r/ProgrammerHumor • • Jun 01 '23

Meme HTML is not a programming language

Post image
9.1k Upvotes

500 comments sorted by

1.4k

u/Isteppedinpoopy Jun 01 '23

Electric circuits are the original programming language

454

u/trollsmurf Jun 01 '23

Water and mechanics before that.

Of note: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Difference_engine

306

u/Away_Kaleidoscope_96 Jun 01 '23

don’t forget about red stone before that

138

u/Dmayak Jun 01 '23

Everything is just different atom patterns, we're programming in particles.

44

u/Stealth_Paladin Jun 01 '23

waveforms are just a collation of signals, which are just topological bumps and wiggles

10

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Quantum Programming

→ More replies (9)

13

u/AngelLeliel Jun 01 '23

RNA, the OG programming language.

17

u/Usling123 Jun 01 '23

Ah, to be back in the coal mines, stumbling into redstone. The good ol' days

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

People are so fucking smart, it blows my mind

→ More replies (5)

34

u/classicalySarcastic Jun 01 '23

Verilog and VHDL have entered the chat

9

u/LavenderDay3544 Jun 01 '23

And SystemVerilog, SystemC, Lucid, Chisel, etc.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/LavenderDay3544 Jun 01 '23

Verilog approves.

10

u/Win_is_my_name Jun 01 '23

I was surprised to learn that the AND, OR and XOR operators were actually nothing just a specific arrangement of electronic components

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Win_is_my_name Jun 01 '23

So it's like a virtual breadboard?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SowTheSeeds Jun 01 '23

You mean circuits with semi-conductors?

Because a light switch does not execute any logic when you flip it.

→ More replies (7)

726

u/DontListenToMe33 Jun 01 '23

I just never understood why this is controversial.

First, I’m never going to correct someone that refers to html as a programming language, because I honestly don’t care and it doesn’t matter.

However, programming languages like C, JavaScript, Python, etc. are fundamentally different than languages like HTML, CSS, SQL, MarkDown, etc. Those have entirely different uses. So it’s kind of just not useful to group them all as “programming languages.”

272

u/Quito246 Jun 01 '23

I mean It is like ordering steak and getting pizza instead both are food, but different. Classification of languages exist for a purpose…

→ More replies (37)

50

u/SarahSplatz Jun 01 '23

It's just in the definition of the word. A "program" is a series of steps or instructions for a computer to follow. HTML isn't that, it's more akin to a blueprint.

26

u/Realinternetpoints Jun 01 '23

It’s right there in the name innit? Markup Language

→ More replies (9)

43

u/jjdmol Jun 01 '23

People mistake the markup annotations of an HTML document to be computer instructions, I suppose.

8

u/chronoflect Jun 01 '23

I mean, the annotations are instructions read by a computer to format the website. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

3

u/Intrexa Jun 02 '23

This is totally a definitions thing. I have fairly liberal definition of a programming language to be any language that can produce a set of instructions that can advance a finite state machine from a known state to an arbitrary state. Under my definition, HTML and SQL are definitely in.

"A computer" has a much more broad definition than most people realize. It's more than just a universal Turing machine. They're really good, and flexible, so, they do kind of dominate. A computer is a machine that computes things. That's it. Analogue computers have existed for thousands of years. I believe that since a combinational logic circuit can not have it's operations affected beyond the current inputs, it can't be programmed. A finite state machine is the lowest level of computer that can require a sequence of inputs to produce a specific output, which is why I believe that it is the most primitive computer that can qualify as being programmed.

"Program" has a lot of historical usage for setting a finite state machine to an arbitrary state. You can program a VCR. You can program a thermostat.

"Languages" have hierarchies for their grammar. If it's important that a language be Turing complete, we can specify that the language is a type-0 grammar on Chomskys hierarchy. Advancing a finite-state machine to a specific state requires a language with a type-3 grammar.

So like, HTML is a computer programming language. It's not powerful, it's not as flexible as C, but it's a programming language.

9

u/MattieShoes Jun 01 '23

HTML is a programming language. It is not a procedural programming language.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declarative_programming

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (27)

49

u/Demistr Jun 01 '23

SQL definitely is a programming language.

37

u/vonabarak Jun 01 '23

Very debatable. Some dialects (like PL/SQL) are programming languages or at least can be used as programming languages. But SQL in general isn't Turing-complete and isn't a programming language. It is query language.

81

u/maximal543 Jun 01 '23

Deba-table?

25

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

The most sane discussion member here

24

u/DannarHetoshi Jun 01 '23

"Drop Table mic"

18

u/TehBens Jun 01 '23

I don't see how not being turing complete stops something from being a programming language.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Some SQL implementations are turing complete, for example PostgreSQL

I would argue Turing-completeness doesn't define a programming language, although it is a part of it. So SQL is still not a programming language even in Postgres.

A more general definition is a language meant for writing programs, and neither HTML docs nor SQL queries are supposed to be programs, although they are interpreted by programs

20

u/TehBens Jun 01 '23

A more general definition is a language meant for writing programs

Yeah, that's it. It's so weird ppl refuse that simple truth. Talking about turing completeness sounds much more smart, however.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/BoBoBearDev Jun 01 '23

I am pretty sure SQL is turning complete. It is just ridiculous hard, like iterating a loop using recursion in SQL.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/theggman_ Jun 01 '23

it's a declarative programming language so it is, in fact, a programming language

→ More replies (7)

16

u/Darkstar197 Jun 01 '23

I love SQL to death, but it is a query & database management language. Not a programming language

17

u/evanldixon Jun 01 '23

Sql is indeed a programming language, but after seeing some stored procs with thousands of lines, I wonder if it really should be

12

u/mountaingator91 Jun 01 '23

It's almost like we already have a great naming scheme for programming, markup, styling, and query languages and the different languages in each category fit perfectly in the category they were literally designed to fit in. Why all the debate about reclassifying languages in categories that they were never designed to fit into

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/Acceptable-Tomato392 Jun 01 '23

It's because HTML is the first thing many people learn nowadays. And of course, it's the beginning of the journey, but certainly not the end.

And you can learn enough of it to display something on a Web browser within an hour. This made a lot of people go "Look! I'm programming!" pretty quickly.

Which makes people feel the need to correct them.

Otherwise, getting mad at HTML is like getting mad at a coat hanger.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

If you group sonething in programming languages and something not

Tell me, how you define "programming languages" ?

→ More replies (4)

15

u/xiipaoc Jun 01 '23

So it’s kind of just not useful to group them all as “programming languages.”

I disagree with that. While I think there's some merit to defining "programming" narrowly, all of these languages tell the computer what to do in some precise way, which is what programming is. HTML isn't very powerful on its own, sure, but it is a computer language, and that is kind of a big deal to someone who doesn't know any computer languages. Any distinction between HTML and, say, Python is kind of too esoteric for the computer-illiterate public.

I think we can be clearer with our categories if that's what we want to do. We can say that JS is a general-purpose programming language, while SQL is a database access programming language (because you can do actual programming in SQL beyond just queries), etc. And I'm happy to laugh at any schmuck who thinks writing HTML is programming, hah, what rubes! But eh, you know, it's not that wrong.

4

u/DontListenToMe33 Jun 01 '23

Obviously the big issue is that people use the term “programming language” to gatekeep or feel superior.

To me, it’s just a matter of usefulness. You could technically call English a “programming language” because you give English instructions to ChatGPT which then trans-piles it into something like Python. Right? But it would be utterly confusing if people actually started defining English as a programming language. Like, imagine you sign up for a coding bootcamp and they’re teaching you how to write ChatGPT prompts. 😂

And just saying “CSS is a styling language” is just kind of easier and less confusing than “CSS is a programming styling language.” Just my opinion.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

BUt mUh TUrInG COmPlETe lAnGUaGe

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

It just shows unfamiliarity with a topic in a context where often the mistaken person is trying to demonstrate competence.

