r/PointlessStories • u/Unique_Importance910 • 1h ago
I had the chance to zoom with some popular influencers and I think they were lowkey scamming people.
Years ago there were these 2 french influencers making content for those learning french that suddenly blew up and became quite famous. I am fairly sure they were actually invited to award shows and stuff because of their internet fame. Admittedly, they were kinda cute. As they grew larger, they shifted from educational content to more of funny/typical influencer videos. This was fine but no longer all that useful to me but I kept up because I actually liked them.
Then, they suddenly started talking about a french learning app they were developing. I normally wouldn't mind but they were shilling it quite often and it seemed to over promise. This was when Ai was only starting to catch on (anywhere between 2022 and 2024). By the sounds of it, it actually seemed like a good idea but it seemed like it could be done more cheaply, possibly without Ai (which in this case was actually useful but Ai was still kind of fresh out of the box for these kinds of things) and like it had probably been done before. In fact, even chatgpt could do exactly what they claimed their app could do for free not long after they began innovating their project.
What raised red flags was the price to sign up even before it would release. Iirc, it was like $900+ (possiblly $1000) per a year or something like that. It was sky rocket high and I actually thought that because of their new found internet fame, someone was trying to get in on their money by getting them to invest in this project/take their money to produce a hard to sell product. I actually got tech bro vibes from all of this but I still tried give them the benefit of a doubt because many of these language influencers go on to start a course or something and they typically not cheap and an app is a whole different ball park.
I assume most people learning through social media probably don't want to pay even for programs like Rosetta Stone, at least that was me. Here we have some previously relateable 20 something year olds talking about how this was a life changing product when we all know (at least those of us who spent time trying to learn languages for years) that these kinds of apps are only good for getting some basics in but you will get stuck eventually. I was a bit disappointed but figured they were naive or too optimistic. I also think they were relying on their fanbase's somewhat parasocial relationship with them to sell it.
Fast forward, they are advertising a give away for them to help you with your french or give advice in a quick 1:1 zoom meeting. I had been stuck at intermediate level since forever and I was actually taking french again at university (it didn't help). I actually thought I wasn't that good at it either way and the ad said it was for anyone looking to improve their french at pretty much any learning level.
I signed up and lucky me, I got in! I put aside time and was super stocked to meet them. In the meeting, I am not met by just 2 people (the influencers) but also the person behind the program, but really a sales person. I don't think they really explained his presence and he spoke much more than I thought he should have, mostly giving manager/handler vibes. The meeting was super awkward because I think they were looking for totally green newbies but I was passing all the basic questions because well...french for over a decade will do that. It quickly became very awkward and they seemed rather uninterested and even the sales person didn't bother pitching the product any further. Almost like they knew they were overselling something really basic that a textbook, duolingo or an old CD can teach you in the form of a contrived service that was still in development. It's like they could sense that it would not really fly with someone who knew quite a bit already as they could sniff out it's effectiveness easily. I was stunned because here you have 2 guys who fluently speak french act like they can't say anything more than bonjour or meaningful advice. It wasn't just that I wasn't the right person they were looking for, it's that it felt like they were depending on guillible people buying into an overpriced product.
Both influencers, at least in their claims, are actually trained teachers and you'd assume they could easily pivot and keep things lively if someone was above the learning level they wanted. But they seemed really bothered, like I was wasting their time, perhaps a little panicked too at some points of the meeting too. Maybe the right word is uncomfortable. Their content in my opinion was not even all that basic so I didn't expect a beginner's app. I actually spent time searching the internet for any snark on them after that to see if anyone else thought something strange was going on.
They are still famous and while I don't think they are outright conmen, they did seem very cash grabby to me. I stopped wm engaging with their content after that. It's a strange and obscure memory I have. They are probably the most famous people I have ever met ironically.