r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • May 04 '20

A Complete Guide to Sonnets: A (Brief) History and How to Write Your Own

30 Upvotes

*Note that this is the exact same guide as the one in r/poetry_critics. I was asked to add it here too.

Introduction

Sonnets are a type of poem that follow very strict rules, and while you may ask yourself "why would I want to do that?", well it's very rewarding to know that even with all of the rules and restrictions you can make an awesome poem. Being forced to confine to syllable counts and rhyme schemes forces us poets to get very creative in finding ways to get our point across and I think it's a wonderful learning experience.

What is a sonnet?

You mean other than painful? A sonnet is the general term used for a 14-line poem that consists of a specific rhyme scheme and meter. Due to the meter it is read in ("iambic pentameter") there is 10 syllables per line, although you will find the occasional 9 or 11 syllable outlier.

Types of Sonnets:

There are a few different types of sonnets, but each follow the rule of 14 lines and 10 syllables per line. The difference is the rhyme scheme and stanza breaks. There are 4 main types of sonnets, which I will outline below. As with anything, the art has evolved and there are tons of modernized subtypes, but I'm only going to outline the original 4, or else we'd be here for ages.

The first one I will outline has the most history and thus is a decent bit longer than the others, but in order of appearance:

Petrarchan Sonnet

Shakespearean Sonnet

Spenserian Sonnet

Miltonic Sonnet

History

The word "sonnet" is derived from the the Italian word "sonetto" which is derived form the Latin word "suono", meaning sound. As you'd expect, the origins are Italian. The creation of the sonnet is attributed to Giacomo da Lentini, a 13th century lyrical poet who wrote poetry in the "Sicilian dialect". If you do not know, Sicily is the Island found in Southern Italy. It is still a part of Italy. (In fact, I'm half Sicilian, my grandparents immigrated from there!)

Although he is the creator of sonnets, Lentini is not the namesake of the earliest type of sonnet. That goes to Francesco Petrarch, who was considered the "perfecter of the form"

Fast forward to a bit to Elizabethen era England (1558 - 1603) where the Petrarchan sonnet evolved to become the next three forms: Shakespearean, Spenserian and Miltonic.

After being introduced to England by Sir Thomas Wyatt in the early 16th century, the Petrarchan sonnet was still being actively used throughout the entire Elizabethen era, potentially due to the Earl of Surrey, a man named Henry Howard, both wrote his own sonnets and translated many of the most famous Italian pieces.

Shakespeare himself comes into the picture about 100 years after the introduction of sonnets to England. Like Petrarch, he did not create his namesake sonnet, instead he was considered the style's "perfecter" which is possibly linked to his incessant use of the iambic pentameter (we'll talk about this later)

Another evolution was the Spenserian sonnet. A man named Edmund Spenser is the namesake: it is a Shakespearean sonnet with a more complex rhyme scheme.

The final one that I will talk about is the Miltonic sonnet, which was created by a guy with the most British sounding name ever: John Milton. It is nearly identical to the Shakespearean sonnet, but the content distinction is important enough to make a whole separate category.

Bear in mind, the Shakespearean, Spenserian and Miltonic styles all happened around the same time. Spenser died just before Shakespeare and Milton died right after.

An Iambic What??

It sounds more complex than it is, trust me.An iamb is one type of poetic "foot". Pretty much all poetic feet are two or three syllables in length. The "iambic" foot is two syllables long.

To determine if it's an iamb, check the stresses on the syllables. This is easiest done while reading aloud.

The pattern of an iambic foot is simple: one unstressed syllable followed by one stressed syllable.

Say it out loud. It's helps me to exaggerate the stresses more than normal, but I have a disability that causes me to alter stresses so do what works for you.

Thus, to form a "pentameter" we need five iambic feet. We know this because penta is the greek root for five. We use greek prefixes to denote the number of feet. In ascending order from 1 - 10: mono- , di- , tri-, tetra- , penta- , hexa -, hepta- , octa- , nona- , decta-

You likely won't find anything higher than 10 feet. 10 feet is already odd, and I doubt you'll find a monometer or a diameter (NOT pronounced the same as the "diameter" in

How to determine the meter and foot?

I'll break it down into the steps I was taught:

Step 1. Read the text normally (out loud), but pay attention to where you naturally stress the words. Note you can just whisper-read, you don't have to act like you're presenting it to someone, unless you want to. Knowing the overall tone of the text also helps.

Step 2. Grab your pen! Cut each word into syllables. This doesn't take as long as you might think. Like this: |Am|I|mak|ing|sen|se?|

Step 3. Read the first line slowly and read aloud, make sure to exaggerate your stresses on the syllables. Word by word, mark whether you read the syllable as stressed or unstressed. If you feel that it's unstressed make a mark above that syllable that resembles a shallow, wide "U". If you are using a computer, use an "x". If you feel that it's stressed like me mark it with a left-facing slash "/".

Step 4. Find the pattern. Mostly [x | /]? it's an iamb. Mostly [/ | /]? it's a spondee. Mostly [/ | x]? it's a trochee. [x | x] is pyrrhic. If the pattern is more obvious every 3 syllables: [x | x | /] is referred to as anapestic and [/ | / | x] is dactylic. Don't worry about the names though, you just need to remember "iambic" as it's the most important and how to identify stresses.

Step 5. Average out the number of syllables per line. Do this by adding all the syllables in the entire poem and dividing it by the number of lines. Round to the nearest whole number. Divide this number by the number of syllables in the foot that you identified (either 2 or 3).

