r/PsychMelee • • Jan 07 '22

It’s Time for Us to Stop Being So Defensive About Criticisms of Psychiatry

Thumbnail
psychiatrictimes.com
55 Upvotes

r/PsychMelee • • Sep 21 '21

Involuntary Commitment should be abolished

55 Upvotes

Pretty much in the title. I believe that involuntary commitment (both holds and treatments) should be completely abolished in the US. The main reason for this is that there are SO MANY stories of abuse and coercion and all that, and history has shown us time and time again that we can't simply hope everyone acts in good faith. There are people who want to help, I'm not denying that. But from what I have heard online, this industry has a SERIOUS problem with power-tripping. And the simplest and most effective solution to stop it is to take away their power, and allow people to walk away.

I know there are people who actually need treatment. But they can pursue that on their own, maybe with some federal subsides. I just don't think 1 or 2 doctors thinking you could, maybe be crazy is a valid basis for denying nearly all civil rights.


r/PsychMelee • • Mar 01 '20

"I've been diagnosed with mild depression and anxiety". It probably means you're alive.

53 Upvotes

I don't want to hurt anybody's feelings, but I'm often a bit worried when I read people on forums trusting a mild depression/anxiety diagnosis uncritically, as if it really meant something ; it seems to me a dangerously gullible and naive behaviour.

To me that kind of diagnosis just means your doctor acknowledges your problems and your pain, and would agree to prescribe you something if you asked, (something that your health insurance will cover thanks to this diagnosis).

I understand it can be a relief for some people to finally hear a diagnosis and get some validation from a medical professional. Or that sometimes you need an external point of view, a doctor to be fully aware that you're facing a real problem, to realize that something needs to be taken care of or changed.

But this kind of diagnosis may also be the beginning of a long series of problems, which are likely to appear when people take potentially unnecessary medications that are far from inert placebos.

It seems sometimes patients believe a mild depression/anxiety diagnosis is something carved in stone. But actually, you're the one who explained your doctor how you feel, how anxious or depressed you are. Your doctor doesn't know you personally, he doesn't follow you through your day, he as no way to measure how your mental struggles affect your life. He has to rely almost entirely on what you told him, and on the few things he noticed during the short appointment you had.

The way your doctor assesses your depression and anxiety resembles the way he would assess physical pain, asking you to rate your pain on a 0-10 scale.. In the end, you're probably the one in the best position to choose if you really need some medication or not, because the doctor diagnosis is mainly based on your own self-assessment and your subjective life narrative.

But it sounds like some people need to believe there's a lot more to it than that. And they would readily give up their responsibility to rely blindly on medical support. I understand it can be a relief to lean on medical authority, but I find this dangerous as well.

Mild depression and anxiety may just mean you're alive : it's an old idea that some pain in life is inevitable. You have to decide how much pain, anxiety and depression you want to endure without medication. And if you decide to take some medications for it, you have to be well informed about the risks and benefits, and weigh those risks and benefits for yourself.

The idea that some pain is inevitable reminds me of an old French joke about physical pain. It said something like : "If you're over sixty years old and you wake up one morning and don't feel any pain anywhere, you're probably dead..."


r/PsychMelee • • Feb 16 '24

We need a "give depressed poor people money" study

50 Upvotes

Title is self explanatory. I want a study where you take poor people with "depression" and just give them money so they can have better housing, health care, and food. Then I want to see if they're still depressed or what percentage are.


r/PsychMelee • • Jul 13 '21

What psychiatry means by "antipsychotics are effective"

50 Upvotes

A meta-analysis of short term (around 6 weeks) corporate antipsychotic studies tallied what the studies found was the change in PANSS scores in the placebo and drug groups post 2009 and pre 2009.

The change in scores in the drug group minus the change in scores in the placebo group was -8.6 before 2009. After 2009 the change was -5.8(1).