Some people see this behavior as gatekeep-y, but I appreciate this behavior. If I'm making mistakes, please correct me.

4

u/ExcitingTabletop Jun 01 '23

It's kinda in the name. Hypertext MARKUP LANGUAGE. It's a markup language, not a programming language.

But yeah, if someone lists HTML under programming languages on a resume, I won't care. Hell I might even do that.

2

u/Stealth_Paladin Jun 01 '23

because I honestly don’t care and it doesn’t matter

You make references that suggest you've been around the block a bit -- but I can only imagine you are new to programming if you think how much something matters, matters.

I have had hour long conversations about what to name a single variable, on an easy day. We are not agreeable people haha

2

u/Saturnalliia Jun 01 '23

My car is an airplane and you can't convince me otherwise!

→ More replies (30)

175

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

I have a feeling a lot of people treat the term “programming language” as a vague synonym for “good”

59

u/Gabo7 Jun 01 '23

My dog is a programming language boy

10

u/EightBitMemory Jun 01 '23

I’m having a programming language day today!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Unfortunately, unless your dog is turing complete, he is not a programming language and therefore, no good 😔

14

u/meyerdutcht Jun 01 '23

s/good/imperative/

127

u/MarkusA380 Jun 01 '23

If HTML is a programming language, then by extension so is SVG.

Which makes Inkscape an IDE.

20

u/EvoStarSC Jun 01 '23

Holy Hell!
I have not heard of Inkscape in awhile.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Boom9001 Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

A list of commands that tells a computer what to do (draw in this case) why not be one. It's a very narrow use case but idc if you call it one. Not like programming languages or programmers are protected terms that knowing one qualifies you in all others or that one programming language must be able to do anything.

There's already a programming language called Piet (and others I'm sure) that takes images as its "code" so Inkscape was already an IDE for that programming language.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

[deleted]

23

u/Ash_Crow Jun 01 '23

It's both, you can directly edit the XML if you want.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Nothing wrong with being a markup language.

22

u/typescriptDev99 Jun 01 '23

HTML is a display template language.

20

u/zertech Jun 01 '23

Yup. MARKUP language. It's in the name!!

→ More replies (2)

101

u/Omnislash99999 Jun 01 '23

In my experience people that call HTML a programming language are generally new to coding and learning the basics. I don't see any reason to shoot it down, there are concepts learnt that will crossover.

40

u/meyerdutcht Jun 01 '23

I call it a programming language all the time, and I’ve been programming (never in html!) for 30 years.

59

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Yeah, because when you refer to it, it is strange to always say "markup"

Like, instead of say "This is programmed in JS, HTML and CSS" say "This is programmed in JS, markuped in HTML and styled in CSS" every time , sounds stupid

22

u/loegare Jun 01 '23

I usually say coded

13

u/eloel- Jun 01 '23

markuped

marked up?

29

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Yeah, my bad

It is because Eng is not programming language

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/dontshowmygf Jun 01 '23

Yep. If someone is excited to write in HTML and CSS I'm not going to make them feel bad about it, I'm going to hand them a bunch of HTML and CSS projects I don't want to write.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Yeah man, just don't be "Ackchyually HTML is a MARKUP language 🤓" guy

27

u/sim0of Jun 01 '23

Hyper text programming language

7

u/Anonymo2786 Jun 01 '23

HTPL . seems wierd

2

u/queen-adreena Jun 02 '23

Better that Simplified Hyper Interfacing Text Markup Language.

44

u/AnoKC12 Jun 01 '23

HTML is a Javascript framework providing its own DSL for manipulating the DOM🙂

6

u/phodas-c Jun 01 '23

A programming language is a system of notation for writing computer programs. Most programming languages are text-based formal languages, but they may also be graphical. They are a kind of computer language.

The description of a programming language is usually split into the two components of syntax (form) and semantics (meaning), which are usually defined by a formal language.

It has syntax and semantics... debatable.

3

u/Boom9001 Jun 02 '23

Markup languages are so obviously programming languages. Fairly basic and narrow in their use case but pretty simple to fit any definition.

It's not like people go out speaking them, they are languages written to get computer programs to perform certain actions. Those actions in this case are just a narrow use case to deal with formatting and marking up text. You could literally redo the syntax to be functionally the same but use the more typically programming style and they'd look exactly like other programming languages. They use the style they use however because for markup languages it's easier and more readable. Which is a good thing that it's approachable for beginners not a disqualification.

Python being easy to understand and often looking like just an English sentence doesn't make it less of a programming language.

2

u/AL1L Jun 01 '23

computer programs

Define that then

3

u/phodas-c Jun 02 '23

How print("Hello world") is different from <p>Hello world</p>?

Both do the same.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

15

u/MateusMoutinho11 Jun 01 '23

Let me explain:
I'm a C programmer (author of CwebStudio), and I tend to program in assembly sometimes. And in my opinion, there is no such thing as "true programming", anything beyond the infinite turing tape is an abstraction.
What differentiates is the level of abstraction you are at, from a programmer who moves registers in assembly, to a user who sends a message on facebook, everyone is "programming", programming is writing a sequence of steps that is interpreted by something, (whether un runtime in interpreted languages) or processor alu in compiled languages.
You can consider that html is not programming because "it is not possible to build an html interpreter inside html" (it is not turring complete), (this can be a point)
so assuming that nothing but binaries is programming, html is not programming, as well as python, javascript, C , c++ etc
but starting from the premise that everything is programming, then html is indeed a programming language

8

u/extopico Jun 01 '23

Well, then literally everything is programming. JSON? Plain text?

14

u/samspot Jun 01 '23

I’m confused. I always program in plain text. How do you do it?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DarkovStar Jun 01 '23

Your (and my) comments too. Since Reddit will automatically react to their content. For example auto moderation and etc. Also there are bots. So yeah. Programming.

4

u/Boldney Jun 01 '23

Well, technically every language is just fancy plain text.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/KiltroTech Jun 01 '23

So can you hire my aunt that keeps posting on facebook “how do you get one of them tech jobs kids talk so much about, I would like six figures too for sitting in my ass al day in front of the computer “

5

u/LavenderDay3544 Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

HTML is a document format. Sure it's Turing complete along with CSS but so is MS Word.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/scanguy25 Jun 01 '23

Water is a programming language!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jjman72 Jun 01 '23

The element copper has entered the chat.

2

u/hypatia_elos Jun 02 '23

No, but XHTML is a programming language - you could have programmed only in XSLT for years now!

(Yes, it is horrible, but also very impressive, how impressively verbose monstrosities you can make out of XSLT. Also shows that HTML wouldn't be better if it would be a programming language xD)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Electricity not a programming language???!! What exactly do you think the 1’s and 0’s represent?

4

u/BrobdingnagLilliput Jun 01 '23

Programmers: HTML isn't a real language!

Also programmers: I made a language entirely out of whitespace!

4

u/zertech Jun 01 '23

As long as that includes at least newlines or tab characters, than it still could be more of a programming language than html. Spaces are 0s and tabs or newlines are 1s. Than it can express machine code lol.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Christosconst Jun 01 '23

Its a markup language

4

u/ToMorrowsEnd Jun 01 '23

web works just fine without HTML. it's only there to keep the normals happy. JSON+REST FTW

3

u/Highborn_Hellest Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 01 '23

It's literally in the f... name. It'S A MARKUP LANGAUGE

Edit: what I realize, is the hay when it's stated that html is not a programming language,what some (not all) front end guys hear is that " your knowledge is not valuable". That's not what we were saying. What I'm trying to get at, is that it's not Turing complete, therefore it cannot be a programming language by definition.

As an example, MySQL isn't a programming language either. That doesn't mean it's not useful

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

It's in the name

3

u/SmellsLikeCatPiss Jun 01 '23

HTML is a declarative programming language. There's no ifs, ands, or buts about it. It's just not imperative like any "traditional" programming language, such as C or Java.

2

u/theggman_ Jun 01 '23

going by your logic so is utf-8, since it's directing the computer to execute a set of instructions to display the character.

2

u/Boom9001 Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

Nope. There's a fundamental difference, markup languages are languages Utf-8 is just an encoding.

The chunks of info just correspond one to one with irl language letters. The same way Morse code isn't a new human language it's just an encoding of English.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

The hell with people who don’t understand the abbreviation of HTML itself, it’s a markup language not a programming language.

1

u/Boom9001 Jun 02 '23

That logic proves nothing. I could just say markup languages are a subset of programming languages. Just as functional, impressive, declarative, graphic, and esoteric languages are all subsets of programming languages.

2

u/GargantuanCake Jun 01 '23

I don't hate HTML it just isn't a programming language. It's a markup language. Different thing.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Except it is, electricity is like, the thing that does the zap to make a 0 into a 1.

If we go even deeper, there's beliefs that cosmic rays can flip a bit if is passes through the right spot, meaning cosmic rays are ALSO a programming language.

Y'all being so primitive with your fancy javascript and shit. Real men program with the sun

1

u/steven4869 Jun 01 '23

Both the statements are true. HTML is a markup language that is used to present information whereas programming languages give instruction to computer in order to perform specific task and uses a compiler. By the definition itself HTML can never be a programming language.

On the other hand, without HTML the web won't work. As soon as you type the URL, the request is sent to the server which searches for the index.html file and loads it, then sends it as a response.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

BUT IT’S NOT TURING-COMPLETE!!! (Wrings hands)

1

u/vksdann Jun 01 '23

I mean... technically electricity is a programming language as 0s and 1s are from on/off switches in transistors.

1

u/PhoenixARC-Real Jun 01 '23

HTML is an important keystone on the Internet. That doesn't mean it's a programming language though, just like the wheels of a car aren't individual engines propelling themselves independent from one another.

1

u/Andrew_Neal Jun 01 '23

It's in the name:

HyperText Markup Language.

It's a markup language; not a programming language.

1

u/Big_Kwii Jun 01 '23

throw css in there and you have a turing complete thing

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Everything is programming language when you live in the simulation

1

u/Accomplished_Soil426 Jun 01 '23

" HYPER TEXT MARKUP LANGUAGE YOU DIRTY FUCKS "

-ChatGPT

1

u/Wandererofhell Jun 01 '23

Hyper Text Markup Language, it's already in the name 🙄

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

It's in the acronym.... Hyper Text MARKUP Language not Hyper Text Program Language

1

u/washtubs Jun 01 '23

Is it a programming language? Probably not.

Would it go under the "Programming Languages" section of a resume? Yes, because that way you rule out joining companies with annoying pedantic engineers in positions of power.

1

u/pretty_succinct Jun 01 '23

who the heck hates html?

It is what it is and does quite well at what it does!

1

u/jimmykicking Jun 01 '23

Love this. There is no P in HTML.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/hardiebotha Jun 01 '23

HTML refers to itself as a markup language. It does not disagree.

1

u/mangosawce9k Jun 01 '23

Wait until quantum computing! <insert sad cat with thumbs up>

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

Markup Language, not Programming Language (or a turing complete one anyway)

1

u/Player_X_YT Jun 01 '23

Electrical engineers and VHDL devs:

1

u/SombreroMedioChileno Jun 01 '23

I left web development after 10 years for another field. I do not regret it. It's pretty impressive the elitism that you find in software developers. So many people ready to tell you why you're wrong or why such-and-so language is bad. Somehow opinion becomes fact when all you do is stare at a computer all day.

