r/ProWordPress • u/modmuse91 • Sep 16 '20
Pro WordPress “devs” using page builders—a rant
Basically the title, but I’ve been hired on as a consultant with a web dev firm. During the interview, they said a previous dev used page builders so a lot of their sites use them. I said that was ok, but any site built by me would not, which they said was fine.
Turns out, the previous consultant convinced the owners page builders are best, and the owners have been acting as designers/developers, using page builders exclusively (one seems to know how to code, but also didn’t know how to do a minor change in woocommerce, so who knows).
All I can think is, wtf (excuse my French) is this garbage? I am so over people trying to take the easy (aka cheap) way out, resulting in lazy, glitchy sites, then complaining about it, just to be shocked when custom coding something takes longer. And to call yourself a pro while doing so? What a damn disgrace.
48
u/Saltyigloo Sep 16 '20
Ok please don't automatically down vote this. Page builders get stuff done fast. What is business? Is it about giving the best possible product or increasing the bottom line. Let's be real, page builders are not horrible 100% of the time. They offer the business owners a way of accomplishing a goal fast and for less money.
Yes a fully custom coded site will preform better, be more stable, less maintenance, more secure (possibly).
However it will take like double the time to bring together. Of course there is a place for custom sites. But please do not say there is no place for page builders. I agree if someone is paying 2k+ for a site it should be custom coded. However for the little guys, that just is to much money.
Custom coded sites cost more, that's all there is to it.
I really do not like "code elitists" it's like saying BMWs are the only good cars.
I really think there are pros and cons to both methods of accomplishing the goal of a website. But please try and change my mind.
14
u/yurtcityusa Sep 17 '20
Our agency can't do custom for anything less than $10,000 cad. For under 10k you are getting the ui/ux person adding content and using a page builder and a dev making any tweaks, finishing touches and launching the site.
17
u/Saltyigloo Sep 17 '20
That's what I'm saying. Stick a 70k a year ui guy on a project or a few 100k+ a year coders and a ui guy on it. Business is about the bottom line. If there's glitches a few months later, great, more food for my family. Make that maintenance contract seem worth it. I'm sorry but that's just the reality at the moment, gone are the days of no page builders, the cat is out of the bag.
Covering head in preparation for the downvote storm
6
u/yurtcityusa Sep 17 '20
Although that is one way to look at it I wouldn't go that far.
I must also say 80% of our projects are custom wp sites with budgets well over 20k about 10% is new or fun stuff like headless cms with wordpress or strapi or web apps react custom shopify etc... and the other 10% is client has 10k and is demanding their site should be something like apple and Airbnb... They know the owner personally and they are as tight as a ducks arse. Get the content into a theme they like with a page builder and start hacking away at it.
It always goes over budget.
2
u/modmuse91 Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
Ok, but then be upfront about it. Because I guarantee you they’re still charging clients custom site rates, and most clients are not educated enough to know the difference.
To me, it seems like a good way to rip people off. Instead of saying “look, we can do this fast with this tool, which is generally bloated, can be glitchy, will probably break down the line and will definitely need more maintenance and updating, or we can do it slow, make it solid, lightweight and as light on future maintenance as possible. Which would you prefer?” Some will still say fast but I promise you many would say slow, and recognize the value of high quality. I mean, why be in the business of churning out garbage? I’d rather code 12 sites a year and have them be incredible than 120 and have maybe 30 of them (if I’m being extra, extra generous) be ok, with the rest still needing ongoing maintenance.
Maybe I’m a purist, but 95% of my sites have 3 plugins: Wordfence, WooCommerce, and ACF. I’ve coded my own theme that’s flexible enough where I code custom widgets into the theme and build out flexibility that way. I’ve literally not once had a client come to me because something is “broken” because of a new page builder or Wordpress update, and that’s how I’d like to keep it. To each their own, but if the only way you know how to code is through a page builder, you’re not a developer. Sorry.
1
u/yurtcityusa Sep 17 '20
You ever try timbr with acf? Vastly improved our workflow and time for custom builds.
1
u/modmuse91 Sep 17 '20
I haven’t! I don’t really like using anything that writes code for me (template engines included) and my time for custom builds is generally under a week so I feel pretty good about build time with my system.
1
u/_____jamil_____ Sep 17 '20
i agree with you entirely.
wordpress may not be the best system for you, for this reason
1
u/o0MSK0o Sep 17 '20
Is there any advantage to using timbr over using roots/sage? That uses blade and has controller classes so it also allows for separate logic and markup.
I see a lot of people who like timbr so I was curious about why it seems more popular than sage.
1
2
u/dirtyoldbastard77 Sep 17 '20
I use both. Used to only code everything, but... Well, I have figured out that for some jobs the budget just dont allow customcoding everything - and for many jobs there is really just no need for it
5
u/MyWorkAccountThisIs Sep 17 '20
Super late - but you're right.
I'm a "real" dev. Along with Laravel, Symfony, and Drupal I've code bespoke WP sites by the dozens. Just in case I needed to show my credentials.
My company priced themselves out of most WP work. They decided to recapture it by leveraging a builder. As a dev - I was skeptical.
What am I? Just a button clicker now?
But, after so many years in the industry I know that my dislike of something is almost always attributed to not fully understanding it. So I leaned into it.
Turned out I don't miss making themes. Fuck is it boring.
Another thing I found was creating a custom module for the builder was not only way easier and quicker than a plugin it offered way more functionality.
I would knock out the base theme in a couple days and the rest of my time was spent making features and functionality. You know - the thing that adds business value.
We also taught the client how to use it. And they did. It was a really great experience every time I used it.
Performance? Without doing anything sites were scoring in the high 80s with Lighthouse. Throw in a CDN and a little minification and you got a pretty darn good site.
8
u/MasterK999 Sep 17 '20
This is very accurate. I am sick of so-called WordPress Pros who shit on people who do things differently from them.
In principal I agree that page builders are not ideal but they are a tool and sometimes the right tool for the job.
I build websites for small to medium sized industrial businesses. Project costs can range from $2500 to $25,000. If I build a client a site for the low end of the range and they want the ability to make changes themselves then a page builder is the right tool for the job. I don't care what snob devs think.
4
u/DirtzMaGertz Sep 17 '20
The problem is that most low end customers and small business owners can't change things themselves with page builders. When clients are saying they want to be able to change things themselves, a lot of them are mainly just thinking about updating titles, content, and pictures on things, in which case you may as well just use ACF and your own theme because the product will be better.
4
u/MasterK999 Sep 17 '20
I am not sure who your clients are but I have many, many clients that find it very easy to use page builders after a quick 15 min session where we walk them though it.
However this line of discussion is irrelevant. You do what is best for your clients and I will do what is best for mine. I would never argue otherwise.
4
u/DirtzMaGertz Sep 17 '20
Honestly, a lot of my clients are people who are unsatisfied with their page builder websites and think that the original dev charges too much for changes for what they offer.
I understand that people want to bang out lower end sites fast, but I think a lot of times it is a short sighted goal because the quality of the product offered tends to suffer. I would be very interested to see what the retention rate of these customers that are receiving page builder websites is after a year of using them, because I seem to run into a lot of people that are rebuilding their sites and don't want to use their original dev that set it up.
There is definitely a segment of clients that a page builder suits and clients who want one, but I think a lot of people would be better offer just building a standardized theme to use for a lot of these lower price clients instead of shoving a page builder on them.
2
u/MasterK999 Sep 17 '20
I cannot speak to anyone else but my client retention rate is crazy high. I Currently manage 81 WordPress sites for clients. I have had one go out of business during COVID and one company was sold and left. That is my only client losses in the last 2 years. I usually add 2 per quarter.
Honestly most of the clients moving to a new dev you refer to seem based not on the page builder but of bad devs. If you bang out a crappy site then clients will not be happy.
I build quality sites no matter what the backend details are. The page builder is irrelevant if the site is of high quality, has good speed and proper SEO.
No matter what some purists might say all of these goals are not impossible to achieve with a page builder.
3
u/DirtzMaGertz Sep 17 '20
Are you using page builders for a majority of those sites? Mind sharing what you use for hosting and what page builders you use?
Like I said, there is definitely a section of clients that they are appropriate for and that want them, but I think that section of clients is probably smaller than a lot of people claim. I've used generate press before for smaller things but generally have had pretty bad experiences with other similar page builders and themes.
2
u/MasterK999 Sep 17 '20
Not the majority at all. Just a handful when the client wanted or needed it.
I would agree that the clients that "need" it is smaller than people say. I was not really arguing numbers. I was saying that each job should be evaluated on its merit.
2
u/DirtzMaGertz Sep 17 '20
Makes sense. If you were to recommend a page builder, which one would it be?
2
u/MasterK999 Sep 17 '20
Probably Elementor however I have also used WP Bakery Visual Composer which many people seem to hate but a couple of clients love.
2
u/empireoflight Sep 17 '20
I wonder if you've done much maintenance or bug fixing on PB sites. Or if you've had to redesign a client's site that was built on a PB. I have to believe you haven't, because as soon as you do, you understand why there's so hatred for them.
-2
u/nolo_me Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
it's like saying BMWs are the only good cars.
No, it's like saying someone changing a wheel by referring to Car Maintenance for Dummies is not a mechanic or someone using a self-serve photo printing kiosk is not a darkroom technician.
10
u/Saltyigloo Sep 16 '20
Ok so is this an argument about what people call themselves? Because the guy probably changed the tire ok, and the photographer probably got the pictures developed.
God please can strictly hand code people just retract their claws. I'm not trying to start a fight, I've just noticed that this issue is very toxic. If everyone just put away thier egos we would all be better off.
3
u/jorgeagh Sep 17 '20
Oh wow, I agree with you about the use cases... This is indeed a very toxic topic lol. But just reading through the comments, I'm super interested in learning new ways to move about my business. First off, I'll look into a boilerplate theme. Then uh... Headless WP? I've developed "by hand" in the past, up to creating a fully functional web app (not with WP tho) and tried page builders. They're honestly not half as devilish as these threads make them sound I think, but I'm not sure...
-3
u/nolo_me Sep 16 '20
It's not "toxic" to point out that someone using a self service tool aimed at end users isn't the same as a skilled professional.
And don't you fucking dare come at me with that holier than thou bullshit about putting away egos and not looking for a fight. If you don't want to antagonise the professionals maybe you should stop misrepresenting yourself as one and put in the time necessary to learn how to do a professional quality job.
It's not fucking rocket science, anyone with half a brain is capable of learning how. That's why it boils my piss when bodgers strut around like Dunning-Kruger personified insisting that they can deliver the same results without bothering to learn.
7
u/Saltyigloo Sep 17 '20
Like I said I'm not looking for a fight dude.
Very professional cursing me out like I'm a complete discrase to society. You seem like the type of person I'd want to hire 100%
-4
u/nolo_me Sep 17 '20
You don't get to do something offensive then hand-wave it away by saying you're not looking for a fight; that's like saying "No offence but you're a cunt. Hey, you can't get annoyed - I said 'no offence'".
I can use whatever language I want, I'm off the clock. And sorry, I screen my clients very carefully.
5
u/Saltyigloo Sep 17 '20
I said that because of exzactly how you responded to me lol, I just wanted to address a problem I see with wordpress. Hand coders absolutely freak out at people for useing off the shelf solutions. Anyway I guess I'll never change it. Have a good one anyway.
2
u/nolo_me Sep 17 '20
There's nothing wrong with people using off the shelf solutions instead of hiring a professional, that's what they're there for. What's deeply offensive is charlatans who pass themselves off as professionals but use those same end user tools because they don't have a clue how to do it properly. Their victims end up paying for the same job twice when someone has to step in and fix their hamfisted bodging and they bring the whole profession into disrepute.
-7
u/DanielTrebuchet Developer Sep 16 '20 edited Sep 16 '20
Yes a fully custom coded site will preform better, be more stable, less maintenance, more secure (possibly).
Correct.