These scores are filled out by the corporate psychiatrist who has conflicts of interest favoring the drugs. The active placebo effect means in effect these studies are unblinded and the psychiatrist mostly knows who is taking the drug and who is not. For example a study found 87% of the psychiatrists doing the rating and 78% of the people in a psych study knew who was and wasn't taking a psych drug(3).

Other drug biases in the studies include, the placebo group being put in withdrawal, and multiple types of cherry picking such as not publishing negative trials.

Here are some examples of how someone can see their scores decline(2).

-3 points if the person no longer has one or two vague non-tenaciously held beliefs the psychiatrist finds unreasonable.

-3 points if the psychiatrist no long finds the person boastful

-4 points if the psychiatrist finds the person no longer clearly distrustful

-4 points if the person is no longer frequently irritable and no longer has direct expressions of resentment or anger towards the psychiatrist.

-4 points if the person no longer shows interpersonal distance form the psychiatrist.

-4 points if the psychiatrist no longer needs to have leading questions to get what they consider adequate responses.

-3 points if the psychiatrist finds the person no longer has some rigidity in beliefs and attitudes.

-4 points if the person no longer complains about poor health to the psychiatrist.

-6 points if the patient now agrees they need psych "treatment" because they have a mental illness.

Studies post 2009 find that taking a "antipsychotic" drug will provide you the life changing benefit of agreeing that you need to take psych drugs and are mentally ill/defective.

Studies pre-2009 find that taking an antipsychotic drug will make life better by making you no longer distrust your psychiatrist and stop being resentful and irritable towards your psychiatrist.

This is what according to psychiatry is helping people and providing effective treatment and benefits.

(1) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32141721/

(2) https://sitotapsy.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/panss.pdf

(3) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3538107/


r/PsychMelee • • Feb 16 '21

Patients resist hospitalization and refuse treatment because they have insight

47 Upvotes

The mental health professional's perspective is that patients have some kind of incapacity and therefore they need treatment and/or hospitalization. If the patient resists or refuses, the professional usually judges the patient to have a lack of insight, justifying even more treatment and/or hospitalization.

Patients who have been hospitalized consistently report that they were abused, tortured and sexually exploited in hospitalization. Patients frequently report that treatment has harmed them, sometimes permanently. Patients frequently report that treatment or hospitalization worsened their mental health.

Patients are aware that they suffer from incapacity and that is why they know that they are unequipped to prevent or handle the dangers of treatment and hospitalization. If they are mentally healthy enough to act on self-preservation and mentally acute enough to understand the system they are in, they will attempt the most rational strategy - to deny that they are incapacitated in the hope that this will convince the mental health professionals to release them from something that is dangerous to their mental health and incapacitates them further.

Mental health professionals who can be trusted with having power over patients with incapacities

A mental health professional who can be trusted with having power over incapacitated people would respond to resistance with self-criticism. The professional would consider it vital to learn why the treatment/hospitalization is so threatening that the patient sees it as a worse option than braving it alone in the world with their incapacity. In some cases, patients choose homelessness or even death over treatment/hospitalization, which would raise alarm bells for the professional to rectify what is so terrible about treatment/hospitalization that even homelessness or death is a better option.

The professional would be eager to remove the danger, minimize the danger, and repair the damage caused. Most importantly, they would respect that the patient is making a rational decision by avoiding something that endangers them when they suffer from incapacity.

If the professional, as a last resort, absolutely must inflict the treatment by force, they would acknowledge that they have damaged the patient. They would not deflect acknowledgement of the damage by reiterating that the damage was necessary. They would prioritize repairing the damage they did to the patient, which they would see as their responsibility.

Professionals like this appear to be very rare. I assert it should be a minimum requirement for holding a license to work with patients with incapacities.

