r/PokemonBDSP • • Mar 14 '26

Discussion I don’t get all the BDSP hate. It’s far superior to Violet/Scarlet & Sword/Shield

0 Upvotes

I just started playing Scarlet and it’s horrible. It has all the same things that I hated from Sword/Shield

The open world vibe. Hyper realistic graphics. Too many encounters. Huge map. Unable to get from one place to the next without a over complex map as if you’re lost in a new city

IMO BDSP is much truer to the originals. Easy maps. Clear distinction of Cities and Towns. Familiar graphics of grass, caves, mountains, water

Scarlet/Violet and Sword/Shield both don’t even feel like a pokémon game. They feel like some random openworld game - like GTA or fortnite but they just happens to have wild pokémon in them

I can’t be the only one who feels like this


r/PokemonBDSP • • Nov 08 '22

Discussion Is it normal to have beefy Pokémon like this at only 2 badges? I feel like half my team shouldn't be done evolving; let alone that back on Pearl Version on the Nintendo DS I wouldn't have access to these Pokémon this early.

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Dec 11 '21

Moderator Announcement Upcoming change to the rules

0 Upvotes

Hello Trainers!

Let us first start out by saying how glad we are to see everyone enjoying the game! We love seeing people’s accomplishments, share the heartbreak of having that elusive shiny run off on you, even some of the downright hilarious things you all have shared here!

The above being said, we need to remember that this subreddit is meant to promote discussion, answer questions, and make new friends along the way.

Lately, and really since the game’s release, we’ve seen many of the posts on this subreddit turn into someone just sharing a screenshot from the game, showing off that they beat the Elite 4, showing off the shiny they caught, etc.

As these posts don't promote the open dialogue we’re trying trying to promote here, we’ve decided to implement a set of rules surrounding screenshot sharing.

Beginning Tuesday, December 14th, we will have a weekly screenshot showoff thread!

With this new screenshot showoff megathread comes a new set of rules:

Posts containing screenshots of the game (including taking pictures with a cellphone of your screen) will be removed, and the user directed to post the screenshot in the weekly megathread.

There are two exceptions to the no screenshot rule:

  • Captioned albums of screenshots that are from original content (Nuzlockes for example) will be allowed, so long as they promote discussion.

  • Screenshots of announcements or events (including announcement of said event), whether official or community driven.

As reddit comments do not support posting images, users will have to make use of an image sharing site (such as imgur.com) and post a link to those images in the comments of the megathread.

Once this new rule goes into place, the moderation team will (at first) have to take a proactive approach for moderating image posts. That said, all image posts will have to be filtered for manual review by the moderation team. We ask for your patience if your post isn’t approved right away, we’re all human and have real world responsibilities to attend to as well a volunteering as moderators for this subreddit.

As the dust settles for this new rule, we’ll be relaxing the filter and taking a reactive approach to image post moderation, allowing posts to be go through, then removing posts that break these rules. This change is expected to happen one week after the above rules go into place.

Once again, these rules will go into place with the posting of the first screenshot megathread on Tuesday, December 14th.

We look forward to continuing to try and improve this subreddit to be the best it can be, and seeing all of the wonderful content you all put out!

-Your r/PokemonBDSP moderation team


r/PokemonBDSP • • Mar 17 '26

Discussion Why is Pokémon BDSP hated?

11 Upvotes

This is a very ignorant question, but I’m very not in tune with Pokémon games. I’ve never been big into them, but I recently bought a switch 2 and I’ve been having an itch to play a somewhat classic Pokémon type game (the only Pokémon game I played was Pokémon fire red and it was freaking amazing), anyways I bought brilliant diamond used, and I have been having a really good time.

So why is it so hated amongst more seasoned Pokémon enthusiasts? Thanks!


r/PokemonBDSP • • Nov 29 '21

Image Super fun game but lacks difficulty (at least to me)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Jul 28 '22

Other The only way to stay sane in Pokemon.....

13 Upvotes

Does anyone else think, that the only way to keep your composure in new gen Pokemon games is to release every Pokemon that starts bouncing at the begginning of every battle "awaiting your directions" or "wishing to be praised for every crit" ?

I hate those dialogue lines. They prolong every encounter for no reason at all. I understand that it is meant as an indicator for friendship levels, but is so poorly designed and so incredibly annoying. I cannot play these games for fun. I rather play Pkmn Blue for the 50th time with the most disgusting headachy graphics than playing those games for more than an hour.

Just add friendship to the summary, rather than bloating my combat log. And while you are at it add an easy way to check IV's and EV's aswell...


r/PokemonBDSP • • Dec 01 '21

Discussion A Rant

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Jan 28 '22

Image First all shiny legend playthrough

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Mar 30 '26

Discussion I just spent over an hour making my team hate me so I would stop seeing those stupid messages and then jumping around!

Post image
0 Upvotes

I fought them and fed them bitter healing items, am I a terrible person?🤔

Whoever’s idea that was needs a bop on the head, it’s so annoying!!


r/PokemonBDSP • • Dec 15 '21

Discussion Unpopular opinion: I didn't like BDSP

0 Upvotes

I know I'm gonna get a lot of downvotes but... I just had to say it. It makes me very sad how little effort they put into this "remakes".

I used to critizise SWSH a lot, but honestly, after playing BDSP, now I really appreciate Galar.

The control movement in BDSP is really bad and frustrating, I never use the bike because it's nearly impossible to do so.

The Grand Underground I found it boring, was messing around for a couple hours and never went back down again, it felt extremely repetitive and boring. Also the movement on the caves are frustrating, very annoying, I ended up giving up on it and never getting into a cave ever again.

