r/Potatoes • • 1d ago

Mashed potatoes

Hello all.

I'm making some mashed potatoes, but I have a dispute about where the potato need to be mashed. I say potato can be mashed in the pot where boiled, he says, need to be mashed in a bowl.

How do you mash your potato?

Photos accepted.

Thank you.

11 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

8

u/Existing_Many9133 1d ago

I pour the cooking water off, leave them in the pan, add warm milk and melted butter and mash. When I think they're the proper consistency I transfer them to the serving bowl

8

u/PNW_MYOG 1d ago

In the pot, unless you are using a potato ricer or another implement that isn't a masher.

A pot is flat in the bottom, matches the masher.

7

u/PotatoMailCarrier 1d ago

I mash in the pot.

7

u/Melora_T_Rex714 1d ago

I say, what difference does it make to him? Is he the one doing the dishes? Mashing in the pot uses one less dish that will need to be washed.

7

u/Exotic-Day-1082 1d ago

Drain cooked potatoes and then toss them back into the pot and put it back on the heat for a minute to dry them a bit. Then mash in the pot.

2

u/MaintenanceCapable83 1d ago

This is how I was taught. Works well.

0

u/Onewarmguy 1d ago

What, no butter, salt, or milk? ...Bacon bits? Chives? Cheese? It's almost a sin to serve mashed taters virgin. 😳

2

u/MaintenanceCapable83 1d ago

yes, butter, milk, salt and pepper.
The drying part is what i was agreeing with before adding in the ingredients and then mashing in the same pot.

6

u/BabyRuth55 1d ago • Bravo

The pot because I like to leave the potatoes in the hot pot for a few to evaporate all the water I can, then pour in the liquid and let it get warm without using another pot. In my cold kitchen, everything would get cold if I did it in a bowl.

2

u/Gold-Client4060 1d ago

This is the correct answer. The more surface water removed from the potatoes the better. I can't believe this isn't common knowledge by now.

5

u/ChiliDog762 đŸ„” 1d ago

I've done both. Wife prefers one, I prefer the other. My few is one less bowl to clean.

5

u/montecarlo714 1d ago

In the largest mixing bowl. I make 10 lbs. at a time. Then portion to freeze.

5

u/Playful_Dog3062 1d ago

We have always mashed them in the pot and served from the pot. If we're having guests then we'll mash in pot and transfer to bowl. Pot is less likely to break.

4

u/Ordinary-Abalone-957 1d ago

😂 I mash my potatoes in the pot with all the butter, milk and dolup of sour cream salt and pepper ,mix it well and serve it either in the pot or put it in a proper serving dish if company is around!

4

u/CatholicFlower18 13h ago

I really don't think it matters.

I've never in my entire life seen someone take a bite of mashed potatoes and say where it must've been mashed.

3

u/One_Tree_6100 1d ago

I guess I never mashed them I whip them in my kitchen aid. Butter/ cream. Whip.

4

u/frijolita_bonita 1d ago

That doesn’t turn them gummy?

4

u/stefanica 1d ago

I do the same. Only once had them gummy, and they were waxy potatoes that were probably over boiled. Nice starchy russets whipped with hot milk, cream, or butter do just fine. Don't walk away, just whip them till mashed.

2

u/frijolita_bonita 1d ago

Good to know!

2

u/InsertRadnamehere 1d ago

When you overcook the potato, yes.

1

u/12345NoNamesLeft 1d ago

If they are sticky and gummy they are under cooked.

Russets simmered for one and a quarter hours are what I do.

0

u/Optimal-Hunt-3269 16h ago

Way too long!

3

u/One_Tree_6100 1d ago

I'm not saying this is proper it's just the way I did it. You give me a potato with butter and just about anything on it I'm down

1

u/Exotic-Day-1082 1d ago

Are we talking mixer here or food processor?

2

u/mjmvideos 10h ago

In general, (in America) “Kitchen Aid” means a stand mixer, “Cuisinart” means a food processor.

1

u/mjmvideos 10h ago

I rice them into the kitchen aid, then add the cream and butter.

3

u/tmorse85 1d ago

I've always mashed them in a bowl because I like to let them cool down a few minutes before mashing. I don't need the steam fogging up my glasses while I'm trying to mashed them.

I have a tool I use to mash potatoes. It's not the kind with the curved wire or perforations. Instead, it's just a flat piece of metal on a plastic handle. For me, that thing is a multipurpose tool. I use it to break up so many foods. I'm disabled, and that thing is incredibly useful for me in the kitchen.

1

u/GuyanaFlavor-Aid 1d ago

I've always mashed them in a bowl because I like to let them cool down a few minutes before mashing. I don't need the steam fogging up my glasses while I'm trying to mashed them.

Not just that, but letting them steam off and cool a bit actually makes better mashed potatoes. The steam coming off of them is literally water, by letting them cool a bit you'll get lighter and fluffier mashed potatoes.

3

u/Educational-Rule1635 1d ago

In the pot, multiple reasons:

  1. Residual heat makes it easier to melt the butter.

  2. If I am serving in the kitchen, why dirty another dish?

  3. If I am serving at table, I can arrange the potato mound more neatly in the clean dish.

3

u/Worried_Objective_55 1d ago

I like the lumps.

3

u/NightshadeZombie 1d ago

I mash mine in the pot with the old fashioned masher. The only reason to turn them out into a bowl before mashing is IF your pot has a non-stick coating of some sort and you're using a mixer. Teflon is not a good spice, and the beaters can scratch the lining. Even if you manage to not get coating bits in your current batch of spuds, the microscratches from the metal beaters will eventually cause the lining to flake and then you'll have them in other things you cook there.

We don't use Teflon or non-stick pans at all, so I'm not super worried about if I did have use a mixer. But the masher suits us fine.

3

u/Mojak66 1d ago

Chef John (Food Wishes) says potatoes should be drained, then mashed in the pot before adding anything. Works for me. Depending on how I feel, butter then milk, or cream, or buttermilk, or sour cream etc.

3

u/wilforddog 1d ago

Also! All ingredients that are added should be warm. Not hot. Warm. Do not add cold ingredients to warm taters. ♄

3

u/brolly72 1d ago

It won’t effect the final product as to where they are mashed. I use a food mill for no lumps. The cook decides where to mash the potatoes
..not the eaters

4

u/Human-Place6784 1d ago

I mash them in the pot. Boil, drain, add butter to hot potatoes. Let it melt some. Mash. Drizzle in warmed half-and-half while mashing.

2

u/MilkiestMaestro 1d ago

I put it in a bowl because I use teflonated cookware and I am over-cautious about scratching when I go to mash something in there

I guess if I had cast iron or stainless steel, mashing in the pot would be fine

Anyways, hamburger masher or sometimes just a fork

2

u/12345NoNamesLeft 1d ago

Simmered long time, Russets, drained in a strainer, back into the pot where you reheat the pot with the butter, cream and milk until it boils, machine whip in the pot.

The bowl is for serving.

1

u/olive_tractor_parts 1d ago

Why would you put them in a different bowl for serving?

2

u/RawMeatballz 1d ago

Because people like to have nice presentation

1

u/12345NoNamesLeft 1d ago

You serve dinner by putting the pots right on the table ?

Reread, mash in the pot, serve in the bowl.

0

u/olive_tractor_parts 1d ago

Our cookware includes vintage Temp Tone stainless steel which looks really good so yes, the pot goes on the table. But even if not, I'm not hauling an extra dish out to serve each food item just because some victorian age twit decided that was an acceptable amount of extra work for the kitchen servants two hundred years ago.

2

u/Optimal-Hunt-3269 16h ago

I have started serving in cooking vessels too, when possible. I'm no scullery maid!

1

u/Adventurous-Host8062 8h ago

My Mom used serving dishes at the dining room table every Sunday and most weekdays. This was in the sixties and seventies. It's normal unless you were brought up serving yourself from the stovetop.

0

u/12345NoNamesLeft 1d ago

I use correlle serving dishes and 2x sizes of plates.

Table clearing time, the small plate covers the dish perfectly and they stack up in the fridge like that. They microwave reheat in the bowls with the plate lids on too.

1

u/ToughFriendly9763 1d ago

i mash them in a pot. Bowls have curved sides that would make it harder to mash. 

1

u/Old_Win8422 1d ago

Russet and Yukon cooked in chicken broth. Then put through a ricer and milk and butters incorporated in with a mixer in a Bowl!

1

u/KatieHavok 1d ago

In the cooking pot. The carryover heat of the metal helps steam off excess water from the potatoes, resulting in a fluffier mash and a smoother, less 'gluey' texture. The residual heat also helps the emulsion of whatever dairy you add to the spuds.

1

u/Automatic_Gas9019 1d ago

Way bigger things to argue over. I guess it depends on who is doing dishes and cooking. I am curious as to why would your partner feel the need to watch and critique your cooking teqnique. Is he like the guy on TV that hates how people cook?

1

u/GrowlingAtTheWorld 1d ago

Mom mashed them in the cook pot. Then she would whip them with a hand mixer. And then transfer to the Pyrex Cinderella bowl.fir serving.

1

u/MegaMeepers 1d ago

I make mine in the instant pot. 5lbs diced potatoes (peeled or not), 2c liquid (I do broth and water), 8 min high pressure, instant release.

Transfer to a bowl, add 1.5c milk, 1 stick of butter, and 2-3 rounds Boursin cheese to the instant pot basin and turn on saute. Melt everything, add potatoes back in, and mash with a hand masher to desired consistency

1

u/AwesomeJohn01 1d ago

I remove the liquid, let them steam in the pot a bit. Put the potatoes on a paper plate then put them through my ricer into the pot and add cream and butter and mix with a rubber spatula

1

u/Medical-Dust-7184 1d ago

Really...what difference does it make ????

1

u/Legitimate-March9792 1d ago

In the pot with a masher. A ricer is even better. Never mix with a hand mixer unless you like them gummy. You can transfer them to a casserole dish after they are mashed.

1

u/InsertRadnamehere 1d ago

At home: in the pot.

At work: in the Hobart mixer.

1

u/oh_hey_there_2701 1d ago

Baking then mashing has been a total game changer for me, and it solves your dilemma

1

u/Illustrious-Coat3532 1d ago

If you have a ricer or presser, you don’t need to peel the potatoes. Just boil and throw it in a ricer or presser and the skin will stay intact. Also I add cream cheese in my mashed potatoes.

1

u/DramaQueen581 1d ago

Drain the pot then mash in the same pot, with low heat and add more seasoning and butter and milk etc.

1

u/Appropriate-Bid8671 1d ago

The last time someone tried making a suggestion about how I do a thing in the kitchen I told them to get out, and if they wanted it a certain way, they could do it themselves.

1

u/Wild_Plant_2100 1d ago

I stick my electric mixer into the pot

1

u/Character-Mess-9438 1d ago

I steam my potatoes (1 cup of water instead of 8cups) then add creamy almond milk and salt/pepper/coconut butter. I prefer steamed potatoes as they come out fluffier.

1

u/naemorhaedus 1d ago

you can mash it in your bike helmet. Why would it matter?

1

u/EditorNo2545 1d ago

imo after they are drained it doesn't matter where they are mashed

1

u/RikkiLostMyNumber 1d ago

I do them in the same pot I boiled them in. Cook, drain, back in pot. Mash with masher. Add butter and sour cream, then whip with a hand mixer.

1

u/thannawi 1d ago

I drain them, add butter to the pot/cooking vessel before adding the potatoes and other ingredients. Saves dishes that need to be washed

1

u/olive_tractor_parts 1d ago

Good potatoes can be mashed skins and all on the eater's plate, with a fork. Butter, sour cream, etc added to individual taste.

1

u/MountainTomato9292 1d ago

I mash in the pot and do all my mixing of ingredients there as well. If it’s just dinner at home we then serve from the pot, if it’s something nice like Thanksgiving I transfer to a bowl or whatever.

1

u/PuzzleheadedBag4847 1d ago

I drain the potatoes in a colander, spread them on a tea towel to dry excess moisture and then I use a potato ricer.

Once they are passed through the ricer I put the mash back in a saucepan with butter and/or cream and heat through again.

1

u/lightyana 1d ago

I bake the potatoes and scoop out the pulp and mash. No peeling, boiling or waste. if I’m not making twice baked potatoes I use the skins as appetizers, just add cheese, bacon and whatever else you want then bake until crispy and top with sour cream and green onions.

1

u/shibasluvhiking 1d ago

Always in the pot. Why dirty another dish?

1

u/askmrlucky 1d ago

I use a ricer or a handheld grater from the last century with a fine disk, which accomplishes the same thing as the ricer. And I grate into the pot because that's where I'm gonna finish the cooking. It's different when I'm mashing, except it isn't because I mash 'em in the pot because that's where I'm gonna finish the cooking.

1

u/HotAccountant2831 1d ago

I recently made the best mashed potatoes I’ve ever eaten using my pressure cooker.

1

u/Eskarina_W 1d ago

We use a river, so the potato gets transferred I to a bowl anyway. Then mash in the bowl. The masher is metal so I wouldn't want to use it in the pot anyway.

1

u/boing757 1d ago

I make instant mashed potatoes. Problem solved.

1

u/AmbassadorProper1045 1d ago

In the pot which is stainless steel. What a waste of dishes to do it otherwise. Drain, season, add Milk & Butter & mash. Easy.

1

u/RaNdomMSPPro 1d ago

Drain potatoes, throw back in pot. Smash. Why make more dirty dishes?

1

u/honorthecrones 1d ago

I always do it in the pan. The residual heat from the pan helps to dry out the potatoes.

1

u/Big-Job1431 1d ago

In the pot with milk and butter and seasoning salt.

1

u/Tricky-Usual8921 1d ago

My mother always mashed the potatoes in the pan they were boiled in and I do the same. They're already in a container so why create more washing up

1

u/Classic_Ad_7733 1d ago

In a separate bowl always, but I follow this recipe where you 1st peel the potatoes and then boil them with lots of water. Then using the hand mixer I add milk and butter, mostly butter, and salt in a separate bowl.

1

u/Advanced_Tennis4827 1d ago

The best way is a potato ricer

1

u/Blucola333 22h ago

I reserve some of the potato water for gravy and just mash them in the pot where I boiled them. Less work is the objective. Is your husband the one doing the washing up?

1

u/Burnt_and_Blistered 22h ago

Use a ricer—then the vessel doesn’t matter. Bake the potatoes until fluffy and perfect. Rice them while they’re hot—they’ll steam off a bit of excess moisture. Then stir in HOT milk/cream into which you’ve melted butter (and seasoned).

The ricer? TOTAL game changer.

1

u/TheGreatHey 20h ago

In the end, its mashed. The key is smooth mash is lots of butter. Like a shocking amount. Like your gym coach telling you today is your cheat day. And cream too yeah. BUTTER!!

1

u/Choice-Education7650 19h ago

I mash them in the pan I cooked them in and use a little of the water from cooking instead of all milk. Why dirty another dish.

1

u/uncannyem 16h ago

I use an enameled Dutch oven, the potatoes get mashed in the Dutch oven with a hand mixer.

1

u/PDXCatHerder 12h ago

Between your toes in the bathtub

1

u/Kos2sok 8h ago

Mash in the pot after you drain the water. You can serve it in the pot too or if you want to get fancy plop them in a fancy bowl.

1

u/Prior_Sherbet7724 7h ago

They’re gummy if you don’t drain the water properly.

1

u/Ok-Breadfruit-1359 6h ago edited 6h ago

I use a ricer then mix the butter, cream, salt into any vessel. I would never mash taters in as non stick pot, that would surely scratch the pot.

0

u/Boon1Goon 1d ago

Yukon golds, roughly cut then boiled. Return cooked potatoes to pot, add half & half, a dollop of sour cream, a whole stick of butter, salt & pepper and a healthy dash of Kinder’s The Original Blend. If I have it, I do a dollop of French onion chip dip instead of the sour cream. Then mash like mofo till most lumps are gone then switch to your serving spoon and stir like a witch on crack, adding more H&H till desired thickness.

0

u/4morian5 1d ago

Mash in the pot. 

I'm the only one in the house that likes mashed potatoes, so I make personal batches and the potato masher wouldn't fit the small bowl I eat out of.

1

u/Sugah-mama21 1d ago

Pot, need to get all the lumps out so need a flat bottom to do that.

1

u/Adorable_Dust3799 19h ago

I cut mine up, skin on. Cook in less water. The starch stays in the water and i think greatly improves the taste and texture. I mash in the pot. My mom always used her kitchenaid mixed, but she was cooking for 7 and that freed up her hands to make gravy.

4

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/MobileAd8857 1d ago

This is the correct answer.Â