Step 6. Name the poetic meter! It goes iambic/spondaic/trochaic/pyrrhic/dactlyic/anapestic + prefix determined by final # in step 5 (mono for 1, tetra for 4, penta for 5, etc.) + "meter"

Try it:

Of these 5 sentences one is written in iambic pentameter and one of them is written in iambic tetrameter. See if you can figure out where the iambs are!

a) But soft! What light by yonder window breaks?b) Tell me not in mournful numbersc) And the sound l of a voice l that is stilld) Was three long mountains and a woode) Just for a handful of silver he left us

Well?

The iambic pentameter is a) this is a famous line in Romeo and Juliet!

The iambic tetrameter is d) It's from Edna St. Vincent Millay's "Renascence"

The rest are: b) is a trochaic tetrameter (from Henry Wadsworth Longfellow's "Song of Hiawatha") c) is an anapestic pentameter (from Lord Byron's "The Destruction of Sennacherib") and e) is a dactylic pentameter (from Robert Browning's "The Lost Leader")

The Petrarchan Sonnet:

The Petrarchan sonnet, named after 14th century Italian poet Francesco Petrarch. Ironically, Petrarch did not invent this type of poem, that credit goes to 13th century Sicilian poet Giacomo da Lentini

It is broken into 2 parts: an "octave" and a "sestet". An octave refers to a stanza of 8 lines, the sestet refers to a stanza of 6 lines.

The octave always has the rhyme scheme of the dancing queen (as I call it). It goes ABBA ABBA. Each letter means a rhyme, so each "A" line ends the same, etc.

The sestet has a rhyme scheme of either CDE CDE or CDC CDC. The latter scheme is also sometimes referred to as the "Sicilian sestet" It is more common to see CDE CDE, however I prefer the other rhyme scheme, ironically, I am half Sicilian. This is easier to use in Italian due to Italian word endings being much more similar than in English.

Petrarchan sonnets typically present a "problem" or "proposition" in the octave, usually in the form of a question, and then a "resolution" in the sestet which is called the volta (which translates from Italian to "turn"). This form was also often used in 17th and 18th century England, even after the creation of the Shakepearian sonnet.

Often, Petrarchan sonnets do not have a stanza break between the preposition octave and volta sestet. I split them here for easier identification.

Petrarch's Sonnet 159

In what bright realm, what sphere of radiant thought
Did Nature find the model whence she drew
That delicate dazzling image where we view
Here on this earth what she in heaven wrought?
What fountain-haunting nymph, what dryad, sought
In groves, such golden tresses ever threw
Upon the gust? What heart such virtues knew?—
Though her chief virtue with my death is fraught.

He looks in vain for heavenly beauty, he
Who never looked upon her perfect eyes,
The vivid blue orbs turning brilliantly –
He does not know how Love yields and denies;
He only knows, who knows how sweetly she
Can talk and laugh, the sweetness of her sighs

The Shakespearean Sonnet

The Shakespearean sonnet is probably the most well-known of all, as well as the simplest to write in English. It was heavily inspired by the traditional Italian sonnet, and evolved throughout the Elizabeathen age to what we know it as today.

Many people believe Shakespeare invented the sonnet, however, as mentioned earlier, sonnets date back to the Italian Renaissance and the creator of the sonnet is credited to Giacomo da Lentini and considered to be "perfected" by Francesco Petrarch.

Shakespeare wasn't even the first Englishman to write sonnets! However, much like our pal Petrarch, he was considered the "master of the craft" and thus the style bears his name.

The format is slightly different: it is split into four parts, three quatrains (a group of four lines) and then a rhyming couplet at the end (two lines that rhyme with one another)

The rhyme scheme goes: ABAB CDCD EFEF GG and is written in "iambic pentameter" (unstressed, STRESSED)

See if you can detect the poetic feet in his works:

Shakespeare's Sonnet 130

My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun;
Coral is far more red than her lips' red;
If snow be white, why then her breasts are dun;
If hairs be wires, black wires grow on her head.

I have seen roses damasked, red and white,
But no such roses see I in her cheeks;
And in some perfumes is there more delight
Than in the breath that from my mistress reeks.

I love to hear her speak, yet well I know
That music hath a far more pleasing sound;
I grant I never saw a goddess go;
My mistress, when she walks, treads on the ground.
   
And yet, by heaven, I think my love as rare
As any she belied with false compare.

The Spenserian Sonnet

A Spenserian sonnet is identical to a Shakespearean sonnet, however, it makes use of a more complex rhyme scheme. It goes: ABAB BCBC CDCD EE. Personally I find the rhyme scheme awkward to read, but it certainly makes for some interesting poetry, since you only get 5 different rhymes to work with.

I've written many, many sonnets but this is the style I am least fond of. I find it clunky to read and write. It doesn't help that Spenser's works are written with different spelling than we use today. Everything is very phonetic though and you'll notice a lot of it is pronounced very similar to the modern equivalent.

Edmund Spenser's Sonnet LIV (54)

Of this worlds theatre in which we stay,
My love like the spectator ydly sits
Beholding me that all the pageants play,
Disguysing diversly my troubled wits.
Sometimes I joy when glad occasion fits,
And mask in myrth lyke to a comedy:
Soone after when my joy to sorrow flits,
I waile and make my woes a tragedy.
Yet she, beholding me with constant eye,
Delights not in my merth nor rues my smart:
But when I laugh she mocks, and when I cry
She laughs and hardens evermore her heart.
What then can move her? if nor merth nor mone,
She is no woman, but a senceless stone

The Miltonic Sonnet

This type of sonnet is nearly indistinguishable to the rhyme scheme it chooses sonnet. In fact, if you came across a Miltonic with a Shakespearean rhyme scheme and an actual Shakespearean sonnet in a language you don't understand, you would not be able to differentiate them.

This is due to the difference being, well, the content of the poem.

Simply put: Miltonic is internal (feelings, struggles, etc.) and Shakespearean is more physical, as in to say the things/concepts that surround us, while Petrarchan is more spiritual/religious.

To be completely honest, most people would just call them Shakespearean/Petrarchan and not differentiate. People tend to be more familiar with Shakespeare, and the difference is so small that I only tell people who are interested in literature that my fave sonnets are technicallyMiltonic, not Shakespearean.

(Yes, my favourite are Miltonic in Shakespearean rhyme scheme)

An illustration of the difference

Many people are not entirely sure why we consider this another major group of sonnet, since sonnets are very much defined by structure. It's true that it copies a rhyme scheme of another established structure...(to be fair Milton did sometimes change it up to "stretch the limits of traditional structures")

However...

It sparked the idea of creating poetry about these concepts.

The traditional Petrarchan sonnet often had spiritual themes relating to catholic beliefs. (Repentance, holiness, love for the Christian God, sacrifice, etc.)

The Shakespearean sonnet....well if you didn't know, our old friend Willy Shakes was a rebel. He regularly wrote about lust, misogyny, homoeroticism, greed, infidelity, adultery and acrimony. In the 17th century, mind you.

Read the poem that is in the Shakespearean sonnet section "My Mistress' Eyes". Nearly every comparison there is to something material: a rose, coral, the sun AND it is a literal comparison: he compares her lip to coral -- it's not symbolism or metaphor, it's literally coral.

One of Milton's most famous works is the sonnet 19 "On His Blindness" (found below) in which he contemplates around the sad truth that he was going blind (which is true, Milton did go blind)

The most simplistic way to put it is Shakespeare is more simile and Milton is more metaphor. Wow alliteration!!

John Milton's Sonnet 19

When I consider how my light is spent,
   Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide,
   And that one Talent which is death to hide
   Lodged with me useless, though my Soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
   My true account, lest he returning chide;
   “Doth God exact day-labour, light denied?”
   I fondly ask. But patience, to prevent
That murmur, soon replies, “God doth not need
   Either man’s work or his own gifts; who best
   Bear his mild yoke, they serve him best. His state
Is Kingly. Thousands at his bidding speed
   And post o’er Land and Ocean without rest:
   They also serve who only stand and wait.”

Personal Examples

Most of my sonnets are based off of songs because my favourite way to write them involves intertwining lyrics with my own ideas. The title of the song and the artist are noted. I would add links to YouTube, but Reddit gets picky when I add links. They're very easy to find if you just copy + paste the sonnet titles into Google or YT. They are all good songs but most are indie artists; I recommend you check them out!

Petrarchan

Addict of the Gallery - Faithe MarieArt bleeds its colour through canvas and framePleasing the eye and provoking thoughtAttacks through brushes in forceful onslaughtPaints over tragedy and waits for acclaimif artistry is only made through painthen I’m addicted to the sufferingwhen sorrow can show it’s true colouringcarving ‘til only perfection maintainsBut, why turn something bad to something worse?scraps of failure build me to what I amisolation and loneliness make peaceI’d rather be alone and that’s how this worksreach for me and try to touch but you can’tthe complex mess of being a showpiece

Spenserian

Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd“Hello?” Is anybody in there?a doctor is hovering over methis will ease the pain so you can beardisassociated from your agony

and relieved of all the anxietyeverything surrounding me is a blurProblems forgotten: relieved blissfullyan easy solution for a user

but the spotlight's on: I'm an abuserthere's no doctor, just a man with a viceIronic-- addicted to the curethe only medicine has quite the price

needing more to hide this thing I've becomekilling me slowly 'til I'm comfortably numb

Shakespearean

I am Not Nothing - Beth CrowleyNobody ever made me feel so cursedbut attachment and guilt kept me trappedWaiting to get better, but things got worseit was my fault whenever you snapped

words turned to bruises and pleas turned to shovesa relationship built on violenceAnd yet I believed when you called it “love”It’s time to let go of my reliance

Underneath my fear I find my voicetime to leave you behind and start againWho you chose to be was not my choiceI’ll rewrite my story with a happy end

You always told me that I was weakBut the bravest thing I did was leave

Song of the Abyss - Aviators (which is a song based on Knight Artorias' tragic story from dark soulsOld friend, the darkness has us trappedDo you feel it, decay is closing inI will save you, but that’s my final actFor deadly silence crawls upon my skin

My shield is sturdy but my strength will waneSave yourself while I hold back this monsterWhen shadows take me, I’ll spare you from the painMy will is strong but can’t last much longer

Corrupted beyond the point of rescueTo attempt to change my fate is hopelessFinish me honorably, I beg youFor I am but a slave to the abyss

Put me to rest while I still have my fameSucceed me when the world forgets my name

An Accidental Combination of Petrarchan and Shakespearean (I guess we can call this one Miltonic!

**My Whole Family Thinks I'm Gay - Bo Burnham (a comedy song)**I try to convince them to reassessbut every one of my peers now suspectsMaybe watching SpongeBob had side effectsPerhaps it comes down to how I dress

No matter what we’re doing it comes upNo one tries to keep the message hidden“Hey what’s up? Do you like kissing women?”I try my best but there’s no letup

“She doesn’t get guys, there’s no other way”Haven’t you guys figured it all out yet?It’s because I’m bitchy, not ‘cause I’m gayBeing the “gay friend” is still an assetNobody will change their mind what’s more to say?At least they’ll be cool when I leave my closet…

(Just so we're on the same page, this one wasn't written to be "good" by my standards, it's just something funny I did while coming to terms with my sexuality)

In Conclusion

Sonnets are intimidating. They are highly structured, rigorous and may seem limiting. However, they aren't as limiting as you might think; they force you to find alternative ways to adapt so you can effectively get your message across and are great for learning. Your first one will likely be very difficult, mine was downright torturous -- and wasn't good at all (imo) -- but I have improved drastically.

A thesaurus and rhyming dictionary are your friends. I recommend RhymeZone, where you can sort rhymes by syllable count, find near rhymes, define words, find in-context examples and it also works as a thesaurus.

Good luck! Feel free to ask questions and post your own sonnets below, I'll try to reply with a brief review.

Please do NOT repost ANY of my work without credit to u/PoeticScience. If you wish to post this guide somewhere else, you MUST ALSO link back to this post. Thank you.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Dec 23 '20

On the day I realized I was no longer poor

22 Upvotes
I began to eat parsley, but only the leaves  
and threw away the stems in the garbage  
and I bought the cheapest, best coffeemaker  
I could find. Mr. Coffee, a sleek thing, all black 
plastic, and a flash of almost real silver. 
Later, I cried buckets, for I had never realized
the true purpose of household appliances.
I don’t even use, nightly, the blinking blue clock
that allows me to choose exactly when
my coffee is brewed, just for me.
I think I am afraid, like a dog who guards
her now full bowl, or a bubbe returned
from the war, insistent upon simple fact
that a car will let you down when you need it
but her legs, with hashem’s consent, keep walking.
I cannot live a single life on a living wage.
What does the millionaire want so badly
that he must steal seventeen times my wages,
annual dividends in blood?
How many coffeemakers must he buy to feel
what I feel, making stew on a lark, the roast
bought at a counter, stolen naught but from
the worker’s pocket, with parsley leaves
picked carefully from stems I do not eat.
For the true purpose of an appliance is forgetting
the taste of parsley stems, and shit mason jars
of Folgers, made thrice weekly using a pour over
I stole from a landlord who wished my death.
And I refuse to misremember money as good
for anything but the shuffling crawl toward
the day we may be free of it.

r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Mar 01 '21

Moderator Post Oracle Bone Issue 1 — New Poetry Journal (OUT NOW!)

21 Upvotes

Hey PwB friends,

Oracle Bone is a poetry journal focused on publishing high quality work other poets want to read. It's finally out, featuring many poets from this subreddit and other OCP subreddits. We also feature work by poets outside of reddit circles.

We're fucking excited. Big thanks to u/lastliondance, who did the heavy lifting to get issue 1 out. Also, a big thanks to all the poets who contributed. I don't want to dox anyone.

You can purchase the print version here on Amazon (for $8.98 US). I think there's a Kindle version? u/lastliondance will answer that.

Issue 1 has some amazing poetry. Thanks everyone!


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Jul 02 '20

A Couple Shotouts - u/Beverlydriveghosts and u/Bootsraps17

21 Upvotes

Hi all,

These two PwB buddies have had some pieces published recently. I figured we could give them some love. Both awesome poets, obviously. Let's fucking go!!!

u/Beverlydriveghosts: Bubz got some love from the American Journal of Poetry for her piece Chapel.

u/Bootstraps17: And Boots got some love from La Piccoioletta Barca for The Sick Child and Silent the Sun Falls and for Come April and Silk

Hope everyone is doing well. BLM! Defund the police. Arm the homeless?


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Jan 17 '20

Moderator Post Mod post: Garmo to lurkers.

20 Upvotes

Hi lurkers.

What I regret most of my heavy handedness with marylai is the thought of having put off a bunch of talented poets- possibly even a couple of future great poets- by being a bit of a dick.

So- as well as noting I am not the voice of the sub- though I am here more to critique than to post, my opinion does not smell any better than anyone else’s; I wanted to say to lurkers that I won’t be coming in so hot in future.

As long as you post some fucking criticism before you post three poems in a row.

Also, I am offering a ‘gentle Garmo’ function in penance. If you are new, or nervous about posting your poems: you may either say ‘gentle Garmo’ and I’ll know to take it easy- or you can summon me with ‘gentle u/Garmo738’. I’ll come and be generally nice. (This function may not last too long)

My aim is to encourage poets with promise to become better-across a relatively wide spectrum: excluding completely those who write navel gazing bullshit in endless cliche. Talented beginners are relatively easy for me to break down- I don’t mind helping out.

So- stop lurking. You’ve all been invited here by someone with as good an ear for poetry as mine.

Cheers,
Garmo.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Jul 24 '21

How to get out of bed

19 Upvotes

Outside, rain Rapunzels out

a dark, shifting castle. Each

 

eyelash beats their butterfly

wing. To get out of bed, you

 

Nothing planned for today.

No faces to talk at. If forced,

 

their porridge-thick mouths

lap around thin red lips. To

 

get out of bed. Now. What

dream could gold standard

 

this life? Eat something,

have a cup of coffee. Get out

 

of your head. To get out of

deadboned atrophy, first you

 

Must I tell you how useless

you are? That you can't even

 

Get out of bed? The weather's too

The people are too I am too

 

Tired. Outside, the people's bodies

churn like moving prisons. The world

 

is a gray, coiling, strike-ready. It hisses

on rooftops, through each shingle, down

 

the window. To get out of bed, you

must get out of silence, get out of

 

safety, get out of warmth. Dispel

the unmade cocoon, and reach

 

for the door. But, then again,

maybe some other tomorrow.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Oct 08 '20

When I kill myself

19 Upvotes

They’ll imagine me in the newspapers as roadkill-cold,
all cotton-comfortable, swaddled in the spume -
fish-bitten, white and bloated, fat
like a saint. They’ll have a gummy-grinned photo of me. Some quote
about becoming winged, about learning the harp
and all the tar being dredged from my lungs - and I
will have safely stowed away in a shipping container,
rocking gently with the officially signed for
4K TV’s. That same gummy-grin splashed across my face, and a map
twice the size of my own chest, spread out in front of me.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Oct 05 '21

Okay I'm back to share the final form of this poem i started a long time ago. Title: Weight

17 Upvotes

I thought it was God

There. Silently

Weighing my deeds good and wicked.

How then to look up and notice

I was alone?

Gathering my faults like rocks.

My good deeds like feathers,

Blowing away as soon as I set them down.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Mar 16 '20

Discussion Post Yeah, but, is it Poetry?

17 Upvotes

When I was first introduced to Rupi Kaur’s poetry by u/TheNewPoetLawyerette I stared blankly at the screen. It wasn’t anything that I recognised as being poetry.

You only need to have a single conversation with u/TheNewPoetLawyerette to know she’s smart AF AND loves Kaur’s work. That felt like a contradiction to me. I had always believed that poetry, GOOD poetry was more than short sentences, that it was the love child of art and craft. Where is the imagery? Where is the finesse of word choice? Where is the art, the craft?

To be fair, not all of Kaur’s work is so… flat. Other pieces show hints of recognisable poetry but this isn’t a critique of her work. I want to talk about poetry itself and how we define it, how it changes (mutates). And I say ‘mutate’ because it holds negative connotations. For many fans of poetry, Kaur’s work is a bastard, a mutant, something revolting. They feel it mocks the importance of poetry as a cultural narrative and as art, that it is a degradation of craft.

The first step for me was to get past my own bias. After a lot of soul gouging I came to accept that her work has value for others even if it doesn’t for me. That immediately tells me that I can’t qualify poetry by how I respond to it, by my preference for something meatier. I have to accept that, for some, it is poetry. This conclusion poses more questions though. If Kaur’s work is poetry then why do we encourage and teach the craft of poetry? Why do we critique? Is all poetry good or bad according to its subjective value? If so, how do we recognise good from bad? These questions left me sick to my stomach. I literally felt like god was dying all over again.

More gouging. Blood everywhere. Organs too.

In my search for ‘truth’ I began reading Terminal Identity: The Virtual Subject in Post-modern Science Fiction by Scott Bukatman. It may seem like an odd choice considering his book isn’t about poetry per se but it does reference the changing face of literary work, its appreciation, and its relationship to society. And it was here that I had an ‘awakening’ so to speak.

The main theorist cited in section 1: “Terminal Image” is Guy Debord, whose powerful and illuminating 1967 manifesto The Society of the Spectacle is a radical critique of a contemporary capitalist society in which the spectacle of commodities becomes the world.

Debord says, critically, that modern society (the spectacular society) supplants the authentic self with representations of it, that all that was once directly lived has become mere representations. He believes quality of life is impoverished affecting human perception, degrading knowledge and thus inhibiting critical thought. He maps the evolution of social life as mutating from being into having and having into appearing. He points out that relationships between people have been supplanted with relationships between commodities. And he's right in that images now mediate social relationships between people.

Bringing Debord's ideas into 2020 we can see that social media perfectly reflects that analyses and his concern and belief is that (broadly speaking) social media is changing our perception, that it creates an alternate reality void of definition. In its place we have a subjective reality that is held in the individual as objective reality. Advertising is tailored to reflect back our own preferences, social media too is filtered according to our preferences so that we see far more of those things that we like and less of the things that we don't.

And, what we’re left with today is a society where we’re locked in a perpetual meme war; we live and die each day reviled or glorified by whimsical pop culture, where truth is found in articulate bullshit of 10 words or less. This same culture promotes image over character, wealth over effort, and compliance over integrity. We spend days and nights exorcising and amputating the bits of ourselves and our art that society has decided is shameful or has no value in an effort to fit a perpetually mutating ideal only to end up digging through yesterday’s offal for parts now deemed fitting. We're so disorientated, so busy hopping from one foot to the next trying to stay on the right side of acceptable that we don't even notice the ridiculousness of it all or the fact that by doing so we've aborted critical thought as dissension's bastard.

Ummm, poetry, dude. What’s this got to do with poetry?

It’s easy to dismiss Kaur and her poetry as shallow, void of substance but I don’t think we can or should. Whilst we may grieve the loss of depth, the complexity of nuance and the texture of crafted language we can no more dismiss it as we could have dismissed pop music. Read the lyrics of most popular mainstream music and you’ll find a whole lot of nothing. Yet, people live for those vacuous tunes. Why? Because it resonates, it speaks for them and validates how they feel. They find themselves reflected in that music. So too, people are drawn to Kaur because she resonates, speaks, and validates. Her work is akin to the selfie in that it is a representation of the self, purposefully hollow to allow the reader to climb inside and wear it as a skin.

Whilst Debord is scathing of the transmutation of being into having I think he’s failing to acknowledge two very important aspects of the very nature of us, or, life itself: the cycle of creative destruction and our need to make concrete the abstract.

Nietzsche talks of a universal principle of a cycle of creative destruction, that nothing can be created without the destruction of what came before. This is reflected in the ouroborus, a snake consuming its own tail, and is at the core of capitalism as seen in Schumpeter’s Gale, and life itself in the cycle of life and death. So too, art is creatively destructive and destructively creative.

In all things, humans seek to make concrete what is abstract. We see this in religion. The abstract nature of god is made concrete in the religious fixtures, relics and icons. In art and poetry we attempt to make concrete how we feel about life, what we see and what it means to us. And, even in the piss and shit of real life living we see this encapsulated in the ‘working man’. The industrial revolution pulled him from home where he was surrounded by proof of worth, where his hands were stained with what it meant to be a man and sent him off to work in factories. There, men did what all humans do and sought to make something of himself; and he did. He made concrete the abstract in the form a new masculinity, one that is currently being torn down and recycled.

The panic and absolute suffering we see in today’s males perfectly echoes the reaction to Kaur’s poetry. The destruction of traditional masculinity tears at the fabric of male rationale the same way Kaur’s destruction and democratisation of traditional poetry guts the poet’s rationale.

There is much that can be said about that. I have pretty strong feelings about the dissolution of depth, complexity and knowledge, and how those losses affect critical thought but I’m also aware that my feelings stem from my affection for the old way and cloak my eyes to potential benefits. Perhaps there aren’t any. Perhaps, objectively, it’s just different and neither good nor bad. As u/Bootstraps17 pointed out to me, we have to trust that this generation will make something of it just as we made something of our own cycle of creative destruction.

So, where does that leave us with Kaur, with defining poetry, defining good from bad? I think we have to accept that Kaur and her ilk are heralding a new kind of poetry, the selfie poetry. I think, perhaps, It’s a blending of confessional poetry, the selfie, memes and word art itself. It seeks to make concrete the abstract self, who we think we are, what we project and appear to be in the ethereal world of the internet and in the ever dissolving spectacular society we live in.

Deciding what is good or bad will be figured out by those who can see and appreciate this form of poetry. It doesn’t conform to traditional metrics and it would be foolhardy to apply them here just as it’s silly to apply quality metrics broadly across all poetry. What makes a good sonnet can’t strictly be applied to free verse or abstract poetry. The youth of today are well equipped to make such judgments. Their immersion in technology means they’re learning a new way of processing information thanks to the information age and its influence which has already changed the brains of our children, rewiring their neurology to make use of the abundance of easily accessible knowledge. They no need to store massive amounts of data, they just need to remember where to find it. And we can only speculate as to what that means, long term.

I’ll end this with a word of warning to all fans of selfie poetry. This too shall pass. If we accept that Kaur is a pioneer of a new genre of poetry then we have to accept that, like those of old, it will be torn down, recycled into some new mutant, something that will be viewed as equally revolting to Kaur fans. Will it bring them to their knees as surely as Kaur folded me? I don’t know; I hope not. I hope that they’ll be gifted a lighter touch given this new age is all about quick-fire cycles of creative destruction.

Either way, I was wrong. Kaur is a poet, her work is poetry and has value, regardless of how I feel about it.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Feb 21 '22

Poem 47: This Little Town

16 Upvotes

This little town of Jackson Heights,
of immigrants. The city lights
are not as bright, but we can see
the boulevard, the rising peaks,
how, distantly, by day, the
empire shines so brilliantly.

On Saturday, the local kids
ride back and forth on skates and swings.
Our little town shines with a force:
a lamp, a torch. We are the voice
of those who come to seek a dream,
our little shops, our little streets,

the future paths, the history,
this point in time, the time before,
the children’s laughter, pure and sweet,
so full of possibility.
This spot I’ve filled and left, returned,
I’ll leave a part of me to stay,

to always watch, to always hope,
that all of us will find our way
and not forget this place we found,
the starting point for those who’ve come
on Saturday to Travers’ Park,
this little town, this little spark,

the future paths, the history,
a single step's trajectory,
the form of lines which curve and sway
about the ranks' divide and come
around below the soaring skies
while scattering the scampering

of little feet, in tiny homes,
that lack of things, but not of hope:
it grows, it shines, it radiates.
I’ll let my eyes rest on the sight,
this little spark, this little hope,
this shining star, this satellite,

my home, my wife and family,
this immigrant community,
my grandparents, their sacrifice,
this little town, this little light,
this spot I’ve filled, and now, returned,
I’ll leave a part of me to stay,

just as I am, with all my might,
with open arms, to usher in
the boulevard, the rising peaks,
our little town, this little street,
a prayer, a wish, one candle's light
to guide another's through the night.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Jun 15 '21

Archips Semiferanus

16 Upvotes

Miraculous. To be blown from a leaf

and hang there, just hang there,

your body harnessed

to a handspun silk. And of your body

to rise and dip with the wind as if

no one had ever leapt from a bridge

or the span of one day

to the next.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Apr 13 '21

Leftovers, new monometer series about food

16 Upvotes

i.

apple

plump in

monarch's

mouth: the

red of

satin,

jowls,

rubies.

 

but just

as fruit

may rot

upon

the earth;

your name

the earth

forgets.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Mar 21 '20

In the Mayhem of Silence

16 Upvotes

It all went limp –
the bags, the cobwebs, the rain.
even the chains – even the chains,
draped loose as curtains, brush the floor.
Even the gray stain on the pillow slipped
a bit before pausing, the hinge unhung the door.
And all the several fibrous hums –
the fridge, the gripe, the train, the pipe –
an octave lower than before.

What then must all this madness claim,
to comb distrust’s distressing mane,
flowed as garland, flowed as pain,
upon the head, along the vein.

Come want, come spleen and in between
such vaults in hollow echo run,
as moss to cypress drag and preen
to cut a flickered ravaged sun.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Dec 31 '19

Discussion Post January Discussion Topic

16 Upvotes

Hello PWB! An early happy 2020 from me; it's 6 hours to midnight here in Amsterdam and the fireworks are obnoxiously loud here. I say this as an American, so it's saying something. Anyway, happy New Year, maybe read this & respond tomorrow -- I am posting this early because if I don't do it now, I'll likely forget.

For our January discussion topic, I'm dying to know—literally waiting with bated breath—to hear your personal poetic process. By which I mean anything which is in any way connected to your writing process;

Do you keep a poetry journal? A regular journal? A dream journal? Do you keep a list of fragments in your pocket, in the Notes app on your phone? Or do you constantly come up with fire lines on your commute, think to yourself, “I'll remember that later,” and tragically forget it completely?

When you write – is it on paper, with pencil? With your favorite fountain pen? With a broken crayon? Typed into a word doc for the sneaky poet's right click + synonym feature? Scribbled onto a cocktail napkin and stuffed into your back pocket, to disintegrate in the wash?

When do you know that you're finished with the poem? When you're finished, do you slap it on PWB without a second thought, for certain mods to silently judge (me)? Do you sit on it for two months and return to it on a rainy Sunday, painstakingly picking over every single word with a fine tooth comb (me)? Do you send it to your internet pals to see what kind of thoughtful and constructive feedback comes from a virtual workshop like this very sub?

Any and all thoughts about poetic process are welcome. Not only welcome, but, in my humble opinion, important – if poetry is to be treated like a serious craft, I personally believe it should involve more work than a few keystrokes & submit. Let's debate it in the comments! xo


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Sep 03 '20

Watermelon poem no. three

15 Upvotes
It is impossible to carry a watermelon
they tell me, lips sticky and pink,
without feeling shame, or pride

for doing so. I understand:
all that juicy, juicy pulp, and seeds
that grow when one is swallowed.

But tell me, will watermelon seeds grow
in my barren, scarred stomach.
Thump my belly to ascertain my ripeness.

I want so badly to be sick with creeping 
green vines crisscrossing the back 
of my moist crimson, woman throat.

Let my body be good enough to birth 
another watermelon, so that I may 
at least replace the one I ate

so delicious, crisp, and red
with you, last summer.
Of a watermelon seed, this is all I ask.

r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Jul 26 '20

Sea Legs

15 Upvotes

Sea Legs

He could not have predicted,
by logic, stars or quivering rod,

how kissing the crescent moon rising
from her shoulder would swell

her ocean tides, breaching
the levee of her composure.

Nor, whilst tucked in the aromatic
timbers of her hull, breathlessly

gripping the ivory gunwale
of her thighs: starboard and port,

that his sea legs could be gained
whilst on his belly.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Jun 12 '20

Terns

15 Upvotes

We never saw the pump
that drained the lagoon.
We only saw fish,
drowning as fish.
And when the tide
broke over the sand bar,
the fish rose like rafts,
and there were terns —
so many terns — then the grey
iridescence of scales
under moonlight.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Dec 03 '19

Discussion Post December Discussion Topic

15 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

In the short few weeks we have had this subreddit we have really compiled an impressive group of talent. The charisma you all operate with and the true kindness you show to other poets really make this a unique and helpful space for all of us. The mods here at PoetsWithoutBorders want to make this sub not only a great place to share poetry, but also a close community where we have discussions that will inspire, educate and encourage everyone who takes part. With that, let us begin with our first discussion topic.

What is your favorite line from a poem? A line that brought up intense emotion, a line that has such beauty it transcends language, a line that made you see the writer as not only a poet, but a philosopher. At the end of the day a poem is simply the sum of the lines it consists of. Which one stands above the rest?

For me one comes to mind. “Death steals everything except our stories.” The last line of Jim Harrison’s poem Larson’s Holstein Bull. I remember reading this poem in eighth grade. After finishing that line, I knew I needed to write poetry. In a way that line has inspired everything I have ever written. Its simplicity paired with the profound meaning encapsulate everything I try to do with my poetry.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • May 11 '21

Thumbs & Sweet Potatoes

14 Upvotes

Being the hundredth monkey
I am left with a dilemma — wash
the potato or abstain.

I alone hold the key.

I might rather remark
on the grip some dirt provides
and maybe the microbes.

I may relish some grit
in my teeth and a slow
enameled erosion.

I may wonder whether
one simple conformity
makes me less so macaque.

I may think about churches,
furrows and electromagnetic
intrusion.

