PREFACE: I am a LONGTIME DGD fan. Having listened since 2009 and their release of Happiness, I've loved their creativity and musicianship for years. I've seen them live several times. I enjoy music from all of their eras, whether Johnny, Kurt, or Tilian are on vocals. Will Swan is my god, and Happiness is one of my favorite albums of all time.
With that said, they're releasing too much too quickly. As a result, while a lot of their new stuff is technically creative from a musicianship standpoint, none of it is catchy anymore or leaves a lasting impact.
Mothership was their last good album. Their new music is boring and not catchy at all. This includes Prisoner and the entirety of Artifical Selection. One listen through Articial Selection was more than enough for me. Prisoner was boring and I can't even hum a guitar lick or line from it after listening to it, none of it stuck. It feels like they're just churning out what ever they can, with music that's just "good enough", but now made without any heart. I no longer get a sense of excitement from the band wanting to show the world their excellent musicianship and creativity, and instead, it just seems like Will Swan is procedurally making up guitar licks on the spot, then Tillian adds some non-catchy vocals, and Jon Mess just fills in the gaps with whatever at this point. Sometimes I wonder if Tililian ran out of catchy ideas after Mothership. It's as if they found a formula to make decent but no longer amazing music consistently and quickly and have stuck with it. I have little hope for Afterburner, especially if Prisoner is really what they wanted to show off first.
I refuse to continue the DGD circlejerk just because people are too afraid to speak out against this band on this sub. Their new music , while not explicitly bad music, is truly mediocre compared to their previous efforts.