Mental health professionals who should be forbidden to work with patients with incapacities

A mental health professional who immediately assumes lack of insight is proving to the patient that they are willing to distort reality in order to sacrifice a vulnerable person they are supposed to be caring for, just to defend their own ego and save themselves some intellectual labour. A person like this should be forbidden from going anywhere near people who suffer from incapacities, yet it appears to be the way most mental health professionals think.


r/PsychMelee • • Jan 02 '21

Why does a psychiatric hospital look more like a prison camp than a day spa?

41 Upvotes

Reimagine a place for people in "mental distress" who did not commit crime.

One where you are called, "sir or mam" not just at the front desk but through the entire facility.

Imagine a massage table, a room for facials.

Imagine calling your client "sir", or "madam" or whatever they prefer.

Imagine sparkling water it comes in plastic bottles and you could offer it along with a warmed blanket.

Imagine a valet and a consierge.

Imagine the broom in the corner isn't frayed and everyone is in a private room.

If that's not what's happening why?

Is it a gulag and a prison, or a place of healing?

If it's a prison why are there crayons, board games and hacky sack

If it's not a prison why are there lock downs

If your facility could decide what it is, then maybe people could react accordingly

Keep in mind your clients haven't been to trial and haven't committed a crime.

We see ourselves as your customer.

Many of us came there on purpose, or because we trusted you.

Could you imagine a luxury hotel that wouldn't let it's clients leave?

Imagine a spa where you had to get a lawyer to get back out?

This is why detainees fire you and complain

If we are criminals we want our lawyers and a hearing

If we are not criminals....which we absolutely are not...stop treating us like criminals.

If the place is there to deal with criminals stop subjecting us to it.

Remember some of us are in here because we believe we were hit with a direct energy weapon, or we believe we've had multiple stalkers.

We don't understand the victim blaming and we don't understand why you are treating us like we're guilty of smuggling crack into the airport.

Keep in mind too putting someone who is already frightened in to mix with people who are violent is absurd.


r/PsychMelee • • Oct 14 '24

Why psychiatry is to blame for the suicide epidemic

40 Upvotes

Currently our laws, thanks to lobbying by psychiatry, incentivize you, if you're suicidal, to 1) Never talk about it and 2) Don't fuck it up if you decide to go through with it.

Because of psychiatry, if you talk about being suicidal you immediately surrender your right to bodily autonomy. You will, at a minimum; be arrested, strip searched, most likely cavity searched, locked in seclusion, and charged tens of thousands of dollars to have your Human Rights violated. Or the cops will simply kill you upon arrival, which we know statistically is extremely common. The most common victim of a police shooting is someone in a mental health crisis. Mentally ill people are 16x more likely to be killed by police than non mentally ill people. And that's if you're lucky. If you're unlucky you will be restrained, forcibly sedated and electroshocked until you can't even remember who your own mother is anymore.

And this isn't just known and talked about on antipsychiatry forums, this knowledge is widespread. We see memes and posts on pro-psychiatry forums saying things like "Telling my therapist enough to get help, but not enough that they involuntarily hospitalize me." People understand that you can not talk about being suicidal. Doing so can be life-ruining. It is typically life-ruining.

Because of psychiatry people having thoughts of suicide are forced to keep those thoughts to themselves. To never seek help from anyone in any way. They can't talk to friends, family, anyone. And they know they have one shot to get it right. Psychiatry has created within our society the most dangerous situation imaginable. There is a clear solution to stopping the suicide epidemic: abolish psychiatry.


r/PsychMelee • • Aug 05 '21

Man Locked up in Hawaii Mental Hospital for Two Years in case of misaken identity

40 Upvotes

Link:

https://news.sky.com/story/man-locked-up-in-hawaii-mental-hospital-for-two-years-in-case-of-mistaken-identity-12372277

I tried to crosspost this from "nottheonion", where I first saw it, but I didn't see an option for crossposting to here.

Anyway, like the article says, this guy was locked up by mistake for TWO YEARS. Noone in all that time tried to verify his identity, and, more worryingly, EVERY TIME he told them he was not the person they thought he was, they took that as further proof of his delusions, and medicated him even more:

"Yet, the more Mr Spriestersbach vocalised his innocence by asserting that he is not Mr Castleberry, the more he was declared delusional and psychotic by the HSH staff and doctors and heavily medicated," the petition said.

So this is the classic catch 22 of psychiatry: The only way to prove you're sane is to admit that you're not.

Meanwhile, someone who presumably should be locked in a mental hospital (because they're delusional and potentially dangerous) is out doing who knows what.

Then people wonder why there are "anti-psychiatrists" out there who criticise the system.


r/PsychMelee • • Jan 30 '24

What is psychiatry's response to the WHO and UN declaring forced psychiatry to be torture?

38 Upvotes

That's right. That actually happened.

In 2014, the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture wrote that

“this mandate and United Nations treaty bodies have established that involuntary treatment and other psychiatric interventions in health-care facilities are forms of torture and ill-treatment.79 Forced interventions, often wrongfully justified by theories of incapacity and therapeutic necessity inconsistent with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, are legitimized under national laws, and may enjoy wide public support as being in the alleged “best interest” of the person concerned. Nevertheless, to the extent that they inflict severe pain and suffering, they violate the absolute prohibition of torture and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment. A/63/175, paras. 38, 40, 41). Concern for the autonomy and dignity of persons with disabilities leads the Special Rapporteur to urge revision of domestic legislation allowing for forced interventions."

In 2020, The 2021 WHO report concurred, writing:

"The perceived need for coercion is built into mental health systems, including in professional education and training, and is reinforced through national mental health and other legislation. Coercive practices are pervasive and are increasingly used in services in countries around the world, despite the lack of evidence that they offer any benefits, and the significant evidence that they lead to physical and psychological harm and even death. People subjected to coercive practices report feelings of dehumanization, disempowerment, being disrespected and disengaged from decisions on issues affecting them. Many experience it as a form of trauma or re-traumatization leading to a worsening of their condition and increased experiences of distress. Coercive practices also significantly undermine people’s confidence and trust in mental health service staff, leading people to avoid seeking care and support as a result. The use of coercive practices also has negative consequences on the well-being of the professionals using them."

So, what is psychiatry's response to growing global recognition that forced psychiatry and the biological model of mental illness are harmful? How do psychiatrists justify actions that the UN has literally called torture?

Edit: It's so fun to watch the votes on this go up and down. What are y'all downvoting -- the truth? This is the reality; this is what the WHO and the UN have said. Not sorry at all if the psych-apologists can't handle it. Remember the above next time you hold down a screaming human being and then throw them in solitary. You're torturing a person.

Edit: I hope this has been educational. To any psych field workers out there, I hope that you have learned a few things: 1. The UN says that forced psychiatry is torture. Full stop. 2. That renders forced psychiatry an indefensible position, unless you outright advocate for torture, which is always a losing argument (and destroys any moral credibility you might claim). 3. The justifications that allow psych workers to continue engaging in this behavior are based on discrimination against those with mental illness, another indefensible position. If anyone still harbors thoughts that forced psychiatric care is somehow necessary, I lay this karma upon you: May everything that is done to your patients against their will also be done to you; may every suffering you visit upon them also be visited upon you.


r/PsychMelee • • Sep 01 '19

NIH.GOV: "Hospitalization" increases suicide when the victim believes they were coerced into it, regardless of psychiatrists claiming it was "voluntary."

38 Upvotes

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov:

  • "Perceived Coercion During Admission Into Psychiatric Hospitalization Increases Risk of Suicide Attempts After Discharge."

--https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31162700

Controls:

This study controlled for suicidal history & base suicideality- it can't be dismissed by simply saying those hospitalized were already at risk of suicide.

Clarification:

Psychiatrists often claim people are "voluntarily" hospitalized even if the person was threatened by state officials, threatened by family, or just lied to & misled into such "help."

