r/Polytopia • u/Cum-lord-of-cum • Dec 18 '22
r/Polytopia • u/uniballout • Nov 25 '23
Discussion This game is borked now
I have been playing daily since it came out. I play domination, 15 bots, on crazy. It’s sort of my coffee meditation in the morning. There have been some trying times post updates. Like the bot cloak spam-a-lot days and catapults-a-go-go. Those times were brutal.
But this new update is just trash. Economy is just gone. You can’t build up cities, defend, and also whittle away at another aspect.
The naval aspect is crap. Being forced to only upgrade rafts in your zone is just stupid. You can not react defensively when a tribe comes from the cloud of war to attack. You send out a scout and can’t use it for defense later.
You can’t mount an attack until you build up a force, but all your ships get jammed in your zone. If you are in close quarters, forget about naval warfare. Forget about sending a raft without upgrading it since it’s cannon fodder as a sole unit and you can’t upgrade it out at sea.
The splash damage and the giant units naval attack as it moves is devastatingly bad. I will get in fights with a tribe and not want to agro another. But moving the giant or using a bomber defeats this. I often am fighting a tribe with another tribe sort of helping me or not even engaged with me. This is especially true when tribes are separated by small channels of water. If I move a giant naval, hit my partner and now they are attacking me. If I shoot my bomber and it hits my partner, they turn on me. Sure, you say use diplomacy. But guess what, I have never had a bot ever accept my offer of diplomacy. If they don’t offer, forget it. And it’s too costly of tech for no benefit.
The game is now a slow slog of defender walls and catapults.
r/Polytopia • u/nickjack33 • Feb 04 '19
Discussion I managed to get the pc version of polytopia early - guess how
r/Polytopia • u/jgl142 • Dec 29 '23
Discussion I’ve decided I’m quitting any game against bugs as soon as they appear.
It’s just not enjoyable to play the game anymore against them.
r/Polytopia • u/[deleted] • Mar 19 '24
Discussion Hard truth
After playing everyday for 7 years, this is my conclusion
r/Polytopia • u/Fcreep123 • Dec 19 '23
Perfection Yeah I dont care, cymanti is broken
Maybe before you were able to say "oh cymanti takes skill this and that" At this point it just insanely broken. I'm done with all of you trying to defend cymanti It's the most skillless brainless tribe on the game and I will not stop complaining about it. And I encourage everyone else to as well. If you use the tribe go fuck your mom bitch ass
r/Polytopia • u/MilkImpossible4192 • Aug 15 '26
Fan Content Bros, have you tried making polytopian hats?
r/Polytopia • u/Muralope • Nov 23 '23
Discussion This update sucks
Crazy bots are unfightable, not fun at all
r/Polytopia • u/newtonrox • Dec 11 '23
Discussion Goodbye Polytopia. We had a good run.
Classic Polytopia was one of the best games I had ever played. It reminded me of chess, with simple, beautiful basic moves that nonetheless allowed for tremendous complexity. Easy to learn but difficult to master, and infinitely replayable. I spent hundreds of hours. But the new update destroyed the elegance. It’s not so much a matter of balance, since there were always imbalances of various types, and in any case so much depended on the terrain and spawn conditions. It’s the ugliness, the clunkiness. Classic beauty was replaced with ugly convolution. I do wish that it could be split into two games, because I will miss it. Thank you for years of engaging fun!
r/Polytopia • u/New-me-_- • Dec 29 '23
Discussion Getting 3 stars on domination is genuinely impossible
Why the fuck is the star system in polyopia the way it is? To get the first star for a tribe, you just play a game with them. You don't need to win, in fact you could just immediately surrender your capital and the game will still give you that first star. The second star makes sense, you have to play a decent game in order to get it. But the 3rd star, oh boy. In order to get the third star, literally the only way to do it is to beat a single opponent on Crazy Difficulty in less than 10 turns and without letting a single unit die. I have been trying for hours, and the only tribes I've managed to 3 star are Vengir and Elyrion and those were due to pure luck. Who the fuck designs a system like this?
r/Polytopia • u/jgl142 • Apr 05 '24
Discussion You should lose 100 points
I think those that abandon matches are the worst form of losers. It’s obnoxious and players should be docked 100+ points for doing it. Nothing worse than dominating a match to have some j off accumulate 7 min and ghost.
Edit: I’m all for the resign option. I’m protesting leaving the game with significant time left to run out during a live match knowing you’ve lost.
r/Polytopia • u/Aggravating_Grade_21 • Jul 16 '22
Discussion Polytopia-tribe music tierlist
r/Polytopia • u/Extension-Koala-9372 • Nov 12 '23
Discussion Are the mods stupid for removing the alphabet posts?
Removing this post proves my point.
r/Polytopia • u/st000pkid • Feb 05 '24
Discussion Can we all agree that Polaris is the most bullshit tribe
Get your capital frozen by Mooni on turn 4 or get ass pounded into submission by battle sleds by turn 12. Great game. Both those units need a nerf imo
r/Polytopia • u/Keefyfingaz • Sep 17 '23
Discussion My take on the special tribes debate.
Look, I don't hate them as much as some people on here, but I get a little tired of people saying that Bardur is more OP than special tribes. It's not (and for the record I play as Ai-Mo or Oumaji).
The best tribe on land is Cymanti. Those Centipedes are objectively OP. If you take out the head, another one appears right in front of it. If you take out any middle segment, now you have two Centipedes. This means the only effective way to take out a Centipede is to hit if from behind with chivalry. And if they have climbing or forest protection perks, even that will be hard to do. They also have those spider things with insane travel bonus and the ability to retreat, making an ideal disposable unit to explore land faster than riders can. Oh, and the charge thing.
On water Aquarion is clearly the best tribe. It's mostly because of those trident throwing riders. They have movement bonus on water, ranged attacks, and retreat abilities. And before you try to argue that they're expensive, for me to build an effective water unit with a vanilla tribe, it costs 20 stars. So, that. Oh, and they can move on land or water.
These two are the ones that I feel are genuinely OP
Polaris has those ice shaman things that freeze water and units. I can't tell you how many times I get a giant frozen on my city and then they just pluck away at it until its gone. Or they'll freeze water that was acting as a natural defense against units, and charge me with Ice shamans and those little skating dudes that fly around on the ice. Not to mention, what are essentially catapults with more health. (I don't know the names, can you tell?) The saving grace is that Ice shaman guys replace giants and have less health, so I guess you could say it's somewhat balanced.
Then there's the Dragon tribe (Elyron? Something like that right?) These guys bother me the least. The spread damage on the already ranged fireball attacks can be a pain, but since the dragon has to go through stages, it seems like a mostly fair buff. Also they have to use animals as units rather than resources, so I think this is the most fairly nerfed of the special tribes.
In summary, I think this would bother me less if all tribes had unique units, because then it would seem as though tribe matchups were just part of the game. It would be like a rock, paper, scissors, kind of thing. But in reality, the way it is now, it feels like a chess game, but instead of us all having the same pieces, you can buy a different set of peices that move and attack in different ways. I find that with vanilla tribes, we have the same units and know that our opponents have the same tools at their disposal. This makes the game come down to strategy (like a chess game).
I don't mind that Bardur can level up on first turn, cause so can the Imperius tribe. I understand that hunting is technically a more useful perk, but eh, it seems minor in comparison.
Do people really think the special tribes are equivalent to the vanilla tribes, or do people just like playing the special tribes and get defensive when someone suggests they're factually better than vanilla tribes?
Edit: upon reading some comments, I can maybe concede that cymanti super unit is OP, but rather you need to know how to take down their super units. I still think they're annoying lol. And the fact that the spider units don't suffer movement penalties give them a huge advantage early game cause they don't have to rely on roads. I also don't think it's fair to say "but riders and roads take them easy" because that implies that I have to buy 2 techs to be able to defeat them efficiently. This means I have to spend resources that could have gone to boosting economy on movements techs. It feels restricting imo
r/Polytopia • u/jgl142 • Aug 02 '26
Screenshot Whyyoumadbrooo, do better
You constantly abandon games. This is why I refuse to play you even though i dominate you each time we do.
r/Polytopia • u/Lonely-Candle6691 • Aug 08 '25
Discussion Anyone remember the scrapped cymanti spider?
It was in development when they first leaked the cymanti Tribe. It was sad they didn't add it, it could have added so much to the Tribe. I wonder if anyone remembers the outrage from the community when the dev team revealed the spider wasn't going to be added
r/Polytopia • u/One-Marionberry3163 • Aug 14 '25
Fan Content Presenting: My custom Polytopian!
It’s the first design, I’m not to sure where they would fit in on the tech tree or ability’s or how strong they are.. It’s one of my first polytopia builds! 🚒
r/Polytopia • u/Nearby_Ad_4648 • Dec 10 '24
Discussion SPECIAL TRIBES RUINING THE GAME FOR SOME?