Following pokemon is terrible... You get stuck all the time because of them, sometimes your character just can't move or the pokemon is extremely slow, it reminded me of SWSH following pokemon and it was very bad. In BDSP is annoying and had to deactivate the option, Let's Go was miles better in that regard.

The game in general felt very lackluster, it was easy and childish (yeah I get it, it's pokemon, but still...). I never had an issue battling anyone, not even Cynthia, it was nice to have finally someone strong, but she wasn't THAT strong.

For me, the post game is very boring. Ramanas Park is quiet boring, just go on cave and thrown 100 ultraballs over and over and over and over again with all the legendaries to catch them. Sorry, not my cup of tea, I find doing the exact same thing 2000 times, really boring.

The rematch with gym trainers are very unbalanced. The game was very easy before ending credits, and then all of a sudden the gym leaders are extremely overpowered. Yes, that is good, but what I'm talking about is how unbalanced this was, the implementation was bad, went from 0 to 100 in like 1 min. I personally re-battled 5 gym leaders and had to quit because as I said, it was the exact same thing and just got bored.

I think this must be the game I played the less, barely 40 hours, when I normally play around 60-80h (SwSh I have 120h).

And if you add that I despised the artstyle... (sorry chibi are just not my thing), and that they kept all the bad things from DP instead of actually improving it and adding some nice Platinum stuff... well, they failed. I still can't believe it is impossible to have a playthrough using Glaceon. So the Ice Eeveelution is from Sinnoh but you can't use it until the 7th gym, finishing the entire game. Very nice.

And other things like adding the Razor Claw on your way to the Pokémon League, when you can catch Gligar very early in the game. It's just stupid. It made sense in DP since you could not catch Gligar before the league, but now? Just terrible balance.

I could go on and on and on, but I don't wanna stress out for a game. I honestly can't wait for Legends Arceus, I'm very excited and I hope they deliver...

What do you think?


r/PokemonBDSP • • Nov 28 '24

Image Shiny Arceus Easter Egg

Post image
0 Upvotes

I noticed while shiny hunting that theres a shiny Arceus in the reflection of the glass where Arceus stands


r/PokemonBDSP • • Nov 08 '21

Discussion Remakes Will Have To End

0 Upvotes

I've been mulling this over for awhile, but I wonder if BDSP are the last of the Pokemon remakes. I'm not just saying this as a Unova hater - oh the comments will be fun, come at me, loves - but because...they need to find a stopping point. Especially if the format will be like BDSP going forward. Like, I was looking forward to a Kalos remake, and I'll buy one if it comes out. But the reason I felt Kalos needed a remake is because it left a lot of potential unrealised. But if BDSP is the new remake format now...? What would even be the point of remaking Kalos, other than "Hey no one can find a 3DS for less than 1,000 quid, may as well".

So where will they stop? BDSP feels like a good stopping point: Gens I-IV were all cohesive. May as well go full circle and stop at the remake of the final of the original four.


r/PokemonBDSP • • Apr 15 '25

Discussion Why is this game hated so much on YouTube?

6 Upvotes

I recently started watching ranking list of Pokemon games and this game gets so much vgatl


r/PokemonBDSP • • Jan 18 '22

Wheres my Pink Monkey?!

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Feb 13 '25

Discussion What is with the hate for these games?

15 Upvotes

I always hear regurgitated talking points about why this game is bad from people who haven't played it and refuse to. What would you say to pokemon fans who blindly hate these games? What is your favorite part of these games and why?


r/PokemonBDSP • • Oct 14 '25

Discussion Hi, just have an inquiry why people hated the game?

0 Upvotes

I haven't played the game kn older systems and I've recently bought bundle pack both BD and SP. Is it still that bad for a new player of this gen or is it only bad for those who have played it before and surprised that little to no changes were done.


r/PokemonBDSP • • Jun 07 '25

Image Ugly Shiny?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Found this shiny just a little ago. How do y’all feel about Mewtwo shiny? I’m not really a fan of the green color.


r/PokemonBDSP • • Nov 30 '21

This is the real BDSP that we should’ve gotten

30 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Nov 20 '21

WAS GIFTED A JIRACHI???

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Jan 24 '23

Discussion The Diamond and Pearl Pokédex is awful

0 Upvotes

I never played the original Diamond and Pearl, I only ever played Platinum before this, so I’ve only come to realise now how bad the Pokédex was in those games whilst playing through Shining Pearl. Much is said about how there are only two fire-types but aside from that I don’t understand why gamefreak thought it was a good idea to not include any of the Pokémon they gave new evolutions to in gen IV until the post-game? Like I literally don’t understand, what was the point of giving them new gen IV specific evolutions if you couldn’t even use them in your playthrough? Why can’t I get Gallade, Mamoswine, Glaceon, Weavile, just to name a few, before the post-game? It’s stupid and ridiculous. The only Pokémon I ever see in the wild are buizel, bidoof, geoduck and Zubat and I’m tired of it. I thought people were over-exaggerating about Platinum being the definitive version of Sinnoh but now I understand why. It’s beyond me why ILCA didn’t use the platinum Pokédex for these games, I’m finding it extremely difficult to form a team lmao that isn’t just the stereotypical Sinnoh team of starter, Staraptor, Luxray, Garchomp and then two others. No wonder everyone used the same team in Sinnoh, it’s actually ridiculous.

I know there is the grand underground and stuff but would it have killed tjem to just use the platinum Pokédex?


r/PokemonBDSP • • Dec 06 '21

Image Wtf is wrong with my meditite?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Jan 10 '25

Tool/Guide Help me

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • Nov 09 '21

Meme Everybody in the past week

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/PokemonBDSP • • May 20 '24

Help Did I just get fake Pokémon? The name seems weird (Klawf.net)?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes