r/ProtonPass • • Aug 29 '25

Discussion Proton Aliases seem to increasingly get blocked by Major Services

0 Upvotes

I got a Proton Pass plus plan and have been considering moving over to using aliases via SimpleLogin. However, doing some research via ChatGPT, I found that proton aliases frequently get blocked. Examples include DeepSeek, Adobe, Github, Etsy, Atlassian, LinkedIn, Trello. I assume more services will ban aliases in the future.

So, to get aliases to work there's really two choices:

- Use icloud aliases (icloud aliases are indistinguishable from icloud addresses)
- Buy a custom domain and pair it with SimpleLogin (companies can't reliably know if they're businesses or email forwarding service just from the domain)

Is this the right way to think about aliaseses? I'm now thinking to just use two emails--one private email to be used with services and a public one to hand over to people and for official purposes.


r/ProtonPass • • Jun 21 '25

Discussion NEW 16 Billion Passwords Leaked

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am a proton pass paid member, Id like to ask if the proton monitor actually search for up-to-date leaks? I checked mine now using the built in proton monitor and it shows none. Is this accurate? like does it already includes the recent leaks?

I am trying to save time since I got too many accounts especially in google haha. and changing all of them are kinda bit of work to do.

thank you.


r/ProtonPass • • Jul 22 '24

Feature request Unlimited TOTP access for FREE accounts?

0 Upvotes

Is it possible to provide access to TOTP feature for free accounts ?

Because Proton pass storage needs are negligible, so as a security & privacy focused firm, Proton should encourage their community to use TOTP for as many account as possible to stay secure.

Every competitor at this Password Management market doesn't offer TOTP access for their FREE tier service. If Proton takes this initiative it's gonna be huge step, more people will be attracted towards Proton Pass.

https://protonmail.uservoice.com/forums/953584-proton-pass/suggestions/48663557-unrestricted-totp-access-for-free-plan


r/ProtonPass • • Dec 28 '23

Discussion Crazy EXPENSIVE!

0 Upvotes

I have the $1 plan but I need to get three more accounts for the family. This will end up being a Proton Pass only family account for $156 per year (after seasonal discounts). 1Password is $60 per year. What justifies the $100 difference? Am I getting this wrong?


r/ProtonPass • • Mar 08 '24

Discussion Bitwarden messed up someone's vault

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/ProtonPass • • Apr 27 '25

Mobile Help I have a problem, I put A2F in my Mail account, the same email as for all Proton services, but when I log in to the Pass it asks me for the A2F, but how am I going to put the code in if it's in the Pass?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Is this normal? I added A2F to my ProtonMail on Pass, but when I log in to Pass it asks me for the A2F code.

If I have not logged into Pass on any device, it will be impossible to access the Pass app.

This is kind of strange, I don't know if it's a bug or what. But it doesn't ask me for the A2F code on the web, only on the cell phone app.

So I went to the web and got the A2F code and put it in the app to log in, otherwise I would be in serious trouble.


r/ProtonPass • • Aug 19 '25

Discussion Proton Pass flaw: one password to rule them all?

0 Upvotes

I just bought Proton Pass and honestly, there’s one thing that feels like a huge downside: I have to log in with my Proton account. Which basically means one password (that I can actually remember) is now the master key to Mail, Drive, VPN, and Pass.

That feels risky as hell. One single point of failure for everything Proton-related. Sure, I can set up 2FA, but it still bothers me.

What I like about Bitwarden is the independence. My vault login is completely separate from any email provider or other service. Proton, on the other hand, kind of locks me into their whole ecosystem with one single key.

Maybe that’s “convenience” for some, but to me it feels like unnecessary lock-in and added risk.

Anyone else think Proton Pass is shooting itself in the foot with this?


r/ProtonPass • • Nov 10 '25

Feature request Ad in paid product

0 Upvotes

I pay money for my Proton Pass service. Would be fantastic if I wouldn't have to close an intrusive ad each time I need to access the desktop app. I'm surprised to see enshittification slowly happen here.


r/ProtonPass • • Oct 16 '24

Discussion Weak? Really?

0 Upvotes

I took out a subcription to ProtonPass a few weeks ago and imported my existing from Bitwarden. I've been fairly happy with ProtonPass so far—the ability to have generated 2FA codes and passwords in the same app is really nice.

However, one thing irks me is that every password in my imported archive has been marked as "Weak" by ProtonPass—presumably it does this with any password that was not generaated by ProtonPass itself. I find this a bit annoying as now I have no idea which of my imported passwords may actually need strengthening.

The vast majority are 13+ char random alphanumeric strings generated by Bitwarden, so are in no way "weak" at all. But there may be a few old passwords in my archive from the days when the intarwebs was young, which may be pretty weak or may have been re-used on more than one site. Unfortunately I have no way now of spotting these, since ProtonPass has decided any password "Not Invented Here" should be marked as weak.


r/ProtonPass • • Apr 02 '25

Discussion Proton Pass is not as convincing as it sounds!

14 Upvotes

I am in the middle of password manager transition from Dashlane. It is expiring in May25. So, I decided to look for alternatives.

Nord Pass - clear No, as it does not have 2FA integrated heck it's too challenging. ProtonPass - Bought the 1 mon plan for $4.99, to so see how effective it is. The free plan doesn't offer unlimited 2FA and limited alias support; bought 1Password as well.

What I found after 1-2 weeks of usage

  1. This does NOT work while you are offline. You can not create, amend any item. BIG disadvantage; as people who have password manager, like to organize things. Isn't it this obvious?

  2. It has very good password strength security; but it's also dumb.. because test1test2test3test4test5uuuu will be called as vulnerable password; so as 15 character password with mix of special chars, alphanumeric - My own work password is vulnerable. Funny thing.

    1. Due to it's password policy, I have 25% of passwords as weak, out of 500 items. Go figure.

    2. I liked the quick movement of items between the vaults, but missing the tag options - I am going to assume this as same.

  3. I liked the secure link - button - which will show you if you have shared anything. Like currently active links.

  4. Pathetic support so far. I raised a bug on May 26, I only got 3rd response today. I have emailed them 4 times and I am getting dumb responses.

  5. Passkey support is there, but it won't tell you which website supports the passkey. You have to figure out yourself.

  6. Dark web monitoring - Other than that you are vulnerable - It won't tell you anything. .Marking resolved is just self-soothe button that you don't care about them or have already fixed yourself.

  7. Two password thing and PP tried up with proton account is - I am not sure good or bad things - still digesting.

1Password on the other hand -

  1. It's autofill capability, the overall UI and everything is so neat - excellent thing.

    1. Setting up 2FA is blazing fast when you are on setup page; don't have to open the mobile app. It's really good.

  2. It quite often says, it's offline or disconnected - for a brief 2-3 seconds .. like 2-3 times everytime you are on computer. Little irritating sometimes.

  3. Password strength is dumber - mostly based on length.. so PP is good in this context.

  4. Support is good, I was able to resolve on of the migration issue with 1P team, while PP is still hanging. They are very responsive.

  5. Watch tower is good, from the perspective of missing 2FA, Passkeys, Weak Password, Expiring items. I am not getting good info on compromised website (even though, I know its a long list - the case is open with 1P).

  6. Secure sharing is an option, not as extensive as PP.

  7. When you have edit or add a new thing on your own, it is not as fast. It takes 4-5 seconds to open another windows, a bit turn off here.

I am leaning towards 1P, still have to discuss or listen it otherwise. Anyone who recently migrated to either one can comment or share their thoughts.


r/ProtonPass • • Apr 15 '25

Solved Poll: Should Proton Pass have a separate password?

4 Upvotes

Proton and its CEO repeatedly confirmed that they do not intend to introduce a separate password to Proton Pass.

It is a view of many that the introduced extra password to Proton Pass simply doesn’t make the cut and is not what was requested.

The PURPOSE of this poll is simply to deliver the opinion of users to Proton on the necessity to introduce a separate password OPTION for Proton Pass.

So, do you agree that Proton Pass should have a separate password?

367 votes, Apr 18 '25
229 Yes
138 No

r/ProtonPass • • Sep 20 '24

Feature request A rant on Protonpass

10 Upvotes

What's wrong with ProtonPass

Compared to Bitwarden

Doesn't have copy / paste as an option

When I log in to a website with Bitwarden I can press CTRL-SHIFT-L and my password is copied into the relevant fields.

If there's a TOTP record Bitwarden copies that into the clipboard so you can press CTRL-V and you're in.


It doesn't understand sub-domains.

If I go to https://lemmy.sdf.org and click the username field I am presented with four possible options.

social.sdf.org
lemmy.sdf.org
mastodon.sdf.org
pixelfed.sdf.org

Each of these has its own record in ProtonPass, why can't it tell the difference.


SimpleLogin Integration

If I use ProtonPass to create a new email address it's added to my SimpleLogin account and ProtonPass creates a new "alias" record in my vault. Why?

If I delete the extra record, which I didn't want anyway, ProtonPass disables the email address it just created so I have to go to the SimpleLogin page and re-enable it.

While I'm there I can edit the record and remove the unhelpful "Created through Proton" and enter the web site name.


Thank you for reading, I'll see myself out.


r/ProtonPass • • Apr 04 '24

Discussion Please don't make desktop apps PWA like Microsoft did with teams for linux.

5 Upvotes

ProtonPass, is the only actually good password manager on the market right now that dosen't cost any money (Kaspersky Password Manager moment) and has an actually usable and a good design (KeePass Moment). But the fact that it's a PWA ruins it, because PWAs are very laggy, unresponsive and usually require internet connection, I really hope there will be native app support for Linux, Windows and Mac, because native apps "just work" while in PWA you can as an example select text in the app that should be unselectable. (Please no downvotes I already have a really low karma :cry: )


r/ProtonPass • • 13d ago

Discussion Why can't Proton fix the bugs?

6 Upvotes

I've been a Proton Pass user since it came out (and a user of the wider ecosystem since 2018), and since quite early on logged a bug about how Proton Pass handles forms with more than just a basic user/password (specifically phpMyAdmin logins) - https://protonmail.uservoice.com/forums/953584-proton-pass-authenticator/suggestions/47281619-custom-field-autofill-support

It's been "on the roadmap" and "coming soon" for ages. My Proton Pass even has the custom fields needed to set it up.

Given the latest CEO/CTO toxicity I had a look at a couple of Proton Pass alternatives. First one I tried, I imported my Proton Pass vault, went to the phpMyAdmin page that I use every day and ... fields correctly filled. Using the data already in Proton Pass, no manual hand-holding.

When Proton Ag fail to fix such fundamental issues in a core product it makes me wonder why on earth I continue to pay for their product. At the end of the day, the buck stops with the C-Suite as they're the ones setting priorities and direction, and have been long before the current AI furore, so I don't think anything is going to change.


r/ProtonPass • • Dec 19 '23

Discussion Password confusion

0 Upvotes

I’m a bit confused. To be brief, how does the password system actually work?

For example, I tested the PP service with an old social media account using it’s original username and password. I then went into the PP extension and changed the account’s password in the manager. I did a 50 character alpha-numerical password. However, when I tired logging in with this new info, I received an “incorrect credentials” error. I then logged in using the old credentials I thought I changed.

So, how does PP work actually? Is it that it simply encrypts my password against potential hackers? Or is it possible to change passwords from within the extension and I’m just having trouble?

Said another way: I changed an account password in proton pass, but it didn’t update and can’t be used with the login credentials. Why is this?


r/ProtonPass • • Nov 09 '24

Feature request Add 3rd party email alias integrations

0 Upvotes

They don’t have to be as complex and deep as the SimpleLogin integration

Something like what Bitwarden does would suffice

Just add an option to generate email aliases using 3rd party services like addy.io in the generator

+ Proton this doesn’t have to weaken your marketing because someone would have to find another service first and then add the API key etc

So your SL aliases would still be preferable if someone has a paid plan

It could potentially strengthen your marketing by allowing your users more freedom and not being locked in


r/ProtonPass • • Feb 08 '26

Account help In-App Authenticator Shows "Future" Codes instead of Current Working Codes

1 Upvotes

Ever since last week, the in-app authenticator in ProtonPass is suggesting codes that are technically valid, but they will only work if you wait until they expire, which indicate that the app is suggesting "future" codes, codes that are not valid in the present, but will be valid after 1 minute. I can see this as a fatal security flaw and it needs to be fixed immediately.

Here's the comparison between the code shown on Ente Auth, and what Proton Pass is showing. Censored the 3 other numbers for obvious reasons but you can see it there that Proton Pass is suggesting codes that are not yet valid, as in future codes, while Ente shows the right valid code and the next code that will be valid.


r/ProtonPass • • Oct 20 '24

Extension Help Proton Pass doesn't work on Firefox

0 Upvotes

Proton Pass works on Chrome and Brave, but it doesn't work on Firefox and Firefox based browsers.

I tried a VPN and it worked on Firefox.

Is it because network settings in Firefox?

Created a new fresh profile with just the proton pass extension, but nothing changed.


r/ProtonPass • • Aug 14 '26

Extension Help How To Delete Brave Browser Data Except Proton Login

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm trying out Brave and was wondering if I can delete everything except the Proton Pass Login. I want to clean up most site data but remain logged in to Proton Pass. Anyone have any experience with this?

I imagine deleting the Cookies and other site data will probably blow away Proton, but I thought I would ask.


r/ProtonPass • • Apr 25 '23

Feature request List of features I want to see for Proton Pass

0 Upvotes

There are three thing I would see in addition to Proton Pass from the user that request these features. Since I work for government, and I take my security very highly.

*** First one from 1Password is the able to create firewall rules:

  • Select Country or Continent and start typing to find the one you want.

  • Select IP Address and enter an IP address or CIDR range.

  • Or select Anonymous IP and remove the types that you don’t want to filter.

Anonymous IP detection is based on information from the MaxMind database . There are four types of anonymous IPs:

  • Tor: IP addresses where Tor traffic appears to come from.

  • Public VPNs: IP addresses registered to VPN services which hide someone’s true IP address.

  • Public Proxies: Proxies that are available for free and publicly posted.

  • Cloud Providers: IP addresses associated with hosting services that can be used as anonymizers.

*** Second one from Keeper Security is the able to login with YubiKey

*** Third a desktop application for window/Linux/mac

*** Plus, these addition feature down below:

Usability

  • Full-featured Desktop Apps

    • including a fully functional offline/airplane mode

  • Full-featured in-browser web UI (not extension)

  • In-browser Auto-complete for things like Credit Cards and Addresses

  • Tagging, Grouping, or Favorites

  • Enhancements to the Trash bin

    • Need the ability to ensure that items moved to the trash can only be expired or deleted only after providing a separate passcode.

  • Archive functionality for old items that will likely no longer be used but you don't want to delete

  • Private and public sharing links for individual items and Vaults

  • More granular history per item instead of a general log

  • Undo and Redo functionality

  • Open the website and autofill from the extension with one click

  • Scan and store QR codes natively for MFA

  • Ability to Duplicate items

    • copying between vaults is essential, especially when we can share vaults/items

Sharing

  • Shared Vaults

    • sharing with family or friends that have Proton Pass

  • Shared Items

    • same as above, but also expiring and single-use links to items

  • Role Based Access

    • the ability to lock down vaults and items with permissions that pertain to those with proton accounts.

Support for the following Items

  • Credit Cards

  • API Credentials

  • Crypto Wallets

  • Identification Cards (E.g. Driver's License)

  • Passports

  • SSH Keys

  • Bank Account Information

  • General Associated Documents (linked from proton drive?)

  • Social Security Numbers

  • Medical Records

  • Generic Licenses

  • Software Licenses

  • Rewards/Loyalty/Membership Programs

  • General Inventory Lists

  • Probably more.


r/ProtonPass • • Jun 19 '25

Discussion Change imp. passwords NOW !

0 Upvotes

16b login credentials leaked .


r/ProtonPass • • Jan 22 '25

Discussion What is the point of Proton Pass Mac App?

0 Upvotes

I used to use 1Password and there have been so many instances where the Mac App has useful features. However I just don't see the point of Proton Pass.

It's just a Mac App with bigger window - same as extension.

Curious to know how it different from browser extension


r/ProtonPass • • Sep 04 '23

Discussion Proton Pass is so bad....

25 Upvotes

Wow. I always used Bitwarden, and since Proton Pass is out now, I gave it a try. Created a test account on a site, without email because that service doesn't have that - and after creating my account with a proton-given password, that was it. It didn't save, nor did it give me a prompt to save. So I made an account I'm immediately unable to access. I tried this on 3 different sites, and every time I got no save pop up or anything. It's very much enabled in the settings.

I don't know how you're supposed to use a password manager like this.

This just seems absolutely half-assed and bad, especially given that I can't even find a proper webinterface, it's all done through the tiny extension window. Great idea, absolutely atrocious execution.


r/ProtonPass • • Jul 24 '24

Announcement Everything you need to know about Proton Wallet

Thumbnail
self.protonwallet
1 Upvotes