I wonder how many people stopped playing the game altogether because of special tribes especially...especially..especially CYMANTI... I think I have a few days left playing this game.
r/Polytopia • u/uniballout • Dec 02 '23
Suggestion Bridges are pointless, fix them
I’m sorta getting my head wrapped around the new changes. But bridges seem utterly pointless. Here is why:
Cost 7, but don’t get you even 1 plus population. Pretty much everything you build gets you a population boost. These don’t.
Other tribes can use your bridge. A lot of maps have the rivers separating capitals of tribes. Early game, a bridge often leads to death. Ports are more useful early game. I can put a swordsman in one and if it lives, can now jump over to land or became a bomber. And I get 1 pop to my city.
Mostly a late game mechanic to hustle knights over from distant cities. But ports are usually in place by then and can be used. Ports also link trade routes.
To fix, at least add a population bonus for building one. Or lower the cost.
Of course, the best fix of all would be scrapping Cymanti altogether. But that has nothing to do with bridges. Figured I would throw it out there.
r/Polytopia • u/Sufficient-Ship1571 • Jun 14 '26
Discussion rfm2907 that was not very nice
I was travelling and couldn’t take my turn in 24 hours. I had thrashed you. You beat me by kicking me as soon as it was possible. What a pathetic move. Enjoy your undeserved points.
r/Polytopia • u/Justeeni_lingueeni • Oct 02 '22
Discussion Why Redditors Are So Bad at Polytopia
Everyone that’s active on the polytopia discord loves looking at the reddit posts that make their way into the #subreddit-feed channel. Poking fun at stupid and rehashed reddit posts has always been a great pastime for active members in the polytopia discord. However, there isn't much discussion as to why redditors are so much worse at the game than discord members. Maybe to some it is obvious, but for many it likely isn’t, so in this post I will be taking a deep dive into why redditors are so bad at polytopia.
No competitive communities whatsoever:
Competitions lead to significant developments in strategy and lots of learning. This is fairly obvious, as there is not much of an incentive to improve at the game if you have no goals. This, in my opinion, seems to be the most major reason that redditors are so much worse at the game than discord members. As far as I am aware, there seem to be no competitive reddit communities whatsoever. Discord on the other hand, has several competitive communities. Polychamps has over 2000 members and frequently hosts 1v1, 2v2, and 3v3 tournaments and games, as well as a dedicated server for each Polychamps team where you can get personal training. Giants League is an FFA focused server with over 500 members. Wicked Bender hosts 1v1 tiny map glory mode duels (not sure with the member count there). Additionally, there is an ELO system in the polytopia server (that is not only made better than the ingame one, but was made before). With all these resources and such a dedicated player base, it only makes sense that someone who spends 6 months on the polytopia discord will be way better than someone who’s spent years on the polytopia reddit.
2. No way to make essential strategies and/or information easy to access:
Discord has a system where you can “pin” a message, allowing it to be accessed at any time. Reddit doesn’t have anything like this (to my knowledge, and even if it existed it clearly isn’t being used). This just leads to information being almost impossible to spread around, as it just gets buried and then forgotten about within weeks or even days.
3. Harder to make meaningful conversation:
This is just by design. Discord was made with the intent of having online conversations. Reddit was made to make online posts. There’s much more interaction in a conversation than a post, which makes it easier to spread knowledge in discord as compared to reddit. You can even see this when seasoned polytopia players on discord try to make posts or comments on reddit to teach redditors how to “get gud” it is marginally effective at best.
So I think it’s rather objectively established that the discord community is just better at the game than reddit. It really just makes sense. The real question is; who cares? Why does this matter? It matters because both of these communities have an influence over what the devs think is important to prioritize, whether it’s content updates or balancing (the one I really care about is balancing).
I’m sure most of us are probably familiar with the balance notes in beta. Most of them seem fine, some of them seem intriguing, but there is a very questionable one that competitive players (and many semi-competitive and casual players) have been complaining about as soon as they saw the balance notes. That unjustified, questionable explosion nerf. The reason they got nerfed was fairly obvious; Lots of people complained about doomux. The big problem, however, is that most of these complaints were from reddit. The discord community actually considers these units to be “inefficient, but sometimes okay” or “a really bad investment”. The only real counterargument to nerf doomuxes is that “they’re too strong at lower levels”, to which I say that they would need a rework, not a nerf.
TLDR: Redditors suck at the game and have too much influence over balance updates. Zoythrus, please take everything on reddit with a VERY small grain of salt. Midjiwan, don’t nerf doomux.