r/ProductManagement • • Feb 01 '24

Strategy/Business Is the Vision Pro the most incredible piece of product management you've ever seen?

0 Upvotes

I don’t have my Apple Vision Pro yet. Still, after reading some reviews and the article in Vanity Fair with Tim Cook, I’m convinced this is probably the most impressive example of excellent product management I’ve ever seen.

In the article, Tim Cook says he first tried a prototype 7-8 years ago and knew from that day that this would be a new category for Apple. That got me thinking about all the things that Apple has shipped (and sometimes been derided for) in service of this new category.

When Apple added LiDAR to iPhones and created entire SDKs around A/R, many wondered, “Why?”. What utility does this bring to the user?

When Apple launched the “overpriced” Airpods Max, again, the critics wondered, “Why?”. Are they just repackaging Beats for the “Fanboys” and “Fangirls”? And why do they have head tracking? Why are they adding Spatial audio to Music, is that to compete with Spotify?

When Apple announced the Vision Pro, they said “Spatial Computing,” and everyone said, “What’s that?”. Well, it turns out that Tim Cook has never forgotten that Apple is a computer company. And they haven’t spent billions of dollars trying to make avatars with legs that can walk around a virtual reality world because no one wants that.

It turns out that Apple was playing 4D chess while the rest of us watched, and we never knew it. They’ve been training developers on how to use LiDAR for years. They’ve honed their tech around head tracking and spatial audio for years. And they’ve created a device that could eventually replace every screen you own.

If you want to see what I mean, I highly recommend watching Marques Brownlee’s (MKBHD) incredible review on YouTube. I’ll let you look it up.

After watching that, it’s pretty easy to imagine a desk with no monitor, just a keyboard and mouse (which you can see), and whatever arrangement of screens you can come up with. And it’s easy to imagine that a Zoom meeting becomes a swivel of your chair and your colleagues are all there with you, in your office. When you need a break, you can sit on a carpet in your office, click a button, and be in your happy place, and meditate for a few minutes.

What does this have to do with product management? Well, great product management requires incredible product vision and the discipline as a company to work towards that vision, sometimes for 7-8 years. It also requires you to ship before it’s fully realized, to get your incremental progress out there in the wild.

Product Management is a long game that requires months and years to realize incredible outcomes. Regardless of whether the Vision Pro becomes an overwhelming commercial success ($700m in sale to date) and replaces every screen you own, it’s clear that this is a triumph of what is possible with outstanding leadership and incredible product vision.


r/ProductManagement • • Jun 01 '23

Overemployment? People in your team have other jobs.

3 Upvotes

I don't know if you guys have heard, but a lot of people are having two or three or four jobs, especially technical people (software engineers, solutions architect...) The term is overemployment.

I'm going to share my views, and I would love to hear what you guys think...

a) I personally think it's a breach of trust, I personally think these people are ruining it for all of us. Just got off the phone from a recruiter, She told me about this hybrid position, and I have to come into the office one week in a month, just because the company has had so many of these kind of issues, where people are doing multiple jobs from their home.

b) I also think it's not fair for your team, If your team hires a senior software engineers, not only do we expect higher quality work faster, but we expect you to spend some time with other team members... And when you just do the bear basic minimum, and then go to your second job, you're not really helping the team.

c) they're making the world the worse place, their argument is , loyalty is dead, companies today Do not care for people, so I'm going to screw them over, and feel no guilt.

d) fundamentally I don't have any problem with this, it's just a packaging, these people should be more honest, and brand themselves as consultants. And then they can charge consulting rates...

What are you guys think? What would you do if you found out someone in your team is doing this?

Update: I'm glad everyone chimed in (even though it was tough), and this became the most controversial thread on this channel (for now), it was enlightening and depressing at the same time. I want to thank everyone, for coming here , and expressing your views.

Update2: This is why I created this post, people playing these games are going to ruin WFH

https://www.theinformation.com/articles/meta-calls-employees-back-to-office-three-days-a-week


r/ProductManagement • • Jan 27 '24

Man - splaining

3 Upvotes

(Badass) women of product, what are some tactics to use when men try to explain your product to you? Why does this happen? 😩


r/ProductManagement • • Feb 14 '26

It becomes much easier and faster to explain what is required to 5.3 model than to the dev team. PMs started to use codex, SDE is now reviewers.

5 Upvotes

After release of Codex App and their latest model, I see very interesting results - it is much much easier to explain to model what is needed and steer it to implementation that is required then actual dev.

I see this in my organization - PMs started to come requesting extended license with explanation - “I am very much more productive and I can implement more what I want if I use 5.3 instead of actually writing tickets for developer, they are slow unresponsive and do what I don’t want more often then LLM model”

We ran a trial and it is actually very true:

We selected medium size/complexity of the feature and decided to:

  1. PM drafted short initial explanation what is needed in the format it wants

  2. The same pushes to Codex AND developer

  3. Then me measured how many messages was required to get what PM wants (calls were forbidden - only text)

  4. Dev was not aware that he is taking part in this experiment

  5. We repeated it 10 times

We got shocking results, with 5.3 PM can get what is required after around 3-5 messages. With real dev - 15/20.

Things become worse if dev is a new to the team, even senior required around 20-40 or requested a call…

Month ago we already had this experience with UI part, but now I am very surprised that it happening with Backend.

Now in several teams PMs just started to use codex asking it to create what is required, instead of go with the full flow and requests to dev team.

And I am talking about production systems, not internal/small ones.

As a result our CPO/CEO start asking engineering leader what is the added value of EM/TL what is his view for the future, because new model will be better and better and then what?….

I think guys it is happening what we are discussing for several months already, the old software development approach is collapsing, however the great part is - PM (technical PM with the domain knowledge) is a king now.

After analysis by CTO, our devs separated by 2 groups - the first one who doesn’t like AI and now they are mainly working in the old format with cursor auto-complete without any agentic flows, and the new ones - AI first.

The AI first team is helping PMs now to build things by themself + review code from PMs agents.

Basically we have now the flow:

PM —Feature request —- > codex —Implementation—-> PM/QA (verification) —> Final review (SDE)

So now the main purpose of SDEs is 2 in our case:

  1. Do code review from PM’s agents

  2. Write guidelines for PM’s agents so they follow patterns and it is less to change on their last step. (Improve AGENTS.MD, prepare Agent Skills, building MCPs…)

I think it is happening.

I am very surprised, very.

I am expected to see this in 2027/2030 maybe but it came much faster.

As a product - I am happy, I can build exactly what I want, and I don’t need to speak to multiple teams aligning roadmaps and doing tradeoffs. No, you just start resisting from your agent, it works now as the best engineering partner - finding what needs to be changed and where.

You just build what you want.

If you are PM - start learning tools NOW, and start building, you will be competing with ex-developers.

If you are developer - learn tools how you can work in the new world, you need to become agent manager and tool optimizer/code reviewer.

The old approach where SDE = builder/creator - almost finished.


r/ProductManagement • • Apr 24 '24

I created a 🔥 PRD that would've taken me days in a few hours with 3 AI tools

0 Upvotes

I wanted to create a short (6-7 pages) PRD, started from scratch today, blocked 5 hours(!), and finished it. I usual initially the chatprd.ai (the free version), then took it to claude.ai (paid), added a lot of context and also related documents with instructions, and then finalized it with ~20 iterations of fixing it in ChatGPT (paid).

Normally, I would've procrastinated with initiating it, and then it would've taken probably multiple sessions and overall way more hours. I think the result is really good - it's clear, concise, comprehensive, with nuanced insights that are not trivial. Now let's see how well it survives the engineering manager's first review.

Overall, I think that these tools SERIOUSLY boost productivity. With that, I really think that most people are not using them or using them properly because they're too lazy to put in the effort of adding more and more context and reviewing and fixing it over and over again until it's forged like steel.

Edit: the comments.. Wow 🤕. It's not an ad (if it was, for what, chatgpt?), and the intent wasn't to be smug. Try putting aside heuristics you think of me, the reality is that I'm a senior PM in a big corp working with two dev teams in a high tempo environment. This PRD is for a small feature for a new dev, and the tools really helped create it, at the end of the day I'm writing what to add, what to remove and finalize the doc. So some people here prove my point with their comments


r/ProductManagement • • Jul 03 '23

Is Product Management a "Real" profession?

2 Upvotes

I was recently at a PM meetup and I got a lot of flack when I said that being a PM is not a predefined profession like being an accountant, or lawyer or developer, that our job is to "be like a liquid that fills in the spaces wherever needed" and that that changes from company to company and even from division to division. This was viewed by some (including some high profile Product Directors) as being defeatist and leading to bad product development, my POV is that we are meant to be "jack of all trades" that focus on what brings the most value to the company and that that can change from time to time and place to place. So what do you think?


r/ProductManagement • • Mar 19 '24

Strategy/Business Prediction: LLM prices will go up in the next year

1 Upvotes

Let me know what you think, product pros.

Hypothesis: LLM prices will go up. Or, in other words, current prices are loss leaders to lock in usage.

Evidence:

  1. OpenAI is plagued by outages. This indicates to me that there is more demand than compute supply, and that means they need to purchases more resources. Hence, prices need to go up.

  2. Apple and Microsoft, despite massive resources in talent, acquisition budget, and compute, have chosen to partner with outside firms for their main LLM effort. This lack of integration (Microsoft is not going to give you AI at the price they pay for it) typically leads to higher prices for consumers.

  3. Nvidia just announced their new AI chip… that costs $30-40k. That’s eye watering, and tells me that they are confident that they can charge more in the future, despite more chip makers entering the AI space.

Outcome: Lots of orgs will need to reassess the AI P&L when prices go up and they feel the squeeze in the next 12-18 months.

Contra:

  1. Lots of companies are ramping up their AI hardware offerings. However, chips are hard. They are planned years out.

  2. Small models (like this) will save us! Maybe, but the research still needs to be proved and implemented, ideally on specialized hardware.

Confidence: 65%

What do you all think?


r/ProductManagement • • Mar 12 '24

Tools & Process Rant: Product Designers and User Interviews

0 Upvotes

I am sitting here eating my lunch, reflecting on the #1 pet peeve I have as a PM. This one started about 15 years ago, and continues to chafe my ass to this day.

I remember the first product designer I ever met. We were assigned to the same team. Same backlog. Same personas. Same same. We sized one another up. Where do you begin and I end? What do you do, vs. me?

While there were overlaps, we eventually landed on some discrete sets of responsibilities. For me, I was deep into the domain, the voice of the customer, the difficult task of setting priorities, cutting scope, negotiating with engineers, and collaborating with sales and marketing on launch plans, etc. The product designer was awesome at distilling my raw requirements and designing a great user journey, along with non-functional prototypes that we could test with internal and external folks.

Sounds like a good separation yes?

Not quite.

The Product Designer, for better or worse, insisted on doing a lot of customer interviews along the way. Ok. No problem. I will listen in ok? Sure.

What a waste of our time. The customers. Mine. Everyone's time. Why? Because the product designer had very little domain expertise. They treat the domain generically, as if they could interview anyone from any domain using the same prompts and techniques.

I say "bullshit." User interviews are all about follow questions. And follow up questions rely on both context, experience, and at least a superficial understanding. Don't believe me? Just ask any good beat journalist.

This unfortunate dynamic has since repeated itself, over, and over, and over again throughout my career in product management. Fortunately, these days, I have enough tenure to guide our team in a direction that makes sense, and prevent pointless user interviews from happening.

So. If you're a product manager in this situation, let me say, dude, I feel you. And if you're a product designer who feels miffed about this misguided rant, let me say, dude, I am sorry. It's just where I'm at.

Peace out friends.


r/ProductManagement • • Mar 26 '25

Substack is a great example of Product lead growth

0 Upvotes

I recently started a newsletter in Substack, and I can say firsthand—they’ve nailed product-led growth. It is a good inspiration as a Product Manager. There are two main ways to grow there either you bring an existing audience from another platform, driving a large crowd to Substack, or you start from scratch and rely on social media promotion, and a bit of crowd selling.

You basically work for them also after that because you create articles that are good for the SEO, send regular emails to activate your users (the newsletters), and then push them into your paying your content for upsales. And next is probably for them to use your content for GenAI training.


r/ProductManagement • • Nov 08 '25

Strategy/Business “Product management is a creator role, not a strategic one”. Do you agree?

1 Upvotes

I was reading this PO vs PM thread on LinkedIn and Marty Cagan chimed in and commented “product management is a creator role, not a strategic role. that is the role of product leadership.”

I’ve never really considered the “management” and “leadership” aspects of the product role as two separate things, ie product management leadership, but it does make sense since in my experience strategy is defined at the exec/director/principal level.

And maybe that’s why IC roles like senior and below get disenfranchised about the more tactical parts and complain about not doing strategy in product management because you won’t actually do that until you reach those higher titles.

Thoughts?


r/ProductManagement • • May 15 '25

What I learned from customer interview in startup

0 Upvotes

After hundreds of customer interviews with gamers, devs, and designers, I realized game players do not just want an AI-powered  game generation tool.

One player said he wanted a no-code platform. But what he really wanted? Admiration from peers when they saw what he’d made.

A board-game fan said digital games weren’t for him. Then lit up at the idea of interactive visual novels —stories that spark creativity and unlock branching narratives.

A narrative designer told me he didn’t need help with dialogue. But then admitted: The endless iteration cycles were crushing his bandwidth.

So what I learn from these customer interviews:

Surface-level questions like “What features do you need?” miss the real motivation.

Voice of Customer Interview is the core of product management.

No more yes/no checkboxes.

Ask deeper prompts like: “How do you spend your weekends?” “Why do you enjoy reading?” “What stops you when you write something?”

Maybe they look non-related to game generation, but we can figure out their deep desire. WHY? Because if we understand the why, we can build something really user-centric.


r/ProductManagement • • Sep 09 '26

Mods can we ban new accounts please?

0 Upvotes

This sub is getting over run by 1 month old bots.


r/ProductManagement • • Jul 18 '26

Tech Has anyone seen “Product agents”?

0 Upvotes

There are coding agents and design agents

Why no product agents?

Unless there is?


r/ProductManagement • • Jan 18 '24

Can someone explain what is scope and how you define it

0 Upvotes

New to Product Management in ecommerce in tech. Keep getting asked for scope by senior leadership for a feature that I pitch. What does scope really mean and how do you define it. Is there a good sample scope document that I can look at.


r/ProductManagement • • Oct 20 '21

Straight male colleague makes 50% more than I do (queer woman)

36 Upvotes

I’ve been furious for weeks since I learned that a male colleague who started at the same time I did, in the same role, and progressed slower than I did is making 50% more than me ($150k vs my $100k). We’re both senior PMs.

While I have colleagues whom I would be happy to learn earn that much, he’s not one of them. He’s passed off my research as his own, is a creep in person (touching women without asking, backing women into corners when chatting them up at happy hours), and is overall smarmy and smug.

I’ve been told by multiple people I’m a better PM and they prefer working with me. I also have taken on more projects and training for the rest of the team. But he’s a bit of a kiss-up and knows how to “work” management and play up the boy’s club aspect with our direct managers, who are men.

I’ve asked for a raise without mentioning him or his compensation, just highlighting my own wins, and was told they can’t increase my salary beyond 15%.

I have a very good relationship with the VP of product, a woman I look up to a lot and is a bit of a mentor for me. I’m wondering whether I should ask her about this discrepancy? Or would that make me look petty?


r/ProductManagement • • Dec 18 '25

How to become an AI Product Manager (practical roadmap + courses + real-world usage)

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for some guidance from folks who are already working as PMs / AI PMs or have made a similar transition.

My background:

  • Business Analyst / Ops & Data role at a visa-tech startup

  • Daily work involves SQL, Excel, dashboards, and automation

  • I already work closely with engineering and leadership on prioritization, impact analysis, and execution

  • Not an ML engineer, but fairly comfortable with data and systems thinking

I’m trying to move intentionally toward an AI Product Manager role - ideally by growing into it within my current job rather than switching companies immediately.


r/ProductManagement • • Nov 13 '25

PMs who can't sketch lol, how do you communicate product ideas to designers?

