BIG EDIT: Hello all who are new to this subreddit or have not yet seen this post! 2 things that I need to get out of the way before you read!
Number ONE: DO NOT be afraid to ask for pokemon! I am not trying to scare anyone off or start a witch hunt for anyone who is looking for specific pokes! I just want to address toxic behaviors and players in this sub so that we can work together as a community to eliminate those behaviors and as I've said about a billion times, foster appreciation for those who give to the community.
Number TWO: This community has been very responsive and I never expected the PSA would get this big but so many people included great points that I had to add them in! I hope you'll still take the time to read and maybe even contribute to this discussion as well! (: Now on with the PSA
I love this subreddit. I've found a ton of help and I've even given back to the community before as a thanks, that being said I'm noticing some particularly sad trends in it lately.
There are a lot more LF tags than there are FT tags in posts lately. I get that's the point of this subreddit as it is /r/Pokemongiveaway that being said I feel like people are asking for the same thing over and over and people are also becoming more specific and demanding in their requests.
Again, I get it! This is pokemon GIVEAWAY! and that's all fine and dandy but so many posts lately have just been people asking for the following:
(Pokemon name here)
(specific nature)
(any variant of HOPEFULLY competitive IV's or the even more saddening I WANT/NEED competitive/DECENT cringe IV's)
(I NEED this gender because I'm going to breed to give back to the community blahh blahh blahh) and then never actually host a giveaway.
Even more are the people who demand egg moves. Breeding isn't that hard but it honestly can take a lot of time you guys and I really wish people would realize that or at it least try it out before resorting to blatantly asking for a 5IV bold feebas with 4 egg moves -_-
Then there are the people who just seem rude about everything. Don't just put a title and then in the body put something like "as the title says" or even people who just put "title" or the even more cringe-worthy BLANK body of text!! How rude can you be?? At the very least include a please and thank you even if you don't bloody mean it. I've seen people fulfill some pretty heavy requests and then the OP takes the mon and not a single word of thanks is given to the person who helped them out. Show some appreciation you guys!
Then there are the people who are rude to those who are HOSTING a GIVEAWAY! DON'T bit the hand that feeds you! An excellent point brought to my attention by /u/thatseika : These are the people who leave a comment for a poke and then ignore trade requests, are rude and/or impatient when it comes to receiving their poke (especially when it comes to a high-demand one for coveted pokemon, seriously guys give them some space and don't flood their comments because it makes it really hard to keep track of!) and for some reason log off or have connectivity issues or whatever and then come back later and expect the host to cater to their every whim. People do have real lives to run outside of pokemon guys. Give them some space! If they aren't available for whatever reason whenever you're back on just understand that and arrange another time if they have any mons left. Please don't be mean to someone who "skipped" you.
I'd also like to add that people REALLY need to follow the hoster's requirements! If they say no gender's, for the love of arceus do NOT enforce a gender in your GTS seek -_- They have every right to ignore you and block you if you do so. Giveaways can be a lot of work and often times a big headache. Remember that the hoster is doing a nice thing but at the same time they want to get the giveaway done with as soon as possible as smoothly as possible.
In addition, respect that when a giveaway is marked as completed, that it is over. Do not PM or haggle the hoster. There will more than likely be another giveaway, please just be respectful and let them have a break. Giveaways go a lot smoother and the hoster will probably host more if the experience isn't negative.
The people in this sub are so nice and I can't help but feel like they're being taken advantage of by people who can't even be bothered to include at least a simple please and thank you in their post.
What happened to reddiquette you guys?
Also, as /u/SquirrelLock pointed out.. Can we remember to mark posts as completed when we're done? I understand that some of us are on mobile and can't access a computer right away but maybe even just make an edit saying Request is fulfilled/Giveaway done if you can't mark it at the time and then do it later?
And then there's the issue of the occasional BP item request. I could go on and on about this but seriously guys, nobody has a spare Life Orb. Just don't. Please.
Some excellent points made by /u/coolswampert on how to potentially improve this sub!
Some simple things that might help clean up the subreddit (for better or for worse):
Post in the proper subreddit. If you're here for competitive Pokemon, go elsewhere as described above.