Really if the victim believes they were coerced into "hospitalization" their suicide rate is increased.


Next YSK multiple studies show a 100x higher suicide rate with "hospitalization".

JAMA psychiatry:

  • "Findings: In this meta-analysis of 100 studies of 183 patient samples, the postdischarge suicide rate was approximately 100 times the global suicide rate during the first 3 months after discharge and patients admitted with suicidal thoughts or behaviors had rates near 200 times the global rate. Even many years after discharge, previous psychiatric inpatients have suicide rates that are approximately 30 times higher than typical global rates."

-- https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/fullarticle/2629522

Similarly, according to BeckersHospitalReivew.com suicide rates were 105 times higher among people who were "hospitalized."

  • "The study found estimated suicide rates were 3.2 per 100,000 psychiatric inpatient admissions and 0.03 per 100,000 non-psychiatric inpatients."

https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/quality/5-stats-on-hospital-suicides.html


Next, YSK psychiatrist's opinions on who's "high risk" for suicide are baseless.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov:

  • "About 3% of patients categorized as being at high risk can be expected to commit suicide in the year after discharge. However, about 60% of the patients who commit suicide are likely to be categorized as low risk. Risk categorization is of no value in attempts to decrease the numbers of patients who will commit suicide after discharge."

-- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21740345


r/PsychMelee • • Sep 03 '21

If criminals were treated like mental health patients [Seeking feedback]

36 Upvotes

Policing is to be science-based, so scientific research is performed to determine what thought, feeling and behaviour patterns are associated with each type of criminal. For example, symptoms found to be correlated with stealing:

  • Impulsiveness

  • Inflated optimism

  • A tendency to dishonesty

  • Enjoys adrenalin

  • Comes from a broken home

  • A preference for baggy clothing

  • A preference for concealing the face, e.g. hats, glasses, hair over eyes

  • A tendency to "survey" a room, for example noticing security cameras

Police are trained to scan for these symptoms to determine if someone is a criminal.

So let's say that a guy named Bob goes to the police station to report that he has lost his ID. The officer notes his hoodie and glasses and checks off two symptoms of a thief. He asks Bob what happened.

Bob: Well I was at the surf store.

Officer notes that Bob enjoys adrenalin. Third symptom of a thief.

Bob: I saw a surfboard that was so awesome that I bought it right away. It was a bit expensive but I should be getting a raise soon.

Officer notes that Bob is impulsive and overly optimistic. Five symptoms of a thief.

Bob: There was a cute girl at the checkout and she winked at me, so I might have got distracted and forgotten to pick up my ID.

The officer doesn't think Bob looks like someone a cute girl would flirt with, so the officer notes that Bob is dishonest. Six symptoms of a thief.

The officer has determined that Bob is a thief. He may want to be extra rigorous, so he gives Bob a written test, reassuring him that he is an expert and just here to help with the problem he came in for. Bob answers yes to questions like "Did your parents argue?" and since his job is a camera operator, he answers yes to "Do you notice security cameras when you're in a room?" Neither the officer nor any authority verifies whether the observance of these symptoms were accurate or reasonable, nor does anyone check them for context.

The officer writes in his permanent record that he is a thief. Since scientific research shows that most thieves continue to show symptoms of thievery their whole life, this remains on his record forever and determines his rights, his medical treatment, and judicial dealings.

For Bob's own good, the officer may decide to sentence Bob to prison, where he will treat him at his own discretion with drugs and training programs that are scientifically proven to reduce the observance of these symptoms he observed. No one knows how these drugs or training programs work and they they have debilitating side-effects, but they are definitely a cure because they are shown to reduce the observance of subjectively determined symptoms like impulsiveness and inflated optimism.

Bob may not be informed of the reason why he is detained if the officer thinks Bob will have an undesirable response to hearing he is a thief. He is not informed of any rights. He has a right to a lawyer, but he is not informed of this and might not be granted access to a phone, money or a lawyer's number.

The officer will release Bob when Bob has admitted he is a thief, expressed gratitude for this treatment, and the officer believes he is seeing a reduction in the symptoms he believes he observed.

So that is my understanding of how psychiatry works, explained through an analogy with the criminal justice system. I'm not sure, so I would like to hear any thoughts about anything I'm misunderstanding here.


r/PsychMelee • • Jan 29 '24

Unpopular opinion: Forcibly treating depression & suicidality is a dystopian human rights violation

34 Upvotes

It's ripped right out of dystopian novel. You're sad? You want to die? We will literally arrest you and forcibly drug you until you're happy. You HAVE to be happy! You have NO choice! No bodily autonomy! No human rights! You will be happy and get back to work no matter what even if we have to torture you!


r/PsychMelee • • Jun 24 '21

Common misconceptions: Suicide is preventable

34 Upvotes

Suicide is physically preventable - but this does not increase quality of life. While all suicides are theoretically preventable that is only true if you lock people up. That however doesn't improve or fix anything. Suicide is preventable - but the suffering leading to it isn't and that's the relevant part people overlook.

If we'd live in a society that respects people's freedom suicides wouldn't be preventable. You'd have to focus on the issues causing it.

Removing involuntary holds would force society to deal with the problem rather than ignoring it.


r/PsychMelee • • Sep 15 '20

Involuntary Hospitalization Increases Risk of Suicide, Study Finds

33 Upvotes

r/PsychMelee • • May 05 '20

Almost Everyone Meets Criteria for Mental Illness, Study Suggests

Thumbnail
madinamerica.com
33 Upvotes

r/PsychMelee • • Dec 07 '21

Patient Honesty in Psychiatry

32 Upvotes

I made a comment on the Psychiatry subreddit that will likely get taken down because patients are only allowed to lurk. Gonna copy and paste. It was about how we are taught to lie to our providers about things, mostly because they refuse to listen to us, and then end result is that people have to educate themselves on how to manipulate the system. They were all in there complaining about how people learn what to say to get the right diagnosis, and I was making the point that it is inevitable in an environment where people are not listened to about what they need and want from their providers that they will learn how to lie to get what they need, or even simply to prevent force from being used against them. Here is the copy paste of my comment:

"I'm low key suicidal all the time and the drugs do nothing for me. I had to learn to cut my experience up and reshape it to manipulate my providers into not demanding I either go inpatient or try some other treatment that my lived experience proved doesn't work. Saying it doesn't work is ineffective. That's part of what's happening here. The only way to survive in the system is to learn what buttons to push. And then, I stop accurately describing my experience, and start doing exactly what is described above, generating the right phrasing to get the result I know I can tolerate. The systems itself grooms people to become manipulators of the system."


r/PsychMelee • • Mar 12 '24

Opinion: Psychiatrists should not be reasoned with, debated or engaged with - only resisted

28 Upvotes

“Freedom is never given voluntarily by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed.”

  • Martin Luther King, Jr., 1963 Letter from a Birmingham Jail

I like the idea of this subreddit, but one must come to terms with a fundamental reality: Psychiatrists do not see you as a human being. If you believe you can deprive someone of liberty, restrain them against their will, lock them in solitary confinement, inject them with chemicals against their will, strip search them against their will, electrocute their brain against their will; you do not see them as a human being. You see them as, at best, subhuman, or, worse, an object to be experimented on.

I am reminded of the politcal cartoon where on one side black protestors say "We want civil rights!" and on the other KKK members say "We want to kill black people!" and someone stands in the middle and says "Compromise?"

There is no compromising torture. There is no middleground to dehumanization. There is no reasoning with an oppressor.


r/PsychMelee • • Mar 25 '22

Psychiatrists mis-applying diagnosis

28 Upvotes

From my observation there is a vast amout of psychiatrists who don't even have the proper knowledge to properly diagnose people.