1 Upvotes

This is embarrassing but I legitimately cannot draw or wireframe to save my life. When I try to explain a feature idea to my designer I end up waving my hands around and saying useless stuff like "it should feel more intuitive" or "can we make this section pop more" and I can see them dying inside.

The problem is I have clear ideas in my head about how something should work but zero ability to create it visually. So there's this constant translation layer where I describe the user problem and hoped outcome but the designer interprets it completely differently than what I was imagining.

Should PMs learn basic design skills? Or is that scope creep and I should just get better at describing things verbally? Or idk is it like gift from god like what?? Feel like this gap makes me way less effective at my job than I could be.


r/ProductManagement • • Apr 09 '26

Tools & Process How do you handle product discovery without a dedicated UX researcher?

0 Upvotes

I've been a PM for 14 years and this is still the thing I see kill products most often. Not bad engineering or ugly design. Skipping discovery.

The root cause: most PMs don't have a UX researcher on their team. You know you should talk to customers. You just don't know what to ask, how to avoid leading questions, or how to turn messy notes into something your VP can act on.

I've tried a bunch of approaches over the years:

  • Teresa Torres's Opportunity Solution Trees (great framework, hard to operationalize alone)

  • Rob Fitzpatrick's Mom Test (changed how I do interviews, but synthesis is still manual)

  • Marty Cagan's Four Risks (good mental model, not a workflow)

Recently I've been experimenting with using AI coding tools to structure the whole process. Frame the hypothesis, generate interview questions, synthesize notes into patterns, package findings for stakeholders.

Curious what this community does. Do you have a repeatable discovery process? Or does it get skipped when there's sprint pressure?


r/ProductManagement • • Dec 14 '21

Unpopular opinion: Job should be offered to the first qualified candidate that meets all criteria; not the best candidate from a pool of candidates after all loops are completed.

0 Upvotes

It's the fastest way to frustrate and lose good candidates. By the time a loop is organized for 3-4 candidates it simply takes too long and any good candidates will move on.


r/ProductManagement • • Jul 23 '22

It is Saturday. How much are you going to think or work on your product?

0 Upvotes

r/ProductManagement • • Oct 24 '25

Learning Resources How to become Product Manager in 2026

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProductManagement • • Sep 04 '26

Dear product owners, why are you designing?

0 Upvotes

As a product designer with 20+ years' experience, im finding that increasingly, product owners are using AI to create desigms, and give them to a designer... perhaps to polish up?

This devalues what design do and is generally pretty insulting.

Why do you do it, and why do you think it's okay?


r/ProductManagement • • Mar 10 '25

Just Promoted to Product Manager - Hello my new peers!

0 Upvotes

(Edit: I have offended some of you and that was not my intention. Let me try to reword my post, but I will keep the original text here for transparency.

I am new here, so I don’t know if this is typical, but after reading several posts on this subreddit, I got the impression that there is a general pessimism being expressed about the PM career path. I do find this troubling, as I just got promoted and was hoping to find some inspiration. I am aware that it is common for people to vent frustrations online more often than they share positive insights. Perhaps I can encourage a variety of people to respond to this post and get an honest, but hopefully more well rounded, assessment of how this community feels about product management in general. Thank you all for your time.)

Ok, so I just got a promotion, but my job has not actually changed. I am the product owner on a scrum team who is building an internal compliance application. My previous title was Sr. Business Process Analyst, and my promotion to Product Manager is really just an acknowledgment of the work I have been doing and a bit of a pay bump.

So I decided to learn more about Product Management as a whole (as my only experience is with Scrum) and that lead me to this subreddit.

Wow, is this a cynical and joyless bunch. At least that is what I have seen in the first few posts I’ve read. I was hoping someone could let me know if product management culture is really like this or if I just happened to stumble across this subreddit on a bad day when people are burned out and letting off steam?

I want to do amazing work that makes the world a better place. Ok, I am building a compliance application and it is pretty boring, but I like the process and I hope to do something more grand in the future.

Am I just fresh faced and naive? Does this role suck all life and joy from all who enter the gates? Let me hear why you all love your jobs and how society is better because of all the work you do.