r/ProMusicProduction • • Jan 16 '26

Why modern music tools still suck at structure (Scaler, Toontrack, Logic, Reaper)

2 Upvotes

I’ve been stuck for a long time trying to solve something that most music tools pretend doesn’t exist: musical structure.

And I know you will tell me to use references and marks, but read first.

Scaler 3?

Great for harmony. Zero help for form. It gives me chord progressions, not a song. Bricks without architecture. Should I try Ez Keys? Addictive Keys?

Toontrack (EZdrummer / Superior)?

This is the closest thing we have to structure. Intros, verses, pre-chorus, chorus, bridges. But it comes with a cost: it freezes my intent. You inherit someone else’s sense of flow, tension, and resolution. It works, but it often feels soulless or overly “correct”.

Now DAWs.

Logic Pro’s Global Tracks (Arrangement, Markers, Tempo)?

Useful, but shallow. They label sections, they don’t think about them. There’s no guidance on proportion, energy curves, repetition vs variation, or why a chorus should exist at all.

Reaper?

Incredibly powerful, incredibly neutral. It gives you absolute freedom — which means zero structural intelligence. You’re on your own unless you already know exactly what you’re doing.

The real issue:

Modern tools are obsessed with timbre generation, not form generation.

I don’t want more chords. I don’t want more MIDI packs. I don’t want more loop packs.

I want help answering questions like:

- Why does this section exist?

- What is its role in tension and release?

- How long should it last relative to the whole?

- When should repetition become boredom?

Curious if anyone here has found workflows or tools that actually help with form, not just notes. And if you see that I am lacking musical theory it's because I don't have any.


r/ProMusicProduction • • Sep 01 '24

Question What do you think makes Professional producers "Professional"?

1 Upvotes

Hi, I these days have a doubt about what is the difference between "Professional" called Producers and other random Producers?. What do you think they have so special, is it only experience and placement? or is there something more to it?


r/ProMusicProduction • • Nov 25 '23

Best Studio Monitors For Mixing/Mastering For Cars Specifically

0 Upvotes

I can’t really explain the specific reason why I need studio monitors that are best for cars (like ones you’d use to make music that sounds good in the car, not studio monitors you’d place in a car). Just know I need monitors that are best for cars. If they sound terrible in headphones or in a club, I don’t care. I just need them to sound good in a car.

If anyone has any specific recommendations on a pair of monitors they know of that are best for simulating what sounds good in a car I’d greatly appreciate it.

Any additional advice on how to mix and master for car systems would also be greatly appreciated. Thanks!


r/ProMusicProduction • • Sep 08 '26

I'm so sick of this. I quite then start and then quit again.

4 Upvotes

Okay this is a longer post but not sure what else to do at this point.

I have been music producing for about 6 years now. I have so many plug ins and a fender strat. with a Scarlett 2i2 and UAD Volt now with Logic Pro. I am trying to get into Pop rock music production. I think I get down pretty good concepts laid down, and sure enough when i pull up another track it hits me.

"wow my song is so freaking weak and stupid compared to this. I would much rather listen to someone else track other than mine."

Then I go down the frequency spectrum rabbit hole. Oh well Ill boost 1k cause that's what I think I hear....oh i'll change my amp preset and then tweak it for my electric guitars....Oh well my electric guitars do not come anywhere close to the reference track...in fact neither does my bass.....or drums.....or anything....

Just to be clear. I am not saying my plug ins are at fault

It makes want to scratch the entire song. The worst feeling in the world is spending months on a track only for it to be, "not good enough". Also when one part of the tack you truly believe in sounds exactly how you want it to sound and its super professional....for about 1 second...and then you play the reference track and it blows it out of the water. I have watch tutorial after tutorial talked to person after person. The creative feeling is almost like I cant scratch the itch I want to. I want to make something I am proud of something that I have poured months of time into and it sound the way I want.

Now let me be clear. I am sure creatives are not ever satisfied with the thing they create 100%. I have even heard that Hanz Zimmer said he is still waiting to create the perfect song. And we all know he already has. Anyway, I need help. Im so close but yet so far to the things I have worked so hard for. Please help....

EDIT: After 6 years, I have heard it all. Its not about plug ins. Use your ears, don't over process


r/ProMusicProduction • • Aug 05 '25

Business I am thinking in take a Musical Production course in Portugal Porto

0 Upvotes

I am thinking of diving deep into music production, capturing, mixing, and mastering to start my second business with that. In Portugal, they listen to hip hop, rock, etc. I create modern boom-bap hip-hop and trap. But I want to know how to mix rock, jazz, and classical. I have a home studio and some experience. My other business is clinical psychology; I like to do different things.

In professional experience, you can earn a good income by working in pro studios and doing some work from home for other clients, following my own rules.


r/ProMusicProduction • • Sep 09 '22

UK Garage Production Hub

0 Upvotes

Hi all producers!

I hope everyone is well.

I have just recently started a sub reddit that I hope will help those who produce UK Garage, Breaks, and Bassline. The main purpose of the community is for UKG producers to share tips, works in progress, and generally just meet like minded people :) So far I can't see any reddit page dedicated that focusses on UKG production.

If this sounds like your thing I have included a link below.

https://www.reddit.com/r/UKG_Production_Hub/

Anyway thanks for reading and I hope to see you in the community.

Ant


r/ProMusicProduction • • Jan 06 '25

How do I get pro at compression

0 Upvotes

I’m an experienced music producer, releasing music at a professional level. Recently, I’ve been focusing more on mixing. While I feel comfortable with most processes, compression is the one area I haven’t fully mastered yet. I use a lot of saturation and re-amping, which naturally compresses my signal, so I typically only reach for a compressor when I need to clean up or tame peaks. However, I know there’s so much more to explore with compression. Does anyone know of any in-depth resources for mastering compression or have personal tips they could share? Thanks in advance!


r/ProMusicProduction • • Jun 19 '23

How Long Did It Take You to Start Making Songs after you Started Learning

0 Upvotes

I'm currently learning how to use primarily Logic Pro to produce music for myself (I'm an artist and learning how to produce to better express myself in my work and have more control) and sometimes I will dabble with Ableton live lite (for now until I can upgrade to the full version). I will say I'm still a novice. How long did it take you to start making full songs (including mixing and mastering yourself) when you started learning music production? Do you have any tips and tricks for me? advice? How many hours a week should I put into learning music production with a DAW like Logic Pro to start producing full songs on my own that are mixed and mastered by myself? Thanks!


r/ProMusicProduction • • Oct 08 '24

Question Should I get a silicon Macbook pro?

0 Upvotes

I'm looking at getting a silicon MacBook pro but not sure if I should spend so much money.

I feel some context is needed so this might be a long post.

I've been working as an audio post production engineer for just over a year and I'm loving it but I still like to make music in my spare time. I work from home on a company Aplle Mac Pro which I also use for my music (I have my own i5 intel laptop from 2018 but It's been giving me problems recently, that's why i use the work computer). My main problem is that my work computer only has 512 GB storage, which runs out very quickly when installing pro tools, all the necessary plugins I use for work and my personal DAW (cubase) and my own plugins which I've bought. I want to separate my stuff from work and also try out Logic pro. Because of this, I've been looking at getting my own silicon MacBook pro. I have enough in savings to buy a refurbished one with 32gb Ram but only 512 GB storage (would really like 1TB but haven't been able to find one in my price range, might get an external SSD to store all my projects) but feel uneasy about making such a big purchase, mainly because I'm not sure how far I'll go with music (stay a hobbyist forever while i work in post production or transition into music full time)

Should I just go for it? Or are there better, more affordable alternatives for someone in my situation?

Sorry for the long post, I feel this is a somewhat unique situation that needs some solid advice.


r/ProMusicProduction • • 11d ago

Question Is it possible to make a really professional record completely ITB?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I hope you're all doing well.

I've been a singer and music artist-producer for a long time, and I'm still in the middle of the process of trying to make records that truly sound professional ITB (In The Box). That means making music without using all those highly expensive hardware synths, EQs, compressors, and FX units.

After 10 years in this beautiful realm of music production and audio engineering, I'm starting to feel like I'm just chasing clouds. Here's my situation: I have a lot of plugins installed on my computer, and I'm starting to feel like they all sound pretty similar and give you the same result. Because of this, I'm restraining myself from buying new ones.

At the moment, I'm stuck at a point where I can't move forward. I don't know how to get more knowledge. I know there's a lot of free content on the internet and a lot of masterclasses, but they only go so far. They are all based on materials that you can tell have already been processed or have excellent quality beforehand. I just can't find masterclasses, videos, or other resources that actually teach you things from the very beginning.

So again my question is.

Am I just chasing clouds?

I'd love to know your thoughts

Finished song

https://m.soundcloud.com/isach-567287514/ipn-evolution-extended-mix/s-l1Z86x7vKir?si=8ee944797bd54703adffb0e9c1d4b75b&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing

Work in progress

https://m.soundcloud.com/isach-567287514/id-june-3-2024-v2-new/s-Q0kZqNRl91g?si=7b01a82ca7334360a8c372210fdf448d&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing


r/ProMusicProduction • • Feb 03 '26

Do you prefer working with raw WAV rhythms or MIDI when producing groove-based music?

0 Upvotes

Lately I’ve noticed that a lot of rhythm loops sound exciting on first listen, but once you start arranging vocals and harmonies, they fight the mix.

Personally, I’ve found that less-processed, performance-based WAV rhythms tend to sit better, especially when the groove is part of the arrangement rather than decoration.

Curious how others here approach this:
Do you prefer raw WAV material you shape yourself, or MIDI-based rhythms you fully control?


r/ProMusicProduction • • Oct 05 '26

Vocal chains

0 Upvotes

I am trying to find the best vocal chain rap and then for rnb what are the vocal chains you use . I am a fl studio user for now but moving to pro tools very soon.


r/ProMusicProduction • • Oct 14 '26

what is this sub about

0 Upvotes

post deleted for not being "professional" I make money from music its my main income what exactly do you need to get accepted to this sub corporate speak???


r/ProMusicProduction • • Jun 07 '23

Question Easy way to automate synths.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I’m really struggling to automate synth.

On those one I have this automate volume and then a 16th note tremolo. I guess the real things I’m struggling to do is tie any effect knob to an LFO and doing this on the volume is tedious. Any video recommendations for automating/intro to synths would also be much appreciated 🙏


r/ProMusicProduction • • Mar 10 '26

Is mastering becoming obsolete for independent musicians?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this recently.

With modern plugins, AI tools and streaming normalization…

Is traditional mastering still essential for independent artists?

Or is it becoming something only major releases really need?

Curious to hear what producers here think.


r/ProMusicProduction • • Jan 11 '26

Question Any laptops for music production? Budget: $800

0 Upvotes

r/ProMusicProduction • • Dec 29 '24

Sound selection

0 Upvotes

I’ve just started getting into music production and writing (I’m 19 is it to late), and I just don’t know where to find good sounds to use or sample, where do artists like Travis Scott find these sounds to use


r/ProMusicProduction • • Apr 11 '26

Considering finally moving to ProTools. Still worth it?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been a Cubase user for over 15 years but I’m kinda tired of relying on freelance jobs from my home studio and want to look at some possible part time work at bigger studios in the city.

But I’m also hearing people talk about about how Logic and Reaper and quickly becoming the standard over ProTools (or will soon).

My question is: has anyone recently moved over to ProTools and would you say it’s still worth the cash and time investment today?


r/ProMusicProduction • • Jul 03 '26

Looking for a Long-Term Producer / Creative Partner

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm an independent artist looking for a producer who's interested in building something bigger than just a single track.

I'm leaning toward a cinematic, synth-driven dark pop sound with alternative influences—moody, emotional, atmospheric, and anthem-like. More than someone to make beats, I'm looking for a creative partner who wants to help shape a unique sound and build an artist over time.

I write my own songs and have a clear vision for the direction I'm headed. Since I'll be working full-time, I'd love to find someone who's passionate about producing and interested in growing together rather than treating this as a one-off project.

If you're into creating immersive, emotional music and enjoy collaborating, I'd love to hear your work. Send me a DM with some of your music, and I'll send you mine to see if we're a good fit.

Thanks!


r/ProMusicProduction • • Feb 07 '25

Discussion Polyphonic Audio

0 Upvotes

Starting with a pre-recorded song. I would like to refine my transcription process from Isolating a piano part in a song to converting from polyphonic audio to midi ready for scoring.

How would you go about this?


r/ProMusicProduction • • Jun 17 '25

Plug ins

0 Upvotes

What are some of the best plug ins for Logic Pro for making EDM music? I’m new to the game and was curious if it would be worth it to get some.


r/ProMusicProduction • • Aug 04 '25

Question Is there a better way to describe myself if I am an "Acoustic Music Producer"?

0 Upvotes

Almost everybody I know is putting "music producer" alongside whatever else they do. Guitarist/ music producer, songwriter/ music producer etc.

I understand that it is true but, as someone who has up until now been chasing that live sound and organizes musicians for recording sessions, I often feel that what I am doing is very different.

Someone that downloads garage band and knocks out a few tracks in their bedroom (not that I have anything against that) and someone who is writing parts, arranging, leading a band, choosing a room, etc. seem worlds apart to me.

So far I have been using "acoustic music producer" but I am not convinced it is the best. Essentially I would like to know if there is a better label or tag I can use to find other people producing music in that "old fashioned" way.

Does anyone have any suggestions for me?


r/ProMusicProduction • • Nov 20 '23

Question I collabed with someone who uses a different distributor than I

0 Upvotes

He uses Distrokid and I use Amuse, if I don't sign up for his distributor do I still get the song on my Spotify/Apple list? First time collabing with so a newbie to this kind of stuff. Also, should I just use multiple distributors since I'll probably collab with others in the future? Thanks!


r/ProMusicProduction • • Sep 08 '24

Guitar issue

0 Upvotes

Fyi i use logic pro

I have this guitar pan, left and right. I can’t perfectly get both of my guitar tracks to line up with the metronome.

And because of this, putting drums on the track is impossible because they are delayed on beat)

I may be wrong, but I once saw a plug-in that allows you to run the entire recording through a plug in, and it will automatically put them in sync with whatever the BPM is. Just curious if anyone knows a plug in like this, or something similar I could do manually in Logic Pro.

*If anyone needs the video, to hear what I am talking about. DM me personally and I can send it to you, because I can’t upload a video.