r/ProxyEngineering • • Oct 07 '26

Reviews I’ve tested a bunch of proxy providers recently. Here’s what actually stood out to me [HONEST REVIEW]

1 Upvotes

i have spent a decent amount of time testing different proxy providers lately, mostly around scraping and automation and i have noticed that the differences become pretty obvious once you stop looking only at the price per GB.

these are 5 that stood out to me for different reasons.

1. SOCKS(.)MARKET

What I liked

  • simple setup

  • residential + mobile options

  • low barrier to testing

  • good for smaller projects where i don't want to commit a lot upfront

  • i've had decent results with residential traffic on the targets i've tested

What I didn't like

  • like any residential pool, some IPs are obviously better than others

  • i'd like to see more detailed usage/performance analytics

  • it's not the provider i'd automatically pick for a huge enterprise workload

Pricing

  • their shared proxies starts around $0.40/day on the plans i have used

  • their private proxies starts around $1.00/day depending on the duration/plan

  • there are also short-term private residential options

What impressed me
the simplicity. i can get a proxy running and start testing without having to build a complicated configuration first.

2. Decodo

What I liked

  • huge residential pool

  • 195+ locations

  • country, state, city, ZIP and ASN targeting

  • both rotating and sticky sessions

  • good dashboard and documentation

What I didn't like

  • the price gets less attractive at small volumes compared with some cheaper providers

  • there are a lot of configuration options, so it can take some time to figure out what you actually need

Pricing
their residential pricing currently starts at $4/GB pay-as-you-go.

Monthly plans currently range from $3.75/GB for 3GB down to $2.75/GB for 100GB. Enterprise pricing goes lower with larger volumes.

What impressed me
the amount of control you get without having to go straight into an enterprise setup.

3. Oxylabs

What I liked

  • very mature platform

  • strong location coverage

  • sticky sessions

  • multiple rotation options

  • HTTP(S), HTTP/3 and SOCKS5

  • good tooling around larger scraping setups

What I didn't like

  • expensive compared with the cheaper providers

  • probably overkill for a small scraper

  • the pricing makes more sense when you're actually using enough traffic to justify it

Pricing
their residential proxies currently start at $6/GB on the smallest tier.

That drops to $5/GB, $4/GB, and eventually $2.50/GB at 1,000GB+ volume.

What impressed me
the overall polish. it feels much more like infrastructure built for production workloads than something you just buy for a quick test.

4. Bright Data

What I liked

  • massive network

  • very strong geo-targeting

  • lots of proxy types

  • sticky and rotating sessions

  • good tooling around managing larger proxy deployments

What I didn't like

  • pricing can get complicated

  • there's a lot of stuff available that you may never actually need

  • i'd spend some time figuring out exactly which product fits the project before buying anything

Pricing
their current residential pay-as-you-go price is $4/GB.

Their larger monthly plans are currently $499 for 141GB, $999 for 332GB, and $1,999 for 798GB.

What impressed me
the sheer amount of infrastructure and targeting available. if you have a very specific location requirement, this is where that flexibility starts becoming useful.

5. IPRoyal

What I liked

  • relatively simple to get started

  • residential pool covering 195 countries

  • sticky sessions can run for up to 7 days

  • pay-as-you-go option

  • no monthly minimum

What I didn't like

  • the smaller plans aren't particularly cheap

  • less of the enterprise-style tooling you get from the bigger providers

  • i'd still test the actual target instead of assuming the IP pool will work everywhere

Pricing
their residential pay-as-you-go pricing currently starts at $7.35/GB for 1GB, $6.25/GB for 2GB, and $5.51/GB for 10GB.

Subscription pricing is slightly cheaper, starting at $7/GB for 1GB, $5.95/GB for 2GB, and $5.25/GB for 10GB.

What impressed me
the straightforward setup. it's one of those providers where you can get something running without spending ages figuring out the platform.