Be courteous. Really. It takes 10 more seconds to say something nice and (fake a) smile and let someone know that you appreciate what they're doing. People remember that. I know I do.
I realize many people are not happy about the large amount of [LF] threads but as many others (including the mods) will tell you, that is a cornerstone of this subreddit. It does not exist solely for large giveaways, people are welcome to request things too. If you don't like seeing them, there is 0 obligation for you to fill them.
If you post an [LF] thread, make sure you're courteous and not demanding of anyone who tries to help. Think of everything they had to go through just to happen to have what you're asking for. Realize the favor they are doing. I know most people are courteous on this subreddit so it's not a big problem. Make sure you're following the posting rules and not requesting anything against the rules or outlandish.
If you post an [FT] thread, make sure you're courteous and not demanding as well. As of late there have been more giveaways asking for Heart Scales and other items back, even going so far as to declare that the higher IV/good Pokemon will only be given to those who donate high-price items (also in light of the recent GTS method, a good way to have Pokemon stolen). That is a trade. Go to /r/pokemontrades. Again, so many people are wonderful and give things away completely free and it feels like it's an issue that shouldn't even have to be addressed. Make sure you follow posting rules before you run a giveaway as well, and please have some patience with the people posting in your thread.
It's completely up to the host on who (s)he wants to trade with or how they want to decide who gets what, and I know lots of people get annoyed with "leechers", but giveaways that are only for people who have hosted X giveaways of their own rub me the wrong way. The whole point is to be charitable and give away to anyone who wants what you're offering. However that is simply my view on giveaways, and as stated before, the host is entitled to do whatever they want as long as it lies within the subreddit rules.
Most importantly, it needs to be remembered that we are not here to be vigilantes. We are not here to yell at each other for not being courteous. I'm here to give away Pokemon to others who want them. John Smith is here to get a free Pokemon every once in a while to help his game. It's that simple. In the end, let the mods do their job and if the rules or what is allowed is not to your liking, then there is no obligation to participate here. I think with a little patience we'll all get along quite alright, but if it's so extremely unbearable to you then I'm sorry but the world might not change. I would love to see everyone enjoy this subreddit for what it's all about though.
Another trend I've been noticing is the increase in people getting their DS' stolen over the past couple of weeks.
C'mon guys.... this is pokemon giveaway. You can ask nicely for these things. You don't need to make up an excuse to get good mons (although I am sure there are people who have SERIOUSLY gotten their system's and games stolen and to those people I am sorry for your loss.)
As /u/Azuraptor said him/herself below:
"There should be a new rule about saying your DS was "stolen". It. Doesn't. Matter. Would it kill you to wait and do one LF at a time? Or wait until a giveaway? Even if your DS was "stolen", that doesn't grant you immunity to rule 1 of not asking for 3+ IVs. Also, I don't care if you have whatever excuse, asking for decent IVs is obviously just an attempt to maneuver around the rule. A sad loophole attempt. It comes off as if you just want to work less yourself and reap the benefits of others hard work. Buckle up, grab your destiny knots and your everstones, and get ready to breed, children."
RULE NUMBER 1!!!!
Follow it! Stop saying decent IV's. People are being generous here. The phrase beggars can't be choosers comes to mind.. Pokemon with 3+ perfect IV's CAN NO LONGER BE REQUESTED! It's rule number 1 for a reason.
Can people please start including proof if possible or something? I get that it'd be pretty damn hard to prove your DS was stolen but if you bought a new DS or something or had to make a new save file why not post a receipt with a date on it (and any other pertinent info on it blurred/blacked out, we don't want any card numbers here) or a screencap of your DS with your new trainer file and a picture of your reddit name next to it or something?
Please you guys?
Again I absolutely love and adore this subreddit but I feel like it's becoming something more saddening lately and I don't like it. I've wanted to do this for a while now so I'm sorry if I offend or piss anyone off. Thanks for reading.
Edit: I've edited this post about 20 times because you guys are really responsive and bringing up really good points! Keep 'em coming!
And hey mods as a semi-serious joke can we get a bot that automatically deletes a post if it includes "hopefully" or "decent" in the body? XD