Nintendo would not manage to make a game that achieves what Monomyth does. If they did, and they sold it for $20, everyone's wallets would be open! I feel personally blessed that the devs are insistently making no money from this. For me, it's a top 10 all-time Pokémon game.
LOVE: Fakemon, their balance, the boss fights, the graphics, the music, the story.
Fakemon battle balance: 10/10 Brilliant. Giving no documentation is, it turns out, an excellent decision when the fakemon designs so clearly communicate their typings and niches. I loved learning the dex, its abilities, and its matchups, and I loved the microgame of probing away at the foe until you figure out its typing - or catch one for yourself and learn everything. In this game there is a massive reward for working on your dex. If you like documentation: be patient, engage with the game on its own terms, and it will reward you.
Not only that, but everything has a niche. Kodaismos, the monolithic tank, is a competent specially-oriented ResTalker that can become an excellent support mon thanks to its ability to tank anything, freeze foes, set rocks, and moonblast. Punxearth is a crit machine or an EQ/Wood Hammer spammer. Dexcon learns Sketch. Slizon is Super Effective. Riotgeare is an insane Stamina exploiter. Acolith has an unbelievably good typing and carries through the early gyms with Chatter. All this and more awaits. There are a few monstrously powerful threats but there are very few mons outclassed by others, and there are over 360 to collect. Everything is a blast.
I cannot stress how hard this is to achieve.
Fakemon: I didn't go wild for all the designs but some of them are immediately perfect. Ontomb, Thatchoof, Ravond, Tagling, Overgrove, Kokunai, Slithoom, Pupnik, Tomtop, Upbrute, Scribix, Quixotic, Tonsatuzi, Shimantle, and Volet were all 10/10 for me, and the list goes on.
Boss fights: Outstanding. The champion fight is, without question, the most memorable one done in a pokemon game. All the bossfights are tough, fair, and fun, and all of them leave you room to show off, outwit, and outmanoeuvre the AI in your way.
Graphics: All of the graphics are perfect. The world looks cohesive across an astounding range of environments and set pieces. The spritework on some of these Pokémon sprites is beyond what I thought was possible.
Music: Music is always ridiculously hard and I liked a lot of the tracks here, but what tips it over is the battle frontier, the title screen, Willow's theme, Speedwell, and fucking LUCIANO
Story: The main game story will make you well up, get excited, get horrified, and above all, laugh. The two lead characters are an extremely well written pair, and watching the two of them spiral in opposite directions is a pleasure.
For me, this is a game about recovering and reconciling from being bullied. In this story you watch someone go "I was wrong", and save their victim from the trauma they created - and manage just in time. It is wish fulfilment for everyone who's been kicked as a kid, and gutwrenching to re-live that deeply personal spiral of hate that bullying can tip you into. It is a deeply special and personal story and I was lucky to play it. More touching, serious, dramatic, with more gravitas, than anything game freak has ever written. All the gym leaders rock.
The world is alive. In the postgame, the entire world is repopulated and changed by a time skip. In each pokemon center, the news ticker reels off the madcap tales of the world you're living in. It's right there, and you can feel it.
It also contains the second-best written signpost in videogame history. You will know the one when you get to it - the sign is rotted away and barely legible. (The best written signpost is, of course, in lavender town in Celia's Stupid Romhack)
The devs themselves: These people believe wholeheartedly in their particular vision. Every interaction I have had with them has been positive, and I haven't yet seen any actual evidence of all the accusations (like u/cayden68's insubstantiated claim, below, about the devs "shutting down any attempts of sharing documentation") that people have been slinging their way non stop since day dot
LIKE: Maps, battles, economy and exp balancing.
Maps: Consistently a very high standard, particularly loved Old Bay Island which is a jawdropping open world section. Sometimes I found them a little oversized or cumbersome, but I was never bored, and the spritework is exceptional. I did think there were a few too many long snow routes in the lategame and some early routes are mazelike, making backtracking occasionally bothersome. I personally loved barbed cave, that shit's cool and encourages you to rewire your team with flying types.
Battles: All okay, but a bit of a slog at times because most trainers are competently wielding four bulky pokemon in the lategame. You'll make it through it anyway.
Economy and Exp: I felt like I was able to grind up new team members thanks to the use of soft level caps, even though it's a bit hard to switch out your team without feeling punished long-term. It's easy to keep one or two flex-slots and carry four or so favourites through the game. I wound up using 10 or so different pokemon which was great. It is an astonishing work of playtesting that the economy system is making it so the player is having to spend every penny on items, but this does gate secret base décor behind gym 7 or so.
COULD IMPROVE: Postgame writing.
My biggest criticism is that I think the postgame's main story writing wasn't up to scratch, but that's really it. This is something I could wax lyrical about but I won't because why should you care? It doesn't change my recommendation!
BEST BIT: Cohesion
TLDR: Together, all of the above sings in unison like an orchestra. The hardship inflicted by the tough exp and economy mechanics and the heavy focus on massive, harsh, sprawling wilderness environments tie perfectly to the main villain's obsession with hardship and give a feeling of conquering something against overwhelming odds. Despite everything you prove you can do it. The game has resource problems and a lack of handholding "QOL" because it is tonally correct for the game.
What a special and cohesive experience this is. Up there alongside HGSS and B2W2