What I actually care about

after testing different providers, i don't really compare them purely by price per GB anymore.

i usually look at:

  • successful requests

  • failed requests

  • retries

  • latency

  • session stability

  • location accuracy

  • IP quality

  • bandwidth wasted on failed requests

  • how the pool performs on the actual target

because a $2/GB proxy isn't actually cheaper if you end up wasting half the bandwidth on retries.

that's probably the biggest thing i have learned from testing different providers. the "best" proxy depends heavily on what you're actually doing with it.


r/ProxyEngineering • • Jul 25 '26

Discussion 💬 After testing multiple proxy providers, what factors actually matter when choosing one?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been testing different proxy solutions recently for scraping projects, and one thing I realized is that choosing a proxy provider is not as simple as looking at the number of IPs or the price.

At first, it’s easy to focus on things like IP pool size, locations, and pricing. But after actually using proxies in real scraping workflows, I found that some other factors usually have a much bigger impact on the final results.

For me, things like connection stability, IP quality, success rate, session control, and how often requests need to be retried are usually more important than just the advertised specs.

Novada was one of the proxy services I recently tested during this process. The setup was straightforward, and the overall experience was stable for the scraping tasks I was working on. It also reminded me that a good proxy service is not only about having a large IP pool, but also about how reliable it is in real-world use.

I’ve also noticed that many proxy providers offer trial access now, which is actually helpful because different projects can have completely different requirements. A proxy that works well for one use case may not be the best fit for another.

Curious how everyone here evaluates proxy providers.

When you try a new proxy service, what matters most to you? Is it reliability, pricing, location coverage, success rate, integration experience, or something else?


r/ProxyEngineering • • Oct 09 '26

Guides Why scraping protected sites keeps getting pricier

1 Upvotes

I've been digging into why scraping heavily guarded sites keeps costing more, and the breakdown surprised me.

Where the money goes

  • Residential and mobile proxies that look like real users

  • Rendering JavaScript before content appears

  • Paid challenge solvers

  • Retries when requests get flagged

  • Spoofing browser and TLS fingerprints

Proxies keep getting cheaper, yet the cost per successful page keeps rising. More bots means tougher bot managers, and one defense upgrade can multiply costs several times overnight. Past a certain point the data is worth less than the effort to get it.

Check these first

  1. Open the network tab. Many sites load listings from an internal JSON endpoint.

  2. Randomize delays and spread out your requests.

  3. Skip hidden display:none links, since they are bot traps.

If you don't code

A browser extension that runs in your normal Chrome session lets you skip building stealth setups. Minexa.ai is one. The flow:

  1. Open the list page and click 'Yes, I'm on the right page'.

  2. Confirm the pagination it detects.

  3. Review the highlighted list and columns.

  4. Run the job and export to Excel or Google Sheets.

It handles JavaScript-heavy and location-based pages without config. When a value is missing, it leaves the field empty rather than guessing. Grab the Chrome extension or read the getting started guide.

Public data still falls under GDPR and CCPA when it's personal, so keep your collection narrow.

Related: Stop fighting anti-bot walls and start pricing your data


r/ProxyEngineering • • Jul 22 '26

Hot Take 🔥 Too big to fail. What happened with NetNut

4 Upvotes

NetNut is facing a major crisis after researchers linked its proxy network to “Popa,” a botnet of more than two million compromised devices, including smart TVs and streaming boxes. In early July 2026, Google and the FBI began disrupting the infrastructure, while domains were reportedly seized.

Google said hundreds of threat groups routed traffic through suspected NetNut exit nodes. Reports suggest devices were enrolled through hidden SDKs in streaming, IPTV, and utility apps, often without clear consent.

The fallout includes millions of lost IPs, reduced reliability, account disruptions, reputational damage, and risks for resellers using NetNut’s infrastructure

How CyberYozh Ensures Proxy Quality and Security

CyberYozh protects proxy quality through ethical IP sourcing, continuous screening, and rapid abuse response. Its IP Checker detects fraud risks, blacklists, and suspicious network types before proxies are used. Residential and mobile IPs come from informed, consenting participants, while a dedicated abuse team investigates reports and removes questionable addresses quickly.


r/ProxyEngineering • • 25d ago

Guides Datacenter vs Residential Proxies: A Quick Setup Guide

1 Upvotes

Choosing the wrong proxy wastes money or causes failed requests. Here's how to decide:

1. Define your workload
Open datasets and downloads? Prioritize speed. Geo-testing or persistent sessions? Consider residential IPs.

2. Choose your proxy

  • Datacenter: Fast, cheap, high bandwidth, but easily identified by ASN.

  • Residential: ISP-assigned IPs, generally better reputation, but more expensive.

3. Check IP quality
Run an ASN lookup and check fraud scores or abuse reports before deployment.

4. Configure sessions
Use static IPs for long sessions and rotating pools when multiple IPs are required.

5. Build hybrid routing
Send public downloads through datacenter proxies and location-sensitive requests through residential ones.

6. Test
Compare latency, HTTP status codes, costs and failure rates.

Tip: Benchmark before scaling.


r/ProxyEngineering • • Sep 06 '26

Build 🤓 Tired of monthly residential proxy subs? I built a provider with non-expiring data

1 Upvotes

hey guys, i got so tired of burning money on monthly proxy subscriptions and losing all my unused data on slow weeks, so i decided to just set up my own provider.

it’s called phantomproxies[org]. the main point is residential data that never expires. You buy it, and it just sits in your dashboard until your bots actually use it.

it's pulling from a clean 64M+ residential pool with ~0.5s response times. if you've been looking to try out a new provider or just need a solid backup option, give me a shot. i set up a small $8 / 2GB tier so you can test it against your current setup without committing to a big monthly plan.

i'm running this completely solo right now, so if you give it a spin, let me know how it works for you or if you hit any bugs!


r/ProxyEngineering • • Jun 06 '26

As an MCA student, I got tired of scrapers bypassing protections on self-hosted applications, so I started building my own solution

Post image
4 Upvotes

I'm currently an MCA student and over the last several months I've been spending a lot of my free time building and deploying projects on VPS servers.

One problem I kept running into was automated traffic, scrapers, and bots. Tools like Nginx rate limiting and Fail2Ban definitely help, but I found myself constantly wondering how much traffic was still getting through and what additional protections could be added closer to the application layer.

When I started looking at existing solutions, many were either cloud-based, designed for larger organizations, or simply didn't fit the kind of self-hosted and privacy-focused environments I was experimenting with.

So I decided to treat it as a learning project and started building BotGateway, a lightweight anti-bot gateway written in Go.

The original goal wasn't to compete with Cloudflare or enterprise WAFs. It was to better understand modern bot behavior and create something that could run directly on infrastructure people control themselves.

Along the way I've learned a lot about:

  • Automated scraping techniques

  • Headless browsers

  • Traffic analysis

  • Rate limiting strategies

  • Request fingerprinting

  • VPS security

The project has grown much larger than I originally expected, and now I'm looking for feedback from people who manage websites, APIs, SaaS products, or self-hosted services.

A few questions I'd love to hear opinions on:

  • What are you currently using to handle scrapers and automated abuse?

  • What limitations have you found with existing solutions?

  • For those running self-hosted infrastructure, what features would you want in a lightweight anti-bot gateway?

  • Are there any detection techniques or security approaches you think are underrated?

I'm still learning and building, so constructive criticism is more than welcome.

Thanks for reading.


r/ProxyEngineering • • Jun 25 '26

Discussion 💬 Proxy count is overrated. Subnet diversity matters more than people think

4 Upvotes

A lot of proxy providers lead with the biggest number they have.

10,000 IPs.
100,000 IPs.
50M+ IPs.

