r/Proust • • Mar 23 '26

Right there.

1 Upvotes

That whole world of hidden relationships, ambition, and social maneuvering isn’t just hinted at, Proust puts it on full display through Morel. The way Morel moves, manipulates, and navigates desire and status feels way too precise to be accidental. It’s like Proust isn’t just observing from afar, he’s writing from deep familiarity with that coded, double-life reality.

Was Proust gay in real life?


r/Proust • • Jan 28 '25

Proust and peers at the table

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

Club Saudade: my animation is a glimpse of anachronistic decadence in 30 seconds. These digital ideas take time and begin life with a layered collage of the 4 of the most inspirational people for me right now, preparing for more AI animations #lumaaidreammachine "remembering, waiting, hoping, amid the ruins of all the rest; and bear unflinchingly, in the tiny and almost impalpable drop of their essence, the vast structure of recollection.”

Proust #Huysmans #Moreau #Montesquiou #hauntology #Time #Nostalgia


r/Proust • • Jan 26 '26

best translations

0 Upvotes

vol 1 davis

2 mandell

3 treharne

4-7 scott moncrieff, kilmartin, enright

no explanation needed.


r/Proust • • Mar 23 '25

Finally Finished Remembering

Post image
19 Upvotes

What a ride it’s been. I started in January of 2024, took a lot of breaks, and feel so lucky to have found and completed this series when I did.

“At last I should achieve that for which I had so much longed for and believed impossible during my walks on the Guermantes side as I had believed it was impossible,when I came home, to go to bed without embracing my mother, or later, that Albertine loved women, an idea i later accepted unconsciously, for our greatest fears like our greatest hopes are not beyond our capacity and it is possible to end by dominating the first and realizing the second.”


r/Proust • • Dec 23 '25

I brought Proust to a "Self-Improvement" book club, and it was a disaster. Here is why that makes me hopeful.

67 Upvotes

I recently attended a local reading group held in a chain coffee shop. The vibe was frantic. People arrived late, quickly ordered the minimum required coffee, and opened their notebooks.

The hit of the night was a finance book about "optimizing asset allocation." One guy, a habitual note-taker, scribbled furiously, terrified of missing a single profitable sentence.

Then, it was my turn. I introduced Marcel Proust’s In Search of Lost Time.

The room went silent. The scratching of pens stopped. Eyes glazed over. Someone checked their phone. Finally, a tired-looking attendee asked, "But is it useful? Like, what’s the takeaway?"

That moment stayed with me. It made me realize we are living in the era of the "Tool Book."

The Obsession with Utility
We seem to have lost the "Salon" culture. We don't discuss art or existence anymore; we discuss survival.

  • Finance books teach us how not to be swallowed by capitalism.

  • Self-help books teach us how to not have a mental breakdown while being swallowed.

We are so obsessed with turning our brains into "efficient machines" that reading fiction—especially something as dense and slow as Proust—feels like a waste of time. As Byung-Chul Han argues in The Burnout Society, we are patients in a high-pressure emergency room; nobody wants to hear poetry, they want a cure.

Why AI Makes Proust More Important
Here is my hot take: In the age of AI, "Utility" is a losing game.

If you are reading books just to learn a formula, a template, or a communication hack, an LLM (Large Language Model) can already do that better than you. AI creates the ultimate "Standard Operating Procedure."

But AI cannot feel the taste of a madeleine dipped in tea. It cannot experience the irrational, non-structural "tremor" of jealousy, memory, and time that Proust describes.

Literature as the Last Sanctuary
The awkward silence in that coffee shop made me realize that reading literature is now an act of rebellion. It is a refusal to be a machine.

  • It calibrates our sensitivity.

  • It helps us identify self-deception.

  • It reveals how time shapes us.

It won't make you rich. It won't get you a promotion. But it might make you hate yourself a little less at 3 AM when the world is quiet.

I realized that uselessness is the point. It’s the only thing AI can’t replicate.

Question for you all:
Do you feel this pressure to only read "useful" non-fiction? Do you think the ability to appreciate "slow" literature is becoming a lost art, or am I just being too pessimistic?

