I just got done watching some of season 17 on Netflix. I've noticed there's still an element of "cut throat" that feels very off-putting. I am glad there is less drama and bickering, but I still can't help but feel really sorry for some of these designers. At the end of the day many of them are struggling artists. They wave $250,000 that's donated by an extremely wealthy corporation, wave it in front of desperate designers' faces, then beat them down. This isn't merchandising college or an internship. Their opinions don't actually sell; 99% of all contestants aren't getting anything out of the competition.
They slave way, blood sweat and tears only to have their work torn into. I've watched it for many, many years and I'm just at a point now where I question why they feel it's appropriate to demonize contestants and professionally demolish them. Nadine, for example, was scolded as if she was a spoiled narcissistic child ... For calling her model curvy. Yes, she squirmed into an excuse because the pressure was on, but she didn't call her model overweight nor did she attempt to blame her.
Yet the judges reemed her and wouldn't let off that "she insulted her model, blamed her, and essentially called her fat". That's not what happened. Does ANYONE in their right mind actually believe this grown woman who's lived a life, paid her own bills, built her own skill-sets and crafts ... Decided to "worm her way onto Project Runway" to abuse the models and call them fat?
And yet this is absolutely the narrative the judges ran with. They smeared her. They destroy reputations, and self-esteem.
It's not right. Entering a competition out of desperation in an extremely tough society as an artist where paying bills and getting seen is very difficult — should not be grounds for privileged wealthy folk to destroy your reputation, self-esteem, to put you down and demonize you.
Nobody even asked if she was calling her model overweight; they simply insisted she did, and insisted she was attacking her model. That's the story they wanted, so that's the story they went with. It's beyond insane. You don't do that to another human-being, let alone a full grown professional adult. You aren't her therapist, the police arresting her for a crime.
And the judges' choices are sometimes questionable. The fact that some of them have capitalist success is not an excuse to ruin someone's life.
It's traumatic, and people will walk away with a very hostile and negative opinion of Nadine. What was her crime? She needed money, and she's an artist ... The show needed adults to manipulate like some form of hunger-games for entertainment, where some artists are glorified and treated like saints while many are torn down and demonized for no reason. For every person they help, they destroy many others. It's insane.
I don't think I can keep watching. I walked away for a while after some insane stuff Tim Gunn and Heidi Klum were doing to, and saying about contestants. I gave it another chance with the new hosts and wow I don't find it amusing. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.