That sounds impressive, but by itself it does not say much.

The better question is: where do those IPs actually come from?

Because 100 proxies from the same small network range are not the same as 100 proxies from 100 different network origins. On paper, both setups give you 100 IPs. In practice, one of them gives you diversity, and the other gives you a crowded neighborhood.

That “neighborhood” is the subnet.

A subnet is basically a block of related IP addresses. Different house numbers, same street. If too much traffic comes from that same street at the same time, many detection systems can treat it as one coordinated source, even when every request uses a different IP.

This is why simply adding more proxies does not always fix reliability issues.

If the extra IPs come from the same few subnet ranges, you are not really adding much. You are just making the same pattern bigger.

A healthier proxy setup usually has a few things going for it: IPs spread across unrelated subnets, different ISP origins, clean reputation, consistent geo targeting, and session logic that matches the workflow. Sometimes you need sticky sessions. Sometimes you need rotation. But rotation only helps when it actually moves you to a different network origin, not just to the next IP in the same block.

This is one of the layers we care about a lot

Raw IP volume is useful, but it is not enough. The real value is in how the pool is built: how broad the ISP distribution is, how much subnet diversity exists behind the dashboard number, and how predictable the sessions are once traffic starts moving.

Our residential infrastructure focuses on wide network distribution across regions and ISP sources. For workflows that need carrier-grade traffic, we also support LTE/5G mobile proxies. The goal is simple: reduce clustering, keep sessions stable, and give teams more control over the network layer.

When evaluating any proxy provider, I’d look past the headline IP count and ask a few practical questions:

Do they talk about subnet diversity, or only total pool size?
Can they keep a sticky session when the workflow needs continuity?
Can they target by country, city, or operator when location matters?
Do they offer IP reputation or fraud score checks before use?
Does rotation actually move across different network origins?

If the answers are vague, that usually tells you enough.

Speed and price matter, of course. Nobody wants slow or overpriced proxies. But for serious workflows, network architecture matters just as much.

Raw IP count gets attention.
Subnet diversity is what often decides reliability.


r/ProxyEngineering • • Jun 17 '26

Discussion 💬 why is our community color pink?

12 Upvotes

hello wonderfull community of scrapers and anti-bot warrirors,

since the dawn of time we have set ourselves to becoming the best in overcoming the anti-bot giants - showing the incubents that data of thy Internet shall always be open to everyone, not resitrcited by capital and built on one core fundamental - Freedom!

how the hell is our community color Pink?


r/ProxyEngineering • • 20d ago

Discussion 💬 Where Do Residential Proxies Really Come From? AMA with Jason Grad, CEO of Massive

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ProxyEngineering • • Oct 06 '26

Discussion 💬 What actually changes your proxy provider choice in production?

0 Upvotes

I’m curious how people here actually choose proxy infrastructure once you get past the usual “best provider” lists.

For a real production workload, which inputs genuinely change your decision?

My current shortlist:

  • target / site type

  • required geography

  • traffic volume and concurrency

  • sticky vs rotating sessions

  • residential vs ISP vs datacenter

  • pricing model / effective cost

  • reliability / retry rate

  • compliance or IP sourcing requirements

But I’m more interested in what experienced users actually care about.

A few questions:

  1. What are the 3–5 inputs that most often change which provider you choose?

  2. What information do providers usually fail to show?

  3. What do you trust more: provider documentation, community reports, or your own tests?

  4. What unknown would immediately disqualify a provider?

  5. Do you optimize for $/GB, success rate, or cost per successful result?

I’m especially interested in whether the answer changes between SERP, ecommerce, social, and general web scraping workloads.


r/ProxyEngineering • • Sep 16 '26

Discussion 💬 I built a tool to test websites on the new iPhone Duo

Post image
0 Upvotes

It supports iPhone Duo + 30+ other devices, including foldables, Android, iPad, and Surface.

Link: https://duoresponsive.com/

The useful part: it has proxy support, so websites that normally throw connection refused because they block iframe requests can still be previewed.


r/ProxyEngineering • • 24d ago

Build 🤓 I got tired of free proxy lists where most “working” proxies are honeypots, so I built a scraper that actually verifies them

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProxyEngineering • • Sep 06 '26

Hot Take 🔥 Residential vs Mobile Proxies for TikTok: Which Is Best for Account Management, Automation, and Scaling?

4 Upvotes

A team launches ten TikTok accounts. They give five accounts costly mobile proxies. The rest use static residential IPs.

A week later, the residential accounts look healthy. Several mobile accounts hit verification checks. The problem was inconsistency.

TikTok sees more than an IP address. It can compare the network type, location, device fingerprint, session history, and account behavior. The mobile IPs changed too often. Some sessions also jumped between regions. The residential accounts stayed tied to one stable environment.

Mobile proxies still have a real advantage. Their carrier ASN and CGNAT pattern resemble normal cellular traffic. That makes them useful for cloud phones, app-based workflows, and mobile-specific testing.

Residential proxies are often enough for a few established accounts. Static IPs work well for stable sessions. Rotating residential pools are better suited to public-data collection, regional research, and scraping.

The practical lesson:

  • Keep the IP, region, device, and session consistent.

  • Use sticky sessions for logged-in accounts.

  • Use rotation for unauthenticated data collection.

  • Don’t assume a mobile IP can hide unnatural behavior.

Proxy type matters. A coherent environment matters more.


r/ProxyEngineering • • 13d ago

Guides Gaming Proxy Guide 2026: SOCKS5, UDP, DDoS Protection, Ping Stability & Best Proxy Types for Gaming

0 Upvotes

I started testing gaming proxies because one connection kept getting ugly during peak hours. Average ping looked acceptable, but the session felt terrible: random spikes, packet loss, and short bursts of rubber-banding.

So I routed the game through a SOCKS5 proxy with UDP support located close to the game server and compared both paths during the same evening.

the result was interesting. The proxy added another network hop, so raw latency wasn’t magically lower. What improved was the route itself. Traffic avoided a congested section of my ISP’s path, and latency became much more consistent.

There was another benefit: the game session exposed the proxy IP rather than my home IP, which is useful for streamers or competitive players worried about targeted DDoS attacks.

That changed how I look at “gaming proxies.”

For live play, I’d prioritize:

SOCKS5 + UDP → stable/static IP → location near the game server → low jitter → low packet loss.

Rotating residential pools make much more sense for regional store or QA testing than an active match.

For gaming, the most useful thing is how stable the entire network path stays under load.


r/ProxyEngineering • • Aug 07 '26

Discussion 💬 I realized that I spend more time reading Reddit posts than proxy providers' landing pages

7 Upvotes

And it's not because their websites are bad or something, it's because on reddit I find the most insightful information with real people sharing real experiences. Do you feel the same or trust landing pages or reviews?

Because usually, landing pages tell me just:

  • How many IPs they have (which is sometimes total BS)

  • How many countries they cover (and almost each proxy provider has the same country coverage)

  • How much they charge (well that's probably the only thing that I look for on landing pages)

Reddit has been able to tell me answers or experiences like:

  1. "We've been debugging this issue for three days with this provider"

  2. "Don't pay this much to use this provider, they're not worth it"

  3. "We switched from Bright data to Nodemaven or decodo because sticky sessions were more reliable for our workflow"

That's the kind of information that actually changes buying decisions.

Marketing tells you what a product is supposed to do

Users tell you what happened at 2 a.m. when production broke

I'm pretty curious about this... where do you spend more time researching infrastructure these days?


r/ProxyEngineering • • May 21 '26

Anyone else using proxies and still getting inconsistent results?

8 Upvotes

Proxies definitely help with access, but I learned they’re not the whole setup. At first I thought changing IPs was enough, but if everything still runs from the same browser setup, same device traces, same habits, and same workspace, accounts can still end up feeling connected.

That’s why I started using Geelark. I can match different proxies with separate cloud phone environments, so each account feels more isolated instead of everything overlapping. Made testing way easier because I wasn’t just changing the IP anymore, I was changing the whole environment too.

Anyone else using proxies but still getting weird account behavior sometimes?


r/ProxyEngineering • • Sep 05 '26

Discussion 💬 IP pool overlap across residential proxy providers

Post image
8 Upvotes

Greetings, fellow engineers. Was wanted to see how much overlap actually exists between residential proxy pools sold by different providers. Sampled each provider's IPs until new-IP discovery dropped below 5% over three consecutive 1,000-request ranges (or hit a 2M request ceiling), then compared raw IP overlap, ASN similarity via MaxMind, and used the some-hard-to-type index to estimate overlap at true pool size.

Two things came out of it: a handful of providers are essentially reselling the same pool under different brands (IpnProxy, Proxidize, DataImpulse, and Ghostealth showed 75%+ raw overlap, ~100% if adjusted for estimated pool size), and a much larger group shares IPs to varying degrees (10-70%+). Long story short - if you get banned on one provider and switch to another expecting a fresh IP range, you might just be renting the same flagged IPs under a different label.

You can read more about methodology and find a GitHub link to raw pool overlap table in the article on my website (contains affiliate links on other pages): https://proxy-db.com/article/youre-buying-the-same-proxy-twice

Feel free to ask questions about the table, used methods and whatnot!


r/ProxyEngineering • • Aug 12 '26

Guides residential proxy takeaways from 3 weeks of per-profile account warmups

2 Upvotes

been doing a small warmup batch for social and marketplace accounts, 42 profiles total, mostly us residential ips from the same provider but split by city where i could. tossed every profile into AdsPower so fingerprints and proxy settings stayed fully separate while i watched how the ips behaved.

what worked best was boring consistency. one residential proxy per profile, same ip for at least 10 to 14 days, timezone matched to the proxy location, and no user agent swaps after cookies landed. the stable profiles did normal browsing first, then logins, then light posting or store actions. fast account creation on fresh ips still triggered checks.

what broke was mostly proxy quality. a few “residential” endpoints had bad history or kept rotating mid-session, and those profiles hit phone checks quick. browser isolation keeps cookies and fingerprints apart, yet messy behavior or dirty ips still sink the whole thing.


r/ProxyEngineering • • 10d ago

Help 🆘 Incorrect results from google

2 Upvotes

Did you also notice the incorrect given results from google when scraping? I have started to see this since Tuesday. Like the positions of certain urls are just dead wrong. I always have to check manually with incognito on and proxies set to certain locations. Was there some sort of google update that is giving such results? I don't get it. Maybe someone else encountered such changes when scraping google?


r/ProxyEngineering • • Oct 08 '26

Discussion 💬 Is Web Scraping Legal? An Internet Law Professor’s Insights on Public Data, CFAA, Copyright and Terms of Service | AMA with Eric Goldman

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/ProxyEngineering • • Aug 28 '26

Hot Take 🔥 What the fuck is happening with DataDome

Thumbnail
github.com
2 Upvotes

r/ProxyEngineering • • 9d ago

Hot Take 🔥 Opinionnnn

2 Upvotes

Honestly, 2extract seems pretty useful, especially if you're someone who regularly works with web scraping or data collection. Finding reliable proxies can be a headache sometimes, so having residential and mobile proxies in one place sounds convenient. Definitely something worth checking out. 2extract


r/ProxyEngineering • • Oct 13 '26

Discussion 💬 How to Bypass DataDome, Akamai, Incapsula & Kasada: AMA with Hyper Solutions' Founder - Patrick van den Bosch

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes