r/Professors • • Apr 22 '22

Rant

OK, kids. The next time you write for an extension because you have this massive workload and you’re all stressed out and your anxiety meds haven’t kicked in and your profs don’t understand that you have OTHER COURSES I’d like you to stop, take a breath, close your laptop, pick up a notebook and a pencil and go to the library. Then I want you to find all the material you’ll need for your assignment using only print sources. When you find those print sources, I’d like you to stop by the props department at the theater building and borrow a typewriter and start writing. Once you’ve completed one page of your assignment on said typewriter and you have just a smidgen of a taste of how much work it was for your over-50 faculty to get their advanced degrees, then — and only then — you can resume your email to me about your “workload.”

21 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

69

u/AvengedKalas Lecturer, Math, R2 (USA) Apr 23 '22

Just because you had different difficulties when you were in college does not make the difficulties students have nowadays any less real.

-66

u/CharlieBrownXmas Apr 23 '22

Yes, it does. They’re asked to do half the work with ten times the tools. It’s the guy with a backhoe bitching to the guy with the shovel

32

u/sherlocksvillain Apr 23 '22

With all these marvels of technology, how much faster do your grade assignments? If not at least twice as fast, never complain about workload

55

u/Fancy_Calendar_7464 Apr 23 '22

My sister took her daughter on a campus tour of the University of Massachusetts at Amherst last spring. At the center of the campus is a 26-story library built in the 1970s. The perky student tour guide told the group: “If you ever get lost on campus, just look for the library and you’ll know where the campus center is!”

My niece eyed the tower and whispered to my sister: “Is that whole building full of … books?”

33

u/CharlieBrownXmas Apr 23 '22

Not full of books — they based the design on another building and, when they built it, failed to account for the weight of the books. It swayed in the wind and bricks fell out so they had to pull out half the books. When I was there they had a perimeter fence around the building and an underground entrance so students wouldn’t get hit by falling bricks.

9

u/proffordsoc FT NTT, Sociology, R1 (USA) Apr 23 '22

I remain skeptical of the first half of the story but the fence and covered entrance were definitely there 1999-2005. I should ask my kid’s friend who’s just finishing her freshman year there if there’s still a safety perimeter.

5

u/CharlieBrownXmas Apr 23 '22

Well, if it was a myth it was a good one because there was most definitely a safety fence around the Umass library.

2

u/proffordsoc FT NTT, Sociology, R1 (USA) Apr 23 '22

Oh for sure (got my PhD there). It’s a safety hazard because it “spits bricks” I’m just not sure how much of the WHY is actually true. I’ve heard similar tales about other university libraries.

20

u/pmmeBostonfacts Apr 23 '22

i’m sorry that’s something i want to know everything about like what?!?

21

u/professorkurt Assoc Prof, Astronomy, Community College (US) Apr 23 '22

There was an urban legend - and just a legend - that the main library at Indiana University was built without taking the weight of the books into consideration, and therefore the library was sinking.

This is actually an urban legend that is associated with a bunch of university libraries. The UMass Amherst library swaying/sinking is similarly a myth, so much so that it is listed as such on their Wikipedia page.

8

u/caffeinated_tea Apr 23 '22

It's also the lore with Low Library at Columbia, which is one of the most photographed buildings on campus. Now it's full of administrative offices and there's a zillion separate libraries (including one main library). I have no idea if it's true, but I definitely accepted it as fact when I was younger.

4

u/Cautious-Yellow Apr 23 '22

there was a building on campus where I went that was (apparently) supposed to have a swimming pool on the top floor, but they (apparently) forgot to account for the weight of the water.

3

u/dreamtigerz FT, Math, CC Apr 23 '22

I heard this story about Walden Hall at NMSU. Always wondered how it could possibly be true.

34

u/PersephoneIsNotHome Apr 23 '22

And now ride your bike to the actual campus and hand it to your professor in class, because that is how you hand in papers.

13

u/quantum-mechanic Apr 23 '22

my bike chain came off and I had no idea how to fix that, the campus bike technician was sick that day

4

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) Apr 23 '22

Is your bicycle a Quantum Bicycle? Cool!

3

u/quantum-mechanic Apr 23 '22

Yes, and the spanner I use is very small

1

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) Apr 23 '22

0

u/CharlieBrownXmas Apr 23 '22

Literally. Biked the nine miles from NortHampton to Umass and back every day it wasn’t snowing. Uphill only one way, though….

9

u/RoyalEagle0408 Asst Prof, Bio, LAC Apr 23 '22

Wow, you also went to undergrad during a pandemic and a huge climate crisis?

1

u/CharlieBrownXmas Apr 24 '22

Yes, the climate crisis makes it so difficult to access the internet… And are you referring to the pass/fail, no attendance policy, ”oh, well good enough,” turn-on-zoom-and-play-video-games-pandemic? That pandemic? I wish.

12

u/musamea Apr 23 '22

I feel like I grew up during a peculiar time ...

Applied for college in the late 1990s: filled out all of my applications and mailed them by hand.

Applied for grad school in the 2000s: applications filled out online, writing samples sent by FedEx or snail mail.

Applied for jobs in the 2010s: everything electronic, yay, I'm thinking "why the fuck did it take so long for someone to figure this out??"

12

u/BowlCompetitive282 Apr 23 '22

I submitted college apps by hand/mail in the very early 2000s. I remember my parents were suspicious of application fees ("This place has to be a scam") so I ended up having to call the colleges and verify. One college, trying to get me to attend, even sent me a crisp $20 bill as a refund on my app fee. I guess I beamed "poor and first-gen student"

1

u/CharlieBrownXmas Apr 23 '22

“ Applied for jobs in the 2010s: everything electronic, yay, I'm thinking "why the fuck did it take so long for someone to figure this out??"

Yeah, cuz that was SO MUCH EASIER

26

u/AdoraBellDearheart Apr 23 '22

Upload you CV, your diversity statement, footprints of your first child, your transcripts from kindergarten and your cover letter, a budget and a research plan. Now type it into these boxes that cut off at 347 characters also

12

u/SabertoothLotus adjunct, english, CC (USA) Apr 23 '22

Get told that your last name can't be accepted by the system because it's too short, resulting in being unable to submit the form at all

5

u/AdoraBellDearheart Apr 23 '22

Or too long so it doesn’t match you CV

2

u/musamea Apr 23 '22

Well, it was for me. Shrug.

240

u/SabertoothLotus adjunct, english, CC (USA) Apr 23 '22

Bear with me as I tell you a story. I swear this is relevant:

A man at a factory is expected to produce 10 flangiplangers every hour for 8 hours a day, five days a week. That's 400 every week. It is a lot of work assembling them by hand-- the kanibbling rods are particularly fussy and labor intensive.

Management looks at the situation and decides to purchase a machine that can attach that kanibbling rod exactly the same way every time, cutting down production time by 50% per unit.

Is the assembly worker's job now easier? Management certainly thinks so. They should easily be able to produce twice as many as flangiplangers in the same amount of time, right? Their quota is now 800 per week, and management thinks they're being lazy and selfish when they complain about repetitive stress injuries and mangled limbs caused by the new, faster pace of production.

We are management in this scenario. The student is the worker. We look at all the tools they have that we didn't and assume that the difficulties we had are now non-existent rather than exacerbated by the tools themselves.

Yes, you had to take the bus to a different campus to find the print copy on of the article you needed. But you knew it was there, and it was the only article on that topic. Now there are 15,000 articles on that topic in the electronic databases, and another 5 trillion hits on Google (one more reason to not rely on Google for research) that a student needs to be able to navigate and evaluate.

The sheer amount of information available makes research difficult, especially when we just assume they know how to find what they need because the tools are available. I wouldn't know how to build a flangiplanger, or even how to use one without somebody explaining it to me first. Would you?

TL;DR: technology doesn't actually make anything easier, it just raises our expectations about how easy things should be. We complain that "back in my day, things were much harder!" without bothering to understand that things are an entirely different kind of difficult today.

24

u/adventurevulture Apr 23 '22

Exactly this. Well said.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '22

Correct.

1

u/RedMethodKB Apr 28 '24

This response is the essence of based

1

u/SabertoothLotus adjunct, english, CC (USA) Apr 28 '24

I can't tell if you think that's a good thing or not.

57

u/orthomonas Apr 23 '22

Never have I seen a colleague do 'old_man_yells_at_cloud.gif' better than this.

162

u/moosy85 Apr 23 '22

Well, back then it was easily possible to get a job with no or just one publication. So there's that 😂 "Back in the olde days it was so much harder" is just a narrative that keeps being repeated by every generation. But there are a lot of other things that have become harder.

14

u/NewSodomMississippi Apr 23 '22

You're not wrong, but my god did the OP's post trigger my printed text trauma! Lit reviews back then could take months just to get all the sources! Inter-library loan was like being a kid in the weeks leading up to Christmas, except December 25th could fall on January 20th or March 2nd. Just wretched, except for the subtly different smell of the paper of those publications.

Now, we can do that all from our desks or even phones. And what we can't get from our own institutions is almost certainly available from the Kazakh National Library, AKA Sci-Hub. Glorious!

And actually, typewriters increased the drudge work of all writing by a factor of 20 or more. Especially because many institutions didn't allow any corrections -- a single typo and you had to retype the whole damned page! Also, don't forget that typewriters mean cross-references, numbering of all kinds, and references were a manual nightmare.

So now that I think about it, I think you are wrong! Things are vastly easier now.

199

u/falsecompare_ Master Instructor, English Apr 23 '22

…this feels very “we had it harder” in a ugly way. definitely understand it’s a rant and that students definitely take advantage of kindness with extensions but college is hard now like it was then. just in different ways.

35

u/BiologyPhDHopeful Apr 23 '22 edited Apr 23 '22

Agreed. Higher Ed is difficult for each generation for different reasons. The sheer volume of information (and the speed with which it gets published nowadays) is staggering. Students have to learn and sort through new content while living in a time where there are nearly equal amounts of misinformation and truth available at the push of a button. Many majors have more “basics” to cover, and/or must learn information from different disciplines to be competitive in todays job market (like genetics and bioinformatics/coding, for example).

Not being slowed down by older technology (or lack thereof) is largely beneficial…. But the new standards for publications, achievements, grants, etc. are much higher than they used to be. Many young students are navigating this during unprecedented times, only to graduate and enter a workforce/system that is fundamentally broken in most places around the world.

I don’t blame younger students for not knowing how to handle these challenges. Our education and social systems failed to prepare them properly. (Which can lead to the problematic behavior and perceived entitlement that seem to be more prevalent than in prior years).

36

u/AFK_MIA Asst Prof, Neuro/Bioinfo(US) Apr 23 '22

This - I've avoided my "But back then there were only 3 journals" comment, but really I'm teaching stuff to students now that didn't even exist yet when I was in grad school, plus all the stuff that did, and I'm a new professor, not an old one.

55

u/Sleepless_in_MA Apr 23 '22

Yeah…definite “uphill both ways in the snow” vibes.

81

u/swtcharity Apr 23 '22

Nah this ain’t it. The amount of published material now is exponentially higher than “the olden days.” You had to type? Students still have to type. And now they get to wade through thousands of search results vs 7 printed (GASP!) publications.

3

u/trevor_ Apr 23 '22

In my experience, my students are using cites from the first page of google results. They are not wading through thousands of arcane academic database search results. And they make liberal use of copypasta. May you be luckier than I am!

10

u/Penkala89 Apr 23 '22

To be fair, to even begin wading through these databases first you have to sign on to the university library page and ping a code to your phone for TFA. Then choose a database. Then enter in your search, which may have to be expressed differently depending on the database you're using. Then you get a bunch of results with arcane titles, and the preview shows the slightest of snippets that may well just show part of the references from a paper they cited. Then you actually select an article and are taken to another page that doesn't actually link to the article itself, but a landing page where you can download or view the article (assuming it's actually available).

I still of course require students use databases and scholarly sources, and demonstrate how to use them, but I can understand the allure of typing a few words in the default search bar on one's phone and getting instant information.

64

u/AFK_MIA Asst Prof, Neuro/Bioinfo(US) Apr 23 '22

Coming from the perspective of someone who studies stress, I think this is poorly considered. Certainly back in the day you had fewer resources and fewer tools. To accomplish anything you had to take the very limited tools you had and just do a lot of work. The grind certainly was a thing - however, grinding with limited tools is something our brains are good at. "Good stress" is when you have a challenging problem to solve, but you also believe you have the tools to handle it.

In contrast, "bad stress" happens when you don't have a way to be in control of solving the problem. Students today have very different problems from students several years or decades ago - it's a lot easier to perform the work itself if they choose the right set of tools - but they have thousands of tools to choose from - and more importantly, very little understanding of which tools are the right ones. Broadly speaking, we professors do a poor job of teaching on this point, because we assume that students simply understand all of the latest technology (which they don't). This problem is different - and more importantly - the "new" problem is one that our brains are poorly adapted to. They aren't good at handling abstract problems with multiple solutions without a good basis for choosing an approach - that is, their problem is that they don't know what tool to use rather than the task simply being tedious.

51

u/imasinger Grad Student, Science, State School (US) Apr 23 '22

back in my day! But really, It’s still hard. Now instead of the sources you have limited to your library, we have all the sources on the internet. It’s severely overwhelming to know what to look for/when to stop. Plus the fact that we have to go back through all the articles you may have + what’s been done since.

I’m actually taking a grad school break because of this. And god forbid we type something that might be flagged for being too similar to one of the articles because there are 100 new papers referencing depression. Technology is overwhelming. Sorry for the rant. I hate the “I had it harder” mentality.

79

u/annalbananal Apr 23 '22

The "someone has it worse!" rebuttal to someone asking for help is pretty unfortunate and out of touch, to be frank. I think it's also pretty insensitive to make light of the mental health of students given the state of the world and their education system right now. I'm not at all saying your frustration itself isn't valid, but this attitude is... I dunno, it's just kinda harsh, if not outright mean.

33

u/Jes-Marie Apr 23 '22

Disheartened by how far I had to scroll to find this response. I’m only hoping that the lack of empathy I’m seeing here is also due to the state of the world.

-27

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) Apr 23 '22

pretty insensitive to make light of the mental health of students given the state of the world

The state of the world is not significantly worse nor more stressful than in the early 1970s.

17

u/annalbananal Apr 23 '22

I'm not saying it is or is not worse than anything. The comparison itself is missing the point. Things are tough right now and a lot of people are struggling, students included- I'd even say especially. The unique struggles of students past do not invalidate the unique struggles of students today, even if you don't understand them.

13

u/AFK_MIA Asst Prof, Neuro/Bioinfo(US) Apr 23 '22

The state of the world is not significantly worse nor more stressful than in the early 1970s.

I'd probably argue that it's more stressful in specifically the ways that are more mentally harmful. Sure the world broadly was probably worse in the 1970's, but it was worse in ways that the human brain was decent at handling.

7

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) Apr 23 '22

Tell that to those of us in the Selective Service lottery.

Of course, everyone always claims that things are uniquely worst for their generation (old or young), because of course, that is what they experience.

2

u/AFK_MIA Asst Prof, Neuro/Bioinfo(US) Apr 24 '22

I addressed that already, but to restate it for you. It's not a question of magnitude, it's one of type - and how the neurobiology interacts. The "I might be drafted" stress, despite being more "important" still has a smaller neurobiological effect than "I don't know what to do." I'd wholeheartedly agree that someone who was young in the early 70's probably had it "worse" - but they also were far less likely to have crippling anxiety about the challenges they face, whereas "kids these days" have an objectively easier life, but also have challenges that are far more likely to give them anxiety disorders. It's not as simple as you are trying to pretend it is.

3

u/AvengedKalas Lecturer, Math, R2 (USA) Apr 23 '22

But information is so much more readily available thanks to technology and social media.

7

u/SabertoothLotus adjunct, english, CC (USA) Apr 23 '22

Well... "Information" maybe. Which is a different animal to relevant/useful/accurate information.

As I tell my students, the great thing about the internet is that it allows anybody to say whatever they want... Which is also the worst thing about the internet. Just because it showed up in a Google search doesn't make it true or reliable.

Relying only on Google for research is like letting Tinder decide who you're going to marry.

3

u/orthomonas Apr 23 '22

They said, in the middle of a pandemic.

-14

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '22

"But my COVID induced depression!"

34

u/PersephoneIsNotHome Apr 23 '22

That notification in your campus mail box (that was 1 mile from my actual dorm) that the ILL you needed for you research paper was in.

16

u/writergeek313 Apr 23 '22

The one you had been waiting for for weeks.

8

u/musamea Apr 23 '22

Oh lord. If you needed an article from another library ... it wasn't going to get there until that paper was finished, handed in, and already graded.

38

u/PersephoneIsNotHome Apr 23 '22

Assigned reading on reserve. 1 hr windows. have to physically book them in the library and read them in the library.

12

u/nomstomp Apr 23 '22

God I miss that somehow.

27

u/PersephoneIsNotHome Apr 23 '22

Not me. I read all my PDF’s in my lamb-y pajamas now with a coffee and the dog ,not like a heathen

36

u/sherlocksvillain Apr 23 '22

Get your point, but this is a pretty mean and spiteful way to respond or even think about your students.

8

u/imasinger Grad Student, Science, State School (US) Apr 25 '22

OP needs either to retire, or connect back to reality. Maybe try actually taking a few classes at another college during the summer or something. Humbling yourself like this every once in a while keeps you connected to the current day.

24

u/FeatherTime Apr 23 '22

So your post is about asking students to have some empathy, and maybe compassion for you and your workload.

But then maybe it’s a mutual thing? Maybe it would be more effective if we as educators had more empathy and compassion for the challenges our students have gone through, especially during this pandemic?

Speaking personally, it’s been hard enough for me to survive during all of this, and I have a partner and a pretty good support network. Imagine trying to manage the past two years as a teenager.

13

u/henare Adjunct, LIS, CIS, R2 (USA) Apr 23 '22

"I had to lug the borrowed typewriter uphill both ways!"

27

u/IceniQueen69 Apr 22 '22

Right! The hours I spent in the library going through volumes of MLA Bibliography to find things a Google search will turn up in seconds.

18

u/quantum-mechanic Apr 23 '22

I once took the inter college shuttle to a different college because they were the only one that had the journal I needed for a certain piece of data

4

u/Amethyst-Sapphire Apr 23 '22

I definitely drove the hour to the main campus from my regional campus to get journal articles, too. Interlibrary loan back then took two weeks and was photocopied and sent by mail. Not the less than 48 hours it is now.

10

u/SlowGoat79 Apr 23 '22

Ok, I’m a former academic librarian and I love all the nerdy things. But searching the paper format of the MLA sounds…..awful. Really, really awful.

3

u/IceniQueen69 Apr 23 '22

Kinda was. But I always enjoyed that stuff anyway. Spending that time alone in the stacks, no phones for distractions, felt like I really focused on things.

37

u/shwarmaramen101 Apr 23 '22

You sound like an asshole Lmao

5

u/Danny_Shass Apr 23 '22

You sound like a clown🤡 everyone get out their small violins🤣 students now a days don’t have real problems cause when you went to school you had to take notes on slabs of stone🥺

5

u/Corsair_Caruso Apr 26 '22

These kids today don’t know real work. I had to join the church as a child to even learn how to read, and we had to write on vellum! And then I died of the plague!

17

u/Snootch74 Apr 23 '22

Shut up.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '22

🙄

10

u/mathisfakenews Asst prof, Math, R1 Apr 23 '22

I understand if you are just venting but this is honestly just a pretty shitty take on the situation. You can't point out all the technological improvements which make it easier to be a modern student and pretend there aren't also many ways in which it is harder.

Why can't both be hard? Suffering isn't an olympic event. Students today can have a difficult time without it somehow erasing your own struggles.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '22

Hi! I hope you are doing well. Undoubtedly teaching will be tough at times, and you may not always like certain students. It happens. Students won’t like you either.

As far as your complaints, you are very ignorant to assume that these students have it any less difficult than you did. As a student, how many times did you have to figure out new technologies just to submit your assignments? How many times did you have to download stuff to a personal computer just for a class? How many times were you expected to have access to a computer at all times?

I hope you come to understanding, but in the meantime you might consider counseling. While I recommend finding a counselor near you, you can also check out

r/socialskills

r/therapy

2

u/DarthMomma_PhD Apr 23 '22

Dude, I‘m 40 and I had to do this for all of undergrad and most of graduate school too! I even remember hand plotting data for certain things in the lab as an undergrad.

Well, ever except the typewriter. That is pretty hard-core. I did use a typewriter on my college admissions forms, but that was for neatness and since the forms were pre-printed you could basically only use a typewriter if you wanted your forms to be typed and not handwritten.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '22 edited Apr 23 '22

My rant is next students feel that way, they should start working on assignments earlier than wait until the last day.

But regarding the workload: many of my students work between 20-30 hours a week. They have to this so they can afford rent and other living expenses. This might be what they meant by "workload".

1

u/Nylonknot Apr 23 '22

This made me laugh and also reminded me of the time my niece told her freshman biology professor she just couldn’t make it to an 8 am class because she couldn’t get up at 7:30.

-12

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '22

They really have no idea what it used to be like in the before times. Now they even get downloadable lecture notes, recorded lecture, and 24-hour professor access. The times sure as hell have changed.

-26

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '22

They have it so good and they don't even realize it.

-15

u/CharlieBrownXmas Apr 22 '22

Right? I’m not saying “hey you, your generation sucks,” I’m only saying “just quit yer bitching.” Can you imagine what these guy would do if they had to rent a study carrel just to save commuting time between the dorm and library?

10

u/IceniQueen69 Apr 23 '22

I rented one for the semester to get away from my incessantly chattering roommate. Back then, most of us didn’t even have earphones or things to cancel out roommate noise. 🤣

5

u/SlowGoat79 Apr 23 '22

At my undergrad, senior honors theses-writing people could apply for a little office in the library. They even had windows!

0

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23

I did exactly that after nearly dying at 19 years old, and the professor refuses to grade my 40 page paper I had to write from the hospital because he didnt feel like it

Understand that students today are under insane stress, and are people too.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '22

[deleted]

8

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) Apr 23 '22

Ours shredded essentially the entire collection of the Science and Engineering Library.

3

u/iTeachCSCI Ass'o Professor, Computer Science, R1 Apr 23 '22

Well now I need to go on an expedition to find out just what is in my university's library.

2

u/RoyalEagle0408 Asst Prof, Bio, LAC Apr 24 '22

When I was in grad school I was looking for a specific reference that had not been digitized. I e-mailed the reference librarian to see where the journals were (due to some construction at the time) and got, instead of a helpful response, told how to find digitized resources. I knew how to use the Dewey Decimal system and all that, so I wasted an hour just wandering around finding the journals. I can only imagine how most I would have been otherwise given that no one wanted to help with outdated paper journals. My guess is now they have been tossed.