I wrote a longer reflection on this "Salon Culture vs. Survival Anxiety" and the economics of reading Proust. If you're interested in the full essay, you can read it here:
Proust vs. Utility: The Lost Salon in the Age of AI


r/Proust • • Jun 02 '26

Grim but Fun Question Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I've started rereading In Search of Lost Time, and a silly, dark and fun question crossed my mind. Marcel is narrating all of his thoughts to us, we're fascinated by them, or we should be. But if he said all this to real people, they'd eventually try to murder him with an ice axe just to shut him up.

So, I want your opinions, thinking of all the major characters, choose one and decide how many hours of listening to his neurotic analysis of sidewalk and stones it would take before they'd try to smother him with a pillow or pull his vocal cords out.

I'll start with one of my favorites, Albertine. My guess is twenty hours of listening to Marcel ramble about his fears of roving gangs of lesbians before she shoves him down a staircase.


r/Proust • • Dec 26 '25

I still don’t understand why Marcel is so consistently obsessed with the Oriane de Guermantes.

10 Upvotes

His true affection is already shifting toward Albertine (and if interpreted through a lens of homosexuality, what then does the obsession with the Duchesse signify?). Why is this the case? Moreover, there is a clear age gap—it's a relationship between an elder and a peer.


r/Proust • • Nov 23 '23

When to start?

5 Upvotes

(Please forgive my formal language; I very much enjoy writing like this whenever I get the chance)

Greetings

On a multitude of occasions, I have felt overwhelmed with a sudden compulsion to commence the exceedingly revered writings of the great Marcel Proust. Already a year ago, when I was a mere seventeen-year-old gent, I felt this incessant will—indeed very much in a Schopenhauerian sense!—to initiate what would undoubtedly become a new chapter in my life through the reading of Swan’s Way, to be followed by the subsequent volumes. To my dissatisfaction, I have often felt plagued by quasi-diabolical doubts regarding my current age; I fear my measly age should inhibit my enjoyment of this epic tome—for any other term would surely detract from its sheer brilliance. In this last fortnight, however, I have felt inordinately inspired to neglect these hateful doubts and to finally commence this immense journey. My reading plan would be as follows: each and every morning—for I shall not allow for inconsistencies!—I shall set out to read a mere few pages, so as to let these words of literary prowess sink in deeply. As such, my reading shall be elongated over an expected one to two years, which methinks should be apt for this masterpiece. Do please let me know your thoughts concerning my aforementioned feelings; I highly value the meaning of experts like you!


r/Proust • • Sep 25 '26

Which one of your life's deepest questions has been explored by Proust?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Images are AI-generated (NK).

Next week I'm gonna launch the fourth season of my Proustian hangouts at a cafe. This time, heavily AI-assisted. Instead of following Proust’s footsteps and being limited to the perspective presented at each point in the story, I’m gonna discuss some of the novel’s deepest questions from different angles, side by side. AI is gonna help me find the scenes and quotes relevant to each question.

You can see the twelve questions I picked for this event below:

- The Fate of Desire

Does having what we want kill the wanting?

- The Dilemma of Habit

Habit protects us, and deadens us. Which one do you prefer?

- The Desire to Know the Beloved

Would you want the whole truth about the person you love?

- Knowing the Beloved

Can we really know the people we love?

- Fighting Impermanence

Does wanting somebody not to change count as loving them?

- Good and Cruel

Are there good people and bad people?

- Redemption

Can a cruelty be repaired by a service the victim never lives to see?

- The Impermanence of the Self

Has time changed who you are?

- The Real

Which part of your life do you consider real?

- Lost Time

Have you wasted your life?

- Remembering the Beloved

Do you prefer to forget or remember your beloved?

- Time Regained

Is the past lost, or preserved?

# What important question do you think is missing?


r/Proust • • 16d ago

Where to start La Recherche?

1 Upvotes

Dear all,

I guess this has been asked many times here, but I’m seeking advice.

Where would you advise a newcomer to start “La recherche”? The size of this work is overwhelming and it’s difficult to really see an entry point?

Any hints? Any suggestions to get the taste of it and then move on independently?

Thanks.


r/Proust • • Aug 02 '24

Do you enjoy reading In Search of Lost Time while chemically elevated?

12 Upvotes

We talkin drunk or high. On the one hand, it would make the beautiful prose even more oneiric. On the other hand, I frequently get lost in the sentence structure while sober and those substances are not known for their memory enhancing properties.


r/Proust • • Jul 14 '26

Video lecture: How to Read Marcel Proust's In Search of Lost Time

Thumbnail
youtu.be
43 Upvotes

r/Proust • • Aug 30 '26

Albertine, Albertine, Albertine...

28 Upvotes

I am wondering for those that have enjoyed Volume 5 and Volume 6, what did you like about it? They are by far the worst volumes of the entire series. I know Time Regained is very good but unfortunately I have been stuck on The Captive and The Fugitive for over two months.

It's a painful read. He just goes on and on, incessantly, about Albertine. She's dead. Get over it.

So, tell me, what am I missing?

Edit: I am genuinely surprised that I managed to get some upvotes for this post. So perhaps it's not just me who feels this way about this segment...


r/Proust • • Nov 12 '25

Anyone reading 'In Search of Lost Time' wonders which volume is best, so here's a ranking of all seven, from most enjoyable to least. Or do you disagree?

Thumbnail
frenchlitforall.medium.com
10 Upvotes

r/Proust • • Oct 11 '24

Proust and his habit of dropping the biggest bombs en passant

7 Upvotes

If there is something that irtitates me about the Recherche is how so many important things are mentioned in passing or even subordinate clauses, like characters dying or Msr. de Charlus molesting a nine year old boy. Saniette being bullied by Monsieur Verdurin so much that He has a stroke resulting in His death afterwards left me devastated and it was mentioned in a footnote!

But then, Proust seemed to be self aware of this If you think of the Duchess of Guermantes' reaction when Swann laconically tells her that He is terminally ill and she is absolutely distraught and irritated by her husband skimming over it as If it's nothing. She is a kindred Spirit for the Reader in that moment but it only happens once in the entire novel.


r/Proust • • Sep 07 '25

Who do you think had the biggest dick in ISOLT?

47 Upvotes

My friend and I agreed it must be Morel. None of the other characters really exhibit BDE—Marcel in particular as well as Charlus come across as probably on the smaller side. But Morel's upward mobility is best explained by the hypothesis that he was packing serious heat.

Saint-Loup seems much too eager to attain a reputation and stature in the military to be already well endowed where it counts, and his interest in Morel suggests that he is a size queen rather than a Chad.

Finally, it is difficult to imagine that Charles Swann would have had so much difficulty in snagging Odette if he had been even slightly bien-membré!

Thoughts?


r/Proust • • Mar 20 '26

This is AI.

0 Upvotes

It’s a bit ironic how quickly people jump to “this is AI” whenever something is well-phrased. Using AI isn’t inherently a bad thing,it depends on how it’s used. If someone hasn’t engaged with the book, they can’t meaningfully prompt or contribute anyway. What matters more is whether the ideas are actually understood and reflected on, not just whether a tool was involved in shaping the words.


r/Proust • • Nov 17 '24

The Climax of In Search of Lost Time

5 Upvotes

Finished ISOLT after 16 months. I found the climaxof Gilberte presenting (procuring) her 16 year old daughter for Marcel hilarious and creepy. I know this is a somewhat uncharitable reading, but come on, Marcel (around 40 at this point) tells Gilberte he wants to only hang out with 'young girls in flower,' to shower them with presents and get a chaste kiss from them in return. Pretty weird lol.

Reading the whole thing was a wonderful life experience of course


r/Proust • • Nov 21 '25

For someone as obsessed by money & fortune as Proust was...

13 Upvotes

...there is something to be said about his vile omission of Celeste from any arrangement to guarantee her a minimal revenue after his death

He waited till he was literally dying to repeat "quel malheur quel malheur " of this whole situation, or if a check he writes while dying would be honored?

Celeste ! Celeste who gave him her youth, her life!

What a flaming douchebag


r/Proust • • Mar 05 '26

[Original] Damien Kim – Madeleine [Dream Pop | Korean Indie | Official Video] / Proust Effect

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Proust • • Aug 01 '26

Restarting a Proust club after 30 sessions—now I’m terrified I’ve promised something too ambitious

21 Upvotes

For seven months I facilitated a weekly Proust club in a café. In roughly 30 sessions we discussed only the first half of Swann’s Way.

It is hard to call it a traditional book club, because I was the only person who had read the assigned section. I’m a cognitive scientist, so my approach was to identify the central theme of each section and explore it through a scientific lens. After that, I would pose a question and invite everyone to share their own views, memories, or experiences.

When we reached “Swann in Love”, I was excited because I thought the narrative would encourage more people to read along. It didn’t. The format stayed essentially the same. Eventually I became busy with other projects, stopped preparing a literature review each week, and simply read and explained Proust. Attendance dropped to three people for several weeks in a row, and I felt that was probably the right moment to stop.

The café owner, however, is a devoted Proust admirer. She wants her café to be associated with him and genuinely does not mind if only a few people attend. She recently asked me to restart the club and even offered to become a co-host.

When she asked what I would like to do differently, I realized that after about thirty sessions I had already said most of what I could say section by section. I asked for time to think. During that reflection, with the help of AI, an idea emerged: instead of expanding each passage through science, I could choose a major theme—still not sure what—and discuss how it develops across the whole novel. The conversations might become more philosophical than psychological. The café owner loved it. We are now thinking of advertising the series as “A Dialogue with Proust About Life.”

Very soon I realize how enormous this project is. To trace and integrate the major themes across In Search of Lost Time feels like an immense intellectual undertaking. Part of me worries that I have promised something far beyond my abilities.

So I’d love advice from people who know Proust well:

  • Would you go ahead with this plan?

  • If so, how would you structure it without turning it into a lifetime research project?

  • And if you think this is too ambitious, what alternative format would you propose?

TL;DR: I facilitated a weekly Proust discussion group for seven months, mostly without participants actually reading the book. The café owner wants me to restart it, this time as a broader philosophical “dialogue with Proust about life.” I’m excited by the idea, but now I’m overwhelmed by how ambitious it is. Should I continue, or change direction entirely?


r/Proust • • Nov 12 '25

WHOA! Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Getting through The Fugitive, what a tragedy about Albertine, and what revelations after!

(Edit: Not) Marcel hears it from Andree that Albertine was something of a Ghislaine Maxwell to Morel's (!) Jeffrey Epstein

Because apophenia is awesome I realize I read the above within minutes of seeing the recent news about the Epstein emails... The plot sickens.


r/Proust • • Jan 05 '26

I'm hesitant about whether to continue with Volume Five.

8 Upvotes

Happy New Year every Proust fans, I just finished Volume Four. At the end of Volume Four, one of the protagonist's ultimate controlling tendencies was revealed—using marriage to disrupt Albertine's same-sex social activities (the factor that causes the protagonist anxiety and suffering).

If this were how he treated his first love Gilberte, it would simply be resignation and departure, but this more extreme action makes me uneasy just from reading the titles of Volumes Five and Six. I may have recognized part of myself in him, but I also hope I'm not the kind of person who would take such actions. I feel a sense of "immersion breaking." How should I deal with this discomfort?


r/Proust • • Jun 08 '26

Swann's Way Week 4. He gets his mom to read to him

13 Upvotes

A Reader’s Personal Guide to Swann’s Way

4.

From: In this particular instance, the article of her code which made it highly improbable that—barring an outbreak of fire—Françoise would go down and disturb Mamma

To: … albeit the coming event was in no way dependent upon the exercise of my will, and seemed not quite inevitable only because it was still separated from me by this short interval.

*

When I think of “Proustian” in terms of style, I think of sinuous sentences overflowing with figurative language: metaphor, simile, hyperbole, personification, paradox, metonymy, synecdoche, and more. When I think of “Proustian” in terms of theme, I think about memory, grief, obsession, art, love, class, and the tension between expectations and reality. In my rereading of Swann’s Way, I find the style and themes present from the get-go. Within the first 50 pages, you can see the structure and ideas that will flourish across the remaining thousands.

A typical passage, which is no less striking for being typical, comes this week when he describes the outdoor, nighttime landscape:

Things outside seemed also fixed in mute expectation, so as not to disturb the moonlight which, duplicating each of them and throwing it back by the extension, forwards, of a shadow denser and more concrete than its substance, had made the whole landscape seem at once thinner and longer, like a map which, after being folded up, is spread out upon the ground.

He personifies the landscape, “mute expectation,” presents a subtle paradox, “a shadow denser and more concrete than its substance,” which ties in with the idea that projections can be more potent than their source, and ends with a simile of remarkable specificity and detail, “like a map which, after being folded up, is spread out upon the ground.” This all works in concert with the narrator’s own emotions, as he’s silently waiting for his mother, so the landscape’s mood is a projection of his interiority, just as the shadows are projections of the objects, another Proust hallmark.

Last week’s reading left off with the narrator sent to bed. He wants his mom to join him. He needs to connect with her in some way, so he asks the maid, Francoise, to deliver a note, claiming his mom demanded he send it, but Francoise can see through the lie. (Here he makes an observation that rings of the “noble savage” stereotype, saying that “like those primitive men whose senses were so much keener than our own, she could immediately detect, by signs imperceptible by the rest of us, the truth or falsehood of anything that we might wish to conceal from her.”) He’s in agony, but the writing of the note and the belief that his mom will read it soothes him:

for that forbidden and unfriendly dining-room, where but a moment ago the ice itself—with burned nuts in it—and the finger-bowls seemed to me to be concealing pleasures that were mischievous and of a mortal sadness because Mamma was tasting of them and I was far away, had opened its doors to me and, like a ripe fruit which bursts through its skin, was going to pour out into my intoxicated heart the gushing sweetness of Mamma's attention while she was reading what I had written. Now I was no longer separated from her; the barriers were down; an exquisite thread was binding us. Besides, that was not all, for surely Mamma would come.

The style again comes through. The simile “like a ripe fruit” and the hyperbole “my intoxicated heart” pair with his obsession for his mother. The power the writing gives him to insert himself into her dinner, of joining her psychically if not physically, lets him bear the separation. The agony he feels for her will find echoes in romantic loves, and the narrator makes this plain already when he compares his waiting for an answer from his mom to a man waiting for an answer from a lover after sending a message through a third party.

He waits anxiously and listens as the dinner winds down and the family talks of Swann’s change and pity him for his “wretched wife” who’s involved with Monsieur de Charlus (one of Proust’s greatest creations who will have a spotlight in later volumes). When the narrator’s mom climbs the stairs, the narrator pounces on her, knowing that his father is close behind and that the fear of a scene might cause her to step into the room with the narrator, aware that he is using his father’s approach as “means of blackmail,” which fails because the father arrives before the boy can hide. But the narrator is surprised to find that his father tells her to go with him, because the father isn’t so rigid and maybe because he doesn’t love the narrator as much as the mother and grandmother do, because “they loved me enough to be unwilling to spare me that suffering, which they hoped to teach me to overcome, so as to reduce my nervous sensibility and to strengthen my will. As for my father, whose affection for me was of another kind, I doubt if he would have shewn so much courage, for as soon as he had grasped the fact that I was unhappy he had said to my mother: ‘Go and comfort him.’”

Amidst all this, we get a glimpse of time’s tragic passing:

Many years have passed since that night. The wall of the staircase, up which I had watched the light of his candle gradually climb, was long ago demolished. And in myself, too, many things have perished which, I imagined, would last for ever, and new structures have arisen, giving birth to new sorrows and new joys which in those days I could not have foreseen, just as now the old are difficult of comprehension. It is a long time, too, since my father has been able to tell Mamma to "Go with the child." Never again will such hours be possible for me. But of late I have been increasingly able to catch, if I listen attentively, the sound of the sobs which I had the strength to control in my father's presence, and which broke out only when I found myself alone with Mamma. Actually, their echo has never ceased: it is only because life is now growing more and more quiet round about me that I hear them afresh, like those convent bells which are so effectively drowned during the day by the noises of the streets that one would suppose them to have been stopped for ever, until they sound out again through the silent evening air.

Swiftly and briefly, the narrative opens to the future, we’re reminded that what we’ve been reading is in a distant past, and the child’s pain of missing his Mamma for the short dinner gives way to the adult’s grief for the extended separation that has come in adulthood, grief at the fact that while he can hear the echoes he can never return to their source. And the abstract loss of a moment, which we often might not feel because it happens all around and all the time, is replicated and embodied by the demolition of the staircase wall.

In the past, though, in the narrator’s childhood, he’s momentarily happy. He gets to possess his mother for an instant. She’ll read to him. There’s a fun drama to choosing the right books. His grandma has gifted him George Sand novels because she refuses to get him anything poorly written. His agony is soothed, but in the midst of this victory, he reminds himself that this night can’t be repeated, that his desire runs counter to “general requirements” and that the following night he would again be a “victim of anguish.” Time’s passing and its destruction of static bliss haunts him even when he’s a child. He sees his future self suffering; his future self remembers this past and finds little solace. Scenes echo through the grief.

 


r/Proust • • Aug 28 '17

How true is the rat/pin fetish claim?

0 Upvotes

For those aware of this claim, how true is it? It seems insane