The general criteria for personality disorders for example state, that the disorder must cause clinically significant distress (in social an work life).

It seems like an innocent sentence but let me repeat that again with highlights: (the disorder) MUST CAUSE (clinically significant distress).

This therefore implies that the distress a person experiences must not come from external events or factors but must be a direct consequence of the disorder. The causality is such, that the disorder itself must be the entity causing the distress.

Many psychiatrists simply ignore or flip this causality requirement. There's a difference between the personality disorder causing distress and some external event X causing distress.

The argument is essentially this: An event X causes distress (let's say X = death of a loved one). Based on your reaction to event X you are going to get diagnosed with a personality disorder. Because the fact that you feel distress or "react in a certain way" apparentely implies a personality disorder. Which is entirely wrong. Because the distress isn't caused by the personality disorder but it is caused by X (the death of a loved one).

Similarily even if your reactions are "abnormal" (for whatever psychiatry considers to be an abnormal reaction) that still doesn't imply a personality disorder because as long as the "abnormal" reaction doesn't cause (secondary) distress then the criteria, that the personality disorder must cause distress is just not fulfilled.

Now as an other example. Suppose you have compulsive behaviours (hinting at OCPD) that cause you emotional distress THEN the emotional distress is in fact caused by the OCPD in which case the causality requirement is fulfilled and the diagnosis would be correct.

So... don't let yourself get fooled by psychiatrists into an incorrect diagnosis!


r/PsychMelee • • May 28 '20

Why are psychiatrists allowed to ignore civil rights? A polemic arguing that mental health patients are treated worse than criminals. How could the system be reformed?

Thumbnail
vjmpublishing.nz
28 Upvotes

r/PsychMelee • • Dec 15 '23

Beautiful Mind Movie Was Manipulated

27 Upvotes

At the end of the movie, A Beautiful Mind, John Nash stated he’s taking the newer drugs, when in reality he stopped taking antipsychotics.


r/PsychMelee • • Jul 28 '22

The New Study on Serotonin and Depression Isn’t About Antidepressants

Thumbnail
vice.com
27 Upvotes

r/PsychMelee • • Sep 20 '21

Psychwards and mental hospitals are generally portrayed as abusive in media. And it's pretty much accepted to be at least not helpful by most people who have experience in one.

27 Upvotes

Genuinely interested what people in these fields think about that.


r/PsychMelee • • Dec 16 '20

I just want to be allowed to be sad and dissatisfied with life while not being labeled as sick.

26 Upvotes

If others find psychiatry helpful that's good for them. Personally I am deeply sad and dislike my life I really don't want to participate in the world because it offers me nothing. Sure I will enjoy myself if I am able to but I would rather just leave the world. Not in a suicidal way I just want to leave the world not harm myself I think I am beautiful and there is nothing wrong with me. I think there is a lot wrong with the world but of course not everyone in the world is bad. I just want to be allowed to say this and feel sad about it without being called sick. It definitely makes me sad that things are like this but I am not sick my emotions are okay and right for myself.


r/PsychMelee • • Aug 06 '20

What should be done about involuntary hospitalization?

26 Upvotes

Let’s start this discussion off with a couple FACTS…

Fact 1: the status quo is unacceptable. As it stands, folks can be tossed into the hospital on a whim, without any avenue for recourse. The term ‘danger to self or others’ has lost all meaning as those in charge are able to fabricate subjective interpretations that can be applied to just about anyone who walks through the door. The facilities are abysmal, seemingly designed to increase the stress level of patients, making it impossible to stabilize through any means outside of blasting the patient’s head with meds.

Fact 2: something similar to involuntary hospitalization is necessary. There are certainly people out there, like me, that have the capacity to lose their fuckin mind and vault into a mental state where they are (objectively) a harm to themselves or others. This may be a fraction of the cases that are subjected to involuntary hospitalization, but our existence is undeniable. Furthermore, it’s important to note that while we’re out of our minds we will actively refuse any sort of psychiatry intervention that folks attempt to impose on us...that’s why the ‘involuntary’ part of the treatment is key.

