r/ProCreate • u/enter1101 Procreate Expert • 23d ago
My Artwork Harry Potter Dementors - Procreate šš»
6
u/enter1101 Procreate Expert 21d ago
Iād like to clarify my intentions regarding my Dementor artwork.
To be honest, Iām not very familiar with the controversies surrounding Harry Potter or the discussions about transgender issues. I simply came across the Dementors from Harry Potter, liked their visual design, and decided to draw them because I found them interesting as an artistic subject.
My intention was purely to create artwork based on a design that inspired me. I didnāt draw it to support or oppose anyone, nor did I intend to offend or disrespect anyone.
I hope you can understand that my artwork was created purely out of my interest in the subject, without any malicious intentions. I simply wanted to enjoy drawing and share my work with others.
Thank you for understanding.
0
u/letternumbertwo 19d ago
Understandable, ignorance isnāt always malicious and not everyone is aware of the intricacies of certain issues. Now that you do know, hopefully you can do some research and understand. Your art is wonderful and I would love to see more - just keep in mind the history behind whatās inspired you :)
9
u/oreo-cat- 22d ago
The dementors are great but what catches my eye is the background. It almost looks like an old, faded daguerreotype
3
3
32
u/PenguiNNNNNs 23d ago
Your gonne get destroyed for this hereā¦
-15
u/scotty_booooy 23d ago •
![]()
Its was so random seeing how the procreate reddit community of all things despises Harry Potter. Like with the amount of random shit in that universe and how almost everyone born between 1999-2010 grew up with it in some capacity I thought there'd be way more fan art of itĀ
53
u/SM0KINGS 23d ago •
![]()
![]()
we did grow up with it. it was super important to a lot of peopleās childhoods. you know what else is super important? standing up for our trans brothers and sisters. purchasing from/supporting a terf who actively gives money to anti-trans agendas doesnāt sit well with most of us.
now. is this art supporting joanne? no, technically it isnāt. but a lot of us have binned the whole IP because of its relation to its creator. i personally donāt understand why people are still fans despite her rampant bullshit and therefore i lump anything harry potter into the garbage pile. āseparate the art from the artistā doesnāt work for me when the person in question is alive and well, active in their bigotry, and who takes your money and spends it on a cause i fundamentally oppose.
-27
u/oreo-cat- 22d ago edited 21d ago •
![]()
![]()
āOur trans brothers and sistersā? So⦠humans only come in two gender options? I guess the rest of us are kittens or something seeing as we apparently need you to swoop in and save us.
You do realize that you could replace about three words and it would read like a terf rant donāt you? Nothing quite like trying to virtue signal and slipping up. Never change reddit.
Edit: Loving the comment and block because apparently their opinion matters more than mine so I need to "knock it off." Sorry, but since I apparently need to really clearly spell it out for people, I'm a nonbianary person and I find the above comment insulting. I still feel that way, regardless of whether you people will actually consider my opinion. So no, I'm not going to "knock it off"
29
u/Cute-Fly1601 22d ago
Hey, I'm NB, cut it out. Bashing a well-intentioned person over the head because they did an oopsie does nothing but push people away. Their argument is correct, and chastising a (presumably) cis person for defending trans people is counterproductive. All good if you want to point something out, but going for the kill over something like this is wild. I get it's rough out there right now, and there are plenty of people who deserve that level of anger, but someone advocating for trans people in a slightly incorrect way is not that person.
11
u/SM0KINGS 22d ago
the funny thing is that iām not cis at all. joanne is most vocal about trans people and to try to keep things simple i went with ātrans brothers and sistersā lmao i canāt
6
u/Cute-Fly1601 22d ago
My bad for assuming! I appreciate you sticking up for people, sorry someone came at you like that š
4
u/SM0KINGS 22d ago
all good my friend. iām old and just starting to deconstruct my gender shit and iām still learning. i didnāt know if joanne was as shitty about non-binary or genderqueer people as she seems to be about trans folk, specifically trans women, so i kept my language basic. and if thatās an error, iām more than happy to learn from it! hopefully that commenter took something from our exchange too lol
4
u/Cute-Fly1601 21d ago
Much appreciated, never too late to deconstruct gender shit. Ive been at it for 7 years and am still working on it.
