r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 13 '26

πŸ§ͺ Changed Formula Breyers Ice Cream: The biggest downgrade in ice cream history. It’s not even legally ice cream anymore

Thumbnail
gallery
2.1k Upvotes

I miss those days when Breyers' entire identity rested on its all-natural, four-ingredient recipe: milk, cream, sugar, and vanilla beans.

Today, most of their 'ice creams' don't even legally qualify as ice cream. To cut costs, they pumped the recipe full of corn syrup and gums, quietly rebranding the tubs as "Frozen Dairy Dessert."

Instead of a creamy treat, you get an artificial, gummy paste that eats like frozen Jell-O and refuses to melt in your mouth.

And to make matters worse, they killed off their golden-era legends: the '90s Viennetta cakes, Butter Almond, and the original, real-fruit Peach and Cherry Vanilla formulations.

RIP to an absolute classic.


r/ProductGraveyard • • Jun 04 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued My fingers always hurt trying these

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Mar 16 '26

πŸ“¦ Packaging Downgrade Paperstraws are the biggest scam of this decade

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 08 '26 Regret

πŸ’° Bought Out Pre-Amazon Whole Foods: The absolute peak of grocery shopping, is now just a side hustle for Jeff Bezos

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Remember when Whole Foods felt like a distinct, premium health food store with its own unique vibe? Before the Amazon buyout, it was the go-to spot for niche, local organic finds and a truly independent grocery experience.

Now it's just a Prime delivery warehouse where you can occasionally buy overpriced kale.

RIP Whole Foods (1980-2017) Completely murdered by Amazon.


r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 15 '26 Helpful Heartwarming

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued β€œSnackwells”. Gone but not forgotten. I’ve been thinking of these nonstop recently.

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

I remember stealing these from my grandmas cupboard as a kid. They were so good! I remembered them recently and went searching, just to find out they were discontinued years ago. Now I’m sad.


r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 20 '26

❓ Missing/Removed Feature iPhone features we’ve lost over time, both hardware and software. Which one do you miss most?

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 02 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Carnation Breakfast Bars: The greatest morning cheat code ever invented. Nothing today even comes close.

Thumbnail
gallery
925 Upvotes

Before the aisle was flooded with a hundred identical, chalky protein bars, there was the Carnation Breakfast Bar.

If you grew up in the 80s or 90s, this was the ultimate morning cheat code. They had this incredibly distinct, dense, crunchy texture coated in thick chocolate that melted perfectly if you dipped it in milk.

Ahh miss them.


r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 14 '26

πŸ› οΈ Ruined After Update SoBe drink in the glass bottle

Post image
625 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 06 '26 Bravo

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Planters cheez curls and cheez balls, these were the best snack a 90’s kid could ask for

Post image
611 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Oct 08 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Ritz S'mores

Thumbnail
gallery
523 Upvotes

these things were so good they need to bring it back ! No clue why they discounted these


r/ProductGraveyard • • Oct 12 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Kudos Bars, discontinued in 2017.

Thumbnail
gallery
470 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Jul 08 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Cookies & (2002-200?)

Post image
469 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Oct 05 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Hershey’s Kissables

Thumbnail
gallery
414 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Sep 09 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued WHYYYYYYYYYYY

Thumbnail
gallery
380 Upvotes

The service is from Netflix. Apparently, they had these interactive shows where you’d pick what the characters did. My 3 favorites are Battle Kitty, We Lost Our Human, and Carmen Sandiego:To Steal or Not To Steal. But, and maybe this is old news, they removed them in 2022. WHYYYYYYYYYY?!

I don’t get why they did it as it was their greatest experiment and people LOVED it. It’s STUPID as lots of people loved it. Just keep it


r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 16 '26 Regret

πŸ”» Quality Drop Doc Martens: The boots that survived the 90s, but couldn't survive the 2020s

Thumbnail
gallery
330 Upvotes

It's sad how Doc Martens quality has gone completely downhill. If you compare old pairs vs new ones the difference is depressing. The leather feels like cardboard coated in a layer of plastic, and they start cracking at the creases after just a few months..It's like you're paying a massive premium just for the yellow stitching and the logo at this point.

They used to be boots you'd pass down to your kids, now they're basically disposable. Rip OG Dr Martens


r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 17 '26

πŸͺ¦ π™³πš’πšœπšŒπš˜πš—πšπš’πš—πšžπšŽπš Snapple Elements drinks, RIP. These drinks were so good!

Post image
316 Upvotes

May Snapple rest its soul in general, it’s far from its glory, but these were the best! The earth and rain were my favorites if irc.


r/ProductGraveyard • • Mar 15 '26

πŸ§ͺ Changed Formula I will never forgive Ferrero rocher for ruining Butterfinger

Thumbnail
gallery
314 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Jun 06 '26 This

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Nabisco Suddenly S’mores

Post image
310 Upvotes

Does anyone remember these little gems from the late 80s/early 90s? It was marketed like a s’more that you’d make at a camp fire but they could be heated in the microwave. I tried to recreate them with melting chocolate, marshmallows and Nabisco Lorna Doone cookies several years ago but it wasn’t the same.


r/ProductGraveyard • • Jun 01 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Almost Home Real Chocolate Chip Cookies

Post image
303 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Oct 05 '26

πŸ–οΈ Destination Decline Nickelodeon Suites Resort

Thumbnail
gallery
275 Upvotes

The original hotel opened on July 7, 1999,and was branded the "Holiday Inn Family Suites". At an October 9, 2003 press conference in New York City,Holiday Inn and Nickelodeon announced a partnership and renovation of the hotel, which would transform it into the Nickelodeon Family Suites by Holiday Inn. The announcement followed a two-year deal in which Holiday Inn promoted SpongeBob SquarePants at its locations.

The resort features one-to-three bedroom suites and two waterparks, the Lagoon Pool and Oasis Pool. A "4-D" film theater using SimEx-Iwerks technology, 3,000-square-foot arcade, golf course, multi-level basketball court and family game shows are held at the hotel, and "Nick After Dark" event locations were also previously held at the hotel. The resort formerly contained a shopping area with a Nickelodeon-brand retail shop and a buffet known as the "Nicktoons CafΓ©",among other restaurants. Near the entrance of the resort was a time capsule formerly buried outside the former Nickelodeon Studios complex at nearby Universal Studios Florida.

On January 18, 2021, the debranded Holiday Inn Resort filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy


r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 23 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Giggles Cookies, discontinued in 1990 because they lost popularity.

Post image
273 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Jun 08 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued What discontinued product would instantly make millions if brought back today?

271 Upvotes

r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 16 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued kudos bars πŸ₯² disco'ed in 2017

Post image
268 Upvotes

i loved these bars growing up in the aughts , gone forever ~


r/ProductGraveyard • • Mar 13 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Bring back dumbphones

Thumbnail
gallery
263 Upvotes

We need dumbphones back...smartphones are taking a toll on us.


r/ProductGraveyard • • Apr 19 '26

πŸͺ¦ Discontinued Anyone remember these?

Post image
241 Upvotes

I wanna know why these were discontinued because they absolutely SLAPPED. They had cookie, they had caramel, they had chocolate. They were the perfect little sweet treat