1

u/extopico Jun 01 '23

It's literally called a markup language. Where does this HTML is a programming language thing come from?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23
  • Gemini

  • gopher

  • ftp

I can list more :D

1

u/arjunsahlot Jun 01 '23

Also everyone: putting HTML/CSS in the programming languages section in their resumes

1

u/samspot Jun 01 '23

Maybe if more people thought it was programming they’d be willing to learn it. Instead devs think its beneath them and write broken markup that lacks the most basic, built-in accessibility. So yeah, i am for regarding it as programming.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

What about TCP via pigeon? No electricity there. 🤷‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

HTML literally stands for HyperText Markup Language. It is absolutely a language.

1

u/CirnoIzumi Jun 01 '23

how is it hating?

Rust is not a markup language

ruby is not a stylong language

python is not an intermidiary language

html is not a programming language

1

u/PhatOofxD Jun 01 '23

When it literally has 'markup language ' in the name :/

1

u/MrSaltyMcSaltFace Jun 01 '23

HTML is just heavy abstraction on top of SGML technically

1

u/snurfy_mcgee Jun 01 '23

He's the best kind of right.

The way html has evolved though I actually view it as a programming language at this point. Like yeah, pure html is not but you consider all the frameworks, scripting, css magic etc how does it really differ ?

1

u/Smitellos Jun 01 '23

Wiki page about programming language had html commented with note: " Stop putting HTML here you asses, it's markdown language not programming one"

1

u/McGuirk808 Jun 01 '23

I am really surprised how controversial the comments in this thread are.

1

u/cdemix Jun 01 '23

HTPL is one, though.

1

u/SillAndDill Jun 01 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

For traditional reasons let's continue to distinguish between markup and programming.

But let's not be snobbish and act like html is entirely different and can't handle any logic at all.

SrcSet is a good example.

SrcSet in html is basically declarative programming with a set of conditions that are equivalent to:

"if window width < 500 then img.src=small.jpg; else if window.width < 800 then img.src=big.jpg; else img.src=biggest.jpg;".

So don't treat HTML as unworthy. In some cases HTML alone can solve complex tasks

1

u/GhonaHerpaSyphilAids Jun 01 '23

It's a markup language like xml.. it doesn't think just does

1

u/DudeManBroGuy42069 Jun 01 '23

Can we agree that HTML is 50% a programming language?

If not, what percentage is it?

1

u/LoveConstitution Jun 01 '23

Neither is javascript ...

Who cares what things are, economically speaking

1

u/NekulturneHovado Jun 01 '23

So what is it then?

1

u/NotACryptoBro Jun 01 '23

I mean it has "markup language" in its fucking name. We didn't call it HTPL for a reason.

1

u/BenAdaephonDelat Jun 01 '23

Yea anytime I see "html programmer" listed I know it's a job posting made by someone who doesn't understand development.

1

u/JaggedMetalOs Jun 01 '23

Is this actually a thing? Because in all my decades of being a web developer not once have I heard someone call HTML a programming language.

And that's not hating on it either, markup languages are important!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

HTML is a markup language, it even say that in its name, HyperText Markup Language. Which is not a programming language, for example look up the MD file which is the markup language that you probably use to write your README file in, would you consider that a programming language?

1

u/Glum_Future_5054 Jun 01 '23

No point at all in this argument 😅 it is a markup language and had it's own purpose

1

u/Express-Procedure361 Jun 01 '23

Somebody tell me if I'm wrong... But isn't that also not even true? You can create web pages with XML & XHTML

1

u/JonLSTL Jun 01 '23

HTML5+CSS3 is Turing Complete, but if you're willing to click the mouse in order to advance the machine state.

1

u/jamcdonald120 Jun 01 '23

I dont get why some people are offended that HTML isnt a programming language, Programming languages arent somehow better or more complex, its just a classification to describe their use.

You might as well go arround claiming a Mustang is a Pickup truck

1

u/defenistrat3d Jun 01 '23

Hypertext Markup Language

To be clear, I don't consider HTML a language... but I see why this could be difficult to "get" for someone that is dev-adjacent.

1

u/angrybeehive Jun 01 '23

Someone should make a YAML version of HTML.

1

u/Oswald_Hydrabot Jun 01 '23

Is electricity not a programming language?

1

u/Top-Chemistry5969 Jun 01 '23

Does it have synt* GET OUT!

1

u/zeeblefritz Jun 01 '23

Isn't the difference to be able to actually process data vs HTML which just essentially defines where things go?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/SenatorCrabHat Jun 02 '23

If you hear this phrase from someone for real, it lets you know that you are about to see a lot of divs and native HTML5 functionality recreated in JS.

1

u/MineKemot Jun 02 '23

Isn't it "HyperText Markup Language"?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Why is this even a thing???

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Okay, now I'm curious, What about HTML/CSS isn't programming? You're writing a set of commands, translated into code, calculated, and output. ..?

1

u/SkyProfessional9735 Jun 02 '23

Markup language- used to present information Programming language- used to give instructions But technically markup language is Also providing instructions to perform certain task presenting information in various ways is also a task I’ll tell you what real problem is HTML is comparatively easier then other languages so the people who knows other languages think it as a insult to see html as a programming language I give you a example my friend knew html css he used to call himself a coder and we used to make fun of if but when he learned Python the cycle repeats now he was making fun of people who knew html css and calling themselves as a programmer 🤣

1

u/TheAccountITalkWith Jun 02 '23

SCSS is probably super conflicted with itself, lol.

1

u/SomeRandoLameo Jun 02 '23

That is very true

1

u/OracularLettuce Jun 02 '23

The closer you get to the hardware the more electricity becomes the programming language.

1

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Jun 02 '23

Electricity isn't a programming language; it's all of the programming languages. What do you think those ones and zeros are made of?

1

u/ShooterMcGavin000 Jun 02 '23

It's not about hate. Nobody hates HTML. Just the dudes that think they're coding gods just because they now some html, those we hate. Learn a real programming language. And 2nd most html on the web isn't even written manually. It's either server site rendered or the dom tree is build during runtime through a js frame work.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Is english a programming language? :hits-blunt:

1

u/eirc Jun 02 '23

Markup languages are programming languages.

1

u/SoftwareHitch Jun 02 '23

The people upset about html not being called a programming language are the same people crying over Pluto not being a planet

1

u/GabrySPCR0007 Jun 02 '23

I wouldn't care if I was a web developer and someone told me that, it's not like if HTML is or isn't a programming language makes it any different...

1

u/doglitbug Jun 02 '23

Web can totally survive with out html

1

u/No_Estimate_4002 Jun 02 '23

Electronic circuits are not a programming? Say it to my system verilog.

1

u/Grand_Gap_5984 Jun 02 '23

🤣🤣🤣

1

u/xTH13M0x Jun 02 '23

we don't hate html, but it isn't a programming language, it's a markup language, it's in the name. That doesn't mean it's bad, it just have a different purpose than a programming language.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

my website works without internet - localhost:8000

1

u/ikeengel Jun 02 '23

My relais feel offendet now

1

u/Awkward-Cat-4702 Jun 02 '23

*Insert Mr. incredible meme here:

if it has an L in the acronym saying its a Language then it is a Language!

1

u/Revexious Jun 02 '23

HTML - Hyper Text Markup Lemonade

1

u/TheOtherGuy52 Jun 02 '23

I feel like the threshold is turing-completeness. A programming language should at minimum be able to feasibly execute any possible program (turing-completeness), and having clean syntax and streamlined high-level framework design is a bonus.

Magic: The Gathering is more of a programming language than HTML is.

1

u/KuuHaKu_OtgmZ Jun 02 '23

If saying HTML isn't a PL is hating it, then saying potatoes aren't fish is hating potatoes

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Electricity is absolutely a programming language.

1

u/Realay367 Jun 02 '23

You are turning complete and don't let anyone tell you otherwise... wait a minute, are you?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Web cannot survive without your mom as well, doesn’t make her a programming language

1

u/Amaloy_J Jun 03 '23

If HTML isn't a programming language, then there are NO front end programmers. Only write the interface for the app? Not a programmer according to this statement.

