and the angular speed ω.


Suppose pennies fixed in orbit are free to slip and rotate

We imagine pennies that slip and rotate freely but are kept in place and in orbit. There is a binding force keeping the pennies in orbit, but each sits on a little frictionless pad so it is free to rotate. In that case, no spin is induced! And here is the best part...


Pennies: Orbit and energy gap? Therefore spin.

Hydrogen: Spin and orbit? Therefore energy gap.

For the pennies, the logical flow is as follows:

(1) suppose there exists L and

(2) the friction constraint (a binding energy correction to the primary force keeping the penny a fixed distance from the center).

(3) therefore, there is an induced S

Alternatively, consider hydrogen - a single electron interacting with a proton.

(A) first suppose the electron has spin S

(B) we must conclude whenever there is also an L

(C) we will have a spin orbit energy correction. fine structure of hydrogen.


r/PurePhysics • • Jun 10 '22

Contemporary Math

0 Upvotes

Does anyone know anything about contemporary math or somewhere I could find some homework help?


r/PurePhysics • • Feb 22 '14

Need this paper, vpn is down

0 Upvotes

Well for some reason I cannot get access to this...I should, but it's an anomaly...

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0011227573902609

"A low temperature uhf NMR system ☆ N.S. Sullivan, 2, R.V. Pound"

Anyone help? I'll kill the post. I can pm you my univ email.


r/PurePhysics • • Nov 10 '23

Watch this 2 min to understand: why physical object CAN go faster than light ‎️‍🔥 ‎️‍🔥

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Aug 02 '13

"All known intrinsic magnetic moments (of electron, muon, proton, neutron, nuclei) are shown to be caused, to a very high precision, by circulating currents and not magnetic charges." (J. D. Jackson, 1977, CERN 77-17) [pdf]

Thumbnail scipp.ucsc.edu
5 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Aug 07 '13

The Truth About Geometric Unity

Thumbnail vixra.org
0 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Feb 04 '17

Anybody know the physical interpretation of TENSOR...????

5 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Jul 18 '15

Could a dropped spinning baseball gain spin?

1 Upvotes

I would like to share my thoughts about the experiments in this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/gifs/comments/3deddo/the_magnus_effect_when_a_small_amount_of_spin_is/

When I was looking at the gif I started wondering what happenes to the spin velocity of the ball during its fall. It even seems possible to me, looking at the gifs, that it is increasing during the fall, but I will find this quite strange if it really would. More likely is it only is the horizontal speed which increases.

So I would like to ask you what really happens.

Let's talk about the spinning ball as a unit with two sides: the side of which the wind over it aligns with the surface movement: the aligning side; and the other side: the colliding side. There are also two scenario's to mention: if the ball is falling faster than it would roll with its spin: hard wind; and otherwise: soft wind.

Some analysis brought me some hypotheses. I don't know that much about aerodynamics, so correct me from wrong:

  • Cancelling out increase and decrease of spin: The airflow around the ball increases the spin on the aligning side (only with hard wind), and decreasing the spin on the colliding side. This could be cancelled out to each other, up to a certain extend. What's left is a standard friction:

  • Standard air friction with correction: A spinning ball in the air will have a standard surfacial air resistance stopping its spin. Lets picture a ball spinning on your finger, but without the friction of your finger. This ball eventually will, though very slowly, stop spinning. This might be the same rate at which a falling ball could stop spinning. Anyhow, this friction is dependent on the air pressure, and the overall air pressure on the ball's surface might be greater when it is falling, so the friction will be higher.

Why the spin might increase:

  • Since the air is bent over the ball because of the Magnus effect, the aligning side might be larger than the colliding side.

  • Turbulence on the colliding side might decrease it's friciton. I imagine it possible that higher collision speed between the ball's surface and the air could create more wirling turbulence on the surface (maybe because of the surface texture of the basketball), correct me from wrong. In contrast the air flow on the aligning side might be more likely to behave planar, with a higher relative friciton.

When it does gain spin, it would be also funny to note that this basketball will have a terminal velocity together with a terminal spin and a constant falling direction. This would be pretty cool.


r/PurePhysics • • Apr 15 '14

I think I discovered something about a typical matching scheme for NMR probe circuits (x-post /r/ece)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Jan 19 '14

Would it be possible to do problem of the week challenges like /r/math is doing

1 Upvotes

Is it possible for physics? We are a diverse bunch here, and I don't know if I'm clever enough to write the problems, but I'd definitely enjoy it if someone tried. The competitions at /r/math are pretty fun.


r/PurePhysics • • May 14 '19

The Art Of Physics - Demonstration Of Order And Chaos

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Dec 05 '25

Free online Pure physics Class. Contact 0774233555

0 Upvotes

I MAKE PHYSICS AS SIMPLE AS DRINKING WATER


r/PurePhysics • • Nov 06 '13

Application of statistical mechanics to financial markets. The Bitcoin economy can use a fresh perspective.

3 Upvotes

I am aware this can be done, and I want to use it to understand some things about cryptocurrency. I don't know where to begin however. I cannnot seem to apply the theory by thinking alone (does the energy map to...price? Price velocity? Utility? etc). Likewise I cannot seem to find a resource that

  1. is concise

  2. is free

  3. is written for an expert in physics, and novice in financial markets
    ^ this may be the main problem...I don't speak finance, I speak physics

If you guys can point to any good references I'd appreciate. A simple google search has yielded some information but it has not given me satisfaction as applied to my particular problem.


r/PurePhysics • • Jul 31 '13

Anyone used arduino as a DAQ board? Arduino for control systems? Silver haired advisor, used to paying a lot more, is (understandably) skeptical

3 Upvotes

/r/ECE recommended a microcontroller to solve my RF problems. They pointed out there's an arduino shield made for labview, which I intially thought was a good idea, but I figured cut out the middle man and get a stepper motor shield. Has anyone used them extensively?

The stepper motors are to control the caps in a resonant tank. The question on DAQ is more rhetorical at this point, but I'd consider it in the future if someone has had success. Any way you slice it, $30-$50 is a cheap probe/preamp/whatever in terms of test equipment.


r/PurePhysics • • Jul 30 '13

Carlo Rovelli describes the historical development of Loop Quantum Gravity vs. String Theory

Thumbnail arxiv.org
13 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Jul 30 '13

What are your perceptions of biophysics?

5 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Nov 30 '13

This paper provides an alternate explanation to the observed ground state electron configuration for lithium (ie; why it is (1s^2)(2s) and not (1s^2)(2p)). Does anybody here have any comments or criticisms of the arguments used? (x-post from /r/physics)

Thumbnail arxiv.org
5 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Oct 12 '16

So You Want to Learn Physics...

Thumbnail
susanjfowler.com
5 Upvotes

r/PurePhysics • • Apr 30 '14

TIL massless particles can only have states of maximal or minimal angular momentum

5 Upvotes

If S = 1, generally we think of {1,0,-1} as allowed observable spin states.

For spin J there are usually 2J+1 allowed states. Not true for massless particles.

For instance the S = 2 graviton - you'll only ever measure 2 or -2 (if you find it). Same for photons - always +1 or -1.

TMYK


r/PurePhysics • • Aug 07 '13

Paper I just finished writing about falling through the Earth.

Thumbnail
arxiv.org
6 Upvotes