Spud fit In the year 2016, a highly influential book was published about a so called potato diet.[1] It was written by an Australian man known as Spud fit. The strategy was imitated by other youtube users with the result that most of them have lost weight. What is missing in the ongoing debate around the potato diet is a scientific analysis if this simple vegetable is important or if it is only a life style trend which will be forgotten in 5 years.
Before it make sense to argue about the pros and cons, a short look is given how obesity is solved usually in western countries. What is known from the statistics is, that the average body mass index has grown over the last decade. The medical literature has described the fact as a worldwide obesity crisis. The cause for this reason is not very complicated to analyze. The unhealthy food tastes very well, and this motivates the people to eat more than they want.
Weight loss camp In the past, some strategies were initiated with the aim to fix the issue. One of the widely known paradigm strategy is a weight loss camp.[2] According to the amount of information in TV and in printed format, the weight loss camp is the number one recommendation in western countries to solve the obesity crisis. What makes this concept so popular is, that the topic is not only explained from a nutrition perspective which is equal to count calories, but the psychological implications are analyzed too.
The sad situation is, that weight loss camp have failed to stop the obesity problem. Only a small percentage of the users has profit from these camps, and most of them will gain much higher amount of body weight after leaving the camp. From an abstract point of view, the average weight loss camp is based on two elements:
sporty activities, which includes running, bicycling and swimming
healthy nutrition, which means that the participant has to eat tomato, fresh food, cucumbers, salad and wholemeal bread
On the first look, nothing is wrong with this combination. It is an accepted wisdom, that salad is a healthy food and that outdoor activities are burning calories so that the participant will improve it's healthy condition.
Failed lifestyle The disadvantage of a weight loss camp is, that the recommended lifestyle doesn't fit to the personal situation of the participants. For example, long distance running is an activity which is preferred by athletes who want to pass a marathon. It is unlikely, that an overweight person is able to imitate this behavior. Let us analyze the situation in detail. Suppose the trainer in a weight loss camp invites the participant to do the same what he is doing over a week. On day 1 he runs the small distance of 10 km and breaks it's former record. On day 2 the trainer reduces it's activities and went only to the gym to make a few body building exercises. On the day 3, the trainer runs 20 km, on day 4 he is swimming a longer distance and so on.
Are the overweight participants of the weight loss camp able to repeat the demonstration by it's own? Are they are able to run the same distance? It's a rhetorical question. What is observed in reality is, that the user will try to follow the instruction one. But then he finds out that it is outside of his physical condition. And he will give up the challenge. That means, it is his personal failure and nothing has changed.
Eating potatoes There is a large difference between a classical weight loss camp and a potato diet. The main difference is, that most participants of a potato diet doesn't make additional sport. And they are never eating less food but more of it. This combination is the opposite of what is teached in a weight loss camp. How can a person loose weight if he doesn't make sport at all and if he increases the daily calories? Answering this question is a bit harder one. What is known from many youtube videos is, that the strategy works great in reality. Most overweight user finds it easy to follow the potato diet, because the change in their personal life is minimal.
In the easiest case, the user eats every day some potato in addition to the normal food. In the enhanced version, the user eats nothing but potatoes. In both cases, the person has the feeling that his stomach is full. The most surprising fact is, that after a single week the weight has reduced a bit. And after one month, the participant has a clear sign, that he has passed the challenge. That means, he was able to reduce his body weight and he is confident, that he can do the same in the future.
References