I may think these hands
too nimble.

I may rethink these thumbs.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Apr 02 '21

Brushfire

14 Upvotes

Some miles off, a brushfire burns
and the smoke, like the skirt of a tireless Sufi
turns. Neither rising nor sinking
but silently stitched to the ancient
waist of wind and drought — whirled
— the one vast spark that would
make a blaze of such dry tinder.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Mar 03 '21

Love poem.

14 Upvotes

And you press right up against me in the garden -
Your azure eyes and purple lace shawl wrap around like the calling evening.
Your burgundy lips are tickling the edge of my ear,
And you whisper, slowly and softly
“You’re such
A massive
Twat”

This is an old one that I dug up earlier, that I thought you might find funny.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Feb 05 '21

Elegy for Lisa Montgomery

14 Upvotes
Lisa,

Do you have any last words?

I never wrote you and
I didn’t even know your name until
two weeks ago. But we could have known
one another, like sisters
close enough to touch hands. Lisa.
I’m sorry I did not know.

Dear Lisa,

Let’s say heaven is a place, and not a feeling,
where the knives in our hands drop
and we sit at a table playing dominoes.
I have never played dominoes, Lisa,
and my ticket to the great beyond is current
-ly unpurchased. But Lisa, did they teach you
your lesson? Or did they teach you to play dominoes?
Not the kind where small, rectangular bones
lie flat on a table. Lisa,
I mean the kind where you line the bones up
and knock them over.
Lisa,

Did you know that I have a sister?
Do you know it now? I didn’t
get to tell you, Lisa, about my sister and I.
Like yours, she tried to save me
and like yours, she failed. And I hate
that picture of you they used, and not
the pictures of you and your sister, Lisa.
I haven’t seen my sister in years.
Are you off the map too?

The day they killed you, Lisa, they took
your face mask away, gently
the newspaper emphasized, gently, they emphasized 
the femaleness of the prison guard
who did it. But Lisa,
no moment of your life was gentle.
The needle that pierced your almond milk skin
was not gentle, nor were the hands
that refused to save you.

My dearest Lisa,

Have I told you about my mother?
Not the woman who birthed me, but a palm frond
blowing in the wind, and the smell of pussywillow,
and a white veil, and hands made of coco butter.
I see her sometimes, in the window, and she loves me
like she loves power lines, and broken children.
I hope she finds you, Lisa. I think you’d like her,
veiled, but not in mourning, to display
the liveliness of the amniotic air you breathe.
For, with a small gasp, Lisa, you too are held
upon her stubborn, kind knee. Smell the honey,
Lisa, not the chemical sweetness of the poison 
that violated your blood, or the afterbirth.
Her voice is the voice, Lisa, and you are all
you need to survive, no more
than the child you needed to be,
a child of god, Lisa.
Lisa, a child of god.

r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Nov 10 '20

Call for Submissions - Oracle Bone Press (GIVE US YOUR POEMS, ME HUNGRY!)

14 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

u/lastliondance (the heavy lifter), u/garmo738 and Nuz are starting a poetry and arts journal.

Hi everyone,

We are looking for your best! If you don't want to pay the $3 fee on submittable, just email me 3-5 poems at [email protected] and our team ( u/garmo738 and u/w33nuz and me) will take a look.

I got my start here on r/ocpoetry and would love the opportunity to read your poems!

Submission Guidelines:

Oracle Bone is a poetry journal created by poets for poets. We want your most challenging work in any format (we accept both traditional and experimental poetry). We’re looking for:

• 3-5 original poems in a single document (10 pages maximum)

• Single-spaced document with 12 pt. font and clear stanza breaks

• Previously unpublished work. If your work is accepted, we acquire first serial rights worldwide.

All submissions will receive a response within 1-2 weeks. We look forward to reading your work!

Originally posted by u/lastliondance in r/OCPoetry

Oracle Bone Press Website (Work in Progress)

Oracle Bone Twitter

Oracle Bone on Instagram

Submittable

If you feel more comfortable, you can DM on reddit with your submission. Don't be shy!

With love,

Nuz


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Sep 14 '20

Eventide

14 Upvotes

At eventide, when the proxy
of being melts into the maple’s
black pool, when stars are annulled
and a perseid moon dangles
the heads of our love, we,
born of stone resume our hardening.
Hard such that metallic they come,
these riverine tales that sprout
as headwaters from an uncleaved rock
only to crust on our cheeks, on the rims
of our eyes — lime and the salts
that spark a wound. Thus sparked,

At eventide, stripped of light and all
that drags us on: the fury of fingers,
the finches’ golden scrap, the cruel
commerce of posture and propulsion,
we are left at the mouth of it, eventide,
to wrest deep our loves from oblivion.
But what we find there, in our dank
travail, fixed before memory’s dim torch,
animate only by flicker or twitch,
the gray husks of those with which
we strode the sun, vagrant to the loss
that marks our passage, our severed way.


r/PoetsWithoutBorders • • Sep 10 '20

doe eyes

14 Upvotes
halo spotlightslooking outin waiting dark,
flashing & staringfrom web-like veinswinking & streaking:
a fractal networkof cracked ice, reflectingsplintered vertices
of blood & panic:whirling lightslike rays to heaven,
waiting in the darklikehalo spotlights
a creaking wheel
a screaming nascence
or a howling annihilation

 

(sorry for weird formatting, was the only way I could think to get things aligned how I wanted)