r/Polytopia • • 7d ago

Discussion Hey Dev Team

Turn off or down the ruins with fishing on dry boards. It used to be just annoying when it happened. Now it’s like every third match. It really is impacting play on dry boards and not in a positive way. I liked the suggestion to place a few water tiles or just turn it off on dry.

7 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

11

u/keenantheho 7d ago

I don't know why, but it's also happening like every other match I have. I even got sailing once...

5

u/jgl142 7d ago edited 7d ago

I remember being like fishing?! That sucks. Now it’s like “ please don’t be fishing”. I’ve gotten fishing and then ramming 😂. I just quit after that

8

u/Sivetus Ürkaz 7d ago

i'll take your argument seriously if you make a stat of at least 20 games, noting all ruins and what they were

5

u/AL441 7d ago

Pointless.

His argument is sound. Don't offer a reward as a tech that can't be used in this map. 🤷

1

u/Sivetus Ürkaz 7d ago

his argument is that it's only annoying because

it's like every third match.

and that it's not, unless he's super unlucky..

and, if yes, i want proof. until then i'm not accepting this take

1

u/jgl142 6d ago

it happened about 3 or 4 times. But I kept forgetting to post. I’d say it’s about 1 in 5 games.

1

u/jgl142 5d ago

See proof

1

u/AL441 7d ago

The fact it happens is enough to fix it. Clearly an oversight. Go play a bunch of games on this map type and then see how you feel

1

u/Sivetus Ürkaz 7d ago

i have nearly 5k games played, and about 1k of them on dry. it is disappointing to get a fishing ruin there, sure. but then, it's still a part of the game

it's not like getting it puts you in a disadvantage, it only doesn't give you an advantage.

also, say they actually removed it. then they'd also have to remove farming ruins for bardur, vet sword ruins on tiles on archi where they're jus stranded, riding branch ruins on archi, meditation in the middle of the battle, any vet sword ruins on the edge, etc etc, we might as well make players choose their ruin result

1

u/jgl142 7d ago

well I’ve played more than double you almost exclusively on dry. So I might be slightly exaggerating. But it’s more the it was in the past by a significant margin

1

u/Sivetus Ürkaz 7d ago

so you play enough games in less than a week to make a good sample out of it. i'd like to see that, geniuely! if you're down to note it. 👀👀

2

u/jgl142 7d ago

Yeah I definitely will. Honestly, it has increased significantly.

1

u/WeenisWrinkle 6d ago

it's still a part of the game

It doesn't have to be.

1

u/Sivetus Ürkaz 6d ago

it's oddly specific. if it was actually never useful, i guess they could; but it

  • progresses you to tower of wisdom;

  • can be useful if there's a kickoo, or (and especially) aquarion on the map -- and even more so for those two.

1

u/jgl142 5d ago

how many do you require?

1

u/Sivetus Ürkaz 5d ago

i don't require it, but how many games did you play since?

1

u/jgl142 5d ago

No clue. But fishing appears anywhere between 3-5 matches in a ruin

→ More replies (0)

1

u/WeenisWrinkle 6d ago

You're correct that they're not getting Fishing more often than statistics would say.

But it's still really dumb for Fishing to be a ruin reward on drylands.

3

u/MilkImpossible4192 7d ago

dry boards are dumb, they need small ponds

1

u/vel_cirapt_r 7d ago

An oasis!

1

u/MilkImpossible4192 7d ago

yeh, exactly

2

u/Dready-Womble 7d ago

But the gamble is part of it!

5

u/MagazineConscious687 7d ago

Ruins are meant to be a gamble, sometimes they help and sometimes they don't. They could also give you another useless tech, or a veteran sword miles away from any frontlines, or an explorer revealing 3 fog tiles.

On the plus side, you are now a tech closer to the tower of wisdom.