What’s to be done?

I know the opinion of many who frequent r/antipsychiatry and r/radicalmentalhealth is that the system needs to be tossed out entirely…I don’t think that’s feasible. While abolishing involuntary treatment may save countless from trauma & abuse, it would leave folks like me…folks that can potentially lose their mind…without any sort of safety net. It would leave me and my ilk free on the streets until we do something regrettable that we can’t come back from. While the current state is unacceptable, completely abolishing the system without a viable alternate is equally unacceptable IMO.

So, let’s find some middle ground, yah? Lets discuss what could be done in the short and long term to create a system that does less damage while still helping those who need help.

Possible short term solution:

Change moves slow af, amirite? In the short term, I don’t think we can expect any sort of fundamental change or an established alternate to take over. I think we need to focus on advocating for some baby steps down the road to a long term solution.

My suggestion is: have an option to opt out of involuntary treatment. Just a piece of paper that you sign to say “IDGAF how crazy I might get, I DO NOT CONSENT to involuntary psych treatment”. I’d imagine this sort of paper would need to be signed on a stable mind and require an appointment of some sort…it would kinda defeat the purpose if someone who’s already lost their mind is able to sign it. Alternately, signing the opt out papers could have a delayed effect [u/O_G_P], where it's not active immediately, but goes into effect something like 6 months after you sign.

Additionally, we could have the ability to appoint someone who can make decisions for us, with regard to involuntary commitment. i.e. if you reach a state that might be considered 'harm to self or others', the doctors would require the signed approval of someone you've appointed before they can involuntarily commit you. [u/OnTheWheelhouseFloor]

Alternate [u/cortexplorer]: help people to make individualized algorithms to assess which steps should be taken when. In addition to helping a person become more mindful of their symptoms and alert them to when they need to take better care of their mental health, triggers can be defined such as 'involuntarily hospitalize me if and only if...'

Possible long term solutions:

In the long term, the system needs some sort of fundamental change or there needs to be a viable alternate to involuntary commitment. Some ideas I have on the topic:

  1. Require evidence that a person is a ‘harm to self or others’ [u/endoxology].

  2. Design facilities that are relaxing, perhaps even enjoyable, to promote stabilization.

    1. Make various types of exercise available all day

    2. Have a computer room, possibly with games

    3. Make shit more comfortable…jesus the existing facilities suck

    4. Serve halfway decent food, available whenever

    5. STOP SHINING THE GODDAMN FLASHLIGHT IN MY FACE EVERY 15 MIN WHILE I TRY TO SLEEP

    6. Allow friends/family to visit whenever, perhaps even stay over

  3. Give the patients the option to stabilize without meds and offer up a slew of coping mechanisms to help em along

  4. House arrest instead of hospitalization [u/O_G_P]

  5. Design objective tests (possibly with an MRI) that folks can take to free themselves from the facility [u/O_G_P]

  6. Eliminate extensive wait times in triage/ER [u/grayperegrine]

  7. Allow patients to contact the outside world, in comfort (better than a single phone outside the nurse's desk with a contentious line of patients waiting to use it). Perhaps allow cell phones. [u/grayperegrine]

  8. Create a voluntary treatment facility that deals with folks who haven't reached a crisis state, with more liberties than the involuntary facility has, sorta like a halfway house. [u/kayakingsheep]

  9. Strengthened protections for patients and accountability for professionals. Something like 3rd party observation. [u/ACaffeinatedWandress]

  10. Proper channels to pursue recourse if the patient is harmed by the system [u/ACaffeinatedWandress]

I know some of these fixes/alternates are pie in the sky, but that’s why they’re long term solutions.

Anyone have anything to add or a criticism of something above?

Anyone that believes the current system should not be changed wanna explain why or why the above suggestions might not be feasible?