Page builders have no place in a professional development environment. Period. It's the equivalent of a wedding photographer using a camera phone to shoot a wedding. Sure, you get pictures at the end of the day, but it's backyard quality and should not be considered a professional product. Don't ever pay someone to photograph a wedding using a camera phone. Don't ever pay someone to build you a site with a page builder.
Page builders are great for people that want to try to build their own sites. That's quite frankly their purpose. But to use a tool like that for a paying client is inexcusable to me. You can either afford a professional website, or you have tools like page builders to build it yourself. Paying someone to build a page builder site should not be an option.
I've had clients pay thousands for garbage page builder brochure sites. Crap like that is incredibly prolific in this industry and it makes us all look bad.
As far as the "fast" claim as a benefit of page builders... who cares? I don't see why people use that argument. I can take a new client and have a fully custom site designed and developed in a week or two. If you can't wait a week or two for a high quality product, I'm not sure what to tell you. If I'm using one of my boilerplate themes I can knock a site out in a day. How much faster do you need than that?
Know what I do for low-budget clients? I have a basic boilerplate theme I've developed that I can customize in a matter of minutes. They still end up with a high quality product for cheap, but don't have to deal with the bloat and all the downsides of a page builder (and the inevitable sea of 3rd party plugins that come with it).
Page builders are not professional tools. They are tools for novices and the unskilled. I've been in this industry for 15+ years... I have never heard one single valid argument in favor of page builders in a professional development environment. I can create a custom solution just as fast and just as cheap as anyone selling page builder garbage, but the end results are worlds better in all measurable ways.
2
0
u/MarchesaCasati Sep 17 '20
There are literally professional photographers that have moved from Film to DSLR to iPhone. Most often, all of these formats have been processed with Adobe Photoshop. It's not always about the tool, results are what matter.
0
u/nolo_me Sep 17 '20
Those are people who learned how to use a DSLR first and are making an informed choice to use an iPhone for some things, not people who use an iPhone because they don't know how to use a DSLR which is what we're talking about here.
0
u/DirtzMaGertz Sep 17 '20
It's a bitch to shoot RAW on phones so using an iphone for professional jobs sounds ridiculous to me. The designers and photographers I work with would never use a phone for a professional job they were hired for.
16
u/wranne Sep 17 '20
When we have issues with page builders we don’t throw them out, we develop them. A page builder you can bend to your will is an incredibly powerful tool and is exactly what’s happening with Gutenberg.
3
u/key-bored-warrior Sep 17 '20
Gutenberg is a step in the right direction and will hopefully spell the end of page builders. ACF flexible content fields also do a much better job
1
4
u/JohnLocke84 Sep 16 '20
Imagine the faces of a lot of our clients when we said ... - We use WP as headless -
4
u/nizzok Sep 17 '20
Look, at some point it’s about efficiency and time is money. There’s no hill worth dying on for purity of code. Why reinvent the wheel every time you sit down? In theory, a “Pro” should be able to make a good product regardless. The issues you mention “choppy” sites, that is bad, but the builders themselves are a symptom not the cause. The choppy-ness is from someone using a builder and not polishing, laziness.
3
u/mar_sa Sep 16 '20
Congrats on the job, so tell me this in your opinion what is the best practice(workflow) and tools to build a efficient clean WP site?
3
u/teszeract Sep 17 '20
One thing I'll comment on: I really like keeping content, markup, presentation & logic all separate from each other.
Gutenberg with Lazy Blocks is making this pretty easy for me. If a cllient needs to edit a bit of content - media, text etc - I wouldn't want them to need to stumble around a pagebuilders' complexities. With Gutenberg & custom blocks (doesn't have to be Lazy Blocks) we can some pretty clean and safe edit screens.
I would use siteorigin on occasion, as a block within Gutenberg, and sparingly as possible. It's the one builder that seems stable and not too ambitious. Most of the other pagebuilders end up combining the markup, content and presentation (css) into a frightful frankenstein of a workflow.
-4
u/MarcReymon Sep 16 '20
I’ll respond with my simple answer: headless Wordpress for the CMS + Frontity for the front end. It’s a trillion times faster and more efficient.
15
u/DanielTrebuchet Developer Sep 16 '20
Headless WP is powerful and definitely has its place. There's no denying it. But I would say it's a stretch to go so far as to suggest that it's the appropriate solution for the majority of sites. I would argue that it absolutely is not, but that's admittedly my opinion and I'm open to the idea.
2
u/rmccue Core Contributor Sep 17 '20
Strongly agree, and I spend an inordinate amount of time convincing people that headless is not always the solution. There's a huge amount of complexity that comes with it, and that's only appropriate if the benefits outweigh the costs. Even at our scale (enterprise), it's still far from an easy decision.
2
3
u/iamadrunk_scumbag Sep 17 '20
Umm gutenberg is a page builder no? It's here to stay. The client knows next to nothing most of the time and doesn't want to know that's why you were hired.
2
u/krautgamer Sep 17 '20
The difference between "WordPress Development" and "WordPress Implementation" has to be communicated more.
There is nothing inherently bad about using page builders, if you're upfront about it. And if you know the possible downsides of the approach.
Same thing with code. I've seen a lot of horrible custom themes, where the page would have been fine with a page builder.
The key is to educate and communicate. And to know the fact that if you're not writing actual code your're much rather a "WordPress Implementor" than a "WordPress Developer".
2
u/KrashKartMedia Sep 18 '20
I've been doing WordPress support since 2011. What I can tell you is that everybody has their opinions and you just have to work with it. Sometimes I really don't like debugging page builders. But you can never fault somebody for wanting to use something. especially because you don't know if that's all they could afford or if they really just believe in the product. Either way it's not wrong.
I now work for a hosting company. You won't believe how many of the big names use page builders. Get used to it. Start supporting it. It will only make you a better developer. Because you know how to do something multiple ways. That makes you valuable.
I used to work for a pretty big WordPress development agency. When I left they were starting to look into a couple builders.
-6
u/DanielTrebuchet Developer Sep 16 '20
I wish I had the words to express how much I hate page builders and all the countless issues I've inherited because of them. Are they great for aunt Martha who wants to build herself a brochure site for her quilting hobby on the side? Absolutely! Perfect! Nothing better for her than a page builder.
But page builders have absolutely no place in a professional development environment. It's like a wedding photographer using a camera phone to shoot a wedding. It's like hiring an excavation crew that shows up with a plastic shovel instead of a back hoe. It's like hiring a mechanic that only know his way around a screw driver and a buffing wheel. It's simply not a professional tool, period, and just because you can overcharge a client for a site built with one doesn't make it such. Just because it can perform a task, doesn't mean it's performing the task the way it should be done, or the way a paying client deserves.
Page builders have their place. That place is nowhere near a professional development environment.
The people defending page builders are obviously not the ones who have to pick up the pieces in a year when either a) the site gets hacked because all the plugins fell out of date and a security vulnerability was exploited, or b) the client realizes they need to change things up or update the functionality of a site and the original drag and drop jockey that cobbled the POS together has not the slightest idea how to address any of that.
No shit, I just wrapped up a project for a client who came to me not even 1 month after their page builder site was completed. It was super slow, super clunky, and when they told their "web guy" that they wanted to add 15,000 pages of content he looked at his page builder and shit a brick. Said there was no way WP could even handle that many pages... what a clown.
3
u/modmuse91 Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
This is just like one of the projects this firm just had me do. I refused to use the page builder for the responsive design (it also couldn’t, because glitches, no shocker), and they were genuinely upset it took me 10 hours to code the responsive design for the site, which has two different layouts for two different languages. Like, absolutely nuts. If I didn’t need the money, I’d quit. I might still anyway, since they’re already laying on the pressure to either “go faster” or use a page builder (because apparently they come with responsive design built in...even though they literally just had me code in responsive code for one because it obviously does not). The irony.
-3
u/nolo_me Sep 17 '20
Looks like similar clowns are downvoting you out of insecurity. This is what you end up with in a skilled profession without a professional standards body. Cowboys and frauds everywhere.
12
u/dietcheese Developer Sep 17 '20
Or, some of us are mature enough to realize that page builders have their place, just as custom-built sites do.
4
u/iamadrunk_scumbag Sep 17 '20
Thank you. There is no one size fits all situations. They hire us to make the call for them.
0
u/nolo_me Sep 17 '20
And their place is a DIY solution for end users who don't have the skillset to develop a site for themselves. Nothing to do with maturity.
0
u/Bryn26 Sep 17 '20
Oxygen Builder is not like the rest. Give it a try. Lean output, designed to blend code and components, amazing community of skilled devs, excellent addons like Advanced Scripts and Hydrogen, disables the WP theme framework and more. I haven't come across a better middle-ground for custom development and cost-effective workflow.
0
u/ListenToMeCalmly Sep 17 '20
This is a typical example why devs exist, and are separate from CEOs and sales. Because while the dev is good at building stuff, his job is not to do business analytics. Because he is not very good at it. This is a great example.
Imagine a client get two offers: A) We can accomplish what you need. It will cost $5000.
B) We can accomplish what you need. It will cost $10,000 because we don't like to build in a specific way.
The job as an agency is to make money. The agency offering B will earn $0. You are telling me you are B. Because A is more attractive to most clients.
The job as an agency is to earn money. The classic way is to offer cost effective solutions of sufficient quality.
3
u/key-bored-warrior Sep 17 '20
A decent agency doesn’t need to justify the costs because the results speak for themselves and clients understand that. It’s like everything, yea you can get it cheaper but that doesn’t always make it better. Some people understand this, some people don’t.
1
u/DirtzMaGertz Sep 17 '20
Except there is huge pool of clients willing to pay for quality services so it's not worth the time for Agency B to chase low end jobs.
2
u/ListenToMeCalmly Sep 17 '20
It's an equally large pool of clients who don't have such a budget. There is a need for cost effective solutions. If there wasn't, page builders wouldn't exist.
1
u/DirtzMaGertz Sep 17 '20
It's not exactly costly to build a standard theme or re-use parts you've already written. I know I wouldn't feel good about getting 5k to hand over a page builder website. Maybe for simple things under 1k but if someone is paying over 2000 for you to build them a website, I think they expect to have some decent longevity out of that site and I don't think that handing over a site with a bloated front end is a very good solution and it's bad for any SEO they are hoping to build. It's also a nightmare to ever redesign a site that uses a page builder and usually results in trying to migrate the data to an entirely new build.
I think using page builders for anything but the most simple and cheapest jobs is short sighted. It's a lesser quality product because you wanted to cut costs and I think long term most clients end up out growing those sites and getting them rebuilt.
0
Sep 17 '20
[deleted]
3
u/key-bored-warrior Sep 17 '20
I totally agree with you but the point I got from the OP is that someone who uses a page builder can hardly be called or refer to themselves as a pro. Garbage coders may be garbage but at least they are writing the code and that makes them 1 step above a page builder still
0
Sep 17 '20
[deleted]
1
u/key-bored-warrior Sep 17 '20
I’m not saying that, it does matter. It matters a lot and if you have ever had to deal with garbage code then I’m sure you know as well. What I’m saying is that at least they wrote code themselves (or attempted too) and didn’t just configure a few settings then called them selves a developer or worse still, a pro developer.
How do you make your themes, do you use a page builder or do you write the code yourself? Page builders have a place and do a job but when you are looking to make a site that converts and performs well then they have no place in that kind of situation.
It’s also frustrating to me that I have spent years becoming a fairly decent developer and learning how to do it and it’s kind of an insult for someone to come along with Elementor Pro and put a site together and call themselves a developer.
0
7
u/tw2113 Developer Sep 17 '20
Are you and the team you're a part of going to be part of the project long term? If not, then maybe a page builder is a *good enough* idea, because you're not going to be on hand to help with every detail for your custom build/solution. It's not *just* about the initial build, it's about anyone who may have to come in afterwards to help out, and ultimately it's about what's best for the client themselves.
That said, I'm not saying choose the worst page builder just because it is *a* page builder. Make an educated decision on which to use, if chosen to do that. Also, adjust the rates/charges based on this. If it's a small business with a small budget, this is a viable option. If it's a large client that has the budget, aim for a higher, custom solution.
It really all depends on a lot of details, in ideal situations.