HTML is a front end to the server, written in an interpreted script language much like quite a few interface design languages.

1

u/_asdfjackal Jun 03 '23

This is just the programmer version of the "is Pluto a planet" debate. Change my mind.

1

u/humungus420 Jun 05 '23

HTML stands for hypertext markup language. It literally says it’s a “markup language” in the name. Who in gods name confuses this with a programming language

1

u/buzz2jimmy Jun 23 '23

Really true, It's a base of web without HTML can't image web world, right now there are lots of programming languages for web but at the end everything will converted to HTML to deliver the UX!

1

u/Suitable_Designer_67 Jun 25 '23

I am a senior developer that’s been working for 15 years.

The people that liked html enough to learn and respect it are way better overall compared to you complaining fuck faces.

Shut the fuck up and learn html.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

If we say running shoes, nobody will be triggered, because it is shoes for running

We can say cooking apron, and no one will say that "only pan is cooking"

What is wrong with HTML as programming language? When it is language used for programming, to create programs, and only for programming?

"Html/sql is not programming language" is always come from dumb level devs who try to brag with their tiny knowledge (you know, it is very common when low intelligent people try to look smart by hating or criticising something, because hate is easier than realisation)

If you want specify more, you can come up with term like '"executable language", "general purpose programming language"

Html is absolutely sure programming language But Html is not general purpose programming language

If you not agree, tell me please precise definition of programming language by your opinion

5

u/NewPointOfView Jun 01 '23

Seems like by that reasoning, you put on your programming shirt and sit in your programming chair, type use your programming mouse and programming keyboard to enter your programming password to login to your programming computer, then you can open your programming web browser and browse programming memes before opening your programming ide and using your programming language

→ More replies (7)

5

u/theggman_ Jun 01 '23

html stands for Hyper Text Markup Language. i would not deem markup languages as programming languages because their primary purpose is to enrich text with data about the text itself.

you could argue that html is used by an interpreter to get the computer to execute a set of instructions but so does LaTeX, and i do not think of that as a programming language.

oh and btw sql is a programming language that uses the declarative programming paradigm, i have no idea why some people seem to think it's not

1

u/TehBens Jun 01 '23

One can argue that a program is a sequence of instructions and that a programming language is something to generate a program. You could then question if html is based on sequences or based on instructions.

Not a too bad discussion academically, maybe. Not that I really care, nothing is more irrelevant than if somebody calls HTML a programming language.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

One can't argue that programming language is something to generate sequence of unstructions because:

Many declarative programming languages and whole deckarative programming style which try to get rid of sequence of action

Everything in computer is generated insequence of instructions

While you can't precosely define "programming language" term, all thesises "X is not a programming language" are dead at start

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

1

u/JosebaZilarte Jun 01 '23

HTML is simply a description language, not a programing one. And there is no shame in it, specially now, when many programming languages also are created to be interpreted by other pieces of code.

1

u/aedvocate Jun 01 '23

I mean writing HTML is literally coding, if you want to be nice about it

I'd also be okay with saying that an html doc is a program that is run in the browser - you write it all up, and the browser parses / interprets it then displays the result 🤷‍♀️

sure 'markup language' is right there in the name but

I don't really feel like there's any need to split hairs about it, you can write a whole 'program' including UI and even a degree of state management in just HTML so

-3

u/Osleg Jun 01 '23

I don't know what the arguing is about, HTML == Hyper Text (now attention) Markup language

Not programming language... You see, in the name?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '23

I never knew Java has „programming language” in its name

→ More replies (2)

1

u/AL1L Jun 01 '23

I think they're confusing it with HTPL, obviously

1

u/Boom9001 Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

Are brown bears mammals? Obviously not it's in the name, they are brown BEARS.

I could just say markup languages are subset of programming languages and your "it's in the name" argument is just as stupid as my example.

It's an artificial language used for programming. It's a programming language.

→ More replies (1)