First of all, I'd like to set some context. I run two companies in the UK which use WordPress extensively. The first one (now in its 12th year) is a small digital agency, offering consultancy, training and website development to our (niche) client base. Projects are reasonably big, always bespoke (ie no off the shelf themes, all done from ground up, project managed, "big picture" thinking around strategy, branding, workshops, etc - typical project 6-9 month duration). The second one is a more productised solution for our niche, offering much lower cost WordPress based sites with our own "special sauce" components and functionality, typically (but not always) using GeneratePress and WordPress multisite to deliver.
I have been involved in WordPress development for 10+ years and have thus been watching the development of Gutenberg since the outset.
Our original MO was (like most agencies / individuals I know) to make custom ACF Flexible Content fields. All good - lots of flexibility, but (and I'll come back to this in a moment), lots of control - you could design row by row, test row by row, make sure that everything worked ok across devices - all good. Also lots of options to add new stuff as the client asked for it - although sometimes a bit clunky to have to delve right into what is essentially your own page builder - reasonably ok to support and design / develop for.
With Gutenberg we (again, like many agencies) held off for a bit - the initial Gutenberg was pretty terrible but after a couple of years it had matured enough to be practical for large and reasonably complex sites. With it came some pretty major concerns that I have talked through with fellow agency owners - and in fact got looped in to Matt Mullenweg at one point - but basically these concerns (as I say, not just me but for pretty much everyone I've spoken to) revolve around issues of freedom and design control and, correspondingly, audience. Gutenberg (certainly at first - it's a bit better now but not 100% solid) gives unprecedented levels of control to your site editors. Even at its most locked down - as in, turning off pretty much all blocks, the "block locking" options available - it's still relatively easy to - frankly - really badly balls up a page. All it takes is a copy-paste from one of the hundreds of (sometimes - really bad) block / block pattern sites, or even from another page on the same site - and your whole page falls apart - it's literally Frankendesign, a hotch-potch with no visual purpose at all.
Although the editing experience is much more fluid now (images are a dream compared to previous iterations, copy-paste is a joy when populating a big site, etc etc), these layout issues are considerable. With full "lock-down" they can be bearable - but still - I don't think anyone would argue that what you want your clients to have is full control over their site. They're not designers, they're not tech people - they're (in my 20+ year experience anyway!) people who want to edit their content which is, after all what a content management system is actually about - managing content... You don't want them to have access to change the site fonts or colours, in the same way building in controls to move the logo from the left side to right is almost always a waste of time because it is extremely rare that anyone wants to do that...
And then... here comes FSE.
Now - I've tried really hard to understand who this is pitched at. Is it the "Wix / Squarespace" market - in other words, lowest possible denominator - ie "business owners" who now don't need to go and employ a designer or developer - guys with agencies or running single-person WP houses seem remarkably redundant in this world, and although it is arguably cheaper for the end user - it isn't necessarily easier. Like - in this world, surely you'd just recommend wordpress.com which has not only all these tools but also does the irritating hosting / maintenance / etc side of things...?
Or - is it that us agency / design & dev individuals are literally now supposed to design in the browser, lock down everything then save out using the Create Block Theme plugin?
Does the core development team really think that end-users understand concepts around styling a page, implications around layout when thinking about block styles, padding, margins, grids? Let alone theme.json or the wider, more complex picture stuff like global styles vs local ones? The clients I work with want to make things bold and maybe add a link and an image - they have zero concept (and why would they...) of what a "cascading style sheet" even is, let alone how to use one.
I would really appreciate anyone's thoughts on this. I just don't understand, strategically, where and why WordPress is heading in this direction. What worries me most is that what seems to be the core motivation: give everyone more control is actually a dangerous simplification of reality. I don't want to think that the core team is ploughing ahead making things just because they can rather than because they should - but, honestly, I don't see much evidence that there is deeper thinking going on.
Would love - genuinely - to be proved wrong, and would love to understand everyone else's thoughts on this. Apologies for the insanely long post, too ;-)