She's definitely mostly focused on trans women, but she's largely opposed to anyone gender queer unfortunately.
Have a great week, take care!
1
u/charming_liar 21d ago
Genuine question: why do you (and the three other people) feel the need to point out that you're enby? Is your identity somehow more valid than OP's? They literally say āthe rest of usā to include genders outside of ābrothers and sisters." Itās pretty ironic to lecture someone about whether they should feel offended when the original comment wasn't in any way supportive of them. I'm just wondering what I'm missing
2
u/Cute-Fly1601 21d ago
Their comment was taking offense on behalf of nonbinary people. Someone who isn't nonbinary telling them to calm down could (reasonably) be taken as talking over them. As I am nonbinary, it's more defensible for me to call another NB out if they're a touch out of line. Not saying someone else couldn't, but it's fair to point out that you share and identity with someone when discussing issues pertaining to that identity.
I don't think their identity is invalid, I never said anything of the sort. I don't know them, but I'm not one to invalidate someone over an argument. It's also fine to be offended, I've been there. My issue was with personally attacking someone who was clearly well-intentioned in the way that they did. I'd take issue with that regardless of their identity.
Not sure who you're referring to as OP, since I'm assuming it's not the artist, so apologies if I'm misunderstanding. The person I responded to has since deleted their comment, so if it seems like I'm fighting with SM0KINGS, I'm not. I'm actually defending them haha. If im misinterpreting your comment here my bad.
1
u/charming_liar 21d ago edited 21d ago
If the comment looks deleted, they blocked you, and honestly, with this reply, I canāt really blame them. Itās pretty ironic to lecture someone about being offended when youāre the one refusing to accept that they had every right to be. Like who are you to decide someone is āout of lineā?
Edit: Also the claim that it was to "simplify" the text is really odd given most collective nouns are gender neutral. Yet, they decided to call out two genders, excluding the rest, instead of saying something like "family" or "friends."
0
u/BarneyChampaign 22d ago
I still struggle with understanding how nonbinary is considered under Ā the "trans" umbrella. Is that what you're referring to, saying it was slightly incorrect?
I thought trans men/women have a medical issue that makes their brain disagree with their sex, thinking it should be inverted. Even flipped it still supports a gender binary, though, for both sexes.
Growing up, nonbinary was more in the queer/orientation camp.
1
u/Cute-Fly1601 21d ago
Eh, the "switch flip" is a decent basic analogy, but falls short of the actual issue. Gender is a spectrum, what society considers "male" vs "female" behavior, clothing, etc. is largely dependent on culture, and different cultures interpret it different ways. A transgender person is someone who resonates with an alternate gender expression to that which they were assigned at birth. That includes nonbinary people.
Trans men and trans women can often operate within the societal confines of the gender binary, but there exists a vast variety of expressions somewhere in the middle. Since gender is a purely cultural phenomenon, any binary that exists is solely a cultural one.
The idea of a sexual binary doesn't necessarily hold up either when you consider the existence of intersex people. It's much easier to simplify things, though, and we as humans will often tend toward the most simple way of explaining things. Hence the "switch flip" explanation that a lot of people apply to trans folks.
From a purely cultural perspective, NB people are also lumped in with binary trans people in legislation and cultural sentiment. For most cis people, anyone that doesn't look like their assumption of a "man" or a "woman" gets thrown in the trans bucket.
0
u/BarneyChampaign 21d ago
So it's less something with a hard, medical diagnosis and more whatever the individual wants? I don't think anyone is 100% anything, so with a definition that broad wouldn't almost everyone fall under "trans"? I'm a bi male, and I used to have long hair, wear makeup, and even wore dresses sometimes to experiment with my identity - am I trans?
As far as the sex binary, I don't think the presence of intersex people changes humans being a sexually dimorphic species any more than someone born with 11 fingers changes the textbook definition of "human" to being "a 10 or 11 fingered biped".
Biology is messy, but it doesn't mean there aren't intended destinations during development, and for sex those are just male or female, sperm or ova. There's nothing wrong with being "wrong". I have lots of medical stuff wrong with me, but it doesn't mean I'm not a human, and I'm not trying to convince anyone that I'm normal because who cares anyways.
-3
u/oreo-cat- 22d ago edited 21d ago
Bashing a well-intentioned person over the head because they did an oopsie does nothing but push people away.
This would also apply to OP. And actually, your entire comment would apply to the one I replied to. You don't lift other up by tearing others down, and that's all that comment does.
ETA: Apparently objecting to someone saying there's only two genders is 'flying off the handle,' and point out the words that they wrote is offensive as an enby is a 'personal attack'
1
u/Cute-Fly1601 22d ago
Sure, it would apply to OP. I wouldn't come at a complete stranger assuming the absolute worst for no reason. That's a stressful way to live. If I was respectful and they responded with aggression then sure, but nobody in this thread but you flew off the handle and personally attacked people.
5
u/SM0KINGS 22d ago
bro, iām genderqueer lmfao her beef is most visibly with trans people. youāre the one whoās virtue signaling. cut it out.
1
u/ghoulishcravings 22d ago
oh knock it off ans stop virtue signaling about some shit. you know what was meant. especially given Joanne āthe TERFinatorā Rowling almost exclusively targets trans women. so as a nonbinary person, i support more than anyone my trans SISTERS who are the main target of her heinous acts
8
u/ManicPixiRiotGrrrl 22d ago
artists tend to be progressive and tolerant people so many of us do not like jk rowling
44
9
u/SomeGuyGettingBy 22d ago
Personally, I like this a lot as it gives me the same feeling the art for each chapter did when I first started reading the books in elementary school.
8
u/PalmtopPixie 22d ago
Without the Harry Potter dementors this is awesome. The whole HP thing ruins it
11
u/Normal_Swimming2282 22d ago
Hey dude, letās maybe not support JK Rowlingās work
-8
u/Content_Dimension626 22d ago •
![]()
This is an independent artist, she does not work with JK Rowling. Hope this helps.
16
u/letternumbertwo 22d ago •
![]()
Hey, JK has said herself that she takes any promotion or celebration of Harry Potter as confirmation that people support her views. She uses all money that comes from Harry Potter to actively fund anti trans bills and movements. She shares profiles and information of normal, everyday people, who just happen to be trans, and sends her followers after them like attack dogs. Transphobes have been using Harry Potter artwork as a dog whistle to signal to other transphobes that they agree with their views. Hope this helps.
5
3
-5
u/Content_Dimension626 23d ago edited 23d ago
Looks creepy, great job! What brushes did you use?
Edit: Are people really that upset over an art piece? Good grief....are we 12?
1
u/enter1101 Procreate Expert 22d ago
Thank you for your kind consideration. I made and drew the brush with a pencil brush I made myself. š
4
1
-8
u/Ocelotl767
23d ago
•
Christ alive, people are rude.
this is great, very reminiscent of Mary GrandPrƩ's original illustrations. Dark, moody, strong silhouettes. the value range could be a little better with practice, but good job!
-4
u/Content_Dimension626 23d ago •
![]()
I had no idea why I was getting so many downvotes until I came back to the post and noticed the Title. š People need lives.
-9
u/Ocelotl767 23d ago
Correct. Neil Gaiman got, what, 6 months of a slap on the wrist in the cultural eye for what he pulled? and yet, you mention Harry Potter and make art inspired by an objectively cool creature from the wizarding world, and everyone loses their shit.
-6
ā¢
u/AutoModerator 23d ago
Hello u/enter1101, thank you for sharing your artwork with us!
Would you be so kind to answer the following questions for us?
Can you please share what your process was for getting this done?
And what brushes did you use? (Please specify the exact brushes or brush category because that can be helpful to others.)
Any additional information about this piece is always welcome.
If you made this with Procreate Dreams, feel free to share it over on r/procreatedreams too!
Please reply to this comment so it will be easy for everyone to find, thank you!
Stay inspired, get creative and have a great day!
Join our r/procreate Discord Server to connect with other artists!
If you consider yourself a frequent poster and you have a consistent style/method, please send a modmail to be given a different automod comment that already mentions what you regularly use.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.