r/PowerApps • u/splinter44 Advisor • May 08 '26
Discussion Code App & Canvas Apps
Code Apps is the way to go, I see no use in ever creating a canvas app again and I feel weird that people are still using canvas apps. Opinion?
6
u/Sad_Position_826 Contributor May 08 '26
Agreed although there is I think still a place for canvas apps for mobile apps that require access to the mobile phone's resources
4
u/JohnTheApt-ist Advisor May 08 '26
The cost benefit just isn't there for most small scale apps. Canvas and SharePoint is still going to win out over paying premium licences especially for smaller businesses.
1
u/WillRikersHouseboy Advisor May 09 '26
Or large businesses if they need apps to be used widely in the org. And anyway, everyone is blowing their MS money on Co-pilot licenses instead 🤣
1
u/Comfortable_Glove463 Newbie Aug 08 '26
is there a skill readily available to convert existing canvas apps to code apps
1
u/splinter44 Advisor Aug 08 '26
Ya export your solution and Feed it to AI Claude and it'll reproduce it
1
u/Legitimate-Use7635 Regular May 08 '26
I use a bunch of embedded canvas apps in my MDAs as an easier alternative to pcf's. So for now i still need them.
1
u/5Lax Newbie May 09 '26
What about SPFx web apps? I’ve been using them in place of my canvas apps. Very tempted to try out Code Apps, but I don’t want to fight with IT over premium licensing.
1
u/thinkfire Community Friend May 09 '26
It really depends on the need. Some stuff canvas app is great. Easy to throw together a functional UI, SharePoint capabilities, connect stuff up, offline mode, powerfx much easier to learn, especially if you lived in excel, than typescript/react, etc
I use both canvas and code apps now, each serves it's purpose and will continue to do so no matter much someone hates one or the other for X reason. No need for elitism, they can and will continue to co-exist.
1
1
u/WillRikersHouseboy Advisor May 09 '26
Let’s see… I want to make an intake app for my company to report lost devices. We have 50,000 employees. What should we do? I prefer getting my annual bonus.
1
u/Big_Professional8289 Newbie May 11 '26
Well if someone build low code app with powerfx than blindly building code heavy app without ever owning the code..
0
6
May 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/splinter44 Advisor May 08 '26
Takes months to build a canvas apps - takes week to build a code app
Meaning customer pays way more for a canvas app
Code Apps has no limitations, you can build anything you want in react/vite
The speed of a code app is lightning - the interface is not limited to microsofts controls its anything you want
You can build faster and so have more customers...6
u/CroatoanBaby Regular May 08 '26
It does not and should not take months to build canvas apps. Quite a few quick start apps and template screens that take small modifications to make ready for a PoC then upsizing to an MVP.
1
u/splinter44 Advisor May 08 '26
We are on different wave lengths of software grades I think
1
u/CroatoanBaby Regular May 08 '26
We could probably learn a thing or two from each other, that’s how I see it
3
u/JohnTheApt-ist Advisor May 08 '26
I've built code apps and also used GitHub copilot to build canvas apps using YAML. It's really not that much quicker to build a code app and I'd argue that the limitations of canvas apps is a benefit as it force you to be more thoughtful in your design. Having no limitations isn't always a good thing.
1
u/WillRikersHouseboy Advisor May 09 '26
My problem with Canvas apps is mostly the spaghetti code situation (code sprinkled across controls. you inherit an app: where the heck is that one piece of logic stored?) And also any complex form validation or form customization requires moving to a Patch statement and re-invention of wheels.
Duplicating a Form control should not re-layout all the fields, yknow? That’s madness.
1
u/Chrispy_Bites Advisor May 09 '26
If it's taking you months to build a canvas app, you're doing something wrong.
1
u/WillRikersHouseboy Advisor May 09 '26
It’s far faster for me to build a web app using light JS frameworks (no, you can’t use Dataverse but I cant have Premium anyway.)
The reason I use Canvas apps is when we need tighter governance and I want to CMOA— or else be able to hand that shiz off.
7
May 08 '26 edited May 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/JohnTheApt-ist Advisor May 08 '26
Agreed. We work with mostly SMBs with 50-500 employees. The vast majority of apps (>75%) are built on SharePoint. How they get built is changing but I canvas apps aren't going anywhere. There's not a big enough difference between canvas and code apps for SMBs to justify the spend.
5
May 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-11
u/splinter44 Advisor May 08 '26
I think if you understand data structure and how dataverse/power apps works - you can easily switch to code apps in VS Code and vibe code the entire app, anytime you have issues you ask it was it learnt after fixing it and create a markdown file in project to reference back to past issues, train the AI, and you are good.
6
u/ShrubberyDragon Advisor May 08 '26
Not going to do that with apps with thousands of users in production and not going to do that with non premium apps
-2
u/splinter44 Advisor May 08 '26
I understand - iv never used power apps without a premium license, so im coming from somewhere else i guess
-1
u/splinter44 Advisor May 08 '26
Anyways the goal is you can get apps created 10x faster and customer ownership prices go way down and also roi for them goes up they pay nothing for changes
1
u/ShrubberyDragon Advisor May 08 '26
I mean I totally get it and I like code apps but yeah, I'd say 90% of my customers don't have premium licenses for all of their users because they are very large enterprises.
Code apps have their place though with those clients who do use premium licenses but I would be careful vibe coding anything critical.
38
u/mechapaul Advisor May 08 '26
They are premium. So if you are making free canvas apps for 500+ users like I do it’s a massive investment for a company to move to premium.